Reservations are nearly impossible to get here - my husband tried for weeks. The only thing he could find online was a table for 4 at 10:45pm. He read online that if we arrived at 4pm, we should be able to get into the first seating at the bar. We arrived at 3:53pm on Monday of President's Day weekend - 6 parties ahead of us. This worked out great, we got the 7pm seating (which you can request if you want). The hostess starts going down the line at around 4:30pm, so you'll know your fate for the evening. Also, FYI only parties of 1-2 allowed for walking in at the bar. They started turning on the hip hop music at 4:40pm. We put our names down around 5:10pm, for the bar's second seating. By 6:08pm, I already received a text that our table was ready!
What's the hype about really? A cool Italian restaurant with dishes that are a nod to the different neighborhoods and cuisines surrounding Nolita where the restaurant is located. Some of these dishes are quite creative and you would not be able to find anywhere else. Also, a restaurant on "100 Best Restaurants in NYC in 2025" and also part of the restaurant from creators of Carbone. Also, reservations that are nearly impossible to score. We just were dying to try it, it had to be THAT good.
We ordered the Tomato Martini, House Endive Salad, the Cavatelli with Jamaican Beef Ragu, the Tortellini Pomodoro, the Linguini in 15 Pink Littleneck Clams, the Duck Alla Mulberry, and the Almond Cheesecake.
My Tomato Martini was decent, but nothing super exciting. The House endive salad was good, but nothing particular special or memorable. We did order that dish specifically to get some greens in. The Cavatelli with Jamaican Beef Ragu was an interesting dish - it was spicy, with the Jamaican spices. It was beef but tased quite gamey. It sounds interesting, and I see what they wanted to do with the dish, but I just didn't care for it.
The linguini with clams pasta was very good, and executed very well. However, it tasted like anything I could have gotten at another Italian restaurant. I just didn't see the creativity in this dish.
The Tortellini Pomodoro was recommended by our waitress when we had asked her to suggest a 3rd pasta for us to share. She said this was the most popular pasta on the menu. The tomato sauce was acidic, sweet, and delicious. The tortellinis tasted like little pillows of happiness. This was executed very well, but also I felt I could order this at another Italian restaurant.
We were almost losing hope by this point. But we were still waiting for the Duck Alla Mullberry. BUT wow! This dish blew our minds!!!! The duck was great quality, and had a nice fatiness to it. The mulberry sauce tasted similarly to a hoisin sauce, a nod to the Chinese cuisine. The duck sauce on other side, and orange zest on top, added an extra layer of juiciness and richness, that made it taste like the French dish Duck L'orange. It was such a delightful flavor bomb in my mouth.
Our waitress asked about our duck, and we explained how wonderful it was, but also told her we were kind of disappointed in the pastas. Nothing was bad per se, but nothing seemed warranting of an hour+ wait in line outside. She apologized to us.
For dessert, we ordered the Almond Cheesecake. They also surprised us with a complimentary Affogato! The cheesecake was good, but I felt could have been enhanced with some other flavor besides almond to make the dish pop. It just felt like the almond flavor got lost. The Affogato on the other hand, was unforgettable. It had this ice crumble on the top, underneath hiding was the vanilla ice cream and chocolate fudge. Each bite gets all 3 layers - huge yum!
For those wanting a comparison to Carbone, I think the pastas are about the same as what you can get at Carbone. In some dishes, the pastas I think are probably a little better at Carbone. Also the fact that we were able to obtain a reservation at Carbone made a huge difference.
Ambiance and scene here overall is fun. The dining room is cute, with exposed brick, but a lot of modern touches, to make it feel like old and new NYC all in one. It's an open dining room, open kitchen, as opposed to Carbone, where it's sectioned off into rooms. I enjoyed the lighting behind the bar, warm and with a glamorous feel.
The service was very professional and helpful. We did wait a while for some of our dishes though, such as the pastas, and the duck took a long time, considering that they gave us a 1.5 hour time block for sitting at the bar (although they did not kick us out).
Overall, the restaurant was good.
Was the food good? Yes, but nothing really special.
Was it with the hype? Probably not.
Was it worth going to? Yes!
Would I go back? No
Hospitality was amazing though. They really took care of us, and I really appreciated the experience overall. I originally would have given this restaurant 3 stars on Yelp, but because of the excellent hospitality, I will round up to 4. read more