I had no idea that they had discontinued endless shrimp for a few years?? I saw a TikTok of someone eating there and developed an instant craving for shrimp. It did not disappoint. The server was friendly and kept the cheddar bay biscuits flowing. We stuck with the usuals and devoured Walt's shrimp and the scampi. I tried the marry me shrimp and the server said people normally love it or hate it. It was meh. It was naked shrimp in a light tomato cream sauce covered in panko bread crumbs. It was kind of flavorless. All in all, the Red Lobster in Castleton is always consistent. We left full and happy. read more

See all

We've had some bad experiences in the past at this location. So today we decided to finally give it another try as we typically really like Red Lobster. Our dining experience was OUTSTANDING! The restaurant was very clean, we were warmly welcomed and seated immediately. Our server, Heavenly, took our drink orders as soon as we sat down. We placed our orders and the dinners came out quickly and hot! I had the Endless Shrimp - love Coconut Shrimp, which were meaty with a crisp coconut coating. The Shrimp Scampi and Walt's were good as well. My wife had the Admirals Feast which was excellent. And of course the Cheddar Baked Biscuits were hot, soft and hit the spot. Jason the service manager stopped by to make everything was good. Needless to say we'll be back! Smiles abounded from all of the staff. Thank you for a great dining experience. read more

We arrived and was seated with no wait. The young lady that was our server was friendly and attentive. We ordered the crab legs and most of my crab legs barely had meat and the ones that did were overcooked and cold. The biscuits were the best part of the meal. read more

Red Lobster - That's the sauce on top. - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

It's been quite a while since I've been to a Red Lobster but today my daughter really wanted some seafood so we thought ok let's go. The Red Lobster I remember was relatively affordable but those days are obviously in the past! I should have gone to the expensive local restaurant! For two people for lunch without any alcoholic drinks we spent 120$ with an 18% tip! The food was fine... I had the surf and turf and I will say the chef did a great job on the steak as it was a perfect med/rare. My daughter had a bar harbor pasta with muscles and shrimp and a lobster tail.. (it was lobster fest) The server was very nice and did a great job. Soooo all in all it was fine... but good lord I felt I was fleeced at check out! read more

Red Lobster - Surf n turf - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We had a reservation, so we were able to be seated immediately. It was a nicely decorated and warm atmosphere with current music playing. The restaurant was very clean. I went to the bathroom after ordering a classic margarita on the rocks and a water. The bathroom was a nice size, plenty of room to move around with two sinks and hand soap with paper towel close by. The water didn't warm up much while I was washing my hands and it sprayed out kind of fast causing water to spray everywhere besides just on my hands. It was an automatic sensor type faucet that I'm not too fond of, but it got my hands clean. Other than that, the bathroom seemed clean. We started off with their traditional cheddar bay biscuits. They were nice and warm, soft yet had a nice light crunch to them, love the cheesy garlic taste of those biscuits! My margarita was really tasty as well, I just wish it had more salt on the rim, but it otherwise tasted nice with a lime wedge on the edge that I put into the glass. For the entree, I had the grilled Maine lobster tail, skewered shrimp, and Atlantic salmon, all finished with a brown butter sauce, which all had its own seasoning and garnish and was on a bed of rice pilaf. For my two sides, I had creamy lobster mashed potatoes that had a creamy sauce and bits of lobster both in it and on top as well as a side salad with ranch dressing; the salad came out first. The salad was fresh, crisp, and colorful with mixed greens, tomatoes, cheese, and soft, but crunchy croutons. The ranch dressing had a nice creamy tang to it that complemented the salad well. I very much enjoyed the tender cooked rice that came with the entree. The lobster and shrimp were both hot and juicy and nicely seasoned. While the salmon was seasoned nicely and all of the food had a good presentation, I was slightly disappointed in the salmon. I love a good juicy grilled salmon, but this was slightly overcooked. The seasoning helped it a little, but I couldn't finish it because it was a little dry on the inside due to being slightly overcooked. I loved my creamy lobster mashed potatoes. The sauce was very nice and had a sort of garlicky taste to it, the bits of lobster were nice and juicy and the mashed potatoes were perfectly cooked and melted in my mouth. My wife got the shrimp linguini Alfredo as well as a side salad with blue cheese dressing. Her salad came out same time as my salad and she enjoyed her salad just as much as I enjoyed mine. Her entree had tender, juicy shrimp, in a creamy garlic Alfredo sauce on a bed of perfectly cooked linguini. Her serving of the dish was a big one, so she ate what she could and took the rest home with one of the cheddar bay biscuits. She very much enjoyed her meal. Our server, Jazmine was very friendly, and attentive, always making sure we were doing well with our meals. I'm a member of the Red Lobster rewards club because I love the place. It's just a bit pricey, so we only go there once or twice a year. Despite the salmon being a little on the dry side, I will still return. I just won't get that dish again. read more

See all

It has been several years since I've visited Red Lobster, but with all of the recent changes announced in the media we decided to give it a try after some shopping in Castleton. It wasn't crowded on this Wednesday afternoon. We got there after 5:00pm, but just before Happy Hour ended. We decided to try their $5 alcoholic lemonade drink special. It was pretty good. I decided to go with the Ultimate Spend Less Shrimp special for $15.99. It came with Garlic Shrimp Scampi, Shrimp Linguini Alfredo, and Popcorn Shrimp with Chesapeake Fries. My mother got the Wednesday special of steak and lobster. The portions were large and we both ended up taking some home. I actually enjoyed my meal more the next day. The biscuits were just as good as I remembered. Our waitress was Mary and she was very attentive. She even acted as a hostess to seat us when she noticed the host was tied up with a large party from a nearby nursing home. Overall it was a good dinner experience and reasonably priced. read more

See all

With no plans for Christmas this year, I started exploring options for lunch since the idea of eating at home had no appeal. I knew the usual suspects would be open - Chinese restaurants, The Journey, Denny's, and probably Waffle House or IHOP. However, I was really in the mood for something different and was pleased to see that Red Lobster was open for special hours. I stopped in for a late lunch. The regular menu was available and I was pleased that it was steady but there was no line. I was seated at a four-top near the entrance, though Red Lobster has some dividers and it's generally pretty private. There's accessible parking near the entrance. The entryway doors are a tad heavy, however, they're workable. Seating was easily accessible. I opted for the fish n' chips - one large hand-battered, wild-caught cod along with chesapeake fries, two hush puppies, and a healthy serving of coleslaw. Of course, the meal starts off with their Cheddar Bay biscuits. I also ordered my usual unsweetened iced tea. I feel for anyone working Christmas, however, the team was effective, efficient, and generally in good spirits. Service was good, though not necessarily great. I felt the same about the meal - good but not necessarily great. My server checked on me a couple times, though did bring the check before asking me if I wanted a tea refill (then brought the refill in a "to go" cup when I intended to linger a bit). It was a minor faux pas. While I was surprised the fish was only one piece, I will acknowledge it was a pretty good sized piece of fish and it was cooked well. I'm not sure when they added their hush puppies back, but I loved those as a kid and having them back brought a definite sense of nostalgia. This was a definite nice change of pace and I really enjoyed the meal. The atmosphere was warm and inviting and I had some time to read during lunch. As I was spending the holiday alone, it was nice to be in a public environment without being overwhelmed by it like happens in many restaurants. While seafood isn't always my thing, once in a while it really hits the spot and that happened here. While this wasn't the best experience I've had, it was a solidly good one and a great way to spend a Christmas lunch. read more

See all

I haven't been to red lobster in quite some time. Plenty of parking along with the large restaurant. I sat at the bar, Steve was the bartender. He was very friendly and attentive. Lunch crowd was small. I ordered the coconut shrimp with a side salad. The side salad was as good, along with the biscuits. Biscuits taste amazing. The shrimp were butterflied and servers with a pina coloda sauce. I'm used to an orange marmalade from another restaurant so was not a fan at first. But once I got my mental block, I really liked it. I'm glad I stopped by, good food at a reasonable price. read more

Red Lobster - Coconut shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Very disappointed, April 7, 2026 when I took my sister there for her birthday. I think we had a new waiter. I'm saying that because he rarely checked on us, brought the salad with my main course. And then the next two days I've had three different charges from the red lobster for my dinner that night on my debit card. read more

Please improve on food and service. Plate presentation is everything!!!! Just wasn't impressed whatsoever. read more

Red Lobster - Yuck!!! Won't be back. Horrible ! - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food was great, Portions were great, Service was just ok. Bar service is where they need help

My husband and I went for a date night on a Monday night. There was no wait. Our waiter was very attentive, friendly, and professional. My husband ordered the Monday special 'All you can eat shrimp for $25'. He definitely enjoyed the options. His favorite was the coconut shrimp and the shrimp scampi. I ordered the lobster linguine. I was not impressed with the sauce, next time I'd ask for lobster Alfredo. It was quiet, so we were able have conversations very easily. The cheddar biscuits melt in your mouth! It's hard to not fill up on those and ruin your appetite before your entree. read more

See all

We went there b/c it was Tuesday & Tuesdays are $25 1lb crab legs deal. It was really good but a bit messy... Hubby ordered the "Ultimate Spendless Shrimp" meal for $22.99 he totally enjoyed it. Once again I forgot to take pictures of our meal... =( read more

Red Lobster - Description of what you get... - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Thanks to Chandler aka " The MixOLogist" because my Mango Lemonade with Starry was very refreshing and mixed very well!!! My Lobster Flatbread was very YummyLicious and Chandler recommended it for me to try!!! Ms. Jenn the Mngr was awesome as well and both of them had excellent smiles and their hospitality was second to none! read more

Red Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Red Lobster has been around forever and they continue to draw crowds. The lunch specials make the prices more reasonable. Since the seafood quality is high, dinner prices reflect freshness of the choices. My lunch server, Kasandra, was fantastic! The ambiance is typical of a casual dining restaurant. There's a soundtrack of primarily 1970s music playing in the background. Overall a very tasty relaxing lunch experience for one! read more

Red Lobster - The special includes one side. I have fries & Coleslaw - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Decent seafood at a reasonable price. Nothing exceptional except the signature biscuits. A good Caesar salad and an ample supply of well prepared (not overcooked) shrimp, lobster and mussels over a bed of pasta. The mussels were especially satisfying. The young female server was very attentive, friendly and accommodating. read more

Enjoyed a birthday lunch for my sister during the Thanksgiving week. Red Lobster remains an old school seafood restaurant that you can always count on. The food was delicious and the cheddar garlic biscuits remain a signature...YUM! Our waitress was friendly and the service was fast, despite the holiday and lunch crowd. The ambiance was holiday friendly. We really enjoyed the Christmas music and decor. read more

Red Lobster - Lobster & Shrimp Holiday Feast, Snow Crab Legs, Margarita and a Blue Moon Beer - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

It's been years since I've been to this red lobster location and couldn't be more disappointed. As soon as we sat down the server was very nice and took our order but it took almost 45 mins for a house salad to come out. It ended up coming out with our entrees. We ordered a decent amount of food but the steaks we ordered were not cooked right, the crab legs were very tiny, my beers never came on time, baked potatoe was dry and room temp,and the service overall just declined as soon as we ordered. The manager did come over and comp a few items due to the service provided (which i do appreciate) I will more than likely not return and if i do it will be many years from now. I'm not a critic nor a "restaurant plug" but i knew we should have just went to Texas Roadhouse. If you're reading this just go to Texas Roadhouse read more

We stopped by for lunch last Saturday. The service was fantastic and the food tasted great. However, we ended up getting terrible food poisoning. It started on Sunday night and lasted until Tuesday night. Our symptoms were: fever, chills, hot flashes, vomiting, diarrhea, and a headache. We both ate the coconut shrimp, so it must have been contaminated. Such a bummer because it was such a great experience outside of that! read more

Red Lobster - Cheddar Bay Biscuits - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My experience today was DEFINITELY better than last weeks. I was greeted upon entry. We were seated immediately. The waitress and the manager at the front desk were both friendly and had smiles on their face. Our food came out hot and flavorful. I wasn't lacking the alfredo sauce this time. We left stuffed and happy. I ordered linguine with alfredo sauce and brussel sprouts. My son ordered shrimp alfredo, dragon shrimp, and fries. My bill was under $40 for the both of us, and that included our drinks. read more

Red Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We had so much fun here! I was surprised at the great prices and how good the food was. Underrated place for sure. Only thing was that it took forever to get food, so service was a little slow. Margaritas were sub par, but would still go back for the food. We shared the ultimate feast for $40 and the amount of food was unreal and amazing quality. We were so full and enjoyed some of it for a second meal. read more

See all

This was the worst meal I have ever eaten in any restaurant in Indianapolis. The food took over 45 minutes to get to us . I ordered. Surf and turf with baked potato. I got a steak so tough you need a chainsaw to cut it. The lobster tail was from a baby - very small lobster- I didn't get the baked potato. The server was very apologetic as was the manager. It's no wonder this restaurant chain is in bankruptcy. Don't WASTE your$. read more

Happy to see Red Lobster busy at 5pm on a Sunday. We only had a 15 min wait. Jazz / our server was pleasant and very efficient! Refilling both our iced teas & their famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits! My sister ordered the grilled salmon- which was flavorful and a nice portion. I ordered the 3 types of Shrimp- Walt's famous fried, coconut shrimp and shrimp scampi! The shrimp was delicious and tasty! I look forward to returning to the Castleton Red Lobster location!! read more

I personally experienced a great ending with my family on March 30, 2025 when a birthday celebration was at the Red Lobster at 6410 E. 82nd Street, Indpls, IN 46250. It started out not so good. The waiter we had got frustrated with our birthday party, but the supervisor Christian Peek was awesome, he step in, and made everything great, and the waiter was no longer frustrated, and continued being our waiter, it all worked out. The birthday celebration was simply great. It was 10 of us, the food was great, and hot when served, everything was on point, and we were all happy thanks to Christian Peek, Restaurant Supervisor. He was very professional & pleasant through the entire celebration. Jewel Vaden read more

An oldie but goodie. I've been coming here since I was a teenager. I received a Red Lobster gift card for my birthday and chose to cash in on it today. We came in during a slow time and were seated fairly quickly. Our server, Mary was very attentive and cordial. They've added some innovative entree's in order to stay relevant but those cheddar biscuits are still the perfect starter. They came out hot, flaky and buttery. I ordered the cod sandwich. It was prepared just right: Crunchy, crispy on the outside and tender juicy on the inside. The coleslaw was good and creamy. The wife ordered the Ginger Salmon bowl. The fish was flavorful and well seasoned. read more

See all

We came today to celebrate a 66th birthday and we had a wonderful experience. Shae was our sweet server and took very good care of us! Our meals were delicious; this red lobster is consistently great! read more

Went in for the viral mariners crab boil.. and was very satisfied!! Service was a little slow because they were understaffed but it was well worth the wait!! Food was delicious, fresh and seasoned well. I hope they never take this off the menu !!! Definitely will return!!! read more

I decided to order dinner from Red Lobster and was disappointed with the food. I took advantage of the buy one get one free lobster bisque special along with the biscuits special. It was definitely not worth the price I paid for the meal. The lobster bisque was salty and did not taste good. The fish and chips were cold and tasted bad! The only thing worth eating were the Cheddar bay biscuits and the coleslaw. The biscuits were very good. Normally, I am a Red Lobster fan and like having dinner in the restaurant, but when I ordered through Uber Eats, something missed the mark. The cooks were not on point this night when they were preparing my food. The ambiance at the restaurant and service are usually good and on point, but when ordering through Uber Eats, something does not go right. If you're into Red Lobster, then go dine at the actual restaurant to get the full dining experience, but do not order food through Uber Eats because it is not the same experience. Very disappointed!! read more

See all

have no idea if anything purchased should have been discounted for senior citizen. never addressed. waitress brought biscuits. were ready for drink and appetizer, but she didn't slow down enough for us to tell her. got crab legs. asked 3x's for butter before we got it, and by then, food was not hot. waitress brought out 1 meal (wrong), then the other 3 5-10 minutes later. she told us they ran out of large to go dishes and bread sacks to take home biscuits. never took a plate away. gave our waters to another table. 1 got crab legs with very little meat. for some reason, hers were really bad. the last time we were there, we were not impressed, but we heard the advertisements, and thought we'd give them another chance, and this is how it went. read more

We went for our annual visit during endless shrimp. Some really good updates including jumbo coconut shrimp. Much better product. The restaurant seemed pretty clean and the service was quick. Our server was very friendly and efficient. See you next year. read more

Red Lobster - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We came for our our anniversary. It was a Monday about 430pm, so it was not crowded at all. I got a salmon bowl with Brussel sprouts which was very tasty. Hubby got endless shrimp. It was also lobster fest. I think the endless shrimp would be the best deal. You have 4 or 5 different shrimp to choose from. The biscuits are still The Best! My biggest complaint is the cleanliness. I know everyone is short-staffed, but nobody wants to eat in a dirty place. Even if the food is good, it makes you wonder what condition the kitchen is if the tables and floors are dirty in the dining area. read more

Who can resist their cheddar bay biscuits? They are so amazing. I am too busy to use my boxed mix. So I just do takeout and have leftovers. Six for under $3. Double points through Fri. 6/25. read more

Red Lobster - 6 yummy cheddar bay biscuits! Takeout for 1. - Seafood Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

My server, Shawanee was excellent! She was pleasant and attentive. My food was hot, and fresh just the way I like it! Thanks !

Great meal and service. Tony was great. Lobster pasta was amazing. Have not been there in a long time but will def be back in the near future. Red Lobster has made a great change lately and it has been noticed. read more

Husband has been wanting cheddar bay biscuits for a couple days, so we finally ended up at Red Lobster. They do wait list on Open Table instead of actual reservations, but when we got there they weren't at all busy, but still got my Open Table points. They have some new items on the Menu and they brought back a couple old ones. I got the new Mariner's Feast - Atlantic salmon topped with creamy langostino and Norway lobster sauce, grilled sea scallops and Walt's Favorite Shrimp. It was excellent. Husband got filet ( he doesn't like sea food ) and potato. The iced tea was horrible. I don't know if they need to take apart their machine and really really scrub it down or what. The tea tasted like coffee. We switched to Pepsi. Really great service from Cory R. He kept everything refilled and to the table hot. read more

See all

After dining here I remember why I stopped going. The appetizer was really good and it was crab stuffed shrimp Rangoon. I liked those a lot. The salad was Just ok. I had a Cesar and they were several wilted and brown leaves. But minus those it tasted OK. I also had create your own feast and had the bay scallops oven fried and salmon grilled with mashed potatoes. The mashed potatoes and the salmon were good but the scallops did not taste great and were tiny ones which it did not mention on the menu. Overall it was OK but for the price it wasn't worth it. The waiter was really good and very attentive. He made the experience better. read more

See all

Restaurant was maybe 20% full and we waited 30 minutes to be seated. Server came after 5 minutes. 15 minutes later, we got 3 waters and a coke. Food was good but the service is so slow, I can't see them staying open. It wasn't our server's fault really. I think there were only 2 servers for the entire restaurant read more

I dined at this location on 3/27/2024. I chose to eat here because it was close to the AMC theater. I was not pleased with the service or quality of the food at this restaurant. I tried using my gift card at Red Lobster, but it didn't work. I found out the reason it didn't work. As a result, I don't plan on returning. I don't expect a response from management because if they were interested in providing good customer service, I would have received compensation of some sort at that time. I need people to know that this particular Red Lobster location is not up to par. read more

Angelleca from Red Lobster promptly contacted me concerning my visit, where I described the fact that we had terrible service. She went above and beyond my expectations and sent me a generous e-gift card !! Red Lobster food is always good, that was never in question. I am so grateful that Red Lobster cared enough to make up for this situation. read more

We were pleasantly surprised. Had a gift card we wanted to use in case our Red Lobster closed. Food was really good. Our server was friendly. Sad that so many Red Lobster locations are closing. read more