This location seems a little more vintage and much cozier. We were lucky to make it in time for bingo night too. Gets quite crowded here with patrons. It's a bit small here but does not feel cramped at all Love Polly's menu. Their recipes are consistent along locations too which is greatly appreciated. Fruit is so fresh. Bread is baked fresh too. Quality and simplicity They do have parking Bingo is fun here using the paint dot system. It's lively and lots of winners here too read more

See all

Polly, I finally figured out what you're doing: Trying to go from 4 stars to 1. From good to bad. From hero to zero. From...okay you get the point. I had completed my Bingo Bonanza card by visiting the Los Alamitos location two more times after my last visit to the Long Beach location. I thought I'd give them one more try to redeem themselves as well as my last reward of a free whole pie. I was heading out of town for Memorial Day weekend to a Polly's Pies-less place, and I wanted a bake-at-home pie to share at my destination. I know that Polly's Pies bakes whole pies, but recently learned that Polly's offers five pies in frozen form: Peach Apricot Rhubarb Blueberry Cherry NSA (No Sugar Added) With America's 250th birthday just around the corner, I was intent on getting a blueberry bake-at-home pie. I wasn't too far from the Long Beach location, so I thought I'd stop by and see if I could redeem the reward here. However, when I came up to the register to let the employee know I was going to redeem my reward of a free whole pie, I asked if it could work on a bake-at-home pie. She asked her manager (Irvin I believe), but they informed me that it would only work on ready to eat pies. Problem is, I was planning to head out of town the next day, so by choosing a ready to eat pie, I would have wasted one day of freshness before bringing it to my intended destination. Their ready to eat pies would only last for a few days in the fridge or on the counter, depending on the type of pie, and losing one day would have made a big difference. I don't like to argue since I was recently highlighted as an Elite who embodies Yelp's value of "play well with others", and they clearly didn't play well with me, especially since the fine print didn't spell out a stipulation that would disallow for bake-at-home pies. Wait, didn't something similar happen last time as well? Oh yeah! Danna, the server on my last visit, initially said that a King Edward's Club sandwich wouldn't qualify for a $5 burger/sandwich combo even though the fine print didn't spell out that stipulation. And with management at the Long Beach location becoming even more incompetent at their jobs, I really shouldn't be surprised at their made-up rule about the free whole pie being only allowed for ready to eat pies. As an epilogue, I revisited the Los Alamitos location to redeem the free whole pie, and there, I met one of the loveliest employees that the entire Long Beach team should really learn customer service from. She was happy enough to make the free whole pie reward work on a bake-at-home pie and even egg wash it to boot. That was the best of Polly's Pies. This was the worst of Polly's Pies. A Tale of Two Polly's Pies, not a book by Charles Dickens, unfortunately lol read more

See all

We stopped by this Polly Pies on Wednesday their Bingo Night, this location is much smaller than the other ones we have visited before. Even though it's small, I would say it was still difficult to get an order taken and get the attention of our waiter. We got the Salisbury steak, tuna, salad sandwich, and a couple slices of pie. All the food was up to par. I really enjoyed trying the strawberry lemonade pie. I've never had it before and was pleasantly surprised. It wasn't too tart or sweet and came with a lot of whipped cream. We also got the banana cream pie, which is one of our favorites and the custard pie. In terms of their bingo night, I think they did a great job of keeping the crowd engaged with trivia and random facts about the day and pop culture. I also feel like there was a pretty good variety with the prizes, which include included brownies, bread, pies, and cookies. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - Bingo! - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

See all

Ordered a pie for fourth of July (basic strawberry). I would not go here again. The pie became soggy very rapidly and fell apart. It seemed like the crust was not robust (or maybe even a crust). We opened it up and it looked like a bunch of smooshed Ritz crackers and strawberry had vomited inside the box. Really disappointing for $30. We couldn't even cut it into regular pie pieces more like strawberry with juice chunk and destroyed crust. I was very careful with it and it should not have fallen into mush. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - A strawberry vomit pie. Or well that is what it looked like. Unable to cut it properly already destroyed as soon as it was in a box. - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

I'd always gotten pies from here, but I never ate at one before. We had some business in Bixby Knolls, so we decided to have breakfast here. I was very happy with how nice the place was. A lot of seating inside and out. Parking lot is small, but we found a spot. I kept them simple and had their scrambled eggs, bacon, and potatoes. The eggs were perfect and fluffy, the bacon was very crispy and delicious. The potatoes were OK, but I wish I had had the hashbrowns instead. My partner had the ABC omelette. She was very happy with how good it was and took the rest home. The sourdough bread they gave her looked impressively delicious. It reminded me of the spot in LA that makes bread that big. I always have pancakes and I can never tell whether they are made out of buttermilk or not but these ones were and they were pretty good. The service was also great, so overall I put this place as a go to to drop by for breakfast next time. They have amazing cookies and pies, of course. You can always count on that. Glad to know I have a Polly's pie restaurant so close to home. read more

See all

I had been wanting to try this spot for about a decade now and boy was I disappointed! I LOVE diners! As a kid I was all about Carrow's and I drive all the way from Alamitos Beach to Bixby for Bake & Broil, the most superior diner in all of existence! But Polly's was not good at all. When you walk in, it's pretty cute inside. They have their own products for purchase like jams and breads. You're warmly greeted by friendly staff as well. The one positive note was the employees, mainly our server. She was amazing and friendly. However the Prime Rib Dip was not good at all. Very small portions and not tasty. When we left, we saw an Arby's and I told my partner that I wish we had gone there instead as their French Dip is far superior and that's saying something. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - Prime Rib French Dip - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

Stopped for a late lunch! Polly's didn't disappoint. Service was great and food was yummy. I got the club sandwich with fries - good portions and tasty. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - King Edward's Club - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

Classic American style with pies to droll over. It's a neighborhood classic come here for get together and get me some pies. Not too many restaurants offer pies anymore made in house. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

See all

Who doesn't live a good pie!? Well I was craving their banana cream pie and all I wanted was a slice. Why did I get this craving the day after Thanksgiving!? They didn't have any. They were also very limited on slices available. But they did have a lively chocolate cream pie. So I buy the pie and share half with my neighbor haha. The server was very friendly and knowledgeable about which slices were available and about when the banana cream pies would be available later that day. Inside was pretty busy with the happy people eating food that looked delicious! Great comfort food place and excellent pie destination too. read more

See all

Haven't been here in awhile. We decided to stop in on a Sunday for a late breakfast. Service was fantastic! Loved our waiter!! We split banana Mac pancakes which came with eggs and bacon. Bacon was sooo good too!! Had to bring half of my pancake home lol Sooo good!! read more

How can you give this place? Anything less than five stars? Everyone that worked here was super nice. They really had that Southern hospitality. The food was pretty good for what it was. One thing you can't complain about is the price. I thought there was some kind of error in the receipt but nope they just are really down-to-earth nice, honest people. There definitely would be back again. I had their dinner special. The salad was okay. It was vegetables. The entree was really good and they gave you a full slice of pie. Can't complain about that. Can't even find a place that can replicate this kind of food for this price. So yeah it's a no-brainer thanks again read more

Was crowded today. Food terrific! Orders were King Edward turkey sandwich on sourdough bread. The sandwich included turkey, avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise spread. It came with coleslaw. Good size portions with lots of turkey. All natural bread. Possibly the whole meal was. The taste was very homemade. The other sandwich which i ordered was the roasted turkey garlic aoli sandwich on sourdough bread. Basically similar but no bacon. Came with coleslaw. We also shared some sweet potato fries that were not greasy. Too full for dessert. Also ordered 2 waters. Joe was our server and did a excellent job. Prices are reasonable considering the portions. Photos were a little blurry so we had to skip this time. I might have moved the phone camera because I was anticipating eating their amazing food. Would definitely return. read more

All of the food we ordered here was amazing. The bread and pies are freshly baked and all of the ingredients used tasted fresh. That Pumpkin Dream Slice tasted beyond amazing. We absolutely loved and enjoyed the food. However, our waiter was terrible. It seemed as though he was not good at multitasking, kept forgetting about us, and made us feel like a burden. We had to keep catching him for everything we needed, even to place our order and to pay! The ambiance of the spot however is welcoming and comfy. It's an old school diner serving up comfort food and baked goods. We will return , but hopefully we get a better waiter/waitress. read more

See all

I came to Polly's Pies to celebrate my dad's birthday, and Joe was our server. At first he seemed a bit standoffish, but my dad is such a genuinely kind person that the interaction quickly warmed up. My dad asked Joe his name, how his day was going, and treated him with sincere friendliness. From that point on, Joe's whole demeanor changed and the service became much more pleasant. My dad and I both pay attention to customer service, and it was interesting to see how a small moment of kindness shifted the experience. My dad is also a generous tipper and left Joe a $20 tip. Joe actually tried to give half of it back, but my dad insisted he keep it. We ordered breakfast--eggs, sausage, and country-style potatoes, which were good and satisfying. The only downside was the restroom situation; unfortunately there was no toilet paper and it was a bit messy. Overall, it was a good experience and an interesting little "experiment" in how human interaction can change the tone of service. I might try another Polly's location next time, but this visit still made for a memorable birthday breakfast with my dad. read more

2nd Visit 10.31.2025 Decided to give this place another try. My wife and I decided to have dinner on Halloween since we were obligated to purchase some pies for the the holiday festivities to come that night. Entered the front door and was greeted and seated immediately. The front door hostess had good energy. She smiled and gave us menus and stated that your server will be right with you. I did not catch her name but she was young and energetic. 5 mins goes by and we were greeted by our server Nikko. She gave us waters and immediately took our orders. Ordered chicken pot pie, meatloaf dinner and fountain drinks. 10 minutes goes by and walla! Our food was delivered. All was fresh and delicious. I like the fact we had all the sauces we wanted on the table. (Hot Sauce, ketchup, mustard). It was convenient. Nikko kept checking up on us to make sure all was good on our side. She did that consistently as well as Ashley who was her backup server in training. Overall, I would come back again. It was Day and night compared to my last visit at this establishment. Food was fresh and delicous. Good portion size. Our servers were professional, they exhibited themselves to have great customer service. Place has alot of parking, clean restrooms and clean tables. On my last visit, the tables were greasy. Good experience this time around. Big Kuddos to Nikko and Ashley for being kind with a smile. Great customer service!! I ordered a banana cream pie which was a hit at the Halloween party. Time of visit.. 3 to 4pmsh read more

See all

the food is great, the prices are reasonable, and the wait staff were attentive. I went for breakfast and there was plenty of food. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - French Toast Combo - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

Chicken sandwich was terrific--amongst the finer chicken sandwiches I've had in LA. Hits all the right notes--lightly breaded, buttermilk-brined, juicy inside. Fries and apple pie were just ok--not bad, but not the best. Was going to give 4 stars, but I think the chicken alone elevates this to 5 stars. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - "Comeback" chicken sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

See all

Idk how often they have bingo but today is Wednesday and it was bingo day. Felt like a lot of regulars were there. I would say the food was ok. Nothing mind blowing. I ate and I was content. Decent prices for dinner. I have to come back and see if the breakfast is good. The service was good so I will come back for sure because of that. Very bright inside. I don't know if they have restrooms. read more

See all

We went to Polly's Pies for a quick bite and it absolutely served. To be honest, it's a lot nicer inside compared to the exterior. For a busy Sunday morning, we were promptly seated. There's a current Hawaiian special/theme going for on (maybe permanent idk), so love that for them. I order the 2-3-1 combo ($13.99). I opted for 2 over easy eggs, three Jones Dairy Farms smoked sausage links, a biscuit, and hashbrowns. This was good. The hashbrowns could have stayed on the griddle for a little longer and while I didn't love their sausages, but they were serviceable. I'll probably do the breakfast potatoes and bacon next time. All in all, a very solid breakfast. Honestly, if you're in the brunching mood on a Sunday, make Poly's Pie your girl. It's not only nice and easy - the food is pretty solid. I'll be back to try their lunch and dinner specials. And their special specials. read more

See all

First time at Polly's Pies in Long Beach, and had a wonderful experience. Food was so yummy. The real reason I would recommend this place and would come back was the service from Niko. She was knowledgeable, kind and super attentive to us. She deserves a raise. I approve of this raise. Thank you, Niko. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - Polly's Pie Bites - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

Best olallieberry pie hands down. No idea how their berries are always the sweetest of any pie shop. The glaze isn't overpowering or the main sweet component. The crust is buttery and flavorful, not just a starchy vessel but a crunch component to complement the delectable berries. Run as olallieberry pie season is usually June. You can't go wrong with anything on their menu. Surprisingly some of the best burgers in Long Beach. Service is always kind and warm. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - Olallieberry pie - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

I preordered a Christmas meal and picked it up a week later. The line was long on Christmas Eve and somewhat organized. The pies that were available were set out but those of us who preordered should've been in a separate line I got a ham dinner and ate it the next day. It wasn't the tastiest so I doubt I'll eat there again but I am curious about the pies so I may return for that. read more

Extraordinarily slow service. We were there at 4:30. Not crowded at all. Took 15 minutes to be seated and 1 hour to receive our 2 entrees. Server Perla was extremely spread thin. She was handling every table in the restaurant. She needed some help. Our food came out cold and she forgot to bring our bread. The service trainer Leah was no help at all. On a Sunday night, the restaurant needs more than 1 server. This is a a long standing problem at this location. We should have driven to Los Alamitos (and extra 10 mile ride) which doesn't seem to have the same service issues as this location. read more

Had an amazing time eating at Polly's eye. I tried sandwich and the sourdough is on point. The service was great. I went on Saturday night. It was slow inside but service was fast and excellent ambulances with ignite and cute. Has an old-school feeling with a modern touch, it looks like it's been remodeled recently. It was very quiet. I definitely go back again. I also took a pie home. It tasted so good. read more

See all

Free FUN bingo every week with really great dinner specials on menu is what hooked us! I had previously only come here for holiday pies. The dinner specials are very filling, tasty, and priced so reasonably. The bingo is so fun with some really l amazing prizes. Whole pies, a bottle of wine, a jar of their Bumbleberry jam (jelly?), brownies, cookies, or cinnamon rolls the size of your head! A wonderful assortment of choices every week. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - Grilled cheese, tomato bisque/soup (I don't remember) with fries. This also included a piece of pie I think, too. - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

The picture says it all...... I ordered eggs with cheddar cheese Pancakes and bacon. The eggs came out burnt. The cook tried to cover the eggs with cheese. Absolutely not! The waitress had an attitude( of course ) because I sent them back. After that incident, she never came back to refill my coffee and didn't ask if I needed anything else .I will not be returning. Do better Polly's! Pancakes were delicious. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - Burnt eggs - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

See all

I came here for a Mother's Day breakfast and i totally understand it's very busy but the way our waitress treated us was horrible. Our food sat in the window for at least 10 min she never checked then never put our toast on i was watching toaster then she argued someone stole it and still didn't put any on. Breakfast was so cold by the time the manager brought our toast. Now the manager was really sweet. There was no excuse for the rudeness. And I am not fond of cold food. Bad experience read more

Sadly I got up and left as service was not up to par. I ordered and was pretty clear on my order. So I get water- no lemon as requested. Ordered cinnamon roll warmed. Got cinnamon roll and cold. Tried to get Gloria's attention, no chance. Sat there and just finally got up and talked to the manager. I was so excited to come to Polly's since I moved to Vegas. They need to be better prepared for when it does get busy and work on this. Not good for paying customers and we should not have to work so hard or feel discouraged when. We come to eat at a restaurant. Very disappointed in Polly's! read more

Stopped by on a Friday night and it was busy and they seemed very short staffed. We were seated quickly but it took about 10 minutes to have our waiter come to take our order. We were going to leave but were so hungry. Our food came out pretty fast but the taste and flavor was not there. I ordered the grilled cheese with tomato soup and it was very salty and cold. When the waitress dropped off our food, I asked for a refill on my drink but she never came back with a refill. Since our waitress never came back, I had to walk up to the cashier to pay for our dinner. When the cashier asked us how everything was, I mentioned my disappointment and he just chuckled. To top it off manager was right next to him and did not acknowledge us. Unfortunately, even though this location has been remodeled, I don't think we will be back again. Sad to say, because Polly's was a favorite of ours. read more

Love coming here for pies. They're great quality great prices you can't beat. It's always quick service. Can't complain!

I ordered for delivery a club sandwich with a side of macaroni and cheese with a slice of banana cream pie, and, a pot pie dinner with a slice of chocolate cream pie on the side. The sandwich look like somebody stepped on it. My pot pie looked like somebody stepped on it in both pieces of pie were not included, and the mac & cheese as a side didn't even show up. The only reason I wanted to get from there was because I wanted pie tonight. Katella deli does it it's better. Update, ordered another delivery for the two pies that were missing and got one that didn't even resemble a piece of pie. I really honestly don't know what's happening over there except maybe somebody just doesn't like their job. read more

See all

What's the point of bringing in a printed email confirmation order if these employees aren't even paying attention to the information that's on it? I placed an online order to be picked-up for the future 3 days in advance, and when it came time to pick-up my order, the Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake that I had ordered was not ready! They told me right there and then that they could get it started but they neglected to give me a wait time. So I start waiting a couple of minutes, but I was in a rush so I did what I had to do.... I understand things happen, but what really upset me is that I wasn't even offered an apology nor did they even try to offer me any other pies to substitute it, which is what I did because I brought it to their attention. I ended up substituting for an Apple Crisp pie which is $12 cheaper than the Pumpkin Praline Cheesecake, and I wasn't even given the difference in $12 refund. Horrible service! The Apple Crisp Pie is extremely tasty though, and for that 2 stars, otherwise I'd leave a 1star. read more

My service was horrible. This is my second time visiting the restaurant and I had the same waitress. She served me burnt eggs, then got an attitude because I asked her to change them. She then came back with more burnt eggs. She overcharge me for my meal and when I asked the manager to come over, and she too had a bad attitude. I explained about my bill and yes she corrected it.. Normally, I wouldn't give a bad review because I know people have bad days, but this waitress was consistent with her lack of service to me . It is unfortunate, but I will never go back to this establishment.. love the pies but I deserve better service than what I received twice. read more

Awesome food, best waitresses in the world, and the ambiance is all American on patriots day. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - General area - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California

See all

Awful service!!! Do not come here. Staff member and mangers are so incompetent. They don't even know how to run a business. Everyone's food came out at different time. Food cold and not good. Played it safe with avocado toast took almost 40 minutes for it to come out. Absolutely ludicrous. You get what you pay for here. read more

The food is pretty standard fare and reliable. They remodeled a few years ago and also redid the entrance which helps flow. It attracts an older crowd. Service is good ... when you can get it. They are severely understaffed with bussers and servers, but have plenty of managers just standing around doing nothing. Right now they have one server with 12 tables. And a manager standing around who was annoyed at having to clear a booth. Also, they still serve the soyrizo skillet but have removed it as an optional added protein from build your own omelets. Make it make sense read more

Bad food, nice place. Bad food, yes, but I went there more than once because the light, airy atmosphere is pleasant, and I was staying in walking distance. You'd think a place with "Pies" in the name would know how to make pie. They don't. The test of a great pie is the crust, and PP fails miserably: the "crust" of my friend's strawberry pie was more like cornmeal mush--flavorless and mushy. The fruit served with my breakfast came in a tiny cup insufficient to satisfy a fairy. And I never know you could mess up "homefries," but they can. The only flavor is that of bad oil. So, bad food, really bad, but I returned for more. Crazy, I know. read more

I will start by saying I've only had one thing off the menu. I ordered a chicken pot pie. It had no flavor at all. Very bland. Comes with gravy and cranberry sauce. The gravy is extremely salty. Service was ok. Would not go again. read more

The waiter was extremely pleasant and provided excellent customer service,however they may have new cooks and food was not the standard I'm used to when dining at Polly's Had birthday rewards, hamburger meat was not properly cooked,raw However waiter alerted and immediately provided a replacement burger, no seasoning or flavored to cheeseburger. Do better in food preparation and cooking. read more

"Thrown Out Like the Pies - A Lesson in Poor Customer Service" I don't usually leave reviews, but my experience at Polly's Pies deserves a public spotlight - for all the wrong reasons. If I could've left a negative star I would. I arrived just before 9 PM, hoping to grab a slice of what they're supposedly known for: pie. Instead, I was met with an employee who informed me (without a hint of flexibility) that "we throw all our pies out at 9pm so we don't have any pies available." Let that sink in: a pie restaurant throws away its product - not a few minutes after closing, not when the kitchen's shut down - but exactly at 9 PM. The kicker? It was barely a minute past and there were people still in the restaurant dining. I wasn't asking for a full meal or special treatment, just a single apple pie, the product your name is built on. But apparently, customer service clocks out at the same time the pies hit the trash. To say the experience was frustrating would be an understatement. I called 2 times while on my way so they knew I was coming and I left empty-handed, while supposedly perfectly good pies went into the trash. I understand closing times, but I also understand basic hospitality and customer service - something Polly's clearly doesn't. If your policy is to prioritize trash cans over customers, maybe it's time to reconsider what business you're in. Do better, Polly's. Or at the very least, stop pretending you're about pies when the garbage gets better service than willing paying patrons. read more

Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery - The people still in the restaurant. - Bakeries Near Me - Long Beach, California