Tina was the best helper! Pizza was super good!Super family friendly place with clean bathrooms.

Kim provides some of the best customer service I have ever experienced, hands down. She is welcoming, kind, respectful, and pays attention to every detail. No matter how busy it was, she always had a smile on her face and made every customer feel appreciated. Out of all the Prince Street Pizza locations I've been to, this one being my first, Kim is the reason this one is my all-time favorite. Every time I come in, I hope she's there because I know I'm going to receive amazing service and leave with a great experience. She truly goes above and beyond, and it does not go unnoticed! read more

*Docking stars for service If the food is good, I'm not one to complain about service, but I waited 40+ mins for my order and watched everyone else get their order and leave within 10 mins. I finally went to check on my order and the female worker treated me as if I was the problem. Turns out they forgot my order. No apology or anything. When my pizza was finally ready, they just threw it on the counter and walked away. I read some reviews afterwards and it looks like the attitude is common problem here, which is unfortunate. I came out of town to try this place so this was disappointing. read more

Worst service I've ever received. Attitude of the people here are extremely rude. My first slice was cold and not properly reheated. Second slice I received it was a tad bit warmer but not reheated to a good temperature. The second slice they gave, the server decided to just throw it on the counter and walk away immediately. It was only slightly "warmer" than my cold pizza. I understand it's New York pizza but at least those guys acknowledge you instead of being jerks and giving an attitude the whole time we were there. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

very yummy!!!! + fast and friendly service :3 i had a slice of the fancy prince two days in a row LOL... cute little interior too, but plan to sit outside or elsewhere bc there's no seating inside! read more

Prince Street Pizza - outside - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

See all

I lived in NYC from 2016-2023 and Prince Street was a big part of both my drunk and sober nights when I was there so in coming out to LA I was excited to see that there was one out here. Had a hankering for pizza last night and decided to give it a try. Normally I opt for the spicy spring but I wanted a standard NY pie last night so I got half cheese (my pick) and half mushroom for a friend. It was delivered quickly and hot. I thought it was good but not great. The crust ratio was a little off and it could have had considerably more sauce. But the flavor was there and it definitely had a good dough, even if there were too much of it. Not sure I would rush to order again, but it satisfied the craving that I was having. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Half cheese half mushroom - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

I heard a lot of good stuff about this place from my brother in Chicago and it's been on my to go list for a long time. We were in town for the weekend and didn't want to do a fancy dinner. We got two slices - both weren't very good at all. Originally we ordered 3 but the guy serving us / cashier didn't acknowledge the third so we just decided to get two so we didn't feel like we were bothering him. He was rude and had a bad attitude towards us. That, and didn't bother to hand us our salad. Just kept it on the side of the counter until I asked if it was ours. The Caesar salad was rubbery, and the countertops were dirty with all the utensils. We sat outside to eat and were grossed out by how sweet and greasy the pizzas tasted and how old the salad was. We tossed our expensive pizza dinner and went to Whole Foods to try to fix our dinner situation. Probably won't do this again. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

Perfect New York style pizza in Malibu! Felt like I was back in the city again eating some delicious pizza. They have plenty of selection for whatever you're craving. On this particular day, I was feeling a basic cheese slice, and it was pretty good. The mozzarella sticks were not something I would order again. They had a funky aftertaste. Spit them out right away thinking they were rotten. The cashier at the front was super friendly and helped me choose the best pizzas from the menu. Id come back! They also have a little bar on the left side that I'll check out next time I come. read more

See all

I just came home and I have to admit. I really love this pizza but I didn't hesitate to order the meat lovers when I came in, but there was another piece of pizza that everyone should try. It looks like they took meat sauce with marinara and put it over the top, which is like all the best parts of spaghetti and all the best parts of pizza and I have to agree. It is really good. I love the indoor seating and I love the parking because it was really easy to get to for a place like this I can see that I'm gonna be coming back a lot more. My two slices of meat lovers in the meat marinara sliced were the best. If I had more room in my stomach, I would order more. read more

See all

Im not one to give a bad review. Usually I'd rather skip. The Westlake Village store has superstars working there. I can't say I have had the food here at this branch. Came to pick up an order. Turns out they couldn't fulfill it and I was offered 1/3 of what was paid for. I canceled the order that I Drove 35 minutes each way for. The place was understaffed, perhaps an unlucky day being Friday the 13th and I'm not superstitious. Waited 25 minutes in line. Manager seemed annoyed and made me feel super uncomfortable. Service was very slow, not attentive, left there disappointed and embarrassed. It's a shame because I've heard great reviews. The whole place was filled with smoke of burnt oil, not a pleasant scent. An absolute bust. read more

If you've followed my Yelp journey, you already know: I'm a Bostonian pizza snob. I'm also half Sicilian, and I worked at multiple pizza joints in my younger years--ostensibly to pay the bills, but really just to impress girls (spoiler alert: it didn't work). I rarely find pizza in LA that's even worth talking about. And I'm not talking high-end Neapolitan stuff from white-tablecloth Italian restaurants. I mean real, neighborhood-joint pizza. You know the kind. (No, CPK does not count. Don't you dare.) So on this fateful weekend trip to Malibu Country Mart, I was in a mood. A bitch mood, to be exact. And I'll admit--I came here ready to rip this place apart. Like, I wanted to hate it. I came looking for a fight... ...and I would've lost. Is it the best pizza in LA? Too early to say. But it's very good. And more importantly? My three Boston-born kids loved it. If you think I'm a pizza snob, you haven't met my oldest son. This kid grew up on a dough table in our old Boston pizza shop and is basically a pizza gangsta--and he went back twice for the Prince Perfection (a marinara-only pie!). I was dumbfounded. But when it comes to pizza, he doesn't miss. As for me, the Naughty Pie was the standout. Ever since I moved to LA, vodka sauce pizza has become my guilty pleasure--and with all the meat fixings, this one hit all the right notes. My youngest had the meat lover's, and his review was: "very good." (Which, in kid-speak, means winner.) Bonus discovery: Espresso soda. A bit sweet for me, but surprisingly paired perfectly with the pizza. Didn't expect that. Final verdict: I came ready to destroy this place. Instead, I found myself planning a return trip. I'll be back. Probably angry again. But full. And happy. read more

See all

Pizza gem found and not mad about it! Great deal, fun pizza box, and fed us all. Win, win, win!!! read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

See all

What could improve? Well, let's start with the pizza. I'll stick with Whole Foods across the street before I eat this crap. Overcooked, dry yet surprisingly still greasy. On a positive note, the cashier did have a bad attitude. Miserable guy. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Over cooked dry pizza. I'll stick with Whole Foods across the street before this crap. - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

Pizza is as varied and as personal a preference as they come. This is the ultimate cravable late night munchie with the perfect blend of sweet, fat and carbs. It's not pizza in the traditional sense, think of the old numer Uno style blended with your memory of School Pizza... But in a good way. Sometimes you want a traditional thin crust, good old style New York, or something that tastes oddly like a savory dessert.... This absolutely fulfills that last quest. It's perfect for taking over to the playground if you are watching a bunch of Littles, but I'm personally not a fan of, playground or parking lot dining... So no points for ambiance from me. I would say get some on your next midnight munchie binge but I think they close at like 9, so you'll have to think ahead. Haven't tried freezing it, but I'm guessing it would rebake pretty nicely and much better than regular pizza. read more

Great flavor. Great portion size. The mozzaella sticks are big and the cheese pull is fantastic. Very filling . If you're a glorified big back like me,lol , you wont be disappointed. You definitely gotta stop here in you're in the area. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Mozzarella Sticks and the Spicy Spring 10' Pizetta. - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

This location in Malibu is pretty small. It's more of a grab-and-go situation, though there is a little bit of seating in another room, but those were for those wanting a drink. There's plenty of parking since it's located in a strip mall. The workers there were very kind. We got the Four Cheese and the Sunset Square. It was pretty good even though we ate ours cold at the beach. By the register, there are condiments for you to take that elevate the taste of the pizza. A great place right near the beach. Please note that when coming in the afternoon, it is extremely packed, so you might have to park on the street (free for 2 hours, depending on the time on display). But when you come in the evening, the area is extremely dimmed. read more

Pizza was pretty good but super greasy. They have a big selection to choose from and all looked really good. I went with a slice of spicy spring and that was more than enough. I might come back to try something different. read more

See all

We came searching last minute and they let us in here after they closed. We were so disappointed after they said they closed but seeing our reaction they still served us. We are thankful! read more

Tina and Freddie were so friendly and helpful! Can't wait to come back! Also awesome pizza. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

I love Prince Street Pizza especially the pepperoni and vodka sauce. Their pizza has the perfect thickness and crispy edges. Highly recommend. Order ahead for whole pizzas or grab a slice. Lots of seating inside and parking in the back. read more

We ordered a whole Sunset Square pizza on a Sunday afternoon. We've ordered from Prince Street before and it's always been great, so we didn't think twice. My kids started eating and even mentioned the marinara tasted oddly sweet, but since we've had this pizza before, I brushed it off. After they had already eaten about a quarter of the pizza, I finally grabbed a slice myself--and immediately spit it out. The marinara sauce was overwhelmingly sweet, to the point where it tasted like jam, not marinara. I know it says they use sweet marinara, but this was on a completely different level. We've had this pizza before, so I know what it normally tastes like. This was not it. It genuinely felt like excessive sugar had been added, making it completely inedible. I was honestly upset that I hadn't tried it sooner and had already let my kids eat it. I immediately returned to the restaurant with the pizza and asked for a refund. The two employees were polite enough but not a single apology was offered, which was frustrating given that we paid for a product that was simply not edible. I even said I wasn't trying to be difficult and asked them to try it so they could understand what I meant. They declined and said they believed me--which is fine--but again, no apology, no acknowledgment, no sympathy. There was also an issue processing the refund because there was no manager present at first. When a young female manager (I don't recall her name) arrived, the situation still lacked any apology or concern for the inconvenience. Unfortunately, this experience completely changed how I feel about Prince Street. Between the poor-quality pizza and the lack of customer service, I'm very disappointed. I won't be returning or ordering from here again. read more

love prince streets pizza! it's extremely consistent, you'll always get the same taste you've ordered before. personally i love the spicy spring and the classic. service is always nice. there are not many seating options outside of this location so i'd plan on eating it elsewhere. read more

See all

It's good pizza, for California standards. But it's not NY pizza. Very hard to claim NY pizza and actually attain it.

Everything was top-notch. From the moment we walked in, the hospitality was incredible. The cocktails were creative and delicious, and the main courses exceeded our expectations read more

Prince Street Pizza feels like it was ripped straight from a Manhattan sidewalk and dropped onto the West Coast without skipping a beat. The smell hits you first... cheese, oil, and marinara in the best way possible. It is not one of those trendy overhyped places trying to serve you an aesthetic before a bite. This one is loud about its flavor and quiet about everything else. The Naughty Pie is the star. The little pepperoni cups hold onto that grease like they know it is the whole point. Edges crisped to a slight char and center heavy with sauce. It is not a slice you fold and walk with. It is a sit-down moment. The Meat Lovers goes even further. It is aggressive. Thick layer of meats laid out like armor. Bold, rich, and definitely not made for moderation. You go in with commitment or you leave disappointed. The space itself is tight but does not feel claustrophobic. People stand close but no one is stepping on your shoes. The little bar to the side gives it character. It is the kind of place where you could sip a beer while waiting for a box or slide in solo and still feel like you belong. No weird energy. No fake hospitality. Just counter staff that moves fast and a system that works. Everything stays clean. That includes the bathrooms, which is rare for a spot this busy. The whole place gives off that fast hustle with a side of real chill. There is something about the mix of east coast attitude with west coast ease that makes this place hit different. It is giving small but solid. No filters needed. Just good pizza and a place that respects the slice. It's giving #1 trending on TikTok because the first bite hits harder than the sound drop. read more

The pizza was fresh, crispy, and absolutely delicious. I had gotten the naughty pie with the meat lovers 10/10 recommendations from Tina!! She also made the experience even better she was so sweet, welcoming, and helpful, and made sure we had everything we needed. Her customer service really stood out. Definitely coming back for the pizza and to see Tina again. read more

Yummy pizza. First time trying it and we enjoyed it very much. Will definitely have it again when in the area.

I just went to prince street for the first time and it was absolutely amazing! The pizza was unbelievable and Tina and Freddie were super accommodating and friendly. I would definitely recommend! read more

Do not expect NY pizza, not even close. And having a girl who can't handle it well working by herself, very bad idea! read more

The food was epic. It was so great. The service was amazing. It's attached to a super cool bar. They gave me a cookie that was so good.

I disagree with the negative reviews. I come to Prince at least 2 times a week and I find everything here above board. First, the staff is wonderful. Tina is always nice, Moises helps with our larger orders without a problem, Kim is beyond kind and always makes us smile, the new boy (I don't know his name yet) is super energetic and helpful with bar service. The food sometimes is a wait but that's usually weekends. You do need to pay attention to when your name is called though. Sometimes it's easy to miss and stuff gets cold which sucks. But they always make good on it if that happens. One time I had to wait an extended period of time for several slices and Kim was nice and gave me a drink on the house. Tina always has a good attitude and is "of course" willing to go the extra mile. The pizzas are well made. I wouldn't pay attention to people who are obviously having bad days and give prince a try. It's one of the best pizza places in malibu with ultra friendly service. read more

So disappointing! Been wanting to try Prince Street for AGES since I missed my chance in NY. I was thrilled to find out there's a location here at the Malibu Country Mart. I saw that there was a BOGO Yelp check-in, so hubby and I took advantage of it. The little pizza shop is very cute. There are photos of famous people who have tried their NY location hanging on the wall, and it also opens up to a little bar and seating area on the left of the shop. The pizza pies on display look like there were left out for awhile, we even saw a few flies flying around the display case. Nonetheless, we ended up getting a slice of the Meat Lover's and the Fancy Prince. Our total was $6.50 with the BOGO deal, which is a steal. They reheated our pizza which we really appreciated. Upon first bite of the Meat Lovers was very disappointing. The pepperoni cups had no crisp around the edges. They were thick slices of soft sausage, not the thinner kind I'm used to. The sausage bits were okay, nothing special. I did like that my slice had a lot of meat on it as promised by its name. As for the crust, very doughy. It was not crispy and was very oily. The pizza sauce was underwhelming too. Hubby's Fancy Prince tasted a bit better, but it was still very soggy and didn't hold itself up well. Overall disappointed with the taste of the pizza from here. It's not as good as we had hoped. The BOGO deal is honestly a really good deal, but not sure if its enough to make us want to come back. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Cute togo box - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

See all

Check in on Yelp for BOGO free as of 7/19/24! Came here with a group of friends around 5PM on a Friday evening as we saw the Yelp BOGO offer. We each ordered 2 slices and they were quickly heated up for takeout. Prince Street can be on the oily side as oil collects in the small cup shaped pepperoni, however the freshness and taste make quite the treat! I ordered the naughty pie and spicy Italian and thoroughly enjoyed both. For any friends that are on the lactose intolerant side, I'd recommend taking a Lactaid before the naughty pie as the ricotta can be a bit strong for the stomach. Overall, I enjoyed the pizza, the convenience, and the location amongst other shops/food spots - would recommend! read more

Prince Street Pizza - The Naughty Pie (front) & spicy Italian (back) - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

Whoever the cashier guy is that works Thursday afternoon is awful. We asked to have our slices boxed instead of dine-in, apologizing for the change on our part, and he responds, "Next time, have it figured out." Then he proceeded to throw our slices in boxes and throw them up on the counter. Seriously? There were two other customers in there, not like you were busy. What's with the attitude? The pizza was alright, but the cashier you have with the attitude will ruin a good pizza any day. read more

Best pizza in the world! Unmatched service, atmosphere is top notch! Alfredo's infierno pizza is a new favorite The attached sprouts bar, sparkys is an added plus read more

MOLD IN MY SALAD! this is not blue cheese, this is straight up mold. paid 60 bucks for my whole order for there to be a health hazard in it. read more

Prince Street Pizza - Italian Chopped - Pizza Near Me - Malibu, California

The whole pies are fresh and delicious, but the slices are dry and flavorless. Gave the slices multiple tries but they continue to disappoint. Some honestly look like they've been on the shelf for hours. Not sure what their quality assurance policy is on shelf life but doesn't seem like there is one. You'll be disappointed paying $8+ for a slice that's inedible. read more

Shoutout Tina!!! Excellent service she's the best. Super nice and made the pizza extra good some how. Never in my life have I had a pizza this splendid read more

Tina & freddy are the best!! This is the best prince st location!! I love coming here for lunch!

Amazing service 10/10 great staff and a great atmosphere they deserve a raise 100% amazing pizza as well.