The only place I go to for pizza. I'm a New Yorker and it's hard pleasing us when it comes to pizza. We swear NY pizza is the best. I've been going here for over 15 years now. Love, love, Love it! read more

Usually I go to Renna's at Baymeadows and have always loved the food, service and cleanliness.. Near Argyle Forest today so went to Rennas there. Pizza was awesome as usual. However, tables, windowsills, floors etc. Very dirty. Saw one customer cleaning table before he sat. Only 4 other customers so not busy. Staff leaning on counters, loud conversation regarding what other shifts didnt do and how low they were on certain supplies. If same person owns all locations please drop by .. if owners have seen this situation. Please address. 2 stars was for food.. read more

Went here with my husband, daughter and a friend. Ordered my usual (white pizza with chicken). The wait was not to long. Even though they are short staffed at this time, you would have never known it. Everyone was very kind and friendly. Food was very tasty, piping hot and done to perfection. Thank you to ask who work there. You did an awesome job read more

I really enjoy the pizza but unfortunately I had a very frustrating experience tonight. Getting delivery is 50/50, sometimes they don't have a driver or they're too busy. I ordered my regular, a white pizza which is amazing, then tried to order a Hawaiian pizza for my friends. They Don't make those which is fine but after slowly reading my card number twice the employee said "okay he's reading way too fast" and handed the phone to a much better employee. While I read the card number I could hear the previous person I was on the phone with complaining about me, and how I must think it's dominos. I am a very relaxed person but this experience really tainted my view of Rennas. read more

I didn't have a bad experience, but I was not entirely impressed. Went on a Tuesday for the two slices of cheese and a drink deal. The pizza was pretty soggy.... it was a sad looking slice. Comparing their pizza to NY pizza is an absolute insult!! This is not a comparable place AT ALL. Is it good for a quick bite? Absolutely. Would I eat here again? Yes, the lunch deals are pretty good. Don't walk in having high hopes expecting a slice of NY style pizza because you'll be disappointed. (From a New Yorkers opinion) The staff from what I saw was pretty friendly and the place was clean for the most part. I can take it or leave it basically. No plans of rushing back in. read more

Is it customary to use chicken strips for your chicken parmigiana dinner? Never in my life have I ordered a chicken parm and the chicken was in strips!!!!! The dry strips were covered with a sheet of not melted mozzarella. Did they run out of chicken breasts? This was really bad. Also you could clearly see 4-5 people rolling dough in the doorway in the back. One of the girls was rolling dough with one hand and scrolling through her phone in the other. Not sanitary. read more

Just went to this restaurant for the first time and ordered 2 cheese slices. The employee pulled them from under the counter and heated them up. The employee was very lazy and rude. Ended up returning the slices after being disgusted from them sitting under the counter. read more

I hate that I have to give one star. Never in my life have witnessed what I saw the staff do this evening. As my spouse and I are so excited to sit down and have Rennas pizza what I use to claim was the best pizza in town . I hear sneezing coming from behind the counter , naturally I look .. .... The girl making the pies was having a sneezing fit. Did she excuse herself? NO Did she shield her sneeze using the bend of her arm? NO Did she cover her sneeze with a tissue? NO She did however sneeze on whom ever pie she was making. She did sneeze on all the open ingredients. To make matters worse ...she grabs her shirt wipes her snot as if it was Kleenex then continues to spread the cheese out on the pie. When I got up and said I'm sorry I can't eat pizza from someone who has just had a sneezing fit , blows her nose on her shirt and does not wash her hands , her response ..I use my shirt what???? I said you just wiped your snot with your shirt and handled food. She should of excused herself to the restroom , blew her nose and washed her hands. To top it off a joke was made that she's been like that all day with no complaints and it's just allergies. I'm flabbergasted the manager and other employees found nothing wrong with this situation . I'm at a loss for words. We got a refund thank god they did not start making our order and left. Rennas was known for amazing pizza and great quality service , you felt like family. I don't know if they have new owners or what. I will be trying to locate the owners and depending on how this is treated possibility the health department read more

I have been eating at this Renna's for as long as I can remember. When my family moved to FL from NY 20something years ago, this was the only NY style pizza place in OP. The food is still just as good. It's not particularly cheap but if you want cheap pizza, go to Pizza Hut. The only really downside is that this area has crazy traffic 99% of the time these days. read more

Great place!!!! The pizza is great and is affordable. Two slices and a drink for $8.00. The pizza even by the slice is made fresh (no heat lamps). Great when you need to take the kids for lunch and not break the bank. read more

Terrible service. Terrible food. They gave my family a cheese pizza when the cheese wasn't even cooked. Also, one girl was making pizza without a hair-net. Disgusting. read more

I had a choice in pizza restaurants on Sunday afternoon and I chose incorrectly. The sullen lady with arm ink did not greet me with a "hello" but with a "what can I get you?". I asked for a 14 inch sausage pie, paid and gave a tip. I was ticket 81, and sat at a table that had not been cleaned which had been occupied by ticket 65. I was wanting to leave right away because the ambient vibe was getting dangerous, and there was nearly a fight by two men wanting the last open table. My wife wanted to give the pizza a chance. There was about fifteen tables occupied with only one table eating. The staff was not moving quickly or working together. It was the silence of staff not wanting to be there and they worked mechanically in quiet. After a 25 minute wait I walked up to the counter and received my pizza and two floppy paper plates. The pizza was not the best, it was a bit underdone and bland. After eating one piece I had to look hard for a trash can where I dumped the large pizza. I cleaned up the table because no one else would. I left without any one saying a word to me. One of my fellow customers walked out loudly cursing to himself. We left to go get pizza at the other place I should have chosen on Park Street where we were greeted pleasantly and the staff acted like they wanted our business. I think the owner of the Renna's Pizza at Argyle should know what is going on at their store. I will not return. I have had good pizza at the Renna's Baymeadows location. read more

First time here. Just got sandwiches. The Steak, meatball, and Italian were delicious. I will go back to try other items.

Renna's is the best pizza in Jacksonvliie and good help is hard to find and when you find them it's hard to hang on to them for very long but the quailty of the food has stayed the same for 25 years read more

I had the chicken parmigiana sandwich and it was awful! The chicken was stringy and the sauce tasted bland and store bought. My wife got the cheese calzone with pepperoni. I tasted it to see if it was only my meal that blew, it was ok except that it was bland. For $ 18.94 I expect a lot more for my money. I will not be returning. I didn't try there pizza, but unfortunately first impressions last. I gave it two stars only because the atmosphere was ok, you can get a domestic draft beer and the smells were nice. Good luck to you if you eat there. read more

Ordered 4 XL pizzas, one veggie, one pepperoni and 2 plain. Drove from the far side of Oakleaf to pick up. Kid at the counter said my itemized receipt didn't print, i thought nothing of it then... Bad traffic on Argyle coming home, but pizza still warm. Opened the boxes, no pepperoni. Rats! All that way! Called them immediately, the kid put woman on phone, told me in brusk manner that the kid read my order back to me over the phone initially and did not say pepperoni. Not so. There were 5 boxes on the oven staying warm when I arrived and he pulled mine wrong. Woman was very off putting, mean. After all, pizza was very good, I will order again but I will open the boxes before I leave and get my itemized receipt. read more

Ok, I give this place 3 stars for their pizza, but not for anything else. Renna's has good pizza, but it's pricey. Their rude and they take their sweet time, or should I say they take your time. I would call it in ahead of time because they don't deliver and hopefully your time inside can be quick. read more

Was a long time customer however a bad experience today. Walked up to counter and employee started to take my order when the phone rang. She stopped taking my order, answered the phone and took a long phone order why a line in the store backed up. When she got off the phone I asked if I call a order in it takes priority over a person that came to the store, three employees replied yes. I walked out for the last time. Was my favorite but a cannot stand bad customer service. read more

Would have been ok if the first bite of pizza didn't have gross red colored hair in it. This was our first time eating here tonight ,we took it Togo. The wait time was ok since we had to go to the store anyways. We ordered a pizza with mushrooms and sausage and 1 small and over priced basic salad. I regret leaving a tip on a Togo but as previous service industry employees we know the system. It was all a little overpriced for the quantity and quality of food. Come on ladies .wear a hair net. No one wants weave in their food. We're knocking off restaurants all over this side of town. What is up with the general quality of food and service around here? We won't be coming back. read more

Renna's Pizza - Red hair in my food. Wonderful. - Pizza Near Me - Jacksonville, Florida

The best NYC chewy thin crust in town. And the sub sandwiches like prosciutto, capicola or just an Italian are amazing. The salads are fantastic if your in to that. read more

By far the best pizza I have had in Jacksonville. I'm from the north and it really was some good comfort food with the way they make the pizza. Will be back! read more

Love the food, but staff can be rude...at this location! Who cares if you get good pie!! Pizza is a-ok NY style,..stromboli is great....meatball sub is awesome!!! Good variety! Priced right read more

My wife raved about this place, and as usual, she was dead on right! We had the homemade lasagna, and an extra large cheese pie. First we had a large salad and some garlic bread. Everything was real good. The staff was very courteous, and professional. read more

Very good pizza and as close to NYC pizza as I have found so far. Anyone that has better suggestions please let me know.

This is the best pizza within 900 miles of NYC. I'm a Yankee and a pizza snob. If you're looking for a legit NY style pizza, this is it.

I had pasta with meatballs and sausage... the dinner came with a huge salad and big portion of garlic bread... the girls working were quick, efficient and very pleasant I will be back read more

Absolutely love this place. There's a reason why it's been a staple in Argyle for decades. Best pizza in Orange Park and it isn't close.

I love this place. Great atmosphere and amazing pizza. Be sure to try out the capicola sub they have one of the best I've ever had.

Wasn't overly impressed with the food but it wasn't bad. A little overpriced on certain items and I felt like I was stepping back into the 90's with the interior the way it is. It needs a serious face lift and sanitizing. read more

Have not had a good experience here. I have gotten sick every time I eat here. Will not be back. Dirty, and the staff sucks. They're just rude and always on their phones. read more

Nope, won't come here again.....the pizza isn't that good anymore and the attitude of the staff is B/S. Bye Rennas

The food here is great. My favorites are the Calzones and Pizzas. I like the casual environment, but can be a bit too loud at times. Great for family and small groups. Never had an issue with my order except for one time when I ordered take out and it took my pizza 40 mintes to be ready which caused the rest of the food we ordered to get cold. Aside from that 1 day, never had a problem. read more

I am a super fan of a NY style pizza and they come pretty close. Yesterday, I had some deliciously prepared pizza and brews with my best friend. Not only was the food great but it was matched with the same great customer service and friendliness I like to come by when eating out. They offer 10% off for military but also a whopping 50% off if you come in uniform. They said to "pass the word" so here I am. Living in Jacksonville (orange park area) things tend to be a nice drive to get to. This pizza joint was close by, easy to find and also provides free Wifi. It can't get any better than that. Thanks for the fresh veggies on my cheesy pie. read more

I had stuffed shells, they were very good it came with a delicious salad and garlic bread. One meal was could have easily fed the both of us. He ordered a meatball sub. Also delicious. read more

LOVE Renna's! The smell entering is intoxicating...wish I knew how to make that sauce! We've never once been disappointed with our order. Best pizza ever! read more

Crushed red pepper, you know the stuff, it's on the table in every pizza place in the world, except for this one for some reason. Pizza is ok, just ok, very greasy and very over priced. Rude service. Why the paper plates? Most tables are dirty while employees sit around doing nothing. I won't be coming back. read more

Love their pizza. I just wish they would allow you to add grilled chicken on the pizza or had some hot wings on the menu.

I love this pizza! I've been going there since I was a kid, now I take mine there! Good food, nice quiet atmosphere, great customer service!

They have the best New York style thin crust pizza. The only good thing here is the pizza & calzones, other than that everything is plain.

Rennas pizza is fine, just don't order a salad because they have the worst salads in town and their "house" dressing should needs renna-vating. It's god awful. The pizza is decent, so better stick to take out orders. Their beer selection is dismal at best. Over all, if you stick to take out pizza, you won't be disappointed. read more