A classic Potbelly experience! I come in thinking I'm going to try something new every time and end up getting the classic wreck because it's so good. I honestly lived on Potbelly during my pregnancy, so much so I had to take a break post partum and finally had it again and it hit the spot. The staff was so friendly and efficient, the sandwich was exactly as I expected and you can't go wrong with their brownie cookie for a sweet treat! read more

I've had a hankering for the Potbelly oatmeal chocolate chip cookies for the last week. I love them and haven't had one in so long. Stopped in today and got a bag of smaller ones. The cashier was super friendly and really made my day. Along with the cookies, I couldn't ask for more. This location is large, laid out well with plenty of seating. I'll be back. read more

This location has excellent customer service. I accidentally placed a delivery order as pickup, and "paid" with a free sandwich coupon. I called the store and the employee said I had to purchase a new sandwich in order for one to delivered. My order arrived with both sandwiches and another free sandwich coupon! Very kind and helpful staff! read more

This is the 1st time my sandwich ( The Wreck) was a disappointment. It had white tomatoes!?!​​ read more

Potbelly - My tomato???? - Sandwiches Near Me - Gurnee, Illinois

I loved the food and mac service is always amazing one side note the bread should not taste like burnt burger change needs to happens nothing on the staff though shakes amazing read more

I've been going here for years, this sandwich was not good. The provolone cheese was missing and the meat was skimpy, I could only taste the bread. We ordered a Wreck online for pickup, maybe my tip wasn't big enough. read more

I am long time Potbelly fan! I go here practically once every time I come back home. Unfortunately we have no Potbelly down in the south so my cravings are through the roof when I pass by this shop on grand. It's basically like a Chipotle for sandwiches so what's there not to like?! I got serviced immediately by a really kind server. She listened to my order and made sure to make the sandwich to my preference! It was finished really quick and I was already out the door in less than 10 minutes. Very convenient location right on Grand Ave. next to all the different stores and restaurants. The only thing that would make this place better than better is a drive thru. But for now, I'll still walk in to get these delicious sandwiches! read more

See all

Handicap people beware wheelchairs don't fit in the line because of this big cast iron stove decoration. I hurt my back moving so my friend could get in line to order food. Had to move it twice since she also had to get out of the line. read more

Potbelly - Heavy cast iron stove - Sandwiches Near Me - Gurnee, Illinois

Love this place! Cool atmosphere and excellent service. Have had nothing but good experiences here. Love having this in Gurnee! Some of the best sandwiches in town! read more

I ordered a regular Hammie for lunch. When it came, it was a "Skinny Hammie." instead. The store manager, a very nice young woman, had my order remade and did not charge me for either one. I think she deserves a "thank you"for being gracious. read more

The wreck all time favorite! Good chilly.... Salad good too. Jalapeño chips and extra giardinara pepper read more

Have to say this place is nice with great service. I had a issue with my sandwich (something got into it) won't say what but no big deal. I let the nice lady know at the counter and without question she made me a new one. I love coming here and never had a problem! I recommend this place 10/10 These workers care about their customers and I will continue to come back! Awesome job to this Restaurant Team and their hard work read more

A classic potbelly experience! The place smells of amazing sandwiches and is always very clean. The tables were taped off to follow social distancing guidelines. The workers were very sweet and quick. They did forget my pickle but I was able to run back in and grab it. The rewards program is awesome with occasional free treats and coupons. I try to get something new each time because everything on the menu is amazing. Definitely order a smoothie or shake because they are so creamy and the cookies are a nice touch. Also try the VooDoo chips- absolutely amazing (kind of salt&vinegar/bbq combo very interesting and different)! read more

If you request them to not warm up your sandwich, they can make you a cold sub which is tasty as well. Yummy Oreo shake that comes with a cookie on top. Potato soup was warm. read more

This location is "TEMPORARILY CLOSED" again. Went there this morning just to buy a Gift Card and sign was in the door. read more

I am very familiar with Potbelly Sandwich Works in the Greater Chicago area, but this was my first visit to their furthest North outpost. The thing that I find comforting about Potbelly is that each location is decorated differently but there is a commonality that makes me feel at home. It reminds me of a popular campus sandwich and soup shop back in my College days. Staff was very efficient and friendly- dining area was clean and at the time of day that I visited, quiet. Gentle late 60's and early 70's pop and rock music was in the background. There is a small outdoor seating area, but I can't imagine sitting there since on one side of you there is Grand Avenue traffic and the other side strip mall lack of ambiance. Perhaps it is there with parents and their hyperactive offspring in mind? If you have never tried a Potbelly sandwich, you are in for a toasted treat. Give yourself some time to look over the menu either on-line or in person and then dive into a taste extravaganza. read more

Potbelly - Potbelly "Wreck" and "Clubby" sandwiches. - Sandwiches Near Me - Gurnee, Illinois

Love this place. Tried to order on the app and it only showed the Vernon Hills location. I called the Gurnee one and ask what's going on. The guy that answered the phone said that there was an incident there and they would be closed for a few days. No explanation as to what happened. Does anyone know what happened? read more

Ordered a bigs grilled chicken & cheddar with everything minus onion which, according to the sign in the restaurant, includes mayo, mustard, hot peppers, lettuce, onion, tomato, pickle, oil, and Italian seasoning. What I got: - Flat bread, not fluffy bread like the advertised pic - A sprinkle of lettuce, certainly not billowing up like in the picture - A SINGLE thin sliced tomato - No pickle whatsoever - A pinch of hot peppers - No mayo or mustard - Cheddar cheese? Where??? Oh you mean those two little yellow spots! I see it now. - A SINGLE slice of chicken that's not even long enough to cover the length of the bread. I'd hate to think about what I would have gotten if I'd order extra chicken for $1.45? One more shortened slice of chicken? RIDICULOUS!!! read more

See all

Awesome environment, clean, and great food. Absolutely love the place! Definitely going to come back when I get the chance!

I will no longer be going to this location. The service is not good. In the past four times we have gone here something has been wrong. This last time the sandwich had the wrong bread, and missing toppings. This isn't the first time a sandwich has been made incorrectly, but it will be the last time. read more

Another disappointing visit to Potbelly in Gurnee. This is the second one in a row. I thought maybe the last one was just a bad day but by the emptiness of the restaurant, I am guessing it may be a trend. Since Potbelly doesn't offer a salad without meat, I order the uptown salad with no chicken. You would think that they would at least fill the bowl with lettuce given that I am saving them money on the chicken. My salad today was terrible. It had a small handful of lettuce mix and about a 1/2 cup of blue cheese. I normally wouldn't complain about getting a lot of toppings but I didn't really feel like eating straight blue cheese and that was what many of my bites were. My coworkers sandwich was not great either. Didn't seem to be much meat on it. I am not sure what makes sandwich and salad making so difficult but I tend to think it is an employee not caring issue. My salad clearly wasn't even close to full in the container but it went thru the person who made it without a blink. Disappointing to say the least. I won't be back. read more

We like to get their salads but four out of the last five salads we've ordered have had mistakes. You can say what you want, but my daughter would not order the Farmhouse salad if it has to have bleu cheese, for instance. Happens again, and we are done. Oh, one of these salads was at the Waukegan location. read more

I was pleased with most everything at my visit last night. The guys helping make the food friendly, listened and helpful. The food was made perfect and tasted great. The young girl using the cash register seemed more interested in text messaging. And seemed bothered by my need to pay her and ask questions. It was obnoxious. But again a minor part of my experience there. Thanks for the great food! read more

I picked up a cater order on 5/1 and it was ready exactly on time which was great. I had requested that all tomatoes be on the side (for allergy reasons) and I even called the day before to confirm they had gotten that note and the order would for sure be made with all tomatoes on the side. I picked the order up in Gurnee then drove an hour to my family's party. Opened the boxes to see tomatoes on the sandwiches. I did receive 3 containers of tomatoes on the side but that defeated the request. We had to order chicken for those family members allergic to tomatoes that could not eat the subs. Very disappointed that a request both in print on the order and verbally confirmed could not be fulfilled. read more

Nice energy feel. Good tunes piped in. Freshly made toasted sub with added avocado was surprisingly tasty. Service was ok. The gal whom puts the veggie ingredients on your sub was less than enthusiastic. However she was efficient, just seemed like she wanted to get outta there. We ate in and enjoyed the ambiance. read more

I was there last Saturday my salad was so old that I had to throw it away. The forgot to give me my soup. I can't find my receipt so I don't know if they charged me for it. I really like this place so I was not expecting my salad to be this bad and that they would forget to include my soup. Very disappointed:( read more

I still like their food but will never go back to this location strictly because of service. Last time 10 min just to get someone to come out if the back. This time I ordered a sandwich and a smoothie. Two girls came in after I did order different smoothies and sandwiches. The guy who took both our orders went to go do the smoothies after prepping there sandwiches. When I went to pay I asked if my smoothie was ready she said no only the other ones were what kind of service is that. I will never ever ever return to this location and suggest no one else do to until they train these young people how to do customer service. I blame owners and management. I will however go to any other Potbelly. read more

My parents come here all the time but today i went in here for food that we had ordered today. The guy behind the counter seemed like he had had a rough day but was still so so sweet. The food was scheduled to be ready at 745 we got there about 5 minutes early and the food was done at 750. The guy working apologized for the wait, explained that there was a minor malfunction on one of their equipment that caused the delay, then insisted (after I refused twice stating it was unneccesary) that I took a cookie for the wait. I've always liked this place but people like him make my day. Keep it up potbelly! Sincerely, a loyal and very satisfied customer. read more

My husband and I have been to this location twice, the first time I ordered the regular Italian sandwich with broccoli and cheddar soup and my husband had the big roast beef sandwich and chicken noodle soup. When we got to the cash we were only given our sandwiches and had to remind the cashier that we also wanted soup. We sat down to enjoy our sandwiches and soup but found it so loud in the restaurant that it was hard to enjoy it! It wasn't loud because there were so many customers, in fact my husband and I were the only customers there, it was loud because the staff were laughing and joking around and gossiping about people.... Normally seeing staff laughing and joking around when a restaurant isn't busy doesn't bother me, but the fact that they were so loud and gossiping about people (gossiping about their friends not customers, thank goodness) just rubbed me the wrong way! Regardless of the experience with noise, the sandwiches and soup were FANTASTIC! It was so good that we decided to return the following weekend to satisfy our craving! Now this second visit my husband and I decided to switched up our sandwich order, I ordered the Skinny Hammie and broccoli and cheddar soup, my husband got the big Italian and chicken noodle soup. Again we had to remind the cashier that we ordered soup, seems as though there is a lack of communication between placing your order with the person making your sandwich and the person at the cash. My husband and I opted to eat in even though we had a bad experience the last time, we wanted to enjoy our soup and sandwiches while they were hot. This time there were four other customers in the restaurant but the staff was still loud and joking around, however not as loud as last time and they were not gossiping!!! My husband enjoyed his sandwich and soup, I on the other hand did not enjoy mine. I had asked for the same toppings and condiments that i got last time, however this time they added way too much vinaigrette! The vinaigrette is pre measured for salads in little clear take out containers... So Instead of adding an appropriate amount of vinaigrette for a sandwich, she added the whole container enough for a salad! Next time I will ask for it on the side and add it myself, because this totally ruined my sandwich and made the bread so soggy it fell apart! I'm sure my husband and I will be back, now that we know what and how to order!!! However if something else happens to ruin our experience, I think we might give up on this location and go to another to get our fix! read more

Usually when I go here, i expect amazing food. This time i went, I got absolute trash! my sandwich tasted so plain and just not good...

The food is always good, but there were some big service gaps today. Asked for a peppermint shake, they yelled peppermint shake and the shout was returned. When we paid, we were told they didn't have peppermint and that we were told that in line. Odd that neither my husband or I heard that there wasn't peppermint. Shouldn't they have asked if we wanted a different flavour? Oh, and if there's no peppermint take down the sign. While we were eating we heard them call for a peppermint shake again, ridiculous. Tables were messy and obviously hadn't been cleaned in some time. Most of the napkin holders were empty. Not a good day for Potbellies. Oh and Diet Dr Pepper was out of order too. read more

I love this place. They make great cookies and the sandwiches hit the spot. The shakes are also as great as everyone says they are. What's cool about this location is they usually have someone singing, just like any guy or girl would in a coffee shop with their acoustic guitar. The workers are all very friendly as well. read more

To start with I was super hungry so since me and my husband had been here b4 I figured it was a safe bet...Not!!! I ordered a Big Italian! Usually they ask what you want on it. This guy told me that he was gonna fix it like it's supposed to be fixed! RUDE!!! Bottom line...wayyyy too many peppers and sloppy! Not to mention the huge guy working around the food with no hair net on his extremely long hair!!! I would not recommend this place for ANYTHING! Hopefully this establishment will disappear from Gurnee quicker than it opened up!!! read more

Another yelper pointed out that there is no drive-through at the Potbelly in Gurnee, and she is correct. I posted this review for the incorrect location. Should have been for the one at Waukegan. My apologies for the error. read more

Comfortable, warm environment. While there were only two people working, they were friendly and efficient. They were very busy but kept smiles on their faces. The food was delicious and definitely tasted fresher than some other sandwich shops. The only reason I didn't give my review a 5 was because the dining room needed some tidying up. read more

I have been a fan of Potbelly ever since I found out about this location. It used to be great! I enjoyed my regular wreak with everything for years! Currently not so great... the service is incredibly slow, I'm lucky if my sandwich maker even asks me what I want on it! Also the manager looks like he hates his life every time I'm in there. This location needs some revamping. read more

My wife and I drove out of our way after having a hankering for some potbelly after going to the gym, getting there at 8:15 pm (they close at 9:00 pm). We get to the register and realize there are no delicious cookies left that we worked so hard at the gym to enjoy. Our cashier Diego notices our dismay and says, "If you'd like, I can make you some fresh ones, if you are willing to wait 20 minutes". Right on time after enjoying our last bites, Diego comes to the rescue with a nicely packaged to go container of delicious freshly baked cookies. We felt Diego went above and beyond to ensure we were taken care of. Thanks potbelly!! read more

I was already a big fan of Potbelly's but this location has exceeded my expectations. I have never been to the actual restaurant, but I order catering from them quite frequently for work meetings. The staff is so friendly and helpful. One time I got my order a week early and when I called the restaurant, the manager told me to keep the order (over $100 for no charge) and they would make sure we got the order again on the correct date. They package and label the sandwiches and have each condiment separately packaged. Their cookies are superb. I always get compliments when I choose them for our lunch meetings. read more

Dirty restaurant. Filthy tables. Garbage on floors. Food prep area littered with trash. Pop machine empty. Pop station littered with garbage. Dirty. Don't eat here. I'm never coming back. read more

Please fix the cookies or retrain. They used to be great, now they suck. Sandwich was good. Thanks