Stopped here for a slice after walking around Central Park and I really enjoyed their pizza! We ordered the jalapeño pepperoni and the meat lovers. The jalapeños they had were actually kind of sweet to me rather than spicy, but I still liked it! Their crust is perfectly thin and crispy and I love all the toppings they put! Service is quick, they reheat all your slices for you. They have a little stand outside for people to stand and eat outside of their shop. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

A literal hole in the wall place near Carnegie Hall, but the slices are correct. Large, great sauce and a good crunch to the thin crust. You have two dining options, eat at a tiny standing table or while you walk. Either is just fine when you want a solid NYC slice. read more

Pop's is a proper NY slice to go. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio, and it's got the exact crust you come to NY for. Thin, crispy, and just the perfect amount of slightly sweet. read more

Goals are to do a pizza trip of New York. Let's compare all the pizza windows and figure out which one is best. This could take a while. Now keep in a mind there are a lot of posers out there in pizza window world. Hot take but If they have to advertise their pizza deal (2 slices + soda = $6), they are probably not the best pizza in New York. Our first find on the first day was Pops Pizza. It's off 7th/57th street next to a dry cleaner. There is construction going on at the moment but don't let that deter you. Pops takes cash or card. They have a variety of pizza options. We got the jalapeño & pepperoni along with the margherita pizza. They warm it up and put in a box for us. Seasonings are all outside with garlic, crushed red pepper and Parmesan. You can easily walk to Central Park from here and enjoy your slice. Walking to Central Park gave us the perfect amount of time to let the pizza cool off a bit. We found q seat in the lawn and had our slices. It had a floppier crust, but the sauce and the toppings were well worth it. Even the crust was great to finish. Does this taste better in Central Park? probably. Does this pizza rank as one of the best, in my opinion yes. The variety, ability to take credit cards and proximity to Central Park let it take the cake. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza window - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

3.5 stars Decent slice of pizza near central park and broadway. Grabbed the spinach mushroom and vodka (didn't really taste like vodka though). read more

Really decent pizza near Central Park. Love the meat lovers and the Pepperoni Jalapeno. It's small and there's no seating, but there's lots of places nearby to eat, or you can stand at the counters. I do wish it was open later as the 10pm close time makes it hard for those of us who want a late night pizza. The business is certainly there, but not for me to decide. read more

Omg this is the greatest pizza in NY!!!! Truly!!! Super thin crust, plentiful ingredients, kind service! It was light enough that it didn't spike blood sugar and entirely delicious! read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great slice place near Carnegie hall. Slices were crispy and well balanced. One was plenty!

The perfect slice on the go! After a long walk through Central Park, we popped in here for a bite. There's a stand outside if you want to stand and eat with friends on the street. This spot delivered everything you want in a NY slice, minus the long lines at the tourist traps. We tried the garlic white and pepperoni with jalapeño--both were delicious. I'm already craving my next slice. read more

See all

My wife had a single slice of there spicey pepperoni and thirty minutes later she got stomach sick for the rest of the day. This place needs to be more careful! read more

Amazing pizza to pick up and eat in Central Park! I thought their vodka slice was really good with big pieces of mozzarella. The pepperoni slices were yummy too and very huge. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pepperoni and vodka slices - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

So good! Really authentic loved it & the sauce was amazing! Loved the cheese pizza & the crust was delicious and fluffy

Is this place new? Has it changed recently? How have I never heard of this? No seriously, this may be the best pizza in the Columbus circle area. You may not see something uniquely exceptional about them at first glance, but their fundamentals are as solid as anywhere and once you actually go you'll appreciate how delicious it is. Their crust has a perfect tender yet structured texture. Their toppings are familiar yet paired intelligently with some combinations I don't often see elsewhere (peperoni-jalapeño and mushroom-spinach are two favorites). Their sauce is good (and crucially not too sweet), and the service is quick, easy, and pleasant. If you're looking for lunch or dinner on the go anywhere in the upper 50s on the west side give pop's a try, you won't be disappointed. Note, no seating, it's grab and go (or eat at their outdoor counter). read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I felt so bad when I called to see if they sold by the slice. I tried to find info on it on Yelp but struggled seeing any new information about it. So alas, I went there for science and to try this place out. Walking distance from our hotel, it took just a few minutes to get there. They had so many options for by the slice and settled on 4 different ones. Honestly, enjoyed every single slice with the spinach one coming in as our favorites. They now have two locations so if you decide to order online, make sure you go to the right one. Come give some love to this place and get some great New York style pizza. read more

Pop's Pizza - Huge by the slice menu, every one was great. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This is a very classic NYC grab and go, stand by the ledge while you eat a massive pizza spot! We got 2 pizzas and they were both very different. The vodka pizza is thicker and crunchier while the pepperoni was thinner with the flavor growing in each bite. Each slice was about $6 (not sure what pizza economics are) but the portions for each slice were massive! read more

Pop's Pizza - Pop's Spicy Jalapeo Pepperoni & Vodka - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Super delish, hard working service. Polite and prompt. Tiny little dive pizza joint for take out. No place to sit or even walk. Order and wait in the sidewalk which is fine. They take their craft serious. read more

Pop's Pizza the name drew me in!!! With some much pizza shops lining up and down. Pop's Pizza is a small place right around the corner from many Broadway theatres. The pizza was pretty good. I usually like a certain amount of grease and oil on a thin crust pizza but this had more oil than normal. It was dripping as I picked up the slice and the paper plate was covered with oil by the time I was done. I wished I had taken a picture of the plate. A little too much oil but the slice was still pretty tasty. read more

What can I say. Quick and delicious New York slice! I miss home just for the pizza alone! I can still taste it ! Spicy but still manageable on the palate! Delicious read more

See all

Native New Yorker here. Who is writing these reviews? It's a fair to middling average slice in the pizza desert of midtown. Not for me!

I was only motivated to go to the Central Park for snow bc I can grab pizza from this place. 5/5 for the price and delicious food. One slice filled me up! It was quick service. Limited standing space but people eat quick! Again, great pizza! read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered a slice with vodka sauce, thin crusted, slightly crunchy. Tiny pizzeria with super friendly staff! Our hotel is nearby and we will probably be going back before we leave. Yum! read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza with vodka sauce! - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

i don't know why this is rated so high. Came in for a slice of Margarita pizza and it had one blob of marinara sauce and barely any cheese. Tasted like cardboard. read more

Very typical New York City pizza joint in terms of decor. Big slices, same price as everywhere else in the area. I tried the margherita and it tasted pretty good. A little too salty for my taste. read more

Pop's Pizza gave us a large order of great, high quality pizza for a terrific price..

First review of 2024! We stopped by this little hole in the wall for a quick slice on our way to work and were not disappointed. The slices are large, crispy (the way we like them) and they weren't cheap on the extra cheese. Well spent $11 on two slices; pepperoni and extra cheese. I would definitely come back here next time I want something quick on 57th st. read more

See all

I'm officially ruined. New York pizza is better. And this is the best "by the slice" place I've been to. Dough is wonderfully crispy, sauce is sweet. Simple, fast, polite walk up and walkout service. No frills. Order, pay, get on your way. read more

Pop's Pizza - 18'' Pop's Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

This place is teeny. Tiny. Both itsy and bitsy. But it was delicious. They were friendly and they satisfied a bunch of hungry, tired Manhattan explorers. And more importantly, they introduced us to Grandma pizza. The interweb says that Grandma pizza is a thin crust but after our introduction at Pop's we had it a couple more times on the East Coast and it was always thick crust. Pop's version was simple and tasty and wonderful, just a little tomato sauce and cheese on delicious crust. We happily stood on the sidewalk and inhaled our new discovery and walked away satisfied and far, far happier. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A solid NYC slice shop serving up super thin slices through a window. Service is efficient and to the point but friendly. The crust is good and super thin with just the right amount of crisp. My only issue is that the sauce is a tad too sweet. But for a quick cheap lunch on the fly, it fits the bill. read more

Pop's Pizza - Classic thin slice - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Decent New York style pizza: 1. More Mexican than Italian. 2. Thin crispy crust, cheesy, greasy, perfect size. 3. Price: $5.5 per slice. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pepperoni jalapeno - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I'm not joshing, one of the best New York slices I've ever had in the city. My expectations were low but wow I was stunned. I'd come back here easy. I got one marinara slice. It's is a sweet delicious bite. The oil on top and he thin, chewy crust is such a combo. The dollops of marinara are delicious. I loved every bite of this. Well seasoned. It's a tiny space inside, no tables. There is an outside section to eat under, no tables or chairs. Service is quick. My slice was warm. read more

Pop's Pizza - Marinara - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Read on Yelp that the margherita pizza -- aka margarita pizza, so this review will come up if people search with that spelling -- was one of Pop's best, so I tried it. Ordered a whole pie. It was giant and delicious! Kids and adults all loved it. Would return here any time! Thanks, Pop's! read more

Tiny restaurant. Friendly and quick service. Pizza is quite good, and there is a good variety of options. Will definitely visit again. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

If you are looking for service this is not the place. If you are looking for good pizza, you found Pops. There is no restroom at Pops and you can stand at the sidewalk to eat or swallow your pizza like a seal. There is an up charge of you pay by credit card. There is nothing that mentions the up charge we noticed on the receipt. The staff talent is to prepare pizza not chat with the customer. O tried it but I don't think I'll be back. So many other great places out there is New York. read more

Pop's Pizza - Display of pizza. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Great little pizza spot serving classic New York style pizza with crispy crust. They have a small covered stand on the street for eating on the run and enjoying the hustle and bustle of NYC. We even saw a bus driver pull over and grab a slice! Only in New York. read more

Pop's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Had Pop's Pizza at a Sobriety Society event, and it was delicious! I'll definitely check out the shop next time I'm in the area.

Food is delicious, made in house right in front of you. Margarita and cheese are my go to and never disappoint. I recommend this spot over any. 10/10 highly recommend. read more

Pop's Pizza - Margarita pizza and cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Easy and simple pies. We enjoyed the pizza it was fresh and quick to deliver. Super easy to find and within walking distance to our hotel at the time. The guy making the pizza was very chill and answered my drunk questions :) read more

Good, quick, easy, and affordable, "by the slice" pizza. Better than most of the 99 cent slice vendors, but not quite as good as the higher end Italian restaurants in this area. No seating at all, but there is a covered area out front to stand and enjoy your slice. read more

See all

Best slice in NY, change my mind. Slice is large, foldable, yet still has a crispy bottom. Cheese is thick and stretchy, but not too greasy. Sauce is bright and flavorful. To top it off, the people behind the counter have always been friendly and happy, like people who love what they're doing. Really brightens my day/evening. What more can you ask for from your local slice shop?! read more

During our short visit to the East Coast, the one thing I had to have was my style pizza and this one caught my eye being so close to where we were in central park. It was a blistering hot day but that didn't deter me from my craving for a hot slice. The shop is tiny allowing maybe 2-3 customers to the register to order. They ran out of pepperoni so I opted for the Marguerite. Slices were just $5 + tax and huge! It was ready in 3 min and you can take it to a standing only covered area by the side of the road where there are napkins, garlic powder and oregano. The pizza was nice and hot with the perfect amount of sauce and a great crunch to the crust. Nothing compares to NY Pizza! read more

See all