The combination of their sauce and cheese is perfect. Sometimes I feel like so many pizza places are way too heavy with the cheese. This was a perfect combination. The taste of their sauce is between tangy and sweet. read more

We ordered a pizza at 4:43 and they still haven't put it in the oven at 7pm. They also didn't reach out to us, we only found out because the poor door dash guy had to wait around for our pizza that was never made read more

First time here, ordered a slice of pepperoni and Sausage for carry out and it was very tasty...will return!

Best vegan pizza I've ever had. Hands down. Service was fast and accurate. Everything is tasty and perfect.

The spot to go in the grove for a quick slice or a whole pie! Their slice/salad combo is great. The sausage pizza was delish and so was the salad. Full of flavor! *claps read more

See all

Holy freakin Pie Guy!!! Run, don't walk! This is some serious pizza!!! Chopped salad? Yes please! Lil sausage with some hot honey??? Yaaaassss please times a billion. The floor is prime for dancing too.... read more

Possibly the best pizza place in saint louis. Huge slices, now with a bar/beer as well.

Excellent, reasonably priced pizza by the slice. They are attached to Gezellig and it's a perfect pairing with beer. You can either pick one of their pre-made slices or if you're with a larger group build your own whole pie. Although I have not tried them yet, I've heard their pizza knotchos are excellent and I plan on trying soon. Save room for some pizza next time you're out in the Grove! (their open until 3:30 am) read more

My favorite pizza in town by far. The pies are large New York style slices which you can buy by the slice. Also if your into craft beer it's perfect for you read more

I love this place! Super friendly staff, interesting setup next to a bar ( where you can choose from a huge selection of beers). A small amount of indoor seating is available as well as outdoor seating. It's a great spot for people watching. We ordered a cheese pizza and a Saint Louis Chopped salad. The salad was great...very fresh and tasty. The pizza was excellent. We ordered an 18" Cheese. It's NY style here. The crust is special...crispy and light. Next time I'm there I'll probably order extra sauce as it was lighter than I prefer. If you're not drinking alcohol from next door, there's water and free Koolaid. All the cups & utensils and dishes are recyclable or compost ready. Nice touch! read more

Fresh ingredients and Lov the New York style. The salads has a seasoning that complements it. Never disappoints me.

Went to this spot For the first time after seeing a lot of positive comments as well as seeing that during this difficult time they were giving slices to those in need. Have to say we were not disappointed, have already recommended them to some of our friends and family and will definitely be back! Keep up the great work pizza guy! read more

Great place to stop in to get a slice of pizza on the go. They warm up the slice when you order which is a plus. They offer you nice cup of free coolaid too when you are there. My son, the pizza connoisseur gave it a thumbs up. read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places in town. The location is great. It is right next door to the beer Gezellig. It's the perfect place to stop by in the afternoon or for a late night slice. The slices are large, thin and crispy. The knotchos are delicious and a great item to share with a friend. The free kool-aid is a plus. Everyone that works there is super friendly. I highly recommend taking the pizza class. read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pizza class - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

Ordered one large pizza with sausage, onion, half mushroom/half spinach. Pizza was very NY style but really, really salty.

Best slices in the city. Whole pie, knots, and salad can feed two for a weeekend. Next door neighbor, Gezelig has some great beer selections as well to take with. As you leave don't forget your cup of Kool-Aid either, random selections of your childhood favorite to wash down the goodness that is Pie Guy. read more

The best pizza I've ever had in St. Louis is connected to the best beer bar in St. Louis. Why I hadn't been to Pie Guy until my last week living here, I truly have no idea. The pizza is a delicious homage to the classic NY slice, the service is quick, and the prices are low. A full pie will serve two if you're ambitious enough. Walk through a side door and buy a pint from Gezellig's incredible tap selection, or pick up a can out of their fridge for retail prices. Eat your pizza and drink your beer and be happy. read more

3.5 stars. Pretty good pizza, I have to say. The location is great, right next to Gezellig, and the two are connected. The ordering process was easy, and I liked the table markers (trophies). I had the cheese and the sausage pizza, and liked both. I was a little annoyed at the concept of warming slices upon ordering, and it made the pizza a little too crisp and hard to fold. I was wishing for more toppings, but for the thinness of the crust I think more toppings might make it difficult to eat. It was about $12 for 2 pieces of pizza, which seems a little much for me. I'm glad I gave it a try, and I'll try the knotchos some time, but I don't anticipate myself craving this place. read more

Delicious pizza! They sell by the slice and whole pizzas. Even the vegan pizza was tasty, which is a testament to the chef! Loved that they had shakers of nutritional yeast for vegans. Veggie pizza had fresh veggies, the perfect amount of cheese, thin but not cracker-thin crust. Best slice I've had in a loooong time. read more

Pie Guy Pizza - Pizza by the slice and their attitude - Pizza Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

I've been all over saint Louis and tried most if not all pizza places. La pizza is by far is my favorite pizza in saint Louis hands down....til now. Now that I've been to pie guy I can tell you for sure that this is the BEST place in saint Louis for a pizza ...period. the price may not be what you're used to but you are paying for perfection people and that it is perfect crust great sauce excellent toppings and awesome service...does that not sound perfect to you? Well with all that being said it's still not even half the experience bring your kids friends family whatever this place suits everyone. read more

See all

Pizza is delicious Recommend getting the garlic nuts also huge size pizza 18 inch very good

I have actually never written a yelp review but Pie Guy is more than deserving. Not only is it the best NY style pizza and one of my favorite salads in the city, every time I call to place an order or walk up I am greeted by the kindest owners and employees. It is always this way, no matter who answers the phone. They instantly put a smile on my face. To say they are slammed every time I go there wouldn't give them enough credit. They are quickly getting orders out the door yet are so patient with guests and nice to everyone they come in contact with. I will support you guys for as long as you will have me! A really well ran business with great pizza and even better people. read more

Fantastic pizza, great salad and the nicest guys! Check them out! Just got liquor license and still making the place great! We will most definitely be back. read more

Not one to write reviews but, it's happening today.. Just drove into St. Louis from Michigan and wanted pizza delivered. Ordered their pizza and salad through the Yelp/GrubHub app (which I do quite often from home) and had no issues placing the order - even received the confirmation from Pie Guy. About 45 minutes later I receive a notification stating my order has been cancelled due to Pie Guy being out of my ingredients? How does this happen at a pizza place when my order consisted of a pepperoni pizza and their salad? Called to politely ask why and they had no answer. I am assuming it was an accident/error but at least own it? Will have to try the pizza in person I guess. read more

After assisting on a shoot for a friend, he told us he would treat myself and another friend to dinner at this pizza joint his cousin works at that was just around the corner. We step into Pie Guys Pizza and right away I see the large pizza slices that give me flashbacks of the amazing pizza that New York had to offer. Immediately I'm excited. We order a large pizza with sausage, spinach, mushrooms, and onions. There are two coolers full of water and old-school kool-aid with cups nearby for patrons. There's also a doorway that joins to a bar with an entire cooler wall full of beer offerings for purchase as well as beers on tap. We grab our table number which is attached to a huge trophy (cause we're all winners now), grab some cups of kool-aid, and find a table. After a bit, our large pizza arrives, smelling absolutely divine (it may have been since we were shooting outside in the freezing weather for the last couple hours, but it was heavenly nonetheless). The large pizza was split into six huge slices. The crust was thinner and had an amazing crispness to it. Not overdone, but crispy like you can hear it crackle in your mouth. The sauce-to-cheese ratio was decent with not too much sauce and just enough cheese. And they are gracious with the amount of toppings they include. The sausage on top had a nice spicy kick to it, and the mushrooms had been sautéed so they were nice and buttery. Overall, this was a great New York-style pizza, and I will be back for more. Thanks! read more

Pie Guy is the real deal. They are the first slice I've had outside the tri-state area that actually lives up to the "NY-style" description. And I mean anywhere else in the world, not just in STL. My dad who grew up in Jersey and went to school in NYC agreed. The crust is the perfect combination of flakey & crisp on the outside, and fluffy & chewy on the inside. The sauce was balanced and wasn't overly sweet or salty. The cheese was the perfect consistency. Bonus points for offering roasted garlic as a topping. I live out in Chesterfield but I now find myself looking for excuses to make a trip to the Grove just for a slice. Damn good pizza! read more

I have always loved their pizza. Today I was trying to use door dash and it wasn't working to get the pizza delivered. I called in hopes to get it fixed... and the nicest person named Evan answered and fixed it all and was the sweetest ever. Thank you Evan ! 10/10 recommend read more

They call me Kevin McAllister when I step up in this place because I only get that cheese pizza! Let me tell you something, i'm all about flavor and quality and service and pie guy has it all! If you find yourself stumble drunk navigating the grove after putting down one too many vodka sodas, stop by pie guy for a late night slice!!! read more

The pizza was delicious, the wait to get the pizza was a bit ridiculous. On weekends, order ahead for full pies or you might end up waiting for well over an hour. Don't get me wrong-- the pizza is DEFINITELY worth the wait, but be prepared for the wait. I hope they are able to upgrade their pizza oven to keep up with demand read more

I've dined at Pie Guy on a few separate occasions now and it has yet to disappoint!! Dinner rush on a Friday night, I expected my order (a whole pie) to take longer than usual. To my surprise, it was out in just shy of 30 minutes! True to the NYC slice it was thin, crispy, cheesy & the sausage was packed full of flavor! Next time was a late night endeavor through the Grove, I stumbled into Pie Guy. I ordered a cheese slice (extra crispy) and it was EVERYTHING. So naturally, I ordered another! The last time was a casual evening with a group of friends. We were drinking at the bar Gezellig next door. Mitch came by the table & let us sample a spinach & feta pie. Needless to say, it was SO GOOD and I'll definitely be ordering that next time! *Pie Guy is WHERE IT'S AT* read more

Ordered a mushroom and Olive pizza. Not sure what it would be like. It took about 30 minutes but when they brought it out to our table it was hot and cheesy heaven. Crust was light and crisp and just a little chewy. Not cheap but worth every penny. read more

Hands down the BEST NYC-STYLE PIZZA in town! Crispy on the bottom, with cheese and yumminess throughout my folded very hot slice. SO GOOD! This is the first pizza place I have found that truly matches the NYC pizza experience - even BETTER! Kudos to the Pie Guy team too - they're friendly and fast! read more

I am honest about the fact that I'm a pizza snob having tried most places in STL. I'm not a pizza purist so I also like STL pizza when done right (not sure if that negates my ability to be a pizza snob). So that being said I was excited to try Pie Guys Pizza. I ordered the sausage pizza rather than go for a slice. I've never understood the appeal of buying a single slice. Number one it's not fresh and number two it doesn't make a lot of sense from a financial standpoint. So based on the first point I don't think reviewing their pizza on one stale slice of pizza left under a hot light is warranted or a fair review However, some people like ordering that way so that's just my opinion. I will say that the pizza I ordered was excellent. Right up there with La Pizza to be honest. I'll be trying this place quite a few more times in the future when I get the urge to jump off my clean eating diet for a meal or two. Unless the quality changes, I have a feeling this place will jump into my top 3 STL pizzerias. read more

Smartly connected to their craft beer neighbor in order to enjoy a slice or pizza made to order while having some beer. Pretty good pizza, loved the pepperonis and buttery thin crust. Will definitely be always getting a slice when I return for craft beer. Thank you! read more

Delightful little place with great pizza. Sourdough crust isn't overwhelming, and they'll reheat a single piece fairly quickly or make you an entire pie. Love the coolers of Kool-Aid and missing the knotchos! Bring them back please :). read more

What a great little addition to the Grove, a simple pie shop churning out goodness adjacent to a bottle shop (Gezzeleg). Can you really get any better than pizza and beer? Well, yes. With fantastic pizza, and that's exactly what Pie Guy produces. A+ read more

We bought the Chicago style and the big pizza. The whole family preferred the big pizza it had a great flavor and texture with a good amount of tiny pepperonis which are what we prefer. The deep dish style was ok but not as yummy as it looks on the picture. It could have used more sauce and was much smaller than it looks on the posted pic. We would get the big pie pizza again. read more

Being from New York, it's hard to find a place where you can buy a slice alone. Their pizza is perfect. One of the best I've ever had. The pepperoni is great! The garlic knotchos are wonderful as well! I always look forward to going to the Ready Room for a show and stopping here. read more

The pizza is great. I always recommend it to people I know. Always had a good experience here until recently. Placed an order at 7:30 was told it would be ready at 8:42. Came in to pay and check on my order which was a cheese pizza and half salad. Showed up at 8:35. Cashier said "it's not 8:42 so it's going to be a while." Okay , no worries! I stand there until 8:45 , the guys refused to come back up. After being ignored at the counter, I waited not knowing where to go. Paid the bill and was giving no sort of direction or answer about the order. Whoever is working the counter needs a different job. Rolling thier eyes, avoiding the counter, ignoring people. Even had the guy behind me say " i don't know what's up but that was a weird look" because the guy was rude and dismissive to him as well and gave everyone looks. Not sure why it's an inconvenience for him to check on orders 5 minutes early and then it's still late when the time comes. Didn't come out till at least 9 pm. Only was able to get it after a cook came up and asked if we needed help since the cashier just left. Cashier delivers food and says with an attitude "thanks for your patience" sarcastically. I'd understand the pettiness if I was rude but I asked one question and was treated like I was the dumbest person in STL. If you give a time estimate don't be angry and treat customers like idiots for showing up around that time. A simple interaction just ruined the entire love I had for this place. Unreal. read more

Had been wanting to try Pie Guys for quite some time, and this past week when I finally went to pick one up I was stoked. I'm a huge fan of Casey's pizza if that tells you anything - I'm not what you'd call a "pizza guy" but this type of pizza is my favorite. Nice guys, it's priced very fairly too. Unfortunately, plandemic is still happening so I can't comment on the restaurant itself. Love the pizza! read more