One of the best pie places for banana cream pie, chocolate cream pie, and lemon meringue pie. The crusts are slightly salty with a great texture. Not too sweet and a perfect dessert that doesn't make you feel as heavy. read more

Vibe/ambiance: small local pie shop Service: standard Items ordered: guava marscapone: 7/10; seasonal flavor. i usually love guave desserts but this was a little too tart for me read more

This is a cozy place we happened to stumble upon after dinner. They have a good selection of pies and the staff is very helpful with giving recommendations and answering questions. I got the nyc chocolate chess pie because it's one of their specialties. Nyc Chocolate Chess Pie- Crust is buttery and flaky. The pie base is moist with a rich chocolate flavor and just the right amount of sweetness. A must try! Great experience overall, would love to try their other flavors. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

My friend brought me here and I had the banana cream pie, it was so good. She got the strawberry rhubarb pie. The server was so nice and gave us ice water since it was a heatwave that day! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Strawberry Rhubarb Slice - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Yum! What an amazing pie shoppe in the LES. I went here on an evening night and picked up a selection of slices to share with friends. They were excellent! My personal favorite was the seasonal strawberry rhubarb. Not too tart, lots of sweetness from the strawberries and the star was the crust - moist and oh so buttery. The service was excellent. I got lots of recommendations on the regular and seasonal pies and he was more than happy to give me extra cutlery for my friends. The shoppe is small but perfectly suited for the neighborhood. Will definitely swing by the next time I'm hankering for dessert. read more

See all

Pies normally aren't my go-to dessert when I'm craving a sweet treat, but I did so enjoy the bakes here at Petee's that, on top of the slice I ordered, I took several more home! The blueberry pie was fantastic. The filling was perfectly jammy and the crust both crisp and tender. The chocolate pie was pure heaven: decadently silky, not too rich or overpowering, and delightfully sweet. It reminded me of a soft brownie. The pecan pie was marvelously custardy! Again, I don't often crave pies, but I'll surely return to Petee's when I have the chance. read more

See all

We ordered a variety of pies from here for a team event and WOW, truly unforgettable. The fan favorite across the office was the blueberry crumble... still dreaming about that one. We didn't get to see the shop since everything was delivered straight to our office, but I'll definitely be stopping by in person to pick up pies for our Thanksgiving dinner. Honestly, peak adulthood is having a go-to bakery and even better when the pies are this good. And the funny part? We basically ordered the whole menu because everyone had a completely different "favorite" flavor but everyone tried a little of each and had NO complaints. Some weren't even pie lovers and LOVED a few flavors. What other pie company is turning pie haters into "pie is better than I thought"??? read more

See all

This pie spot in Delancey is their perfect spot for some cozy pie. When you walk-in, it smells absolutely heavenly. The inside of the shop has limited seating and is mostly made for grab-and-go. They also have a variety of pies on display, but you can get slices in little boxes to enjoy! I got their seasonal blueberry and apple pies, and they were both delicious. I thought the apple pie was a bit too sweet for me, but I thoroughly enjoyed the blueberry one. Not normally the biggest fan of pies, but these were good! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The chocolate chess pie was so good an decadent. Wish I could've tried more flavors, but my friends only wanted one slice--everything looked so good! The crust was nice and flaky. Open late so perfect for a dessert after a dinner in LES. Some bar stools, but they were all taken Friday ~9:30, so we stood outside and ate it there. Cashier was very nice. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Salty Chocolate Chess Slice - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Not surprised by $8/slice since I'd seen the reviews but was surprised by how thin the slice was. Think of the height of a pizza slice with some bulky toppings and that's what we initially compared it to. And since the flavor wasn't something amazing, wouldn't make special trip to come here. But since there are nice variety of options and staff was friendly can see why it's popular. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered 3 different pies for a party for my colleague who likes citrus desserts - lemon chess, key lime meringue, and guava mascarpone. The Lemon chess was my favorite - it was so good, perfect tartness balanced with a little sweetness. The crust was really good. Next was the guava mascarpone - so tasty and creamy, not too sweet. My least favorite was the key lime - out of the 3, it was by far the sweetest which is probably why I liked it the least, however it was still really good. The coconut crust is a nice treat. All the pies were a big hit with my group. I'd recommend any of these 3. My delivery came on time and everything was packaged nicely so all the pies looked perfect after removing them from their boxes! read more

See all

Great variety of pies Have gone here multiple times to get a nice late night dessert since they are open pretty late which is nice Service is great. The interior is also super cute and has a nice homey feel to it The line is sometimes long when I go and they've sold out. Recommend the chocolate pies! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Ordered a quartet of mini pies from Petee's, and was impressed with the quality ingredients and flavors that shone despite the rough cross country shipping to Cali. Black bottom Almond Chess, Sour Cherry, Hudson Valley Apple, and Blueberry were my favorites in that order. The Almond Chess is a unique flavor, was beautifully topped with slivered almonds, and possessed a wonderfully balanced flavor that perfectly harmonized the custardy chess, chocolate base and almond notes. Sour cherry was also a winner with wonderfully tart berries amply stacked into the crust. The Hudson Apple features succulent, well seasoned apples that are also generously portioned for a pleasing fruit to crust ratio. The Blueberry mini pie was my least favorite because I found that the crust ratio was too high and I didn't get enough blueberry flavor in each bite. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Mini pie assortment - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I'm usually not a pie person, but I tried their Guava Mascarpone Pie for the first time and fell in love with it. The guava and cheese pair so well together on top of a crumbly, delicious pie crust! Plus, the pie was gorgeous, with pretty flowers on top. I'd recommend bringing it as a dessert to someone's house or birthday, as it's sure to be a crowd-pleaser. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Guava Mascarpone Pie - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I had a sweet tooth so I decided to try out two slices of pie at this cute spot. Ordered through delivery, so can't comment on service or ambiance. - Key Lime Pie: 10/10 (mouthwatering slice of key lime pie. The pie itself was the perfect balance of sweet and sour, and the cream on top added creaminess to the dish.) - Banana Pie: 100/10 (LOVEDDD this pie omg it lives rent free in my head. Not too heavily sweet, which I appreciated. Loved the banana slices in the pie.) Overall, this is a wonderful place to go to when you need a quick fix of sweet tooth. Will definitely be back to order more pies! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Key Lime Slice - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Amazing pies as usual. Every time i come here they are very friendly and informative. Never had a bad experience.

Got lost in NYC and found the most delish Pie shop! One bite of the Cherry Crumble and immediately ordered another slice! When I telll you it smells like grandmas house two days befor Christmas when she's making all the desserts lol read more

See all

Food: The pies are delicious here! My favorite is the Wild Maine Blueberry Pie. Everything about the pie is perfect from the buttery crust to the blueberry filling. It's not overly sweet either. The blueberries are so fresh. The apple, pecan, and chocolate pies are also excellent, but I would highly recommend the blueberry if it's available. Service: Staff are friendly and helpful. Ambiance: The store is very small with no seating so you just order and take your pies to go. Overall, I would highly recommend this pie place! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum yum!! what now to say about PETEES PIES!? they're PUE! can't beat it. believe me. i know pie. go get some read more

The moment you walk into this bakery, you're hit with the warm, irresistible smell of butter it's so good. Every pie slice I've tried so far has been absolutely delicious. This time, I asked for a slice of blueberry to go. I do wish it had the crumble topping, but that's on me for not asking. The staff is friendly, and while it's a grab-and-go kind of spot, the quality makes it feel special every time. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Wild Maine Blueberry Slice - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Came here on a Sunday night with a group of 10 people. Most ordered the key lime meringue pie which they loved. They did say the pie itself was thicker than other key lime pies. I ordered and shared the apple crumb and the brown butter honey pecan slices. I love apple pie and the apple crumb was good but definitely had better. It could do with a little more cinnamon and also more apple slices in the filling, not all sweet since sweet and tart apples together would make the apple flavor a lot more balanced, instead of all sweet. The brown butter honey pecan one was filled with pecans and had a good crunch and flavor. The staff, even though it was close to closing, were so so patient and kind. They explained what pies they had left, which was limited but we also understood it was close to closing. Cute little place on Delancey with a few spots to sit and eat at. I do want to come back and try their other pies, like the chocolate chess one since a lot of people seem to love that one. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

My favs are pumpkins, banana, and wild berry. The staff is always easy to talk to about recommendations. Enjoy

Had this bookmarked for sooo long and just happened to be in the area after lunch! I'm a cheesecake lover so I just had to get the cheesecake but I definitely had to get a pie as well. I got the banana cream pie. The first few bites - AMAZING. The banana cream was so good, and so fresh. The crust and banana cream went so well together. I didn't even know banana cream could be made into a pie but honestly it was the best I've ever had. I did think the whipped cream was a bit much but it was light so that was fine. I did wish the banana cream was more though given that it was $8 per slice. The cheesecake was pretty average, but then again why would you get cheesecake at a pie place right? All in all this is a pretty solid spot for pie. I'm def going back to try the other pie flavors when I get the chance! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Stellar pecan pie. I wish more pie by the slice places existed in nyc. Would come back to try many other flavors read more

Petee's Pie Company - Pecan pie - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered: Banana Cream Pie (~$8/slice) Aya's take: Finally stumbled across Petee's Pie! It was around 9pm and they still had a good amount of flavors available. The Banana Cream Pie joins fresh bananas, whipped cream, and a baked pie crust. The fresh banana and custard part was delicious while the whipped cream portion was a bit too much. I would've preferred those ratios be swapped. All in all, a great try and nice sweet treat to share after dinner. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Banana Cream Pie (~$8/slice) - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

I was looking for a good blueberry pie for thanksgiving and finally find it at this place! I ordered the Wild Maine Blueberry 9" pie and was surprised by how good it tasted. While the crust part was a bit or not much for some people, I actually found it to be perfect as I enjoy eating the pie fillings and less of the pie crust. This pie was filled with blueberries and it tasted very fresh and not too sweet. Just a very well made blueberry pie that's beyond decisions. Pick up process is quick and easy. I can't wait to try the other pies from this place! read more

See all

WOW. I had a sweet tooth at 9:30pm on Friday night & ended up.m trying Petee's! I'm not a huge pie person but the Lavish Chocolate Cream Slice & Banana Cream Slice were AMAZING. Very rich, flavorful, and delicious. I took mine to-go but there's a little bit of seating in the restaurant. The cashier was nice & when asked about her recommendations, she confirmed that these 2 were great choices for a first visit. Next on the list: the apple crumb! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Lavish Chocolate Cream Slice - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Recently picked up the cherry and blueberry pies for Thanksgiving. Both were tasty but the Blueberry pie was AMAZING. As soon I took the first bite I knew I found a perennial desert to enjoy alone or impress friends at gatherings with. The folks working there were quite nice and efficient as well. read more

Came here on a Friday around 930pm with a friend to get some dessert. As we were walking to the door we said "Sorry" to a worker that was coming out with some trash. She basically rolled her eyes at us and scowled and said something I can't remember. It really rubbed us the wrong way. We ended up getting the banana pie and the e guava pie. Both of ours did not have any bottom crust which was my favorite part, making the pie pretty heavy. I will say, the guava came through through! The cashier was also friendly, it was like night and day between the other worker. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

This is a tiny place with some bar stools along with storefront windows. We came in after seeing the good reviews and we were definitely not disappointed. We got two slices- the chocolate and guava marscapone. They were both delicious and light and fluffy. The chocolate pie definitely hit the spot and we finished it right away. It actually complemented the guava marscapone very well which was a bit more tangy and less sweet. Overall, it was just what we wanted. read more

I was unfortunately not a huge fan of the pie. It was served cold, tasted stale, and really had no distinct flavor. It just tasted sweet, with no brown butter or pecan taste. The pecans were stale as well. The place is pretty small, but it's not a bad space for a quick bite with a small group. The workers were really nice as well. I was hoping the pie would be better, but maybe I just had a bad slice too read more

Petee's Pie Company - Brown Butter Honey Pecan Slice - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

My first visit was a friend wanting something sweet. We ordered the coconut cream pie, we planned to share a piece. Upon the first bite I knew that I no longer wanted to share. We had to go back and get my friend her own piece. I will say I did let get a taste, she agreed she needed to get her own slice. The Pies are amazing. read more

This is a pie spot that offers a variety of pie flavors (slice or whole). It ranges from classic fruity pies like Berry Dream to more on the sweet tooth with their Chocolate Sea Salt pies or if you are feeling adventurous like Guava Mascarpone. Yes, these are actual pies they have available and some are seasonal so I recommend trying their Summer's pie selection. I briefly stopped by before heading to a restaurant for dinner to see which pie flavor I was carving afterwards and the lady was kind to show the menu and what was available. I assured her that I will come back which I did so order an Apple Crumbled slice. The Apple Crumbled was quite delicious and room temperature meaning it is not hot and fresh. So ask the cashier if you could put it in the oven to slightly warm it up since it is already baked, set at room temperature, and packaged. The space is very cozy and you see behind the counter all what goes into making, baking, and cooling the pies. It's quite exciting to see them get it and bring a slice ready to eat at their outdoor seating or on the go. The people who work there are very kind and easy going but know exactly what they need in providing great customer service. I highly recommend bringing friends who enjoy a pie slice or get a whole pie to enjoy with a large group. Also they have a beautiful selection of decorative pies on display that are quite eye-catching before taking a bite read more

See all

Not only are the pies exceptional, the staff are absolutely lovely! Definitely make a point to stop in

For Thanksgiving this year, I decided to order pies rather then grabbing something from the supermarket. After doing research, Peete's was said to be the it place to pick up pies for the holidays. Since it's crazy busy with so many pies being picked up, they set up a pie pick up in the basement of Essex Market. A little annoying as it was raining pretty bad but whatever, no biggie. Brought the apple to Friendsgiving, followed the instructions to heat up & we served with fancy ice cream. Thoughts on the pie: I am an apple pie girl to my core so I've had many in my day. This was good, not going to say it's not but was it the best apple pie I've had? No. I really liked that the crust was thin, but a little too thin in the bottom, was hard to get it out of the tin. For the filling, it wasn't "stewed" enough. Just kind of apples with cinnamon. I wanted them more caramelized & gooey. Pretty basic but okay solid. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Apple Pie - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Some of the best pie i've ever had in my life, but absolutely ridiculous pricing. $11 for a single slice of pie and $60 for a whole pie is literally sacrilegious. this is the joke people are always making about nyc and they fall right into the cliche. shame read more

Lots of options and friendly staff. Loved the guava pie and blackberry pie. Very refreshing! read more

Petee's Pie Company - Guava Mascarpone Slice - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Came in on a late afternoon. There was a crowd, but we were able to get some counter space to dine-in. Tried three different pie slices: Hudson Valley apple crumble, wild Maine blueberry, and farm fresh pumpkin. The pumpkin wasn't anything special. Nothing that stood out to make it cost ~$7. The blueberry was fresh, and the pie crust was flakey, but there was barely any sugar. Therefore, a little bit blander. Apple crumble had to be my favorite. The apples were warm, the crumble was buttery and had a good blend of spices, and it was sweetened perfectly. We asked for the pies to be reheated since we were eating there. They normally just come pre-sliced in individual plastic containers. read more

Petee's Pie Company - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

After enjoying a delicious pizza, I wanted to eat something sweet. I checked Yelp to see if there was a place that had a unique dessert. Petee's has a wide variety of pies. I made my way down town and found parking around the corner. I walked in and was greeted by a sweet lady working behind the counter. I am a big fan of lemon and normally opt in for lemon flavors, but I saw that they make a coconut custard pie. I've never had a coconut custard pie. I was intrigued and asked for a slice. They have a bit of bar-style seating on the inside. They also sell merchandise like shirts, coffee, and mugs. The pie had a light crust; it was like a cross between 3 leches and a coconut pie. It was absolutely delicious. I wanted to try another pie, but I needed to practice self-control as it was already 10:30 p.m. I love that they're open late because back in my state, there's not many late night dessert places aside from ice cream. I will be back when I'm in town; the lemon meringue is calling my name. read more

See all

I came here with a friend on a Thursday night for a sweet treat. There are about four stools at the counter inside and a few small tables outside, but all the pie slices are pre-packaged and made to-go. I wish there was more room to relax and eat, but oh well. I had a slice of the apple crumble pie. The filling and crumb top were both wonderful. read more