Came here with family for brunch based on a recommendation, so expectations were a bit high going in. First impressions were solid. The space is bright, clean, and very spacious. It looks like they are doing some work near the lobby area, possibly weather related, but it did not take away from the experience. As soon as we walked in, we were greeted right away. The staff was friendly across the board and our server Emma was great. She checked in often and made sure we were good. Even though we ordered at different times, the food still came out relatively quick. Now onto the food. We had two Godfather omelettes with home fries. They were okay, but mine lacked flavor and the hash browns were overcooked. The potato skins with bacon were good, but also a bit overcooked. The standout for me was the breakfast egg rolls. Stuffed with Taylor ham, egg, and cheese, they were juicy, crispy, savory, and loaded with gooey cheese. Easily the best thing I had. We also had the bacon egg and cheese biscuit sliders, which I was told were good. The fish and chips, on the other hand, did not hit. It was greasy, heavily breaded, and the fish was mushy inside. The fries had a slightly off taste, though not terrible. I also had an espresso martini. It was decent, not the best I have had, but still enjoyable. Overall, the experience was good. Friendly service, a clean and comfortable space, and some strong menu items mixed with a few misses. I would come back to try more, especially the Bandito Burrito, Latin Steak and Eggs, buttermilk pancakes, short rib and egg tacos, Mexicali skillet, Cuban breakfast, cheesy bacon tots, Irish Dream coffee, and Pirate's rum punch. And definitely those breakfast egg rolls again. read more

See all

Shrinkflation is the new name of the game here from my experience over the past couple of months! $14.95 for 2 scrambled eggs, home fries, toast, and 2 sausage links. 1. The new sausage links are significantly smaller than they used to be. 2. You're never going to get 2 eggs. It always looks like a bit more than 1 egg when scrambled, portions are horrible. 3. Home fries are dry and bland. 4. I don't even think they really butter the toast anymore either. This weekend 3 adults and 1 child eating sliders, 2 burgers, an adult shake and a kids shake came to $100. When eating I asked the waiter if I could get a slice of onion for my burger, he told me it would be $1 extra. I said "oh I think you misheard me, can I just get a few pieces of raw purple onion for my burger, nothing fancy?" Nope, after speaking to manager they now want 55 cents for a slice of a vegetable on the burger! I jokingly asked "How much for the entire onion?" They responded that they won't sell an entire onion. And remember when you would get a burger deluxe and there would be a bunch of french fries on your plate, not anymore here. Now they put a small handful of french fries in a small metal cup on your plate, maybe 20 medium fries. Now it's $1.00 for a slice of cheese and 75 cents for lettuce and tomato. So now it's $15.95 for a cheeseburger with a few french fries, an onion ring, cole slaw, and pickles. They won't charge you for an extra pickle slice yet, so at least I could eat a few pickle spears with our $100 burgers. Also, $3.25 for a seltzer?!! This place is crazy! I wonder how many times the topic of charging for ketchup, salt & pepper came up b/c that's next I fear! The prices go up, the portions get smaller, and we get nickel and dimed for every little thing. So I left a significantly smaller tip, if I'm going to get cheaped out on every little thing then I'm going to start doing it too. If prices increase by 20% and portions decrease by 20% and service decreases then that's where I'm going to find my savings. Sorry to say, this is our new reality. read more

I have no complaints about my experience here. I went around noon on a Tuesday. We were seated right away. The service was amazing. Some of us ordered breakfast while others ordered lunch. Everything was made fresh and came out really quick. They have tons of desserts to choose from. We wanted the Knicks milkshake but they no longer had it. The milkshake that is in right now is the Spider-Man milkshake since the Spider-Man movie is out. So we opted to just try something different and got the fruity pebbles milkshake. It was delicious. It was vanilla icecream with fruity pebbles blended in it. For decoration it came with a pretzel rod and a strawberry shortcake icecream bar. I would definitely come back here. read more

See all

Amazing! Stopped on our way through for some lunch. Did not disappoint. Oh, and don't forget the carrot cake to finish. read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Spiked Adult cocktails. - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

This was a traditional looking diner with some elevated menu items including massive milkshakes. The large menu had lots of classics along with creative choices to choose from. The service was appreciated while the food came out promptly. The prices were on the costlier side too. For a shareable, the breakfast egg rolls ($13.95) were ordered. They consisted of Taylor ham, egg, and cheese, with a cranberry ketchup. This was a different type of egg roll and they were great. The egg rolls was extremely crispy, and the cranberry ketchup had the ever so slightest cranberry flavor. There were six halves and they were large with plenty of filling. I shared the cinnamon swirl pancakes ($16.45?) and Albacore Tuna Melt ($16.45?). There were three good sized pancakes. The pancakes were solid. They were light and fluffy. I would have liked to seen more cinnamon sauce present as it was mostly only on the top pancake as they were stacked. The warm syrup was a nice touch though. The tuna melt was also pleasant. There was a nice toast on the bread with plenty of tuna present. The cheddar cheese could have been melted more. The homemade chips were crisp and thin too. Will I go back? No doubt. read more

See all

Great experience but the food quality was mediocre. Took the drive out from the city for a friends birthday as he really wanted to visit. We ordered a bunch of stuff, mostly fried and just ok. Dessert looked great but the taste left me wanting something more authentic... more delicious. Something that tasted as good as it looked which this didn't. Was a good experience for a classic diner but not worth another trip out. If you're local, maybe worth the stop, but not as a destination read more

See all

I visited for a birthday Christmas Eve celebration and was so impressed! This is by far the best looking diner I've seen in a long time. It's such a spacious diner with great holiday decor. Also, A+ for cleanliness in my book with terrific service. There's a ton of dining options with a specials menu of course. Highlights from our meal included the Taylor ham, egg, and cheese egg rolls, vodka disco fries, various chicken sandwiches. The Reuben sandwich was also amazing. I tried a Dr. Pepper dirty coke with coconut cream. That was delicious. To end the meal, we had to try a banana and Nutella milkshake. The diner is well known for their shakes, and it definitely lived up to the hype. Great diner and an excellent dining experience. Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

Came back for more and was very satisfied. Service is quick and portions are big. Kids loved it and plenty of menu items to choose from. read more

See all

Wish I took pictures of the full menu but it was too awkward taking them without being noticed It's a cool, cozy, classic diner with lots of options like burgers, sandwiches, pork chops, tacos, pasta etc a bit of everything. Of course breakfast choices are a staple. Food came out decent time considering it's a diner and always pretty busy. We had a few specials which came with a house salad or soup plus a house dessert. The chicken rice was delicious, the barley soup was subtle but nice, then we tried the French onion soup. Boyyy that was intensely salty but I believe that's how it usually is? Never had before so I can't really compare. Entrees wise? We ventured out a bit. Let's have a bit of fun right? I had the pork chops with mash and corn. Ok that was pretty freaken good. It was battered and smothered in gravy. Yums. The chicken fajita was nicely charred with all the toppings for a messy taco but def wasn't lacking flavor. Of course we had to try a classic burger with curly fries. Juicy, crispy bacon and soft buns. No need to say more really. Now the true adventure of a diner? A seafood pasta feast. Yeah it was loaded with clams, mussels, shrimp and pasta. Supposed to be spicy but my kid added more hot sauce. Nothing was overcooked, sauce was sweet and he def did not go home hungry. Dessert? We didn't need any but it came with the meal so why not? We tried the strawberry ice cream, vanilla ice cream and rice pudding. Rice pudding was sweet but not overly to the point that I couldn't finish the bowl. Wish we had space for their cool milkshakes but yeah that wouldn't end well. Been coming here for years and yup will always keep coming back. Def check them out! read more

See all

I usually love Orange Town and have had great experiences here, but I was really disappointed today. I ordered the Biscuit and Gravy Benedict, and unfortunately, there was a large eggshell on my plate. I let my server know, and they kindly brought me a new dish, but when I started eating, the gravy was still full of eggshells. It actually stabbed my gums, which was really upsetting. What's so sad is that, apart from the eggshells, the dish was packed with flavor. It had a lot of potential. The home fries that came with it, though, were pretty bland and lacked seasoning. On a positive note, the chocolate chip pancakes are amazing!! The whipped cream on top is especially delicious. I also love that they serve Illy coffee, one of my favorite brands. If it hadn't been for the eggshell incident, I honestly would've given this diner five stars. The interior is fun, with a quirky modern-retro vibe, and the staff is always friendly and attentive. I hope this was just a fluke, because I really do enjoy coming here. read more

See all

This place is several things and it all piles into 50s-60s classic dinner! Just as the name suggests. The food and desserts are amazing! The staff and the dinner itself are wonderful! I can't think of a bad thing to say. We are in visiting from out of town. This is our first stop after checking out of the local hotel, and I'm glad we did! Highly recommended read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Just a pic of some shakes on the menu - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

I come here a lot and I think I just need to get my order better bc I leave here leaving satisfied but not wowed.. it is fine thought like totally solid diner. I do think for a diner their portions aren't the best in terms of salads mainly. My fav thing is their loaded fries. It's a nice diner though and pretty big and I will definitely be back. My biggest rec is the loaded fries and wings read more

See all

The wait was quick on a busy Sunday- it was pretty packed. Typical diner vibes. We come here occasionally and the service is usually great- this past Sunday our particular server had a hard time understanding us and therefore couldn't make us simple accommodations that we were requesting. It's not the norm though, so it won't really deter us from coming. The food is always consistent and good. The pumpkin pancakes are a fall special and they were really good. The sliders and tacos were both good. The homefries were really big pieces of potatoes that should've been more chopped up/seasoned. We also got lattes- they were good and came with a delish little piece of biscotti. read more

See all

great food for breakfast and dinner,bang bang shrimp tacos are the best,service is great.

This is my favorite diner in the area. The menu has wide range but isn't as dense as your classic diner's, but the menu is still mostly hits and the service is good. I don't have photos of it but my favorite is the big Chopped Salad (romaine, tomatoes, avocado, asparagus, bacon, blue cheese, green apple, grilled chicken). The ingredients taste fresh and balanced. I'm a big fan of their wings for the table as well. Their burger and fries are on the greasier/crispier side, so I prefer the salad, personally. And then the shakes. They have their own menu. (The menu situation is confusing as there are three different menus with multiple copies of each for the table.) Each is as decadent as they look and every time we're here, parents order them for each of their kids and nary a kid finishes them. Not enough chocolate options in my opinion and I haven't found a clear winner on the menu, but I'll keep searching. As a diner, there are many in the area, but this has the best overall menu and the best options. Haste the day when I'm allowed to order their Fish Bowl. read more

See all

My friend and I had heard of this diner's unique offerings and we decided to pay a visit to try them. Everything we had was fantastic and perfectly prepared. She really enjoyed her caramel latte, as did I with my black coffee. Both variants of the French toast were amazing, and the additional toppings really added something interesting to the mix without being overpowering. We opted to get the maple syrup which is an extra $3 each, but it's well worth it. My friend loved her eggs and home fries as well, and only brought some home because she was too full to finish it all. My short rib and egg tacos were phenomenal and we're the perfect blend of breakfast and lunch influences. I absolutely loved it. Customer service here was amazing. The diner was very clean and the staff was accommodating and quick. We never had to look for a staff member when we needed something. I would definitely recommend anyone check them out. It's definitely worth the trip (we came all the way from southern Westchester) and we'll be back for more soon! read more

See all

Classic old school dinner vide nothing special. Great menu a lot of creative items. Started with potato tots with bacon and cheese. Bacon was way over done probably pieces left from breakfast I had chipotle shrimp wrap. Not much chipotle on it kinda boring wrap. Wife ordered south western chicken sandwich. She said it was ok nothing special But let's face it we all come here for there amazing milk shakes. We shared a Brownie milk shake omggggg it was amazing. Drum stick ice cream cone stuffed inside . Shake was little too watery but it was most enjoyable. Our waiter was very good. Hands on and knowledgeable of the menu. Huge parking lot. Prices are not bad. If I return I'll keep it to dessert. They give u chips on side of sandwiches. Chips are little soggy and stuck together but a great concept read more

See all

The severity was extremely patient, when it came to us ordering, the food came out extremely fast as well which was quite impressive. The ultimate nachos were decent, the buffalo chicken egg rolls were were kinda dry, the white hot chocolate was able to be made with almond milk instead of regular milk since I requested it. It actually tasted pretty. The deserts which they are known for in general, didn't really satisfy my sweet craving. Although, recently I kinda been on a sweet decline. The style and environment of this place is awesome though. I definitely plan to come back in the near future to try out there other crazy foods, shakes and desserts. Overall, enjoyed the experience! ( : read more

See all

We truly enjoy this restaurant . Every time I go to a doctor's appointment, I come here because it makes me happy . We also come here to bring friends who are visiting from NYC. They love it too! REPORT CARD Environment A++++ Clean ,spacious and comfortable: Meals A++++ Delicious and plentiful There are so many to chose from . I am getting hungry just thinking of them ! Staff A+++++ Have to compliment all the staff that we met on our visits here .They helped us ! Here they are ; Martha ,Emma , Ally ( They are friendly and helpful ) Managers : Yosselin and Christe ( They manage this place perfectly l ! ) Victor : ( He cleans up so well ). Can't wait to come back here again. read more

Our small party go three got seated right away after a friendly greeting on a Monday early afternoon. The place is rather large with convenient parking. We tried the well reviewed cheesesteak egg rolls which were delicious. I had a side Caesar salad, my companions had the chicken fajitas and burger deluxe. All was quite tasty and we were pleased with our experience. Will definitely be back for lunch and want to try breakfast and their infamous shakes next time. read more

See all

This place is cute if you're experiencing a true diner experience and service level was acceptable. However, the food is not all that. I tried the buffalo chicken wrap and the chicken was way too fried so it tasted more like breading than any chicken. I also split the chicken Caesar wrap with my cousin and that also lacked enough sauce to really taste like a Caesar. We also ordered a milkshake to share, it was again, just ok. It's a very instagrammable place if that's what you're looking for. read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

I went there with my family a couple of times. The food was decent standard American food. There was some wait time but nothing to complain about. The staff are pretty hospitable. It's your standard diner where you go with your family or friends for brunch. However the real star of the show is the milkshakes which makes the place popular. There's a variety of different milkshakes with cake on top of them that you could order. The one I would recommend is the cheesecake milkshake. Little precaution the portions are pretty big but not a bad place to vist if you are in the area read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

Have known about Orangetown for years and years ever since we found Brownstone & Elm Street (it is similar so it pops up as "Places you may like") so we happened to be in the area for the night so we stopped in. The place is cool, open late night - Breakfast all day, Totally our vibe! Kids love the old school diner feel, Menu has many things but it was late night & I just wasnt in the mood for Breakfast. Kids got shakes & Pancakes, eggs all the usual stuff. It was ok! Over the top milkshakes were good, but we are so use to them now they dont WOW us anymore, I know #Fatkidproblems I got the Shrimp Pasta and Im so mad at myself for doing that, Its a diner I should have known better, I mean it was ok, the flavor would have been better if there was just more of it, There was no sauce so it was just dry pasta, but the flavor was there, it just needed more sauce (And I had saw another pic that looked like soup and HOPED that wasnt what it was, and after seeing I had wished I asked for more sauce) Service was meh, food was just ok.. Wouldnt RUSH back but would def try again for breakfast if we were in the area! read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - S'mores Shake - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

Good takeout! The Greek salad was delicious. Kid's menu has a good variety of options and portions were large.

Me and the lads wanted to spend some quality time after a hard working morning. My buddy Joe here had a splendid time!! He would not stop raving about the wings and how his mouth was watering. Overall my mate Beatle from Brixton really felt at home!! read more

I wanted to come here for the crazy milkshakes advertised online, but we decided to make the visit into a lunch outing too before hopping over to nearby Sleepy Hollow. The restaurant has a very classic diner look and I liked the nostalgic feel it gave off. We were seated right away. Service was friendly but a little on the slower side. From my experience, the food I ate was very basic and typically what you would expect from an average diner. I didn't order a very exciting dish, just the southwest crispy chicken sandwich. They do have more unique items on the menu though -- for example, their cheesesteak egg rolls sound delicious. I ordered the funfetti shake for a dessert. The presentation of this milkshake was amazing! Very bright, colorful, and neatly arranged. I wasn't sure if they bake their desserts on-site, but the cake and cake pop included in the milkshake was so sweet and delicious. I am such a sucker for a good vanilla cake. The shake itself was more underwhelming. I wanted more of a vanilla flavor but the overall flavor was a bit dull and not sweet. I overall had a decent experience and enjoyed the novelty of drinking a crazy milkshake. read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Southwestern Crispy Chicken Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

I don't know what's changed but this place is amazing now. The menu has become more streamlined and has PLENTY of gluten free options! The NJ sandwich is amazing and they were able to customize the french toast to be gluten free. Unfortunately, the gluten free items are nowhere near the size of the regular items but they were super tasty nonetheless. The service was a little slow for the place not being packed but still we got everything we needed when requested. All in all, it feels like they streamlined their menu to the best of what they serve! Lots of breakfast options and there's something for everyone! read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - NJ Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

They have the most outrageous milkshakes and hot chocolates! The food is solid and service is quick and friendly. They could have a few more vegetarian options on the menu. Better than your average diner. read more

Food was large portions and yummy. Orders included grilled cheese- chicken and waffles- burrito grande and the breakfast burger. Service was okay- not notably good or bad. Dessert was to die for. We had cheesecake and of course a crazy shake for the kids to share. Can't wait to come back in the winter for the crazy coa coa as a warm up surprise read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Reese's cheesecake - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

The service is great, the place definitely has that classy classic diner experience. Both my wife and daughter had the iced lattes which were good. We all had salad. Classic Greek, qinoa bowl with Salmon and roasted beet and goat cheese for me. All were good, but a bit expensive for lunch (I guess you get what you pay for) The roasted beets seemed a lot like the ones that come out of the can, but since overall, the salad was very good, can't complain. If you go, bring cash as they charge 3% for using a credit card. read more

Food : had a rock or pebble or a stone inside my chicken salad sandwich. GROSS and Disgusting Dirty silverware : asked for clean fork and brought me back another dirty fork Spoon was also dirty and had food stuck on it Dirty plate was brought to me after asking for a clean one Service : came w a lot of attitude and charged me for food I never ordered , brought me the wrong drinks and left it on my check. Added things to my check I didn't order. Also don't bother asking them to fix anything , they are very confrontational as if u are the wrong one read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - See the ROCK In the pic that was in my food and I almost broke my tooth eating this ! - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

Eh, I'll pass. Their pancakes are really appetizing but the cake on top? You're just asking for diabetes. Same with their milkshakes. They're yummy but it's so much that you can't even finish it so essentially you're wasting $15. I ordered the Tex-Mex Eggs Benedict and found out that the chili had pork so I asked if they could just make some regular beef chili. Apparently they couldn't? To be honest, it was New Year's Day, I was hungover and my server spoke under her mask so I couldn't pay attention much. But I ended up getting the regular Eggs Benedict and it was literally two English muffins with eggs and sauce and some potatoes. No arugula, no pepper, no cute presentation like the desserts. Go to Mount Kisco Diner or Elm Street Diner instead. Definitely not worth the trip through the dense fog on the other side of the bridge for this. read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

Not pictured: the Philly cheesesteak egg rolls A definite MUST Served with sweet thai chili sauce Sweet and savory all in one Weekends are typically rather busy, it's a lovely town favorite to go to unwind and get stuffed read more

See all

My bf and I were wanting to go here for about a month because of the wild milkshakes and the Philly cheesesteak egg rolls. The egg rolls were AMAZING! We loved them. The shake was wild and over the top, but my bf wasn't a huge fan. We also ordered an appetizer sampler which was very blah and bland. We also ordered cheese fries and churros that we had to return because they were not appetizing looking at alllllll. We drove an hr to get here and we would MAYBE return....but just for the egg rolls as a pick up order. Our waiter was very nice. The manager was amazing. Very spacious diner. read more

See all

I have wanted to go to this diner forever due to their insane Instagram posts. I finally bit the bullet yesterday and I was not disappointed! I already need to go back because there are so many things I did not get to try. I had the Giant Bavarian pretzel with cheese sauce- phenomenal. For lunch I had a delicious cheeseburger. For dessert, I got the Cookie Dough Milkshake. It was to die for. I wish I lived closer (i live an hour away in NJ), but I will totally go here again! read more

See all

Pretty good diner. We arrived at 10:45am on a Sunday and it was packed! Turnover was quick but I'd go to Yelp and check wait time etc. Great variety and portions are huge. Taste was okay. The Mac and cheese squares were too sweet. The rainbow cake shake was a hit with everyone (three of us shared) but the cake was not for me tasted too doughy like perhaps it was a bit underbaked. If you want to try their many awesome looking desserts, make sure to share entrees. read more

See all

So, I got dragged here against my own will on a weekday night. I was told this was an "upscale" diner and very different than most. As for myself, I've always hated diners. You know how they say, "A jack of all trades is a master of none"? That's how I feel about diners. They make a bunch of things, but nothing ever stands out or tastes amazing. It's just always mediocre. The person I came here with kept raving about these Philly Cheesesteak Egg rolls. I love Phillies, but usually (at least in NY) they're never as good as I'd expect one to be in actual Philly. Or, they're lackluster in flavor, toppings, etc. I was skeptical but they told me to just try it (I actually ordered it go to). By the third bite I was cursing them out for even encouraging me to eat it. Those things were so damn good. It went perfect with the sweet and spicy sauce (I love sweet, rather than tangy/tart/etc). The crust was baked to perfection. The cheese was perfectly melted and stringy. Each one was stuffed with meat and by the 4th out of 7, I was damn near full. I paid about $12.50 for them. The waiter was cool and service was prompt. The place was clean. I'm still dreaming about these egg rolls. I've never liked diners, nor did I know an "upscale" one existed. I'll definitely be back again. The cook oughta be ashamed of him or herself or making something this perfectly delicious. I truly wanted to hate it, so that I could tell the person they were wrong and that this diner sucked like the rest of them. This diner took away my away my right to do so and I don't appreciate it. I'll be back! read more

See all

I love the burger it's super flavorful and juicy. I also like the coleslaw that comes on the side. The milkshake was amazing read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - burgers - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

Drove here following another food blogger. Hot chocolate was picturesque and the omelette made to perfection they make it so you have to comeback to try everything. read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Hot Chocolate like California Ghirardelli hot chocolate. - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York

See all

I have been following this business on social media for a while and couldn't wait to visit. We had the tiramisu French toast and funfetti pancakes and both were delicious. The pancakes came with a large piece of cake on top and boy the cake itself was AMAZING. I also had a chai latte that was perfect so much flavor didn't have to add anything. We can't wait to come back and try the milkshakes. read more

Orangetown Classic Diner - Live music Sunday - Diners Near Me - Orangeburg, New York