I previously visited this restaurant during a busy Saturday night and was disappointed with the service and quality of the pizzas, so I wrote about it on Yelp. A manager from NYPD Pizza contacted me within a few days asking me to e-mail so I could outline my visit. I finally contacted the manager, David, and he was prompt, professional, and very accommodating. He offered to send me a meal voucher to use the next time I visited an NYPD Pizza. During my second visit, the manager at this location, Rebecca, was very accommodating and very receptive to any requests we had for her. The service was fantastic (shout out to our waiter, Jeremy!!) and the food was much better this time around. My boyfriend ordered the chicken parmigiana and I ordered penne with marinara and meatballs...both were delicious! Finally...ALWAYS order the garlic knots as an appetizer. You will not be disappointed! Thank you for the wonderful customer service and great food...we will be back! read more

This place is great. One of the neatest pizza restaurants I've been to. The service is quick and extremely friendly. The appetizer menu is good but I love and recommend their new fried zucchini sticks. The pizza menu is a bit overwhelming due to the variation. From Mott Street Meat Lover to Joey's Favorite (vegetarian), the're all good. New York's Finest Cookie n' Cream is my dessert of choice. Warm oatmeal cookies over soft vanilla ice cream. I just can't get enough of this stuff. read more

I've been searching for an arugula and prosciutto pizza like I had in New York a few months ago. And while they did not have the exact thing I've been searching for, they do have the SOHO Salad Pizza, and in a word it was...AMAZING. I asked them to make it without the dressing and just toss the mixed greens in olive oil instead, and I had to hold the nuts because of an allergy, but it was fresh, flavorful and very satisfying. The large is definitely enough to share and was under $10. The staff was super helpful, informative and friendly. This was my first visit, but it will not be my last! read more

NYPD Pizza - SOHO Salad Pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

This is going to sound weird, but their hot, hot wing sauce is amazing. I get 3 sides in takeout and use it at home on everuthing. If I could buy a pint I would. read more

We've eaten here twice and I'm a fan. Highly recommend the Wall Street pizza and garlic knots; the thin crust is deliciously combined with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, and mushrooms. If you want to broaden your selection you won't be disappointed by the chopped antipasto or chicken wings either. They're not on the same level as the pizza and garlic knots but good nevertheless. Can't say enough good things about that pizza; now that I'm back in California, I'm craving a slice. read more

The pizza was incredible! Couldn't stop eating! It's the first time I've ever tried this restaurant and I definitely will be going back, the cashier that helped me was very nice as well, I can't remember her name. However everyone in the front of house seemed very nice anyway. Will be going back! read more

This place has great lunch specials! I have never been disappointed in the pizza here! Tons of toppings on my fave...Joey's favorite (minus the onions). Their antipasto is to die for with tons of flavor and endless goodness! My boyfriend loved the pizza and the wings! read more

If you're old enough to remember Gomer Pyle this ones for you... SURPRISE, SURPRISE, SURPRISE! There's great pizza on the West Siiiide. I've been avoiding the NYPD Pizza next to Pei Wei well because it's NYC pizza which usually in my experience means sog city doughy center. Plus it's next to Pei Wei & I love me some Pei Wei. However on a trip to get my taxes done & in an effort to apease my hubs whom loves pizza & wings I ate at NYPD Pizza & LOVED it. They have the best slices deal for lunches & you can get a lunch size portion of wings (6). Just the best deal ever & oh so tastey. The wings were spicey & tangy with out being too vinegary in flavor. No idea how they accomplished that but kudos chef. We'll be back with the fam in tow this weekend. Bringing the teen & his grandma. Should be fun! Thanks NYPD Pizza you're the bestest NYC pizza in my humble opinion. read more

Second trip was the charm. I ordered the garlic knots and chicken parmigiana, both were fantastic. Service was fast and efficient, especially for the fact that it was a Saturday night. Rebecca, the manager, keeps the place clean and running smoothly. My girlfriend ordered the penne with marinara and meatballs. And it was equally delicious! Can't wait to try the chicken parmigiana on a sandwich!!! read more

Got the 10" pete-zer with all the veggies and meats (Minus Anchovies) it was very good. I came for dinner it was a little pricey for the size of the pie. But their lunch specials blows the competition away with the all you can eat 1 topping slices. read more

First time here service was great! Ordered a small pepperoni pizza comes with 8 slices and I was satisfied with it. Not the best pizza I've had but I will say I loved the crust. It was nice and crispy and thick enough. However, the pizza is a little on the greasy side to where you pick it up to eat and the tip drops down. A good pizza shouldn't have that problem but other than that it was good. Not sure if its enough to make me want to come back again but not off my list either. read more

NYPD Pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

Ordered large all veggie pizza (as a vegetarian I know it can be difficult to make a crispy) waitress specifically told us to make order it "extra crispy" so we did.. Out comes a very light pizza... Skeptical, three friends and I all took a bite to confirm our pizza was very much so undercooked. When we were unable to get our servers attention, another server noticed we weren't eating, she got a manager who we hoped could resolve the situation. She asked 3 times if we wanted our same pizza put back into the oven (makes NO sense) then offered to remake our pizza, (though we just mentioned that we already waited once before and weren't able to stay to wait again). The manager did not seem like she was interested or concerned that after a pizza place that had been open for "21 years" just served a pizza that was not done. It's unfortunate, but pizza is pizza. This just was not good. read more

My family have been here a number of times and the food has always been great! Pizza sizes are good. Prices are a bit high for extra toppings in my opinion. My only real complaint is the kids Mac n cheese. They make it watered down....for what reason, I dunno???? My daughter doesn't like it but they both loved the Alfredo! So tell your kids to stick with that and you will have a good time. :) read more

My favorite pizza place. Every time we order pizza is done to perfection. Absolutely love it great customer service and clean place .

NYPD is my favorite pizza places! All of the servers are so kind, especially Nicole & Sheehan! Definitely would recommend this place to anyone and everyone. read more

Best mozzarella sticks ever! A must try. They come with this amazing sweet sauce u believe its a type of balsamic vinegar and fabulous marinara sause. This pizza place is amazing. Totally gives the vibe of a upscale dining experience but with pizza. The wings and pizza are amazing. We ordered the baked cookie with ice cream topped with strawberry sauce and the cookie was backed fresh on the spot. I totally wish we had this place in Hesperia CA where were from. I would never eat another pizza parlor again. A million stars for this place! read more

Me and my husband and our two kids went here Friday night. Great service, Shaina was very sweet and very attentive. The pizza was great. Me and the boys had pepperoni, and a cheese! Classic choice and very good one. Fresh and amazing! We ordered pizza sauce on the side to dip our crust in! Wlthe prices are a little more than we wanted but kids eat free on Wednesdays, and they also offer deals on Groupon! So we will definitely be back! read more

NYPD Pizza - This didn't last long - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

We started coming here when we had a couple groupons and now we're here every Friday night for pizza night. Pizza is great (even better when cooked crispy)! Fried mozzarella and spinach dip are fantastic. And if you have room cheesecake is delicious. All employees are extremely friendly. Andre is the best there is and has made us regulars. We'll be going here for years to come! read more

Been here 3 times and all I have to say is Bam! Fresh hand tossed crust and ice cold beer. The lager and amber ale are amazing, great service and fresh food. Wings are tasty and made just right, we had honey hot and upstate. The pizza we had was Wall Street which is a great meat pizza and we also had a margarita. I personally recommend the wall street. The pizzas are huge and a small will easily feed two. read more

Best place to eat pizza and calzones in the west valley. Food is great and the staff is fast and friendly. read more

NYPD Pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

Ordered a pizza online. Went to pick it up and they hadn't even made it yet. Waiting for it now and it better be great or I'll have more choice things to say! read more

Great food!!! Good lunch specials.

Good pizza, but can be a little on the pricey side for a family dinner. Garlic knots are pretty good, but the zepps were soggy and cold when we got them. I'd recommend eating here for lunch. read more

First timer here and let me tell you I will be a repeat customer. Both the pizza and the wings were absolutely amazing! Thank you for a great dinner tonight. Just superb read more

Went to NYPD with some co-workers, and being from the east coast was interested in how good this place would be. Although I can not speak about the Pizza I can speak about the Calzones. By far some of the best I have ever had. These things are packed with quality ingredients and flavor. I also had an order of garlic knots which were equally as tasty. I liked NYPD Pizza so much I had it again as takeout at a later date. Overall a great place at an affordable price. read more

NYPD Pizza - NYPD Pizza. Goodyear AZ - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

Great pizza loved they split the pizza into 2 choices. Service was great waiter Andre was very well versed on the menu and loves his products. He sampled me beer at no charge and the in house brews wear very good fresh with nice full body flavors. I would come again. read more

NYPD Pizza - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

See all

Average NY Style pizza. Delivery time was an hour. It's not great nor is it memorable but it's not bad either. Slightly better than Dominos. read more

Ordered the Italian Wedding Soup, and the Italian Sausage+Peppers a la Vodka. Both were extremely underwhelming. The soup was almost bitter, an overpowering celery flavor destroyed any attempt to enjoy it. Also of note, as a result of this it tasted nothing like any Italian wedding soup I've ever had. This is further reinforced by it's complete lack of any meatballs (a staple in this soup, under all circumstances). The pasta was dry (lacking sauce), and a little mushy (the bad, way overcooked kind of mushy). The sausage in the pasta, however, was outstanding. The sauce needs to be thickened and the pasta cooked correctly so they adhere to one another. The absolutely overwhelming amount of basil(?) placed on top of the pasta - I assume for decoration - was also a gigantic turnoff. Nobody wants to open a vodka/pasta dish and see 3/4 of the surface green - it was just ridiculous. We'll try them, and review them, again. But these are two pretty basic staples that unfortunately fell very short of even "I haven't eaten all day, I just want food" expectations. read more

Being the pizza snob that I am, I have tried many places that said they had NY style pizza. There's only been two others that came close. Met a friend here last night and I have to say, it gets not much better than this! Our food was on point and the beer was cold, the service was what puts it over the top. I've never had poor service at ANY NYPD location but our server, Steve, well he's just the toppings on the pie! Polite, friendly and knowledgeable makes a return trip in the near future (sitting in Steve's section) a guarantee! read more

NYPD Pizza - STEVE!!!! - Italian Near Me - Avondale, Arizona

Best pizza in Phoenix! Even our kids from Oakland Ca day it's their favorite too! I love the Sicilian with veggies - half order is enough to share with friends! read more

This location used to be pretty consistent. I understand Covid is impacting a lot of restaurants in many ways. This place is definitely cleaning because the taste of dish towel and bleach were evident in the crust. Maybe slightly different ingredients as well? Cheese does not taste the same. Thought it was just me the last time we ordered but it was very strong this time around and family noticed it as well. Maybe we will wait a while before we go back. Haven't given up on them completely but... like I said, we will give it a rest for while and try again in a few months. read more

Pizza was excellent. Atmosphere was really nice. Service was great. Only complaint i have is they don't have fresh cracked pepper for salads or pasta. I think that's a miss. read more

It's clear from the map that we are in the delivery area. And, I have told them over and over I can't order online because even after two years they haven't fixed their computer glitch. And, every time I do a phone order it gets messed up. You charge too much money to mess up my order and the pizza always comes cold. When I call to complain the person that takes the order doesn't seem to care. So, my frustration has lead me to cooking something tonight. read more

Pizza tastes good just pricey, do not like when waiter/waitresses only address the man at the family table.and not ask or look at everyone else sitting there if they would like something else also. Why because they think he is paying the bill, not sure.... read more

First of all, I originally came in prior to pick up an ubereats delivery and the smell was phenomenal and left my mouth watering to try this pizza. I came in right at opening and was immediately welcomed by the manager Christine. She was very kind and talked me through my first visit, explaining the menu and offering smiling eyes. My server Nick was kind, and once again explained the menu and telling me about their lunch specials. He informed me of the wait time for a pizza and slices. Now, to the food, that pizza was amazing. I ordered 2 separate slices and they were equally good. I wish my stomach could hold a whole pie because the flavors were mouth watering and leaving you to want more. I will sure be back for more and bringing my family and friends. read more

The food that I ended up getting was pretty good I had salad and pizza The salad I wanted was on the menu but they said they did not make that salad anymore I said why didn't you take off the menu they said that that in 1A blank spot on the menu on the insert card. read more

Not impressed with the person taking the order but I will give them another try. I ordered 2 pizzas, one pepperoni, one white, and some cannoli's. The person taking my order had the hardest time and made multiple mistakes. He had difficulty understanding my address after telling it to him 6 times and spelling it out for him. He failed to write down my first pizza and told me I didn't have enough for delivery until I reminded him about it. I just knew my order would be screwed up. Guess what, it was. About an hour later my pizzas showed up and I got two pepperoni pizzas. After a brief conversation with the manager they took one of the pies back and said the white will be out shortly. Of course if you like luke warm pizza this would be fine. We ended up tossing one of the pizzas in the oven for 10 minutes just to get it nice and hot. It's not true NY pizza, but it is still better than the other chains nearby. read more

Best pizza I've had in a long time. Thin soft crust, the kind you can fold, perfectly baked -- no burn on the bottom, added "pinch" sausage, which is a little spicy and really good. Spinach salad, plenty of it nice and cold. Very fresh ingredients, mushrooms, onions, bacon, cheese, almonds. Boneless wings Upstate style with blue cheese dressing and celery were very good, kind of sweet/hot but not very hot. Restaurant was very clean and nicely decorated. Service was excellent. Server was very attentive. I will be back! read more

*Updated* My boyfriend and I had recently had some consistent lower quality service at NYPD. We have since then been contacted by management who has taken the time to address our concerns and earn back our business. I will say, that NYPD probably has one of the best management teams that I have ever been contacted by. It shows how much they care about their business when they are willing to take the time out to make things right with their usual customers. I haven't found a place quite like NYPD with such a great taste and NY feel, from my past experiences, and I certainly hope that the past few will not define their normal quality of service. read more

I absolutely love the pizza here, in fact, I love it so much, there have been times where I've gone in to get something else, just so I can try it, but I want up getting the pizza instead. I honestly can't review anything but the pizza and the cookie and ice cream dessert because it's all I've ever had here. The irony is I've been here close to 100 times, I guess I'm a creature of habit when it comes to NYPD but that pizzas oh so good. read more