We just moved to OKI and wanted pizza. We tried out Pepperoni Grill. It was tasty, could have stayed in the oven a bit longer and used more seasonings but all in all very good. I would order from them again. read more

I was looking for the best pizza on Oak Island. This place had great reviews and came up as #1 on yelp. We were not disappointed. We had 50 wings and 4 pizzas. Everything was delicious. The crust was wonderful. A young member of our group told me he usually does not eat pizza crust, but this pizza crust was great and he ate all of it. He is also from PA/NY area so he knows what good pizza is. The wings were also large and cooked perfect. We did take out. They have seating inside, but the area is small. I will be back. A local in the area told me this place has the best NY style pizza in all of the Wilmington area. I cant confirm that, but this place is great and will be our new "go to" for pizza. read more

Best pizza outside of New York. Eat here every time we come to the island. The crust is fresh and has amazing flavor. Ordering online is so easy. read more

We look forward to our visit each time we visit the island! The food is always delicious and the staff is always friendly. Can't complain and already looking forward to the next time! read more

Great food! absolutely delicious pizza and wings. Couldnt have asked for any improvement in any area.

Being from NJ, where pizza is a staple, PG puts out one of the better ZA's in the area. Two locations , OKI and BSL.

Super sweet people. Introduced themselves right as you walk in the door. They take the time to explain the entire menu to you. Pizza by the slice but a ton of non-pizza options also, salads, pastas, sandwiches, etc. The pizza is New York style - choose your slice and they heat it back up. The pizza was delicious - I had veggie. Great crust. Lots of people were coming in and buying lots of pizzas to go. Mozzarella sticks not very good - definitely frozen and store bought or food service bought. My 6 year old likes them though :) They gave us garlic knots even though we didn't order them and they were great! All in all, a darling beach pizza place with super nice folks. read more

See all

Best. Pizza. I've. Ever. Had!! Really long wait but it was a Saturday night we waited alittle over an hour for our pizza but holy moly I would've waited three for how amazing that pizza was! Hands down incredible read more

Best carnivorlicious calzone! When I'm hungry I always run to here! Hard working staff too!

Best pizza in the area! Service is fast even when busy. Very casual with good grab and go!

Great food, friendly staff, good prices and fast service. Had the garden pizza. Awesome flavor!! Highly recommend this place!! read more

Excellent pizza. Would have been 5 stars but the sausage for the calzone wasn't very good.

Got the Margherita pizza and it was really good. My only critique was that the crust was a bit gummy towards the center of the pizza, not really crispy for being a homemade thin crust. Garlic knots were also pretty good but a bit bland. They did need some extra seasoning or cheese. But overall, pretty good. read more

Got the lasagna pizza and it was delicious, knocked a star off because I called in order and they told me 45 minutes which was fine but ended up being 1.5 hours. Delicious though, will get again maybe when it's not so busy read more

Walked up a little confused but a guy inside came out and gave me a menu and told us where to order. We got the white pizza , garlic knots, and Mac & cheese bites and were HIGHLY satisfied. I would recommend this place 10/10. Super friendly and GREAT food! read more

Best pizza and Italian food on the island! I get pizza from there every couple of weeks

Horrible food. Horrible service. Ordered the margarita pizza and there was no fresh basil as in menu description, but small specs of dried basil. All the food my family ordered tastes bad and no one really ate it tasted so bad. We ordered a steak and cheese and there was cut up brown lunch meat on there, not steak. I really don't know how this place received good reviews. We are sad to have wasted our money. read more

Pepperoni Grill - Speck of dried basil (supposed to be fresh basil per menu description), margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

See all

I ordered the cheese & vegetable pizza. If you like a firmer pizza, this is your joint. I like a softer pizza crust. Taste of the pizza was fine. The marinara was ok. Mom had the calzone, it was a little bland. Place decor was nice but I have to say, my window view would have been nicer without the flies bothering me! read more

Pepperoni Grill - Small cheese & vegetable pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

My parents and I have stayed at OKI several times now and this trip we happen to be staying at a house just a few miles from this place so we decided to try it when we didn't feel like cooking but also didn't feel like going to a sit down restaurant either. We got the vegetable garden pizza, a small Greek salad (with balsamic dressing because they didn't have Greek), and a large grilled chicken spinach salad (with honey mustard dressing), all to-go. We all found the food acceptable, edible, not bad, but not amazing either - sort of mediocre for the price (not terribly expensive but, as with most places at the beach, a little overpriced) Further, they didn't have quite enough space for the amount of people there (we were there in the early evening on a rainy Monday, so I'd hate to imagine the crowd on a Friday or Saturday evening) and though we only ended up waiting 20 minutes they originally told us it would be a 35 minute wait so if you're in a hurry and there's a crowd this might not be the best place (although you could order ahead of time I suppose, and they do deliver, even to the beach!). However if you do find yourself waiting, and can find a place to sit, they do have a nice view - nothing like a pier view, of course, but you can see the ocean over the dunes so you know you're still at the beach. So, while the food wasn't the best ever, the convenient location and glimpse of the ocean make it a place we'll probably try again when we don't feel like cooking or going to a fancier restaurant. read more

See all

Pizza was ok. Decent price. Not too greasy. Pretty tasty. No ice in the machine in the middle of summer but ok....wait staff not super attentive but they did look like a bunch of high schoolers. Might be a little more enthused if I would have gotten a different pizza but that's not their fault... read more

It was just ok pizza for me. Very greasy. I did like the thinner crust. They offer gluten free which is nice. I would go back to try something else. read more

Yuk. Long wait. Hardly any cheese, there was 1.5 pepperonis on each piece. Was the driest pizza I've ever had. Skip it.

Lasagna Pizza: "Mamas Lasagna on top of an Extra Cheesy Pie." ...but it's actually just the ingredients of their lasagna on a pizza. when it arrived, i wasn't even sure i received the correct item. called and was told "it's a little misleading." yeah, a little. you should probably change that. everything else was fine. not awful but i probably won't return because i won't know if i'll actually get what the menu says. read more

Pepperoni Grill - "lasagna" pizza ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ - Pizza Near Me - Oak Island, North Carolina

I have always loved Pepperoni Grill pizza. I have always recommended them and given them 4 or 5 ratings. However, I picked up a pizza on Monday that was real "average". I hope it was just an off day. If it happens next time, I will be trying someplace else. read more

If I could give a zero review it would be too much. The worst pizza I ever had . After a bit I had to throw the whole pizza away. Not edible. read more

Been eating here as long as they have been open & am sick of the inconsistency of the food. Management does not care.

We did takeout. Pretty straightforward order. Mozzarella sticks and a pepperoni pizza. Order was ready promptly when we arrived and service was quick and friendly. Unfortunately the food just wasn't that impressive. The mozzarella sticks were decent but generic. The pizza just wasn't good. The sauce was a bit sweeter than I like and the cheese was tasteless. The crust was tough on some parts of edges and soggy in the middle. Bad crust is a pizza sin I cannot abide. Unless you are desperate for pizza or just looking to eat a pie outside very close to the ocean I'd look elsewhere. It's a pity really. With what seems to be a friendly staff and a wonderful location all they need to do is up their food quality a bit. read more

Pepperoni Grill is a life saver! When all the island restaurants are packed with 1.5 hours waitlists, this is the "go to" place! Dine in or they do deliver. It's got a great location right across from the beach with indoor and outdoor seating. Seating is limited, but turnover is pretty quick. Inside, behind the counter is a large chalkboard wall with the menu on it. They have 3-4 beers on tap and I was very impressed to see Ballast Point Sculpin Grapefruit IPA. You know the drill, order, pay, take a number and find a seat. The only thing that bugged me on my first visit was that in an uncrowded place with plenty of staff, I had to wipe down my own table with napkins. I did so slowly and deliberately, hoping someone would say "oh let me do that" but no one ever did. My garden Calzone was pretty tasty, the Greek Salad was nothing special, the Eggplant Parmesan Sub was very good and their pizza was good as well. One night I ordered the Lasagna Pizza = wow! Really great stuff but super heavy and rich! Tons of meats and cheeses! read more

See all

Food was pretty good, but not including any napkins or utensils in the order is a negative.

First night at Oak Island. We wanted something quick ti satisfy the crew. Saw this place and read some reviews. Decided to go for it. Call several times because the line was busy. Finally got through. Honestly incredible. A great variety and delicious. We will definitely be back. Will be our first stop every year from now on. Update: we ordered a bunch of subs for delivery later in the week. Let me say, AMAZING. the subs were awesome, and delivery was exactly when they said they would arrive. Highly highly highly recommend!!! read more

Just an update. As we had feared, our credit card was double charged again (third time in roughly a year), despite the condescending tone of the girl behind the counter that all would be ok. Never, ever, ever order from this restaurant's website. Every time we do, the CC gets processed but our order never does. We actually have to go down to the restaurant because they shut their phones down (defeats the purpose of online ordering for delivery) where we are met with a "well, we're busy." This time we were actually ridiculed for using THEIR website to order. On an island as small as Oak Island, delivery options are limited. Next time we'll just drive to Wilmington. It will actually be faster and the people are actually competent and appreciate your business. Unless you have an extra half hour to dispute duplicate charges EVERY TIME you order with your credit card, you better pay with cash at this dumpster fire of a business. read more

Wow I was shocked by the lower rating. We ordered delivery from pepperoni grill on Memorial Day and it arrived within 45 minutes. Our order consisted of 2 small pizzas. One was pepperoni and the other was Hawaiian and we also ordered 12 Mango Tango wings. This was plenty for our family of four and everyone loved everything! We will be back! read more

Very cute and quaint location. If you're at the beach and looking for a quick bite The Pepperoni Grill is the place to go! The food was DELICIOUS! They have a variety of items to choose from to meet everyone's taste buds. I had a Stromboli. It was huge! Worth every penny. There are beer and wine options or fountain drinks. Inside and outside seating. Not far from the water at all. The staff was very nice and accommodating. Will definitely return the next time I visit Oak Island. read more

Wow! Quick delivery! Food that should be hot was hot. The salad and cannoli we're separate and cold. Generous portion of chicken parmesan, pizza was great. Will order from them again! read more

Best place around to get some awesome pizza, salad, and garlic knots! Food comes out hot and fresh!

Pizza tasted like cardboard and cheese steak tasted like roast beef and cheese was burnt to the bread.

Great little pizza shack, very good service, great homemade crust, huge menu! Indoor and outdoor seating . Lots of business on a Sunday night. Everyone friendly! read more

The garlic knots can best be described as simultaneously overdone and raw at the same time. Not worth the hype at all. The wings were way over done as well. Pizza was okay. read more

Great food. Not great customer service or Togo services. I was looked at like i was crazy when I asked if my Togo had ranch in it. I was handed one with an attitude so I bought two more cups, then got to my car to find no napkins or untensils for my stomboli. Went back in yet again another attitude when I asked where I could get untensils. I've been a waitress for 15 years I know what customer service looks like and it's not this place. read more

Excellent NY style pizza. Several kinds to choose from. Everything I have tried has been delicious. Service has always been great. This place strives to satisfy their customers read more