Really solid spot in Tottenville. Palermo Pizzeria is super consistent and everything we tried hit - pizza, pinwheels, pasta, all of it. Definitely a go-to Staten Island pizza place! read more

I've been seeing videos all over TikTok to try this place on page Avenue. In multiple videos, the garlic knots come out with two different types of sauce, Marinara and vodka. The garlic knots were just OK nothing to write home about and I was only given marinara. Mine didn't come with vodka sauce, so I was disappointed. Tried a couple of different slices that were recommended on TikTok. They were just OK..again its just like your typical pizzeria definitely not what I thought.and the upside down slice was just ok read more

See all

Food and service excellent, pizza bread placed on table as a starter was great! Baked Clams fried Calamari and Eggplant rollatine super awesome!!! Try this place, nice indoor and heated outdoor seating... read more

See all

Place is nice has an open patio with clear windows and very relaxing. The inside is nice very spacious and cool decor. The pizzas are regular size the taste is good my only pointer is a bit too greasy. But will definitely come again and try your Vodka slice!! read more

Palermo Pizzeria and Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Order my Pizza it came an hour late no problem but when it comes ice cold and they forgot my drink great !!

Fantastic pizza Sauce with just enough to make you want to eat it all at once Service fast clean Open till 10 Recommendation read more

Sicilian, plain and grandma slices are fabulous. Staff couldn't be nicer. Place is spotless and prices are fair. Looking forward to trying their meals. Parking lot is a nightmare, you need a plan B in case you can't park. read more

I cannot say enough about Palermo Pizza. Everything I have ever tried from there is delicious. The food is fresh and tasty. If you like anchovies, the Sicilian specialty Sfincione is my top choice. Their staff is courteous and efficient and if I order delivery it arrives quickly. The place is beautiful, clean and has lots of seating. I highly recommend this place. read more

I don't love their pizza and last time we all got sick from the grandma slices They are also quite expensive compared to other pizza places around here read more

Seriously the food was amazing. The pepperoni pizza was my favorite & the garlic knots were a hit. The price was good too! read more

Palermo Pizzeria and Restaurant - A thick slice of pepperoni pizza, bbq chicken, cheese & garlic notes - it was FANTASTIC. - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Their grandma pie is really awesome. Whoever thought of the idea to add sesame seed on the crust is a genius. Get them and thank me later. The staffs and owner are attentive and fast. Definitely try this lace if you are in the area. read more

The delivery guy is nasty and tells lies about you to the owner. The owner stands up for the delivery guy. The pizzas in my opinion are nasty and very greasy. Don't order the lasagna it is not worth the money. read more

Shout out to service & crew tonight at Palermo's Pizza on Page Ave, Staten Island, NY. Unbelievably fast service, handled a minor error with courtesy & delivered before we even knew the difference at no extra fee. Love this place read more

Excellent food, VIP service and most of all respectful caring people. The owner, his wife and daughter are amazingly friendly and their service is 5 stars. I highly recommend giving them a visit and trying delicious, freshly served food. You will not be disappointed. I can't wait to go back again. read more

This is one of tottenville newest and best pizza stores Everything is always fresh and delicious They can be a little bit expensive but they have great food and large portions The chicken francaise is the best I have had in a long time read more

Palermo Pizzeria and Restaurant - Cover of the menu showing website and phone number - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

This is a place that does not get a lot of love on here. Their pizza is to die for. We had the margarita and an upside down Sicilian. Their crust had a nice crunch to it and their sauce is delicious. They have a very big menu and people come in for full on dinner. Plus they give you zeppoles on them. Wonderful staff and they created a really pretty Italian themed ambiance. Oh it's a BYO! read more

What a piece of junk food, it's made by Italians who don't bathe and the place is dirty and smells horrible.

New owner since my last review. Chicken parm sandwich was good. Sauce a bit sweet. $16 but hero was large. Zeppoles were made too big (size of rice balls) so they were very doughy inside and not good read more

Ordered from here online. Order was prompt and piping hot. We ordered a regular pie, one with half mushroom and half eggplant and a couple of Sicilian rice balls. Pizza was delicious, rice balls came with a cup of marinara sauce and were good too. We'll be returning! read more

Pizza is fine 7/10 but the calamari was a crime. First of all it was all rings no tentacles. The breading had zero seasoning. Worst part: it was so wet/soggy that the whole serving was congealed together. I separated it best I could and put it I. The air fryer to try and dry it /crisp it. Taste: 0 texture: negative 10. Price for this mess: 16$! (On average 3$ more than other local delicious spots) read more

Food aboustely delicious. And the pizza 1 and the delivery drivers are kind. Owners are great

Woww, first time ordering from here and the pizza was delicious! The garlic knots & mozzarella sticks were delicious as well! I would definitely recommend read more

Stellar service!! Young Caroline and Samantha brought so much joy to my father on his birthday! The slices are delicious, garlic knots are perfect, and the service by these ladies are spectacular. They're there to help before you even have to ask. Highly recommend, ask for Samantha at the counter; she seems to be there atleast 6 days a week. Enjoy!! read more

One of my favorite local pizzerias to order from these days. There are very few things I've gotten there that weren't good. We love their grandma pie as it has toasted sesame seeds on the crust which just puts it over the top good. I love their chicken soup and pasta fagioli - but I wouldn't recommend the lentil soup. Their hero's and rolls are huge and fresh. Pickup and delivery are always fairly quick, and prices are reasonable. Overall, I have all great things to say about this local pizzeria! read more

I love this place. It's become my go to pizza spot. I cant get enough of their Upside Down Pie, the Buffalo Chicken Pie, and our new favorite the Chicken Francese Pie. Their rolls and Calzones are fresh, big, and stuffed. No skimping at this place. Highly recommend if you haven't tried Palermo Pizza yet. read more

Palermo Pizzeria and Restaurant - Chicken Francese Pie - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Loved the white pie with artichokes and sesame crust!! Also the baked ziti was delicious!!

Came in for a slice and was treated like family! Best slice I've had in a while. Love this pizzeria, Mille Grazie! read more

Ok so tonight we wanted to order pizza my son said let's try Palermo so I looked at reviews and decided to get the upside down pie... order was late very late and I was starving today I didn't get to eat anything today Anyway there was a mishap with the delivery.. when I no longer wanted the order I called but first I threw a frozen store bought pizza in the oven then called just to let them know I was a little upset about it.. anyway the girl apologized and said she will make a new pie n get it here in 20 min I said no I just threw a frozen shit pie in the oven and as we sat and took a bite of the crappy pie my door bell rang she brought me the pizza anyway and some zeppolies (which are my favorite) she said I couldn't let you eat frozen pizza ... she was so sweet and because of this they will always have a customer also because there pizza was very good!!! Thank you so much for caring about your customers and for not letting me eat my crappy store bought pizza read more

Gave this a try tonight because I had heard good things.... everything we ordered was delicious and perfectly prepared. The sauce on the pan pie and chicken parmigiana was outstanding!! I'm very picky about sauces and I was licking my fingers . The zeppoles were one of the best I've ever had... my family and I will definitely patronize Palermo's for our weekly pizza takeout! read more

Palermo Pizzeria and Restaurant - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

See all

Service at this place is extremely unprofessional and unwelcoming. I would not recommend this pizza place to anyone. The entire place needs to be renovated too and the toilet makes a loud noise for at three minutes after flushing. read more

My daughter and son-in-law order from here all the time and they love it. We were in the area today so we stopped in with my daughter for a late lunch/early dinner. The restaurant is clean. The service is friendly and the food is good. When we arrived, they put on the table, delicious focaccia bread, hot and crispy. The fried calamari was lightly breaded and tender. We really enjoyed it. We also had a margarita pie which was very good and my daughter had a calzone which she enjoyed. Before leaving, they served us three complimentary zeppoles with powdered sugar and a dab of chocolate on it. Good service and nice people. We will definitely be back! read more

Customer service and quality is outstanding ! One of the best spots in Staten Island to have pizza read more

Love the Margherita Pizza - can eat a whole pie. Pizza is always great. Giant garlic knots. I am a regular.

I know I'm about to say something hard to believe, I just had the best sandwich I ever had in my whole life. Grill chicken, fresh Mozz and braccolli Rab with olive oil. I wish this place was closer to my house read more

Wide variety of pizzas offered at this place, from quintessential NY style to Pan Pies. My favorite pizza from Palermo Pizzeria is the Sfincione. It's not easy finding that style of pizza on Staten Island and they make it really well here. Aside from that, I find that their standard NY style pizza doesn't really stand out or set it self apart from the typical generic stuff you can find pretty much everywhere. I do however love the sesame seed crusts on their upside down thin crust Sicilian. The sauce on their pizzas are really tangy, and heavily spiced, which may or may not be your thing. If you like sweet sauce then you will love this place. read more

One of the Best Pizza Resturant's on Staten Island. As soon as you walk in you are greeted with a Smile and Hello. I had a White Slice and the Sfingione. The Sfingione was the Best I ever ate. The very nice girl who worked there brought over for free Two Zeppoles. I will be going back again. read more

One of the best pizza in StatenIsland, open till late, jus love it! People here are very respectful...i thank u for your service.

Great food. Great service. The eggplant parm hero was delicious the bread was so soft. read more

Palermo Pizzeria and Restaurant - Eggplant parm hero. One of the best I have ever had hands down!!! Bread is so soft and tomato sauce great! - Pizza Near Me - Staten Island, New York

Palermo Pizzeria and Restaurant is certainly really terrific. The vibe is great. Each and every single menu item that we have ordered was extremely fresh and yummy. Not to mention, the service was great and the staff was really welcoming. You will not be disappointed! read more

ok so let me start by saying me and my sister started getting texts with specials so we decided to order . so I live in tottenville and she lives on forest hill road. so we both ordered and loved the food and the portion size so she decided she will order every week and meal prep for the week . so the second time she ordered they said I'm sorry but you are too for us to deliver! don't you think you should have known that the first time she ordered. my Husband loves wings so we ordered the wing special and it was good. Today I received a text stating Halloween special $14.99 penne vodka and grilled or friend chicken. So I ordered and they sent me an email confirmation. Then I get a call from palermo so sorry but the price is wrong. I said ok but it's paid for it should be honored cause it wasn't my fault and she said no I'm sorry. So needless to say they lost mine and my sisters business ‍‍ Not a good way to start off a new business guys!! read more

See all