This small pizza establishment is a diamond in the rough. Great pies with great flavor! A friend…read morerecommended NB's Wicked Bah Pizza to us and we thought we would try it out since we were in New Braunfels. Just about a block off the main drag, this little pizza joint has a lot of flavor with a little charm. Keep in mind these are all 10" pies so if you're hungry, one pie per person, but the wife and I decided to share the 10" Garden Goddess special pie as our lunch. The pie was covered in Black olives and boast mushrooms, white onions, bell pepper & pickled red onion toppings with a sweet and spicy honey drizzled around. The spicy honey complimented the pickled onions making this a very flavorful pie. We enjoyed the owner's company as we were the only guest this early Saturday afternoon. Bill the owner, was very friendly and talked to us about the history of the company which actually began in the town I was born in, Brockton MA. Small world!! If you're looking for a great pizza that's not your typical fast food pizza, NB's Wicked Bah Pizza is a must to try. We will definitely be back to try a couple more of Bill's selection of pizzas. OH, and don't forget to grab some desert!!! I had the tiramisu, I'm very picky about Tiramisu and this was a great desert that i will definitely get again.

Me and my girlfriend decided to give this place a go! We wanted to try a new pizza place area the…read morearea and stumbled upon this hole in the wall place. The place had decent parking and was easy to find. Once we arrived inside we were quickly greeted with amazing customer service. The place was small and had a family friendly feel to it, and the employees had great energy. Our server helped us out with the menu and recommended the Egg-roll of the week. Which was like an Italian Sub Egg Roll. It was amazing! We also ended up ordering a pizza. Which the server also recommended his favorite the 10" Wicked Roni. Which had Pepperoni, onion, fresh jalapeno & a spicy honey drizzle. Once the pizza arrived we were a little saddened by the size of the pizza, since it was so small. But it does say 10", so be prepared for the size. The only issue that I had for this place and the reason why it lost a star, was because of the bland flavor of the pizza. Maybe it was just off that day, but there was hardly any flavor in the pepperoni or the jalapeños. They weren't even spicy at all! It was as I lost my taste while eating the pizza. Which was a little disappointing because the egg-roll was amazing! But we will definitely want to give this place another shot, because of how great the customer service was and how great the egg-roll was. We will try another pizza next time!

Loved the Margherita Pizza! Our waitress, Taylor, made a special mocktail for my daughter and she…read moreloved it. Pizza chips are a great appetizer or meal. Sat/Sun mimosa/Bloody Mary drinks at affordable prices. I highly recommend this pizza restaurant. Sorry no pics it was that damn good

The environment was great (nice & clean), my waitress was amazing! My Blackberry Mule was…read moredelicious. Where things fall short is the product itself ... the pizza , thin ass crust and hardly any sauce. So for the pizza itself a hard NO Drinks and side items a hard MAYBE

It is New Years' Eve; they were busy, understandably. We…read moreordered and paid online and were told the pizza wouldn't be done at 6:45 but at 7:15-7:20. The wait was a bit frustrating but the pizza (a large supreme with extra cheese-not overly evident) was VERY GOOD! Crust was well done and not too thick. The ingredients were fresh and the flavors were spot on. We will definitely order again.

It's been awhile since I've been here, but it's one of my favorite spots. On this day I felt a…read morecraving for some pizza and this place never disappoints. "New York Pizza Pub", is great, the pizza, the calzones and everything else is amazing. The pizza I had was delicious and just the right amount of crunch on the crust and I had the Garlic Cheese Bread which was amazing. The service is always top notch. Sufficient seating and a good vibe to the place.

Downloaded Yelp JUST to give this place 5 stars. Absolutely freakin' delicious pizza Might just be…read morethe best pizza I've ever had. I can't believe I wish I had known of this place sooner, but I will be coming back whenever I come up to NB in the future.

Great food great customer service and not to overpriced. Also pet friendly! Outdoor seatingread more

We had an event with Crust pizza and everything was amazing. Melanie and her partner were great to…read morework with. They were so kind! I never thought I'd like cauliflower pizza but this was amazing!! Crust Pizza might have turned me into a cauliflower pizza gal. We had salad and cookies too and man do they know how to make a good cookie! Had a great time with Crust Pizza

Ordered takeout, service was brief but very kind staff upon walking in and receiving my food…read more First looks inside and there was plenty of seating. We ordered: The Big Dons 14" Buffalo sauced wings And a caesar salad. Pizza was pretty good, plenty of seasoning & flavor though I must say, once cold, the toppings & cheese slid right off of the crust. Had a good undercarriage and well made for a thin crust. Buffalo wings were pretty good though we had a few of drums that had shattered bones so that was kinda disappointing. Flavor was pretty good, wish they offered a spicier version. Good vinegar kick so bonus points on that. Salad was... OK. For $9 we expected better / more for it not being the $5 "side" portion.

Haven't tried bosses in a long time. We ordered to go medium pepperoni and extra green peppers. We…read morewanted a salad and the woman let us know it would be better to order the large salad. Salad had fresh, crisp lettuce, lots of mozzarella cheese and plenty of croutons. Enough to feed 4 people. We had Caesar dressing on the side. The pizza looked like the crust could've been allowed to brown up a bit. Even though we ordered double green peppers it didn't look like it. The pizza was ok I don't think I'll be ordering from here in the future, it just wasn't as flavorful as I wished it would be. The place is huge and was really busy . It also has a lot more than pizza,...burgers, wings.and more. I'd like to come back and have a burger here and onion rings since they looked really good. The woman at the cash register and who answered the phone sounded kind and friendly despite being bombarded with customers. There was another woman behind a register who wasn't attending to customers, possibly she was a server? Not sure but I'll give her the benefit of the doubt.

burger, 10/10 actually a really good and very filling burger. The wings and pizza are okay, nothing…read moreto go crazy over. Service is also ok they do seem to make small mistakes quite often but it looks like it's always on the kitchen side, the cashiers out front are always very nice. As far as the place goes, it really needs a deep cleaning. Everything in the drink side is sticky tables and floors always seem to have trash. Overall, good place stopped coming here for a while, but recently started giving them a try again.

Been here a few times but haven't done a review yet. The pizza here is delish. And love their…read morespecialty pizzas. My husband loves the wine country one and I have a few faves. The pig & pear and the Billy goat and bbq chicken. Gina try the veggie tonight. Very good and would highly recommend this place for pizza.

We stumbled upon this place when we were in the area and noticed that it had great reviews and we…read morehadn't had pizza in a while. Once we arrived, parking was decent since it was located in a shopping center, and once we walking inside the atmosphere had a new age pizza vibe. We ended up ordering the pizza rolls (which were highly recommended by the employee) and the 14" Billy Goat Pizza, which came with garlic olive oil, shredded mozzarella, caramelized red onions, bacon, grape tomatoes, goat cheese. We also ordered 2 fountain drinks. With a military/first responder discount it ended up being around $47. Once the food came out it was amazing! The pizza rolls were delicious and the Billy Goat was one of the best pizza's I've had in New Braunfels. The only issue I had and why the review lost a star, was that we waited so long. Almost 30 min sitting there before our rolls came out and another 10-15 min after for the pizza. I did see orders coming out repeatedly for pickup and delivery, but the dining area was pretty empty and not one person checked up on us or gave us a time frame until after the food came.

Awesome place to eat, pizza salads and atmosphere were fantastic, I will definitely be back to…read moreenjoy again

Was looking for a place to get some good pizza in the New Braunfels area, and one came to mind…read more Calahan's Pub and Pizza came up and I'm so glad it did, it was exactly what I wanted. But first, depending on what is going on in downtown, parking can be tricky to find. Upon entering the establishment you find a pretty good amount of seating. A kinda of bar feeling but still welcoming for families. You have the option to sit in the main room or the side room with a pool table to enjoy. As you choose your meal you go to the counter and let them know what you'll have to eat. The personnel at the counter are extremely helpful and considerate, answer any questions you might have about the food you are thinking about. They give you a number that you place on your table, and as they bring you your meal again that cordial attitude is on display. After being treated kindly, the next thing is the food. And to be honest the food was brought out and going on the first appearance was very pleasing. Now the taste, I first ordered the "Housemade Dough Bites" at first thought I didn't think it was going to be worth it. But I was completely wrong, these bites were delicious, crunchy and very flavorful and the dipping sauce brought out the taste of the bites. The next item was some chicken wings in a medium sauce with ranch dressing and some celery sticks, they too tasted great, good amount of meat and flavor. The last thing was the star of the meal, the pizza. I got the "Butcher's Block" specialty pizza, and it didn't disappoint, the different meats and the sauce was excellent. This is by far one of my favorites. So if you're looking for a good pizza place, you can't go wrong with "Calahan's".