I love this little Italian spot! My boyfriend and I come here for date night all the time, I love that they don't take reservations and it definitely has that neighborhood feel to it. They change their menu often, there specials are always different too; every time I go I get a different meal and I have never been disappointed! Drinks are good and reasonable in price as well. They usually have a wine on special or a home-made sangria! Definitely check it out if you are in the neighborhood and looking for a fresh, tasteful meal at a very reasonable price! read more

Great neighborhood gem! I had the whitefish special which was awesome - and the clam chowder which was made with a light but tasty base & just the right amount of seasoning. What else but just great food and wine - and what a bargain too!! read more

PR Italian Bistro - Whitefish - yummm! - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Food here is authentic Italian, and absolutely delicious. I've had brunch and dinner here. The menu changes frequently, but there is a core of items that seems to stay constant. There's outdoor seating in the summer. But the dining room and bar are both very nice. I've only ever had slow service once, and I think they may have been surprised by being so busy in the outdoor seating area. read more

Great pizza and salad. Service was cold and not friendly. Attitude was - eat and leave. Busy environment and server didn't give a rip about us. read more

Very very and overpriced drinks! Bartender has no clue how to mix or make drinks.. food is great, but bad drinks

Such an amazing place to eat. Great service, fantastic food and a great environment. Would and will recommend this restaurant to family and friends. read more

PR Italian Bistro - Gelati Italiani - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Went for dinner with a friend. Got seated quickly. We ordered fried mozzarella, shrimp appetizer and charcuterie to start off with. They were all good except we only got 2 pieces of fried mozzarella and there was 3 of us. For entrees, we ordered both pasta special and the samboca (chicken dish). IT was good as well. They don't give you bread basket. We only got a few pieces with some of the appetizers read more

PR Italian Bistro - Menu - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The $18 gnocchi had no flavor at all. I was expecting a better tasting gnocchi but was very disappointed. I asked for garlic bread with my pasta and it came out almost 10 minutes after I got my pasta. Ok experience nothing mind blowing for the price. read more

My wife and I chose this restaurant because of the reviews. It looked very nice in the pictures and the food looked really good. We came into the restaurant with high expectations but were immediately turned off by the waitress who was very dry and acted like she didn't want to be there. We had the appetizer called "Piadone" , which was the best dish we ate there aside from the drinks we had. However, the entrees were horrible. My wife had the "Angel Hair" entree (which included Crab) and I had the "Risotto Montanara"- both which were lacking in flavor. Honestly, if you're going to have entrees that are more than $20, they should at least have flavor. I believe that the entrees are the most important part of a 3 course meal. No flavor whatsoever. Our bill was $98.00 with tip included. Definitely not worth the time or money here. read more

Service was great. Location is great. Nice staff. However Salmon was good but didn't seem fresh. They charged us for refills too. Place needed some fresh air too. read more

Edit 2 - No, you're leaving it here because you're lying and I caught you in it. And like I said we don't review often we only do it when a business is EXCEPTIONALLY awful - its a public service really. It looks like a few other yelpers caught you in lies recently as well. You pretend like you don't know what the person is talking about or you call them a liar to deflect. If you're willing to lie about your business on a public platform, what are you doing to people's food behind the scenes? Things that they can't so easily see? You couldn't pay me to eat at your restaurant again. Also me writing a review on Yelp and my wife writing one on Google is not double attacking you. In fact we both could write reviews on both platforms to lower your stars even more if you'd like us to. It seems like you just make things up when you don't agree with it and can't lie your way out of it I've been going to this place for years. I got two salads over the last few months that had yellow arugula in it, with just a few good pieces sprinkled over the top to make it look nice. So not only do they have bad produce, but they know it and they're trying to hide it. Tried to give it a pass. But recently ordered a few dishes and the containers that the food was in came smelling like mothballs. Like it was in a damp moldy basement kinda smell and it transferred to the food. I almost threw up when I got the food. The meat was really bad quality, like something you get from Walmart. Chef is a great cook but you can't skimp out on the quality of the ingredients and what you deliver your food in. *Do you really have to be that cheap?* Your customers have been supporting you through the pandemic and keeping your business alive. Our account has ordered from you countless times throughout the pandemic and you should recognize that. Instead of giving us quality delivery you give us your worst products because we're not in house to complain about it. Shame on you! Lost a customer here. Edit/Response: Yes - My wife posted on google and I on Yelp. Why would that mean that it is made up? According to my other reviews I am not lying, what would make you say that? In fact, you are lying as you say that. Very unethical - but considering what you're serving other there it is not a surprise. We only post when we are very disturbed with the service - so that others know not to waste money. Looking at the other reviews recently we are not the only ones who see what you're doing. See pic of your 'fresh' salad. read more

PR Italian Bistro - The yellow salad that julianna says they don't serve - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Last night was my first visit to PR Italian Bistro and it did not disappoint! We started with the burrata and the baked Brie appetizers, both delicious. I ordered the Tordelli Brasati, which was a ravioli stuffed with short rib and covered in a brown butter sage sauce which was to die for! Unfortunately we had room for dessert, but I'll definitely be back to try one of the cookie skillets! I highly recommend PR Italian to anyone looking for a delicious meal, great service, and a cozy neighborhood feel! read more

PR Italian Bistro - Tordelli Brasati - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Valentines turned nightmare. Worst steak I've ever ate and i love spending money at fine dine restaurants. I'm disgusted at the fact that I received a ribeye steak that consisted of mostly fat rather than the juicy meat. It's almost as if they took the meat out of the fridge and served it to me like that, that's how raw the meat was. I gagged at the fact of how bad it was. The waiters don't care about anything but to get you out of there as soon as possible. I was rushed just like my ribeye steak was rushed. The worst steak I've ever ate. Highly dissatisfied and flat out disgusted. I payed my hard earned money for raw meat! Furious is an understatement to my actual emotions. Never paying so much for this lack of cooking. I want my money back. read more

PR Italian Bistro - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This is my fav restaurant in this area! The most delicious margarita ever!!! Nice and courteous service is a good point too. read more

Best Italian take out I have had in a very long time. Pasta was great, Caesar salad lasted in my fridge for days, shrimp appetizer was fab. My go to now for Italian take out. Look forward to eating at the actual restaurant given how good it tasted after traveling. read more

Too bad it's not called "Service and Ambiance Rustica" because on that alone it's stellar; but it's called "Pizza Rustica" and the food is not very good. The ambiance was inviting and cute. It's well decorated and good for dates, friend outings, and families. The service from everyone was great with a special stand out being NICK our server. He was the shining star of our dining experience. We ordered: Steigel Weisse (for him) Grapefruit Basil Martini (for me) Prosecco (for me) A starter of Arancini from the specials menu It's balls of polenta with beef and peas in the center that are fried and served w sauce on the side. It sounded different so we ordered it. This irked me. It arrived with one falafel sized Arancini ball cut in half. I learned after we got the check it was $7....that much for something the size of a small meatball? And cut? If we had been a party of 4 would it been cut into quarters?!? LAME! It was not very good either and it was cold. When it comes to ordering the pizza it's very confusing. We each ordered a slice (which is actually the size of a quarter block of a big pizza cut into several squares...? Weird but generous I guess) They only have one kind of crust and it's very regarded. Cheese with pepperoni and garlic for my dining partner. Tutta for me which is cheese w pepperoni, crumbled sausage, onions, black olives, and blue cheese and I requested easy sauce. Neither of us liked it. My partner was very hungry and he really struggled to eat even a portion. He found it incredibly salty. It was. We both didn't like the famous butter crust raved about. It had no taste of butter or olive oil. It was very dry and hard; it felt like we were eating an enormous super thick crouton with toppings on it. We prefer thin crust, and this crust wasn't thin or traditional thick style but like a hard, book thick stale cracker due to a strange texture. We thought the sauce was bland. I only found 2 tiny bits of sausage in my big "piece." I ended up eating the toppings off. It's a shame since the service was great and it's a cute place. read more

See all

No fresh parmigiana or black pepper, think they gave us a jar of red pepper. Pasta was salty and way to much garlic, aranchini balls very tiny and bufala was served as mozzarella balls. Waiter liked to push wine but did not come back and ask us how things were. Not very traditional, asked for some extra bread and gave us two pieces. read more

So, somehow I missed the whole crust/texture deal about the pizza in the reviews. Reading for comprehension is my bag, y'all. But, we'll get to that. My take away from Pizza Rustica? I need to move to Europe. Like, tomorrow. I arrived right when the restaurant opened on a slow Monday late morning and had the place to myself. The owner came up to me, introduced himself, asked what I wanted and I replied I was waiting for a friend and would wait to order at that time. He poured me a glass of water and, rather than ignore me until my friend arrived, he struck up a conversation about Italy, America, lifestyles, what's important in life, what I'm looking for, and how to get it. It was incredibly illuminating. Aside from the whole 'economy might crash,' thought of living a simpler, more connected life was pretty appealing. And, it's always good to get a perspective that's greater than your own. As I pondered his words, my friend arrived and we commenced to the business of eating. When in Rome (heh)... you eat. A lot. As refreshing as water is, it has nothing on aranciata so I downed one of those. Actually, I sipped. I was freshly learned in the ways of savoring life. I sipped. The Rustica salad with artichoke, goat cheese and spinach was a revelation in simplicity. I don't know whether I was hungry or inspired, but I gobbled up every bite while attempting to concentrate on every chew. Savor. Wanting to taste the whole of this restaurant, we ordered a half Tutta: sausage, pepperoni, bleu cheese, olives, onions, and mushrooms. Once I got past the crust (more corn-mealy than I was expecting), I concentrated on the ingredients, sauce, and texture. Each bite was like a good conversation with a friend. Yes, the food was good and I'd gladly come back to enjoy more of it but it was the act of striking up a conversation with a stranger, getting to know someone and having the chance to connect with another human being on a basic level (food is a great equalizer) that makes me a fan. Life is short, it should be enjoyed. I know, I know. Pizza. Yes. But sitting down over a glass over water, waiting for a tardy friend and having the chance to gain perspective from someone who's enjoyed a meaningful way of life... it makes an impression on you. Me. On me. It made an impression on me. Rustica. I like the sound of it... read more

DAMNIT! Here is ANOTHER near-perfect place which I wish existed in my neighborhood. Welcoming, attractive interior; delicious food; reasonable prices and good value; friendly, competent service; BYOB; great for a date, a small group of friends, or a solo weekend lunch...I'm glad that I found it but why does it have to be so far away? According to Yelp, I bookmarked this joint on 5/27, and finally got around to eating there last night. I actually tried to lunch there on my birthday a few weeks ago, but they are closed on Tuesdays. Watch out! I liked the square pizza: perfectly-balanced proportions of the holy quirumvirate of crust, cheese, sauce, and toppings. The crust reminded me of Pizza Hut pan style, which is entirely a compliment. We ordered the Four Seasons (mushrooms, tomatoes, artichokes, and ham), which slightly edged out the Margherita. I'll be coming back to try that one (and others, plus the sandwiches and who knows how much else). A- on the pizza. The caprese salad was one of the best I've ever had. They made a nice balsamic vinegar, herb, and olive oil drizzle over the top. So damn good. A. With one visit, this place blew right past "remember this when in the neighborhood and hungry for pizza" territory and into "date-night destination restaurant" territory. Only four miles of distance keeps it from "get fat by eating here with alarming regularity" territory. If I visit two more times with no disasters, Rustica goes up to five stars (and I am stingy with those 5-star reviews). read more

Randomly yelp this place on Saturday night with my wife cause we just wanted to have a nice dinner we didn't know what to expect so..... We were greeted and seated right away. Our Waiter Adil guided us through the entire menu and recommended our wine and meals and I have to say it was very very good. We had the house red wine and Cereal Killer beer to start. The meal that we had was the Grill Ribs and the Pizza Tutta and for dessert we had the tiramisu. Every bite from the ribs, pizza, tiramisu was incredible so if your every in the area or not I definitely recommend this place and ask for Adil to be your waiter cause he made the night with all his recommendations. Thank you Adil and we'll definitely be back. read more

See all

Heard good things so have it a try. Ordered pizza which took 45 minutes to come out. Received no apology from the waitress who we also didn't see for 40 minutes after ordering. The table was literally two small for 1 pizza platter and a set of appetizer plates so we had to hold our plates throughout dinner to avoid them from falling off, mind you there was only 2 of us. Pizza was fine, nothing to write home about. Oh and the specials? They were scrawled out in writing you could barely read. Won't be returning read more

PR Italian Bistro - Literally can't fit the plates on the table...poor design - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Ordered take out from PR Italian Bistro. Was not given the correct food I ordered and then it was a complete hassle to deal with their team. (Had to email then told to call, they couldn't do anything at the time and was told I would get a call back but didn't so had to go back to email). The food ended up being very subpar so between the poor management and poor food. I see no reason to order from or go to this establishment. Linguine Padovani - bland / flavorless. Asparagus undercooked Spaghetti Bolognese - sour tasting. Stomach turner. read more

This. Place. Is. Amazing. I have been here several times since moving to the area, and have never been disappointed in the food, or the service. The bartenders and servers are some of the nicest people I have met working at a restaurant, and are always extremely helpful. Cocktails are always on point. Things you should order: 1. their puttanesca pizza, it's to die for. 2. arrabbiata pasta, spicy but not too spicy 3. the shrimp risotto special if they have it FYI closed on Tuesdays. read more

PR Italian Bistro - Burrata blackboard special- mozzarella ball w/ creamy center over arugula w/ cherry tomatoes, crostini and basil pesto balsamic - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The food isn't the problem here, it's not great but it's not bad, the problem is the service. Every time I've been here most of the staff (minus the hostess) are so surly they seem annoyed that I'm there. Sorry to offend with my desire to give you money! Beyond that I've waited inordinate amount of time for things like Caesar salad (20+minutes) with no explanation or refill of drinks. I live a block away so I've given this place multiple tries and I'm left with the same impression and felt compelled to write this review so others know what to expect. Btw take a look at my other reviews and you'll note I'm not a person who goes around talking smack willy-nilly read more

It is great eating outside while you can. My gf got the Linguine Padovani. She liked it a lot. I tasted it and I agree. I got meatballs and sautéed green beans. The meatballs are the best I have ever eaten in my life. The sautéed green beans were cooked perfectly and tasty. Our server was a very nice girl. All food arrived hot. I only take away one star because I like my Heineken and they don't offer it. Their menu is also a little short, but other than that it would be 5 stars. read more

We had a wonderful family dining experience and definitely want to return soon! The night was beautiful so we chose to eat outside. Perfect! Everything from the service, to cocktails, and food was everything we hoped for. Matt took great care of us and the owners were hands on to ensure we were enjoying ourselves. We all ordered our own entrees and sampled one another's dishes. A couple of my favorites included the Luna Rossa, Pollo Chioggia, Cacio E Pepe. Be sure to check this place out if you're in the Wrigleyville area and want something more than the normal bar food. Thanks for a great time! read more

PR Italian Bistro - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This place is simply put - unbelievable. I am kicking myself for having bookmarked this business ages ago and only now have gotten around to trying it. The space is tiny, and there was a small wait for a table. When we were finally seated, we had a very pleasant server who explained the large selection of specials in his delightful Italian accent. Listen carefully, because it is loud in there and a bit hard to hear. I don't know what Andy was thinking, but I heard him order a panini. This was a little shocking because we were seated right next to the pizza oven and I was sure the gorgeous pies emerging steaming hot and wonderfully fragrant would have sold him right away. Luckily, I was able to convince him to change his order and I was able to sample one of the very best pizzas in town. A fantastic, rich buttery crust that framed intensely fresh and flavourful ingredients. If you dislike the "cracker crust" so often found in Chicago, or deep dish, then you will want to come here. I ordered a special, which was the Pappardelle al Telefono. While it does sound like it should be "pasta over a telephone", in fact it was a wide noodle covered in an amazing tomato and wine sauce. Hands down it was one of the best pasta dishes I have ever had. Since it is so small in there, if you can't do take out or delivery, I suggest getting there early or going on a slow night. This is a place you are going to want to experience. read more

PR Italian Bistro - the special I ordered: Pappardelle al Telefono - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Those of you that know me know that I love a good deep dish pizza. This place is NOT for deep dish. Now that I've gotten that out of the way, this place has become one of our go-to places for incredibly tasty pizza of the flat-bread variety. Pizza Rustica is reliable for delivery and a great place to meet friends. Located on Sheridan, near the Red line, means that it's easy to get to and so it's easy to set up a big gathering without too many people worrying about parking. For us, it's an easy walk (except in winter) and the atmosphere is always pleasant, the staff friendly, and the wine selection excellent. If you stop by, always remember to check the specials on the wall (it's on the boards opposite to the bar) or be sure to ask the waiters. If you're in the mood for a great pizza, try the truffle pizza, it's our current don't-wanna-cook-let's-order-something-instead fall back. read more

PR Italian Bistro - From the patio! - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Thank you for your response and I am truly glad that you are saying that you do not treat customers differently based on their appearance. I would like to point out that I did not accuse you of anything, yet only pointed out what my parents noticed while dining there therefore I am glad that it was not a factor. I will say that while there they noticed you "Stefano " overlooking the dining area. This would have been a perfect opportunity to come over, introduce yourself as the owner/chef and apologize for their food being "forgotten" the 1st time that way perhaps, it wouldn't have been forgotten the 2nd time as the wonderful waitress pointed out. I've dined around the world and that is just a basic formality. Thank you again for your response and next time they are in town visiting their grandchildren, I will attempt to get them to dine there and to ask for you, in order to get to "know you" and to ensure the best dining experience! -Be well read more

I went to PR Bistro for a Sunday brunch with my boyfriend and we left beyond satisfied. The service was great and our waitress made excellent recommendations. The bloody mary bar was superb with tons of options for every taste. I ate the breakfast burger with a side of fries. It was hearty and flavorful. My boyfriend got the frittelle and devoured the entire plate. I'll be coming back for brunch soon and can't wait to check out the dinner menu. read more

Food, drinks, service are all well-above par. Incredibly impressive. My partner and I decided to go out spur of the moment on a Saturday evening. We expected a bit of a wait, but were seated immediately. We had our drinks within minutes of walking in the door. They have an impressive beer list and the cocktail I had was inventive and so flavorful (bourbon with Prosecco should not work this well together). I am a vegetarian, and my partner is a staunch carnivore. We split a mozzarella-based appetizer that was so fresh and hearty, we both argued over the last bites. He had the ribeye, which was a generous portion and looked gorgeous. He loved it. I had the vegetarian lasagna and the veggies topping it were cooked perfectly and the sauce tasted fresh and house-made, which I love. None of our glasses ever got below half-full. The staff was attentive and friendly. We can't wait to go back. Next time, we decided we have to leave some room to try dessert. I'll try to update when we do. read more

Excellent food I had salmon - perfectly cooked - and a nice big slice- very nice. Guests had pasta arabiatta - They really enjoyed that as well Started w the mista salad - Again; excellent. So why not 5 stars instead of 4? The waiters - They don't smile. They're efficient - And quick But they lack the friendliness I am accustomed to. No chit chat. No banter. No enthusiasm whatsoever. The owner is great - super concerned w making sure the food quality is excellent which it is ..... but - waiters have to be more friendly, welcoming, enjoyable- this is after all hospitality 101. I'll definitely be back though bc this place is a winner. read more

I live in the neighborhood and have been coming here for the last three years and always love the atmosphere, food, and drinks. They have great pasta and I love that they have a changing blackboard menu with new and exciting choices. I wish they would add a few more pasta dishes to their main menu though so that there would be more options. Unfortunately over the years the service has been a bit hit or miss here - sometimes we're ignored for about 15 minutes after sitting down, which means not even having water to drink or the blackboard menu to look at. Overall though I love to come here on date night, order a bottle of wine, some appetizers, and a main dish and have a great time. read more

PR Italian Bistro - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

My new go-to for the solo dining experience in my neighborhood. A very friendly, social bar. The food is excellent. Try the Spaghetti Bolognese, or the Lasagne. Very good Caesar salad. Unfortunately, they do not give you bread with your meal, nor do you get a side salad. Solid drink menu. A tiny bit spendy, No TVs. Great atmosphere. Copper bar. Tin ceiling. read more

I live right around the street for PR bistro and for some reason had never been. A group of friends were visiting and suggested we go for dinner one of the nights-- it was FABULOUS. Made me deeply regret not visiting sooner. All my friends and I raved about our dishes (I got the gluten free pasta- thank you for having this option!) Would love a gluten free pizza/ flatbread option as well. The atmosphere is also incredible and they have great drinks (including delicious, not too sweet ciders) at the bar. So cute, cozy, romantic. Honestly, the best! And not too expensive. read more

First things first....order the Spicy ginger lime cocktail!!! This is an amazing drink and just because you see jalapeño listed as an ingredient, don't be scared off! The flavors blend so well together that you never experience a sharp jalapeño taste, but rather a smooth, completely tasty drink. Hubby and son had the Cucumber lemon and they were happy with their drinks as well, but I'm going on record that my drink was the best! We shared several items for dinner in an attempt to taste as many dishes as possible. We shared some pizza, the Linguine Black Ink pasta dish and the Gnocchi dish. Everything was very good, with my personal favorite being the Linguine Black Ink pasta. This is another location within walking distance of my son's and I know we will back next time we are in town. read more

This place is everything I look for in a restaurant! The ambiance is the perfect vibe of dimly lit and romantic at night but bright and cheery during the day. The food is superb and authentic to the Italian roots they boast. My server, Lexi, was attentive and personable while making sure she was accommodating my every need without making me feel high maintenance! The only problem I've ever with this place is the bartender and his anxiousness to constantly rush myself as well as others I've seen, out the door. It seemed like he just wanted to close up and get out of the place.....Otherwise I highly recommend!!!! read more

PR Italian Bistro - Italian Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I'm not an avid yelper but I was so confused when I saw PR had lukewarm stars so I had to say something. I used to live in this neighborhood and when I did i didn't come here often enough! Now that I live in Ravenswood I craved some really good pizza so I came back. Its a perfect date spot, with lovely ambiance and relaxed atmosphere and the food is really phenomenal. We shared the beef carpaccio special which was awesome but the main star is the pizza. If you are looking for amazing, fresh, inventive, delicious pizza. come here. Immediately. Ps. Cocktail and especially wine list is on point for a small business Plus it's owned by a husband and wife duo, can't get more Chicago than that. read more

I had such a great time at Pizza Rustica, that giving it anything less than a 5 star rating would be wrong!!! Our server (unfortunately never got his name but he had a cute accent) was outstanding!!! Our group of 17 pretty much took up the entire restaurant as well as used up all their plates, wine glasses, and utensils. But he didnt care!!! Super friendly and worked with us in taking our orders, even with the latecomers. My friend was throwing a party here and organized her own set menu. We started off with two options for salad, then in between the salad and the entree we had so many variety of pizzas, all of which were deliciously thin crust (my favorite!). Beware of the jalepeno one, its no joke. Freakin hot! The entrees were only okay but not bad. We had pasta with meat sauce. I would say stick to the pizzas here if you can. The restaurant is BYOB and our group definitely took advantage of that. I cant even tell you how many beer bottles/wine bottles we went through. But our server was really good about clearing off our table. Definitely would come back here again. Great time, great pizza! read more

In case the 490+ reviews wasn't enough of a tip, this place is great! The insides is warm and cozy, the patio is cool and breezy (disclaimer: only on a cool and breezy day). They have a nice selection of salads, soups, pasta and pizzas. In a city that claims to have the best pizza, Pizza Rustica is still tops my list, sorry Giordanos. The Pizza is delicious, great selection of different specialty pizzas, we loved the Sapposa and Pollo Pesto, but the buttery crust is what really sets Pizza Rustica apart. For real, that crust though. Pizza Sizes are half and whole, we split two halfs between three of us, ate very generously and still had some for breakfast the next day! They do get busy after Cubs games, and the Chef may step outside and ask your table to leave as they have other people waiting... so there is that, but otherwise service was great! read more