First time dining downstairs. Very nice vibe. Service and food excellent as usual. Really appreciate the attention to detail on wines, cheeses, ham's. 5 stars read more

Food: 4/5 Service: 4.6/5 Ambiance: 4/5 Value: 2.8/5 6:45 reservation at Roscioli on August 26, 2026. Initially the hostess was going to seat me in the downstairs dining room, which I guess is quieter and a bit more intimate, but I saw some open seats at the bar and asked if I could sit upstairs instead. They graciously accommodated me. I liked the vibe upstairs and also I didn't want to deal with the climb back up. Aleksandra K took care of me. She was nice. She pointed out that they serve two olive oils with the free focaccia - the Tamía from Lazio and another from Sicily. The burrata with prosciutto ($33) was great. More than enough for two people. I took some home. The pastas were dry pastas out of a bag, not freshly made. They are also served al dente which is what they do, and they clearly indicate this, but I prefer a little softer. That said, the Parmesan cheese sauce and carbonara were very tasty. The steak was pretty rubbery though, and the potato puree was all right, decent amount of butter. I wasn't impressed with the dessert menu, so I asked for the bill. But they were nice enough to bring me a piece of tiramisu anyway. I had a couple bites. It was delicious, like tiramisu ought to be. Not over salted like the one at I Cavallini. I will note it is very loud there in the upstairs area. An expensive meal at roughly $194 including tax and tip, but cheaper than a trip to Rome. read more

See all

I know this is an Italian restaurant, but dining here made me feel like I was in Spain again. Maybe it's the bar seating. Maybe it's the drinks. Or it could be the black pig dish, which I often heard whispers of when I summered in Seville. But I digress. You want to know about the food, and I can tell you with confidence that it ranks as one of my tops. My drink, the cherry cocktail, is my favorite of all time. As someone who doesn't enjoy the taste of alcohol and adores a sweet drink, this was perfect. Plus, it came with three - three! - maraschino cherries. I ordered the carbonara as my main dish, but it paled in comparison to the vegetable-focused mains. It's cooked al dente, which isn't my favorite and a tad too salty. The cauliflower and black pig were the stars of the show. The cauliflower was tender, the chili sauce a nice touch, and the pine nuts a wonderful crunch. The black pig was delicious. It sat in a refreshing bed of tomato sauce and green pepper chunks. I would come back here just for these two. read more

See all

Limited menu choices with seating upstairs and downstairs. Service is a bit interesting as they let you settle down and order drinks before giving you the menu. We started with Burrata with semi-dried tomatoes. The tomatoes have a hint of sweetness that matches well with the Burrata. We also got the Prosciutto di Langhirano. Really delicious matching with the focaccia bread. We like the bread so much that we got an order of it with olive oil. We got the Amatriciana, Carbonara, Gricia, and Roman Meatballs for lunch. Everything was delicious. Ended the lunch with Tiramisu and Torta. read more

See all

We tried the Roscioli in Rome and were so excited to see they had a location at home! Our favorite (at both locations) was the AMATRICIANA with the bites of guanciale. The service was impeccable and atmosphere upscale. Would love to come again! read more

Roscioli - Amatriciana - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Roscioli is one of my favorite restaurants in the world. I first went there a couple of times in Rome, and I was ecstatic when they announced an NYC location! The carbonara is a true wow moment for me, but all of the Roman classics are truly perfect. The ingredients are the highest quality, and the pasta is cooked al dente. The descriptions seem simple, but that's how it should be - it's all you need for flavor. On my latest visit, I also tried the Burro e parmigiano "Francescana" from the Modern Classics side of the pasta menu. Seemingly so simple, and so delicious. For a table of 4, we also got the prosciutto and focaccia, the burrata topped with semi-dried tomatoes, the scarola alla napoletana and the secreto ibérico de bellota (a standout for sure!I've rarely had pork so tender and packed with flavor). We finished with a tiramisu, which was especially creamy and one of the best I've had. Roscioli sources ingredients selectively, and I believe that we are getting the best they can find. The food is so delicious, it really speaks for itself! Everything tastes fresh and delicious. There is a purpose for every ingredient on the plate. The restaurant itself is pretty small, and they make the most of the space. The tables are close together, and it can get loud when it's packed. Service is attentive but not speedy, so I recommend going if you don't have a tight time constraint. I've never been seated before my reservation time - arrived early twice and never again. It's a worthwhile treat meal. Our bill for 4 people with all of the above and 1 espresso, no other drinks, ended up at about $75 per person including tax and tip. If you want to dine like you've teleported to Rome, go to Roscioli! read more

See all

The food was excellent and was presented so nicely. Our server, Gabriel was very attentive to the table and so personable which made for a great dining experience! The ambiance was lovely, especially downstairs in the wine cellar. All of the staff were extremely kind and welcoming to the customers. read more

Came here and dined solo last Sunday. I was able to make a reservation for 1 to sit at their counter seating. It's a great option as a solo diner. The service was great and the waiters were friendly. I got a glass of red wine and the carbonara. The pasta was super yummy and rich. read more

Roscioli - Carbonara - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Mangia! Our favorite meal in Rome has quickly become our favorite meal in the City. So hot right now, Hansel-only counter seating for us. No worries there was more than enough space for our feast and they made the best use of it. We started with an excellent dealers choice cheese plate, caponata and bread basket. My wife had the Amatriciana she loves and I had what continues to be the very best Carbonara. Finished with Tiramisu and wondered when we can get back here again. read more

Roscioli - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Food was great, but the delays in service left a bit to be desired. We made a reservation for the a la carte menu in the lower level bar seating area. We were seated promptly and service was friendly. First, our order of meatballs and artichokes came out quickly. Very tasty, but the star of the show was really the pasta here. Unfortunately, we waited at least 30 minutes after finishing our first two dishes before our pastas started coming out. The cacio e pepe and carbonara came out next. Their cacio e pepe was amazing. I'm normally not a fan of it but the flavors and simplicity blew my mind. The carbonara was solid. Unfortunately, after these two dishes we experienced another long wait before our agnolotti and amatriciana came out (which were both tasty as well!). The tiramisu was tasty but the cacio e pepe was still the highlight for me. Hopefully just a one off with the service delays but otherwise I would definitely return just for the cacio e pepe! read more

See all

Came here on a Wednesday and it was fairly busy for the Roman Feast. If you're there for the tasting menu you head downstairs. The space is medium sized with a good amount of tables for 4. I sat with my friend at a booth. We tried the classic wine pairing with it and it def enhanced the experience. They also have an additional 2 dishes that are specials if you want to try additional seasonal items but the general tasting menu is a lot. Def come hungry! I felt like everything was prepared well. The pastas were perfect texture and the meat was very tender. My favorite of the night was Amatriciana Pasta! Overall, had a great experience with friendly staff. Would def come back again! It's a great way to share food in a large party for the holidays read more

See all

They have a service called the Roman Feast which provides you with a four course meal (appetizers, mains and dessert). You can also add wine pairings to each dish. The concept is family style which is pretty unique for a prix fixe meal. They also add some additional dishes as a surprise which was fun! My favorite was the tiramisu which was so so good read more

See all

Really enjoyed our dinner at Roscioli. We booked right when reservations opened a month out and the only slot we could get was 5:30pm on a Sunday, so we ate light all day and showed up ready to eat. Every dish delivered. We started with the burrata with prosciutto and the sautéed escarole salad, then shared the Amatriciana and carbonara pastas along with the Iberico pork steak. Finished with tiramisu for dessert. For three people sharing, the portions felt just right. Service was friendly, efficient, and the pacing between courses was spot on. We were seated downstairs (basement level), which we actually preferred--it was quieter and felt a bit more relaxed. The only downside was the semicircle booth we were in; it was a bit tight on legroom for three people. Minor tradeoff though, considering how great the meal was overall. read more

This is a tiny restaurant and the max rsvp is 5 people. They have seating at the street level and then additional seats in the lower level for the prixe fixe. We sat literally next to the entrance. It was a very uncomfortable seating arrangement for 5 people. Luckily we were able to squeeze onto the bench since our 5th person was a kid. We ordered the Cheese Monger's choice board for $34. It had three different types of cheeses, four thin slices of two, and a little bit of a soft cheese. They were all pretty mild and crowd pleasing. No funky ones. It came with some honey, but no bread. We also ordered the sun-dried tomato burrata for $24. It came with NO bread. We had to order bread separately for $8. The bread was hard, stale and tasted like it was pre-cut for dinner service. Very disappointed with the amount of food and quality vs. cost. The cacio e pepe - it was gummy as other reviewers noted. It should be smooth and warm when served. It was cold. The amatriciana was not notable. We also ordered the fish (PESCE E FAGIOLI ZOLFINI), which was also not notable. The fish tasted it was thawed too quickly from a frozen slab. Tiramisu was standard. A little too much cream for me. Probably will not return. read more

See all

Roscioli began in Rome in 1974 and still runs several beloved spots there. In 2023, it opened its first (and only) location outside Italy on MacDougal Street in Soho, NYC. We sat upstairs in the cozy à la carte room, which is small and intimate, with a little shop selling cheeses, olive oils, pastas, and merchandise to take home. (Downstairs offers a five-course set menu, The Roman Feast). We started with burrata with semi-dried tomatoes and fried artichokes, both apps great. The cacio e pepe and carbonara we split were al dente, peppery, and rich. Service was warm, attentive, and genuinely kind. Simple Roman classics done just right. read more

See all

The service was lacking. I waited probably 20mins for a server. I ordered everything at once. I didn't see her again until long after I finished. I ordered one drink and pasta. Frankly I didn't order dessert because I thought I would have been stranded even longer. So, she dropped the bill and never even came back to check me out. Someone else did when they saw my card out. Pretty sad experience since I was so excited to get a little taste of Rome. The food was stellar and it was cool watching t.he kitchen. But service was disappointing. I will say the restaurant was cute - felt very Italy. read more

Roscioli - amatriciana - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Restaurant from Rome (they are on the @michelinguide over there) right here in NYC. The restaurant is really cute with the Italian pantry items (always lured me in). Our favorite ended up being the artichoke appetizer! Note that there are not many vegan or vegetarian options here! read more

Roscioli - Carciofi fritti - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Had such a great experience doing 'THE ROMAN FEAST' at Roscioli. Roman Feast: $95 (no beverage) + $55 (Standard wine pairing add-on) before tax and tip. This included five courses with five wine pairings. The food was absolutely amazing! Like most pre-fixe, you never think the portions they serve will be enough, but trust me when I say we left absolutely stuffed! If you see more than 5 courses it is also because they did throw in a few extra breads and cheeses. The experience was great too. Our waitress was so amicable and knowledgeable about the foods and wines that were being served. The place is cute. Upstairs seems a bit more casual but still elegant if that makes sense. Downstairs definitely has a more elegant feel to it. Will definitely come back and try their regular menu next time! read more

See all

Had my birthday at Roscioli and did the Roman Feast with the wine pairing. Let me tell ya, they did not lie about the "feast" part There are only two other times in my life where I've been so painfully full. Everything was SO delicious too. Would definitely come again - probably the best priced multi-course menu in all of NYC read more

See all

I stopped by for a weekday lunch by myself - they were pretty busy (even around 2pm) but I was able to get seated at the bar without much of a wait. I had the supplì al telefono to start - really delicious! The breading was great -- not too crispy/oily -- and complemented the delicious inside filling (rice, beef, mozzarella) wonderfully. Definitely would recommend this as an appetiser. For pasta I had the spaghettoni alla carbonara (which I think is their speciality)? The most notable part is that the sauce is very "Roman", i.e. they don't add cream to it, so the mixture of just egg and cheese is much thicker/creamier and saltier. I think it was really too rich/heavy - by the end of the dish it felt like every bite was overwhelming :( The guanciale was nice -- I liked the bold, savoury flavour -- but definitely contributed to the overall feeling of saltiness throughout. Other than that, I have to say the pasta was cooked perfectly (al dente), which I appreciated. Restaurant interior was lovely -- feels very intimate and "home-y" -- and service was kind, attentive, and very prompt. Price point is a little high but it's not too bad for a splurge (esp by NYC standards). I'd definitely recommend giving it a visit (if you can snag a res), and I'd love to come back -- but I'd probably try a different pasta next time :P read more

See all

Terrible. I was so disappointed. The service was marginal at best. Waiter made a mistake thinking I wanted a huge block of cheese. A great presentation the cheese was great only problem, I never ordered it. The waiter then disappeared as he was embarrassed or pissed. Needless to say we will not be back Sat at the counter. It would help if the staff would clean the inside of the glass presentation. Little flies everywhere and nothing can kill an appetite like insects. I hate these reviews but I'm not going to lie read more

Excellent service and one of a kind authentic Italian dishes. Great spot in SoHo. Great wine list and the staff was amazing.

Tasting menu review: I don't know what Roscioli in Rome is doing, but its New York sibling isn't trying very hard. This was the blandest, most boring tasting menu I've ever had the misfortune of spending money on, and I'm annoyed I came. In a nutshell: The tasting menu food is too traditional to be interesting, and too mediocre to do justice to tradition. So what you're left with are dishes of overpriced cliches. - Complimentary mortadella sandwich: This was fine, but nothing I would've spent money on, so I appreciated that it was free. - Burrata Pomodori with Fried Artichoke: I guess they source their burrata from Italy, but given that it's dairy and local dairy is always fresher/healthier than imported dairy, I don't think that's something worth bragging about. This burrata was fine, if a bit too runny, and the fried artichoke hearts were forgettable. - Sicilian Red Prawns, Ossetra Caviar, Pane Carasau: We decided to fork over an extra $32 to try this upgrade. It was literally one prawn, cut in half, with caviar on top. About one spot higher than Coqodaq's $35 single chicken nugget on my list of "Single food items I've wasted money on". - Lasagna Modenese: Delicious and hearty. I wish every course had just been like this. - Mezze Maniche alla Pomodoro: Basically rigatoni in watery tomato sauce, but I guess if you slap on fancy Italian names, people will think it's more exotic than it is. Repeat after me: rigatoni in watery tomato sauce. And not even cooked well. - Misticanza + Roasted Squash / Short Rib: Basically, salad with your choice of main. The salad was just typical packaged greens made limp from dressing. We opted to get both main options to try more things. The squash was tiny, too sweet and barely seasoned with anything. The short rib was equally tiny, though cooked better than the squash. And this is their main course? - Complimentary parmigiana with aged balsamic vinegar: A nice thought, but I can't eat that much parmesan, and the balsamic vinegar tasted like port. Not my bag. - Tiramisu: Really? Tiramisu for dessert? I get it, it's an Italian classic. But this is one of those desserts that's so overdone, it's an eye-rolling cliche for me. So I rolled my eyes over to their alternative dessert , a blood orange / grapefruit sorbet, which was mildly better. Service was friendly, but our courses came out very inconsistently, with long waits after the first two dishes, leading us to spend far more time at the restaurant than we wanted. In short, I won't be putting Roscioli on my list on my next trip to Rome. read more

See all

Love the vibe here - everything is super well designed and it has an upscale casual feel. The appetizers were great - the suppli was perfect and the jamon was some of the best I've had. However, I expected a bit more out of the pastas. The cacio e pepe was good, but nothing extraordinary (Via Carota is better imo) and same for the amatriciana. It was well flavored but I wouldn't go back for it especially at $29 a plate. For dessert we had the tiramisu which was really nice! They also have some nice wines and the service is great. Overall, worth a one time visit but considering the high price point I won't be running back. read more

See all

Definitely get a reservation, this place gets packed very quickly! Did the A La Carte experience, very expensive but the food was good! Got the burrata and sun dried tomatoes with focaccia to start, followed by the sage cappelleti (the STAR this was so good) and the cacio e Pepe. We also got the tiramisu for dessert which was really good! Overall it was a very good meal, just very expensive and I feel like there are other Italian spots in the city that are just as good but a little more affordable. read more

See all

I really had high hopes for this place but was pretty disappointed during my last visit. I made a reservation for the last round of lunch service on a Saturday. The place was packed and after checking in with the host, I was waiting awkwardly by the door for what was 20-25 min before being seated at the bar seating in front of the kitchen. After ordering, it felt like eons for my food to come out. I nearly finished the entire bread basket by myself (which was actually good) while waiting. Sitting by the kitchen, I could tell the service staff was visibly overwhelmed/stressed and the kitchen was busy. I don't think it's my place to make assumptions but the prix fixe lunch menu seemed to put a huge burden on the kitchen and appeared to be what most people in the room were there for. My reservation unfortunately was for the a la carte menu. Make sure to note this when making a booking for lunch! My carbonara felt like the last thing the kitchen made before barreling into prepping for dinner service. The carbonara was not that great surprisingly. The sauce was gummy/not velvety and the flavor was one-dimensional. I will say that the suppli and the tiramisu were quite good. The tiramisu was genuinely one of the best I've ever had but unfortunately not good enough of an excuse to return. The wait staff were super apologetic throughout the meal and comped my dessert because I had literally been there for two whole hours. I wouldn't usually have minded but it was my last day in town and I had places to be. read more

See all

walked in for one on a tuesday night and was promptly seated at the counter. unsure if it was an off day but the carbonara was extremely bland. sauce was silky but had almost no taste, just a mild funk probably from the pecorino. i was chasing around the scant bits of cheese and guanciale on my plate for a hit of sodium. pasta also could've been a bit more al dente. the two olive oils they serve with their focaccia are great but don't save the meal. restaurant is cozy, tables are packed closely. read more

Roscioli - carbonara - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

I came here for the tasting menu with the wine pairing and the food was really solid! I liked the variety I got with the tasting menu between different pastas and lighter sides and appetizers! The wine pairing was also really nice to have and elevated the experience for sure! The staff was really sweet and they went into detail for each dish as well as where the wines were sourced and how they're produced in the different regions! The tasting menu is offered downstairs to the side of the main entrance and the ambiance was nice! There were wine bottles everywhere and books! It felt like I was in someone's wine cellar in their home! I would like to go back but for the full menu and ordering a la carte! read more

See all

Wanted a light meal and skipped an appetizer. Had tagliolini Cacio e Pepe which was superb. The complimentary bread basket was served with two types of olive oil. The Sicilian olive oil was literally delicious These two items and a glass of Barbera made for a fantastic light meal Lauren was a friendly and efficient waitress. The Alimentari environment is a combination gracery and local bistro read more

Roscioli - Tagliolini Cacio a Pepe - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Decided to come here while planning my trip to Rome and got excited there was a location here! Restaurant is very small but had the pleasure of eating at the chef's counter. Service was outstanding and I'm always intrigued to see the kitchen chaos! Started with burrata and prosciutto which didn't disappoint! They have 4 types of bread with 2 very distinct olive oils for dipping. They treated me to a fried artichoke while I waited for my main course. My main course was carbonara which was delicious but a little too peppery for my liking. It was nice to try an authentic Roman style carbonara instead of the heavy cream Americanized version. Will definitely come back here and try more of their pasta options! read more

See all

If you ate at the Roscioli in Rome, this is a hard no. We were so looking forward to our dinner at Roscioli. We at the one in Rome and loved it so much, we went back twice. The atmosphere is nice, and our server was helpful. The menu was not authentic Roman food, just a few of the pastas. We had: - Artichokes - very good, we opted to not have them fried. - Carbonara - good but extremely heavy. The guanciale was overcooked. - Amatriciana - tasty but again the guanciale was overcooked. - Bread - the pizza bread was ice cold. The olive oils were terrific. - Desserts - we passed, the only authentic Italian dessert was the tiramisu. Kind of surprised to see they used Mexican chocolate on an Italian dessert.... We will save Roscioli for Rome. read more

The servers and other staff are excellent--friendly, knowledgeable, and very helpful and accommodating. Pastas are delicious and done well. Focaccia and olive oil are also excellent. Will be a regular stop when I am in NY read more

I was so glad to get a reservation the week of Thanksgiving for the a la carte dining. The space is very intimate and the tables toward the back where we were seated were quite close together. It would be difficult to maneuver if you had a lot of bags or a larger coat. We started with the Crudo and the anchovy burrata. We've never had crude like this, there wasn't much sauce like in asian style dishes of this type but there was a decent amount of spice. We also shared the Carbonara and the meatballs. I appreciate an al dente pasta but this was almost too al dente for my liking, however, this is just my person al preference. The meatballs were good, I don't necessarily enjoy polenta though. Roscioli would be a great place to come with a group of friends so you would be able to try more dishes! read more

See all

Feel so grateful to have gotten an A La Carte reservation at Roscioli. Heads up, you book through Resy, the restaurant requires a $2.50 non-refundable deposit per person upon reserving. I managed to grab a 5PM reservation at opening and had to line up to get seated. The interior is super cozy and inviting. It feels like you're eating in a fine grocery. You can buy items at Roscioli - including olive oil, prosciutto, sauces, etc! We ordered the burrata with sundried tomatoes, cacio e pepe, amatriciana, meatballs chicken and tiramisu. To start though, they bring out complimentary bread and olive oil. The cappelli olive oil was high-quality and had a grassiness to it. Burrata was super fresh. Tasted even better with bread. Cacio e pepe was so light and creamy. Amatriciana had amazing pockets of guanciale and the sauce was nice and bright. Meatballs are the only thing I thought were OK, they came with polenta. And last but not least, don't forget to get the tiramisu. It is absolutely DIVINE. The best tiramisu I've ever had. Comes with this delicious dark chocolate situation - yum. Would come back for just the cappelli olive oil, amatriciana and tiramisu alone. read more

See all

Cute cozy warmth spot. *Pizza e Mortazza - wish it was warm. *Fried Rice Ball - very good with melty cheese inside. *Roasted Veal - not my typical order but feel like it's a very Italian dish, the flavor was good. *Stuff Pasta w/ Ricotta - very good, delicate, sage was a nice touch. *Amatriciana - flavorful, al dente, can't go wrong. *Porchetta Maialino - I'm not a pork person but it's done very nice here. Looks like it was deconstructed and reconstructed, layered in parts. YUM! *Tiramisu - perfect ending at the end. Would love to come back and try burrata! read more

See all

I was so excited to go to Roscioli based on the reviews but unfortunately it did not meet my expectations. I got a 7 pm reservation on a Saturday for my birthday. I'm not sure if it was a technical issue with their seating chart app but my group and a few others had to wait 15 minutes to be seated, which was fine given how small the restaurant was. Once seated, we ordered the bread with olive oil and the suppli. Both were delicious and I really liked the Tuscan olive oil that came with the bread. Unfortunately the rest of the night took a wrong turn. We ordered a bottle of red wine and a server came and presented us with the bottle and then walked away and didn't pour anything. We eventually got served but I'm not sure if it was a staff mixup but we found that odd. For entrees, we ordered the cacio e Pepe and amatriciana. Both pastas were very al dente and hard to chew. The guiancale was overcooked too. Tiramisu was good but overall wasn't thrilled with my experience. read more

See all

Best and most authentic meal I have had since coming back from living in Rome. Had the focaccia, burrata with tomatoes, carbonara, and Tiramisu. Carbonara was as good as the ones in Rome, much better than anything I've had in the US. Everything else was great as well. Pricey but worth it. It's a must go and I will be back! read more

Amazing food and wine choices. Every dish was perfectly prepared. The ambiance was gorgeous and the waitstaff VERY knowledgeable and made us feel welcome. I will definitely eat here again the next time I am in town! read more

TLDR: If you've ever wondered what the food in Rome tastes like - Roscioli is it. They started as a salumeria in Rome, so try some of the salumi. Definitely get the Roman classics. Pasta Burro e Parmigiano, Amatriciana, Carbonara are our favorites. Do not forget the tiramisu. I've eaten at Roscioli a number of times now. If you want the full menu, dinner is when you should go. Lunch is a smaller menu but they do a $55 pre-fixe which is actually priced very well and it is filling. They rotate their apps seasonally but if you're their for dinner, definitely try the prosciutto and their burrata. The prosciutto (being a salumeria) is a cut above the rest. The burrata is incredibly creamy as you'd expect. We really liked the one with the crispy artichokes and zucchini. For pastas, the butter and parmigiano pasta started as a special but it's on the menu permanently now. They use a mixture of three different aged parms and French butter. The Amatriciana is my favorite of the staple Roman pastas, the Carbonara is a close second. Definitely get the tiramisu. Their other dishes are also very good too but if you've managed to snag a reservation and it's your first time - stick with the classic items. read more

See all

Honestly such a wonderful experience here. Had a reservation for 2 that increased to 3 and they were very accommodating ( during the week). Ended up sitting in the wine cellar which is usually reserved for chefs tasting but they served us the ala carte menu. Everything that we ordered was cooked perfectly, flavorful and presented well. I would hands down come back again and recommend it to anyone. read more

See all