We ordered delivery as we didn't realize this place was takeout only, but I have to leave a review to compliment them on the BEST NY style pizza we've ever had in Chicago! There may not be any other choices, but still, we all loved it & will definitely be back for more! We ordered for my Birthday & decided to go with what we heard they were famous for with a Spicy Spring Pie (Spicy Peperoni Pizza in Square Slices), Mercer Margherita Pie (Fancy Margherita in Square Slices), & The Old School 18" Pie (NY style Pepperoni Pizza in a Round Pie). The Spicy Spring Pie & Mercer Margherita were apparently SoHo Sicilian Style Pizzas & while we all enjoyed the different pizzas, our clear FAVORITE was The Old School Pie as it was JUST like a NY style slice of pizza! Amazing flavor & good foldable slices with excellent undercarriage! Highly recommend this place & the service was great as the pizza came fast! The place looked like a good place to pick up a slice from the pictures other people posted online. If you're looking for a NY style pizza then you've found it at Prince Street! We can't wait to go back & enjoy the other types of pizza they have! read more

See all

My tip: order online in advance on their website, then go in to pick-up. Helps you avoid a crazy west loop rush line. I'm sure they're cranking the pizzas out as fast as they can, but just helps cut down on your "in-person" line. Hot honey is so good, a bit oily, but man I love their square Detroit style. 10/10 read more

Prince Street Pizza - The Naughty Pie - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Mmmm pizza. I wanted to have a picnic with pizza, and this place has been on my list for over a year. I thought it would be the perfect pizza to get for a picnic because we could choose the slices we wanted and they put each slice in a cute personal pizza box, making it easy to transport and eat on the ground. The ordering process was really simple and fast. They had a bunch of different pizzas available by the slice, and they heated them up very quickly for us. We were only inside for maybe 10 minutes before getting our pizza. I'm pretty sure I went to their NYC location when I was there, so I'm super happy Chicago has a location too!! Can't wait to go again. The spicy spring is so delicious and so was the fancy prince. read more

See all

This is drunk food. Why is this place rated so highly? It was just okay pizza, 100% NOT worth the price. Now I heard that they are known for their Detroit style pizza and I didn't try that. Based off what I got I believe this is a gimmick spot and the hype is all in the name and expectation rather than the reality. Try at your own risk. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Cheese ricotta pie - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Got takeout on a weekend during the AAPI collabs that prince street has been doing and just had to quickly write that the Soho baos made by Chiu Quon bakery available during week 3 of the event in May were chefs kiss ‍ Very unique, never had anything like it - it was like pizza on the outside, dumpling on the inside. Yes it had a savory onion-ey filling that somehow worked with the cheesy pepperoni goodness As an asian american myself, was happy to see this location in Chicago was participating. Will have to return to try more of Prince Streets standard offerings read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza choices in front display - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Late night, Detroit style, by the slice, fast moving staff, fresh ZA right out of the oven, THIS PLACE IS A MUST STOP. The history and vibe this place offers is great, I had quite the experience. The pizza is delicious, and I love the variety available. I'll be back! Thanks PSP team!!! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Got delivery from here on a Thursday night. I ordered the 18" pepperoni pizza with a side of "not ranch" and marinara. The pizza was pretty dry, not full of flavor and the crust was also very dry and burnt but not in the delicious crispy way, it was not a caramelized way. It was also seemingly trying to be a New York style but again missed the mark. I wouldn't come back but the food was fine. read more

See all

It's a small shop with a bar at the window to eat. We went late night and were able to get slices quickly and take it back to the hotel still hot. read more

A New York staple competing with Chicago in the pizza dept! We had some Inkind credits to be use and ideally we prefer take out because we need readily accessible for a hungry 3 year old toddler. Naughty Pie - little kick to it and a sweetness to it too I'll be honest, I think ours coulda been cooked longer. By time we got home the food was cold but that to blame the transportation of the goods. Just not sure if the mozzarella was supposed to stay in a cheese stick form. I'm more used to the ooey gooey ones. We also tried to plop it back in the air fryer but didn't do it any good. Don't manage to finish the whole pie but when we reheat it in the air fryer it tasted way better than yesterday. So I'm kinda half and half on this meal. Don't hate it but not loving it loving it. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I'm always excited when something new opens up, but the first few times I tried to go, the line was so long that I waited until the hype died down. After a few visits, I've found it's kind of hit or miss. Some flavors are really delicious, while others are just... not it. It can also be pretty pricey for a slice, especially in a city full of great pizza where consistency matters. I'm someone who likes to explore and try different options, but experimenting here has sometimes left me underwhelmed. I've given this place a few tries, mostly because they were on InKind. Early on, this location wasn't accepting it, but lately I haven't had any issues using it. My advice: stick to what you already know and love, because trying new flavors doesn't always pay off. The location is small and cozy. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Returned to Prince St for two Too Good To Go boxes. The food quality remains so high, that we were wowed even with day old slices. The more classic flavors left a bit to be desired flavor wise, but the gourmet flavors nailed it. Recommend the Soho Squares over NY slices any day with their texture and delicately light crisp! Flavor reviews: Original and Fancy Prince--6/10. Good. Nothing special Prince perfection--7/10. One point higher due to awesome crust but wanted more standout flavors Oakey Smokey--10/10. WOW. The smoked mozz is the only difference from the fancy prince and it made all the difference. Depth of flavor was insane Chicago supreme--10/10. This pie is a chicagoans dream. Giardiniera is HOT but in the best way possible. Both the sausage and pepperoni have fantastic flavor on their own read more

See all

I wanted to try this place because I'd heard a lot about it. There wasn't a line when I went, so ordering was pretty straightforward. It took a decent amount of time since they had to warm up the pizza after ordering, but totally worth it. I ordered the spicy spring, spicy vodka, and meat lovers. I really liked all of them. Each slice was just a good pizza slice, crispy crust with sauce and toppings that were properly portioned. The spicy options had a nice kick without being overwhelming, and the meat lovers was filling without being too heavy. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Spicy spring Spicy vodka Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Let me start off by saying I had NO plans or intention of going here...(haha) I was walking by and was slightly hungry so I decided to give a new place a try. Once I saw (The Naughty Pie) SPICY VODKA SAUCE on a pizza... I was hooked. They could have taken all my money. I've never seen such a thing. I only ordered a slice, for about $7 and I really like how they tossed the pizza in the oven before they give it to you. Makes it taste fresh & crispy. The service was great, the lady knew all the slices & had a story for each of them. I look forward to coming back & showing other people this place. Thank you Prince Street Pizza, see you soon! Personal Review: 8.4 read more

See all

Update: Catering / party orders at PSP are also fantastic. Had about 8 pizzas + salad + cake for a large group and everything came perfectly. The pizza is to die for. Literally the best in Chicago. read more

See all

Another New York restaurant makes its way to Chicago! This take-away spot was very good! Lately it takes alot for pizza to impress me nowadays. It's been a while since I've had Detroit style slices. The spicy vodka slice is my favorite! Simple but something about it was soooo good! Their pizza flavors are unique and I want to try them all. There is no seating. Just a small counter in the front where you can quickly eat inside. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Tasty late night pizza. Went on a Friday around 11 and it was easy to walk in the take out door and grab some slices. Parking will be tough if you're not on foot but we were able to get a spot right in front for a quick in and out. ETA: the spicy pepperoni is very good! I liked that there was plenty of it on there and just the right amount of thickness! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Naughty pie (top left), spicy vodka (left), 4 cheese (right) - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Great late night snack! I got the naughty pie and the Mercer margarita! Can't go wrong with either! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Got delivery. $7 cheaper from the site through ChowNow than UberEats. Naughty Pie - 5/5. Exceptional. Fluffy thick base, sweetness from honey, tanginess from tomato sauce. The rare pizza with a crush I want to eat. Yes it is $43, but it is a massive portion. 4-8 servings based on how much you eat. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Naughty Pie - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

This pizza is phenomenal. We ordered a whole pie to go and it was so delicious! Great addition to Chicago's pizza scene read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I loved how many different pizzas you could choose from! They have a ton of combinations that looked great. You can also choose either large New York slice or a square slice with thicker crust. We got the classic New York, the potato, and the 4 cheese. They have the pizzas pre-cooked and then will warm your slice up after you order. It was great pizza, but a little expensive for a single slice. The restaurant is take out only and is a bit crowded inside while waiting for your food to be warmed up. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I finally made time to stop at Prince Street with my girlfriend and it was so delicious. I am so glad we came around 11:40am on Sunday a little bit after they opened because as soon as we placed our order customers didn't stop coming in. I ordered the Green Machine & the Mercer Margherita. My girlfriend got the Chicago Supreme & the Naughty Pie. As soon as we took our first bite we knew what the hype was all about. Can't wait to come back for more! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Ordered a GF pizza online. You can only order GF ahead of time and will need to order a full pizza. I ordered the sunset square. The box had a GF friendly sticker on it. There are disclosures that it may not be safe for celiacs. I was able to enter gluten allergy in the comments section just to make sure they can take extra precaution. They also have a flourless chocolate cake which was delicious. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I got a meat lovers deep dish slice and it was very delicious! But on the contrary, the slice cost $9 after tax! To get an entire pie it was $45! These prices are completely unjustifiable, but otherwise if your a tourist and in the Chicago area around here, it's definitely a good one stop place to try on your bucket list! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

My friends and I ordered 5 different types of pizza slices to try them out, and we all enjoyed what we had. While none of us would say that any of what we got were exceptionally spectacular, they were more than solid. Specifically I tried the Mercer Margherita first, and I thought it was very good because the sauce had both savor and sweetness, and the mozzarella cheese tasted very fresh. However, the pecorino romano didn't offer as much additional flavor subtlety, and as a result didn't really distinguish the Margherita from the Vegan, which tasted almost exactly the same other than vegan cheese instead. The Oakey Smokey suffered from the same issue, tasting too similar to the two kinds I have just mentioned, since the sauce was also the most potent ingredient. While my friends didn't comment too much on their pizza slices, they enjoyed the slices. Overall it was a good experience trying this establishment. read more

See all

The pizza is fine here. I do prefer another one in the area. Workers are nice enough. The space is small, so you're probably not going to be eating here. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

Ordered the naughty pizza which is a vodka sauce and pepperoni. Pizza was really good. Loved the pepperoni - that thick cut small slices were delicious. I also really liked the vodka sauce but recognized it was perhaps a bit sweet/bit heavy. But I quite liked how it added something different. I go back and forth on the crust though - it's a thicker, focaccia / Detroit style type crust that I'm not sure I loved. It was good, just perhaps thicker than I expected; it's not dense, but it is tall. Probably a bit more like 4.5 stars honestly as I'd rather a Paulie Gee's, Pequod's, Ranalli's etc. read more

Prince Street Pizza - naughty one pizza - really good! - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Was excited to try this NY pizza transplant at a street festival recently! While I can't speak to the restaurant vibe, the staff was very friendly and did a great job handling the large crowd. I tried the Spicy Spring with hot honey and a side of the "Not Ranch" sauce, which tasted similar to a Caesar dressing. The pizza was piping hot with plentiful pepperoni that was *perfectly* crispy! There was a generous topping of cheese and sauce, but the thick crust soaked it up nicely and stomachaches were successfully averted. I'm not typically a thick crust person but the texture was closer to a fluffy focaccia. Highly recommend stopping by if you're in the mood for something different- will definitely be back to try more of the menu! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Spicy spring - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Updating my review! Stopped in here for a slice and loved it. As long as I stay clear of the sweeter pizza with goat cheese, I'm good. I tried one of their cheese/tomato sauce pizzas and it was delicious. Crispy crust and yummy interior. Best to eat hot right after it comes out of the oven. Felt like I was in NYC for a hot minute! Staff was kind as well. read more

Some really good pizza flavors, available in a healthy sized slice or a full pie. The slices are Detroit style and they have all kinds of fun flavors. I had the spicy spring and the meat lovers (2 slices). Right on Randolph, pop in and pop out. Small place, took it to-go. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizzas on sale - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

If you're looking for a great late night pizza spot in West Loop, Prince St. Pizza is the place to go. They sell individual slices with so many different flavor options, and you can choose between Detroit style or New York style pizza depending on what you're craving. The toppings are flavorful and the pizza is always great. This has become my friends and my favorite late night spot whenever we want good food after a night out. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I've been to New York a few times already but I've never had Prince St Pizza there. And I'm glad we have one here now in Chicago because this pizza is the truth. I initially placed an order online for pickup. Since kit was a Friday during lent I ordered Mercer Margherita Pie since it has no meat and an order of their Arancini. I unfortunately received mozzarella sticks instead of arancini. I informed the manager and he told me he would take care of it on my next visit. The Mercer Margherita was ok. I thought it would be a little bit thicker and saucier. It still tasted good and I would say a healthy filling. I probably wouldn't order it again though. The mozzarella sticks that I got by mistake were just ok either. They were supposed to be smoky but I didn't even get a hint of smoke. In returned a few weeks later to get my arancini, and the manager on duty took care of it without hesitation. I also took advantage while I was there to get some of their Spicy Spring slices. Definitely without a doubt one of the best pepperoni slices I have ever had. It came with their Fra Diavolo Sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella and pecorino Romano. I like the margherita pizza I ordered last time, this pizza had the perfect amount of thickness. The sauce had the perfect amount of heat and a plenty of pepperoni. A true masterpiece of a pizza. I'll definitely be returning. read more

See all

SO GOOD! We stopped in for a quick slice while we were out shopping. It was kind of busy for Christmas Eve so I wonder what other days look like, but we got our food pretty quickly. They had almost everything on the menu available which was great. The crust is perfectly crispy the way they toast it. We got two slices of pizza and a drink to share (which they very kindly refilled for us once we finished). The staff was very friendly! The only reason I didn't give this place 5 stars is because there's literally 1 bar top that maybe 4 people can stand and eat at. I guess that's the vibe they're going for, but they seem busy enough maybe a table or two wouldn't hurt! read more

Was looking to spend some "inkind" app dollars which is a cool app that has tons of restaurants on it in Chicago and gives you cash back from dining out. My cousin was in the mood for pizza so we went on the hunt. After checking this place out on Yelp and seeing the pizza slices I told her I think we found the one. The square cut is what did it for us as she's from Detroit and I prefer a Detroit or NY style pizza OR the traditional square cut Chicago style pizza (not that deep dish stuff). This place is along a strip of different restaurants and bars it really lives up to its NYC flair as there is no where to sit and it's about the size of a small bedroom lol. They do have a table situation against the window but there are no barstools you eat standing and head on out. We ordered the large meat lovers pizza which was 8 slices and $41 before tax. The pizza took about 45 minutes so we went to a bar and had a couple drinks while waiting. When we went to pick the pizza up it was piping hot and we dug right on it once we got back to our hotel room. That pizza was so good and flavorful and packed with meat in every bite. We of course couldn't finish it and packed it up to bring back home the next day. The cashier a young Black woman was so nice and friendly she walked us through using the inkind app and it was definitely appreciated! Definitely will be back! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

I like the pizza here and they have both Chicago style and New York style. I tried the spicy spring pan slice and the Oakey Smokey thin slice. The Spicy spring just had a tiny kick to it. The Oakey Smokey tasted light and fresh. This place is so near my condo in Chicago and I can't believe I haven't tried it until now. Great place to get pizza especially for a Bears game! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Thin and thick pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

I got a personal pizza one day and coincidentally the next day I got a slice at beyond wonderland. Service was nice and the pizza was fire. Solid stuff. I did pick up and never dined it but the interactions I had were friendly. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Came here on Sunday at 6:30, only waited about 10 minutes in line! They were very quick. We also walked home 10 minutes after getting our pizza and it was still warm! It's a cute spot, small space. I got 3 slices to try. The spicy spring, the naughty pie and the hot girl pie. The pepperoni here is amazing. The hot girl pie was the perfect amount of spice. The naughty pie was my other favorite, full of flavor. I really liked prince st because it is a big piece but it doesn't feel as greasy as other places. Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

The pizza was great, the pizza was airy and crispy not burnt. The service was ok nothing crazy they are fast to get your pizza slice warmed up and get it to you fast. Ambiance is good vibes small place just grab n go. You can eat it in the car or walking outside great area read more

Got Prince Street delivered last night while my beautiful wife was at work. Delivered quickly and very fresh. Fast service. My friends and I got the Spicy Pepperoni and the Fancy Pie. Fancy Pie is a very large Margherita Pizza. We loved both of them. The Spicy Pepperoni is more of a Sicilian style crunchy crust. The price is a touch steep for pizza, but thats America these days. I feel like the high quality and size of the pies justifies the price. You won't be disappointed- I really liked this pizza. read more

Some of the best pizza I've had in Chicago. The slices stay crispy when heated up so there's no pizza flop. The flavors are insane. The vodka slice was my favorite crispy and delicious. Love that you can get slices or buy a whole pie. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Vodka slice, pepperoni classic slice, white slice - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Prince St Pizza has been the talk of the town and lines have been raging out the door. I gave it a bit of time to die off but even then, lines still exist on weekends. I went on Friday evening around 7 and waited in line for about 15-20 minutes and it took another 3-5 minutes to get my pizza slices. For those who haven't been in the storm of it all, there are two lines - one for walk-in orders (left by Sangamon) and one for online pickup orders (right side, Morgan St). I would ask the folks in line to double-check so you're not in the wrong line. They still haven't managed this, so it's still very chaotic. Even if you place an online order, you're still going to have to wait. For obvious reasons, you'll get your order faster if you're ordering by slice vs whole pie. The shop itself is super small and each pizza slice ranges from $6-7. I like square pizzas so I went with the Vodka and the Hot Girl Pie. Both were good but I recommend eating it right away otherwise you don't get the full experience. I would come back again but probably wouldn't pick this spot on a busy evening. Maybe the hype will die down or the lines will improve. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Chicago, Illinois