Their pizza is great. But do not pay until you've received your order. I was told they didn't have an item, offered a substitution, which I was happy to take. But the kid at the door could not tell me what else I could substitute it with so I didn't know what to say. He later said they would just refund the item. I was never refunded. If I go back will make sure to pay in cash or just not pay until I get my order. It's unfortunate because I've ordered a lot from here, but this experience has definitely left a sour taste and it seems like others have had some similar experiences. Great pizza. Poor customer service. read more

I love this place so much but hate it so much. The pizza is so great, but for the love of all pizza, they can't give you an accurate time to pick up your pizza. You call and order and it's going to be an hour and a half. Ok. But then you get there and have to wait 15,20, 30 or even 40 minutes or more. It's never ready on time. I love fresh pizza but they haven't even started making your pizza when you arrive at the time you are told. Why does the pizza have to be so good that I keep going back for the misery of waiting?? FYI, tonight's wait after arriving 35 minutes. read more

Rob took our order The pizza was delicious Given great service -when the pizza slaps, give em a haiku read more

Its tough when COVID is here and you cant actually go into a place, Sabatinos is small but standing outside in the elements with a line does tend to make one want to leave.....good thing I didnt, wow is this pizza good. Fresh and with many varieties makes this place a must to visit. Its going to be a wait, no doubt there, especially on a friday, but well worth it read more

Sabatino's is a great, relatively new, addition to the SOMA food scene. No ambience to speak of, but that's no surprise, and beside the point, for a local pizza joint. Two of us, together, had 5 slices - 2 grandma, and one each roasted zucchini, roasted red pepper/spinach, and sausage/pepperoni. Uniformly delicious - and highly recommended. read more

If you're reading this now, you're probably debating whether or not this place is worth a try. I get it, you're used to your mediocre just okay pizza from your usual spot. You're not ready to experience perfection in edible form. And that's okay, if you're not that's truly your loss. You can go back to your boring run of the mill pizza you always get and continue on without it. But once you try Sab's it's almost a curse in a way, because no pizza will ever be as good again. No other pizza will compare. You'll search for it, you'll hope for it, at times even pray for it, but it won't exist. Sab has found some sort of inexplicable devine combination that other restaurants won't ever be able to live up to. This place will have to be your new regular and if you're not ready for that level of commitment, I fear this place may not be for you. Once you try it, there's no going back. read more

Best Meatball Parm EVER!!! I only wish they offered pizza options in smaller sizes. read more

I needed a place to have lunch today that was within a certain area and I only have an hour to spare. So when I came across Sabatino's I was intrigued. I read the reviews and decided this was a good choice. Well the great reviews were accurate! I had the mushroom pizza and it was delicious. The flavors were spot on and the crust was thin and crispy. My only disappointment was that we couldn't eat inside. They only had few tables and no AC but it was worth the trip. We eat our lunch in the car and enjoyed every bite! Therefore it got 4 stars and not 5. But we will go back soon and take our pizza to go' read more

Got here at scheduled pickup time. Been waiting 30 minutes so far. Not their fault because the place seems to be run by polite teenagers. No adults on property. read more

Went into here with my work crew. Easily the best pizza around. We all left satisfied, yet we wish the place to be bigger.

AMAZING!! Great pie Just come!! Cauliflower pizza is amazing!!!! Service is fast, everyone was amazingly kind! This place is a gem read more

The best pizza in town hands down. This guy Sabatino knows what he's doing. I would recommend the cauliflower crust pizza or a regular roasted zucchini pie. Really fresh and yummy. read more

Sabatino’s - Cauliflower crust pizza! So good! We usually get the pepperoni and the white balsamic. Never disappointed. 5/5 would rec - Pizza Near Me - Maplewood, New Jersey

Simply the best. The wait can be long because of the demand so plan accordingly. The price is not inexpensive but the quality and quantity of the dishes support the cost. You will fantasize about the food after it's all gone. They are incredibly addictive. I could eat them every day. As far as ambiance, the outside dining works well for a warm overcast day. read more

Sabatino's regular pies are perfection and their fancy toppings are also perfection (General Tso's?? Somehow delicious). Order ahead very early on busy days because the secret is already out about this amazing shop. read more

$@&# those guys. They told me to pick up in an hour. Customers have to wait outside in the cold, and EVERYONE'S order takes a lot longer than promised. Some customers got insincere apologies, as if they're routine. I got nothin'. Not sure which is worse. Never again, Sabotaggio's. read more

Great staff, great food. The buffalo wings are amazing, hot squad and ranch are good. Margarita pizza is so good, def would recommend to anyone in town. read more

I was so pleased for our first order. Great customer service with my phone order and the grandma pizza was delicious. Great sauce and light pan pizza type crust. Fresh and delicious. read more

Although Maplewood already has a ton of options when it comes to Italian and pizza this place is really awesome! We've tried a few different pies, pepperoni, sausage, and a white pie. All of them were fantastic! My wife and I also ordered some garlic knots and a couple meatball subs which also were killer. Definitely the best meatball sub I've had while living in Maplewood! The restaurant is pretty small so you can't have a large group there but it's an excellent option for takeout. The staff is super friendly as well. I highly recommend giving this place a try! read more

Do not miss Sabatinos... one of the absolute best slices around. He gets creative with ingredients and never disappoints! I love all slices... but can never ever go wrong with traditional plain. Also, sausage peppers and onions pie is outta this world. Again, DO NOT MISS SABATINOS!!!! Great job tremendous service and even better food!! read more

Delicious and Fresh Pizza.. They have so many options. If you want the best pizza in town that's the place! Great vibes too

Next level pie which far too many fail to get right. The place is super clean (obviously behind the counter as well-as it's a small joint and you can see production) with a ton of heart in quality ingredients. Owner super talented-super friendly and clearly invested in his food in this slammin joint. A must go for you, and a must return for me! read more

Sabatino sure knows how to make a good pizza pie. Margherita is phenomenal. The roasted zucchini pie is insane. I like getting my pie on the well done side, as a bit of extra insurance that the crust holds up. The pizza is definitely the best when sabatino himself is making it. You can taste the love that goes into it. read more

All of the high quality ingredients and delicious food you'd expect of a CIA-trained chef and none of the pretension! Sabatino's is a real gem, bringing modern touches to the neighborhood pizzeria! The zucchini pizza in particular is a real standout! read more

Great pizza shop!! Fresh hot pizza not too greasy. The staff there are amazing and quick to get you in and out around lunch time.

Omg most amazing margherita slice I've had in a long time! The sauce is SO dang good and the basil - UGH! I couldn't get enough! The owner and his mom are really nice, they make you feel like family! read more

Sabatino's is one of the best slices around. This isn't one of those joints that has okay jersey pizza. I'm talking this guy trained in Italy and his pizzas show it. Get a Margherita slice, you'll love it. read more

Sabatino's has become our go to pizza place. The pizza is incredible especially the Roasted Zucchini Pie and Zia Mimma's Pan Pizza but what's even better, the owners are just genuinely nice guys. I highly recommend Sabatino's. read more

Great customer service. My family and I love Sabs. He connects w each and every customer that walks into his restaurant, especially the students at the neighboring High School. read more

Sabatino's has the best pizza around. The owner, Sab, has a mind for creating delicious pizza creations that cannot be found anywhere else. We had the mac and cheese pie, the peppers and fresh mozz white pie and the grandma pie, All were delicious. I loved the mozzarella sticks too b/c the gravy was awesome. Please give it a try. You will not be disappointed! read more

Stopped in on the way home and picked up a Meat Lover's pie and a Whole Lotta Burrata pie. Both pizzas hade perfect crusts. The quality of ingredients was tip-top. We loved EVERYTHING about these pizzas. Chef Sabatino knows great pizza and he definitely takes pride in the end product. You're on the top of my pizza list now, chef. read more

I Live in Flemington passed this pizza spot a thousand times at least finally stopped for a few slices a pepperoni and margarita slice definitely five stars excellent taste high quality ingredients, the staff and owner were very pleasant definitely going to be my knew spot a pleasure Karsten. read more

Sab's has officially passed trattoria as the best chx finger French fry spot in town. Best meatball parm in town too. A gem

Ok...just ok pizza...I get that we're starved for a good slice and pie...and don't want to wait for a table to clear at Arturo's....but five stars? Definitely not...it's an hour wait now at Sabs, generally speaking...last visit, likely my last, ordered a veggie pie... loved that it had real veggies but sadly the crust couldn't support them...was a mess by the time you were done with it...I'll stick with Star over in Orange. read more

Just ate a meatball parm from Sabatinos's it was probably the best meatball parm I have ever eaten , the bread they use is fantastic,

You MUST try Sabatino's. This is my third time, and his pizza the best I've ever had -- fresh and light and with delicious ingredients, in a very pretty and bright setting. Sabatino is a graduate of the Culinary Institute of America. He and his staff work hard to feed South Orange and Maplewoodians. Do not miss this opportunity for pizza which is out of this world. read more

Completely unorganized. Waiting outside for a half hour+ after the time they said my order would be ready. Will not be going back.

Great team! Small shop, clean and well run. Pizza maker, himself, came out from behind the counter to greet our guest who cam all the way from Japan for American pizza! Crust was perfect, and our half zucchini/half sausage and pepperoni was delicious. Great value for money. read more

Stopped in for a pie last week based on a recommendation. I'm very happy, that I did because what I experienced was a very good start to what could be my new pizza go to. The service was just what I expected and the pie was delicious. Yeah, I know, it's just dough, sauce and cheese but it can be magical when done right and these guys have figured it out! Here's what sums it up for me. As I was walking out, I mentioned to the guys behind the counter that "I heard you guys make a pretty good NY pizza" and their response was "I don't know about that but what I can tell you is that we make great Sabatino pizza". Gotta love that! I'll definitely be back... read more

Just the best pizza in the area. Hands down. We love it and get it all the time -- even though it means driving to pick it up ;) That says it all! read more

Coming from South Carolina, pizza this good is hard to come by. All I can say is wow. The crust was so crispy that, when you held it up flat, the slice stood straight out without folding from the weight of cheese and toppings. We had a side of Mommas meatballs too which also were really good. If I lived in this neighborhood, i would weigh about 20 lbs more. read more