Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Shortbread Society

    4.9 (45 reviews)
    Closed 10:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Shortbread Society Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Shortbread Society

    Recommended Reviews - Shortbread Society

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Love the box!
    Mia L.

    I've been following Shortbread Society on Instagram for a few months now and have been curious to place an order from them to try out some of their shortbread. If you follow them on social media, you will see how they transform something so simple, like shortbread, into an intricate delicacy. I was lucky enough to win a free shortbread from them through a social media giveaway. The prize consisted of a free tray of the Birthday Baby Buttercream Shortbread. It is a shortbread that has a cake flavor to it and filled with rainbow sprinkles. It's topped with pink buttercream frosting, more sprinkles, and edible glitter for a little more razzle dazzle. The owner/manager was very communicative during the shipping process, providing me with the shipping information and later checking to see if I received it. They also provided guidance on how to serve the shortbread. Since it arrives in a tray and is usually cold, you want to take it out of the tray and let it come down to room temperature before slicing. As for the shortbread, I thought it was delicious! Personally, I could've done without the frosting or without so much of it, but that's just my personal preference. I'm typically the one who wipes half the frosting off cupcakes if I think it's too much. Overall, I'm grateful for the chance to try out Shortbread Society and look forward to placing an order in the future when I get the chance to go to Jersey City.

    Side view so good
    Vicky L.

    I've ordered from them twice now and their shortbread is legit!! I've tried the millionaires and the billionaires, if you like salted caramel, GET THE BILLIONAIRES!! IT'S SO GOOD!!! Also, I really love the whole secret society concept even though it's not that much of a secret anymore!! Their shortbread is good but their presentation blew me away!! You'll see!! I'll definitely be ordering again!!!

    Banoffee Pie shortbread
    Madeleine B.

    The pics of this shortbread are gorgeous and so is the actual taste of the shortbread! I'm not usually a fan of it because it's typically dry and bland. But this shortbread tastes like a moist cookie or blondie. It is pricey but worth the splurge. Plus, the bakers/owners are the nicest people. The flavors are inventive and always delicious. Highly recommend. BTW they are a ghost kitchen, so you have to DM them on Instagram to place an order.

    Birthday Baby Buttercream Shortbread
    Jessica P.

    Okay wow where do I begin with this product? So I ordered this off goldbelly to celebrate going through financial licensing with my firm. I love anything birthday cake flavored and loved the look of this companies products on the site. I did not pay extra for the absolutely GORGEOUS box they shipped my treat in. That is an option though so I can only imagine what the packing would have looked like if I did pick that. The product itself is melt in your mouth delicious and I love the edible glitter on top. I cannot wait to visit Shortbread Society in person and would love to do so soon as I live on the east coast. Anyway, I hope this company stays in business forever or as long as they're willing to run it! I will be a returning customer in the future for sure!

    Banana Pudding
    Mike C.

    It's a secret. But not really. DM @shortbreadsociety on Instagram for the address. Set up a Venmo exchange with Chef Scottish Francis's wife, stop by the spot in Astoria, and pick up some of the best shortbread you've ever had. Of Masterchef fame, and then more recently locally first at Gossip Coffee and then Sugar & Water as the man behind the doughnuts, Scottish Francis's newest creations are his best yet. They are making exciting new flavors every week, including a gorgeous Independence Day sampler last weekend for July 4th, and for this week a Banana Nutella flavor that looks to be one of the best yet. But definitely try the classic Millionaires flavor for your first time. It will get you hooked and make you keep coming back. Follow them on Instagram for all the details, including some possible changes to location soon and popups in the city for easier access to these must try desserts.

    Rainbow Lemon
    S. Anne T.

    Update: ordered through gold belly again. This time tried the blueberry crumble, OG, and millionaire. Crumble was divine and you need to order it asap. Omg, drooling thinking of my afternoon tea tomorrow. Get it, thank me later. Can't wait to try a lemon rotation on gold belly...until then.

    Pistachio millionaire shortbread
    Ashley K.

    Honestly can't say enough about this company or their products! This is the 2nd time I've ordered them from gold belly (I am not local to them) and they DO NOT DISAPPOINT! The product you receive is exactly as they show it! The owners are so helpful and so sweet! I can't even describe how delicious their shortbread is. I ordered their new Pistachio Millionaires shortbread. Wow. That's all I can say! Quality, presentation, and customer service is spot on. Thank you Chef and Christine!

    Jennifer D.

    I first experienced the glorious gift of Shortbread Society through Goldbelly. My friends sent me the peanut butter cup shortbread for my birthday, and I do not exaggerate when I say this was a life changing dessert. The gorgeous layers and flavors in this shortbread were unlike anything I've ever experienced before in a dessert. I recently visited one of their weekly pop ups to try their new Tiramisu shortbread. It was absolutely delightful to correspond with Christine on IG to place my order and I got to pick up my order from Chef Scottish Francis himself! These two are so passionate about their creation, and I'm just happy to share more love for it!

    Peppermint shortbread
    Gab G.

    Been seeing this stuff all over Instagram for ages and finally got to try it when my friend got me the peppermint shortbread as a Christmas present. It was amazing!! (Picked up in the west village.)

    Alexandra C.

    I came across this place after they did a collaboration with my favorite ice cream shop, Caffe Panna. I love shortbread and was intrigued by the variety of flavors offered by Shortbread Society. As the other reviews indicate, this shop has a secret pop-up theme and you have to order the shortbread in advance through their instagram. After ordering, you are then told where to pick the shortbread up. My friend and I decided to order the lemon shortbread with yuzu chocolate topping and the birthday cake shortbreads to share. I loved the lemon shortbread and think it is one of the best desserts I've eaten this year. The birthday cake shortbread was good, but very sweet with a lot of frosting and not something I could eat a lot of unfortunately. I would highly recommend the lemon one to anyone who loves shortbread and lemon desserts. This place is by no means affordable (nearly 35-40 dollars per a tray of shortbread depending on which one), but definitely a must-try for shortbread fans. I hope that if they eventually go brick and mortar they make the price point a bit more reasonable or consider perhaps doing individual sized portion... I think between 20-30 is probably a more reasonable price for the size of the shortbread tray.

    crookies

    I ordered these cookies for birthday celebration and I'm not exaggerating when I say they are incredible!! We tried four different flavors (The Millionaires Lemon Zest, Jelly Donut, and Cherry Bakewell) andit was nearly impossible to choose our favorite. We also got an order of the crookies and they are absolutely worth the hype. I can't wait to place my next order!!

    See all

    Photo of Hali B.
    175
    15
    0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Christine B.

    Christine B.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Christine B.

    Christine B.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Shortbread Society

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 48,523 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Torico Ice Cream

    Torico Ice Cream

    4.4
    (975 reviews)
    0.3 km
    $$

    Established in 1968, this long-established shop makes all its ice cream in-house. Not only are the…read moreportions generous, but the texture is also incredibly smooth and silky, without any icy crystals or a hard, frozen consistency. Holding it or tasting it gives a substantial, high-quality feel. However, the consequence is that even the staff struggles to scoop it out with their spherical ice cream scoops, let alone the disposable plastic spoons provided to customers. Green Tea: The highest praise Chinese people can give for desserts--not sweet--and it truly tastes like green tea, not matcha. The refreshing bitterness was incredibly pure, even bordering on slightly bitter, which is extremely rare in the US. Vanilla Peanut Butter: Very milky, but extremely salty, like eating peanut butter spread on bread. The vanilla flavor was almost completely masked. Coconut & Cream: I've always trusted American coconut ice cream, but this time it was a bit of a disappointment. The cream completely overshadowed the coconut, so much so that it took me a long time to recall what flavor I actually ordered. Ube: One bite brought back childhood memories, exactly the same as the ube flavor Wuyang五羊 ice cream cone. It was so touching I didn't order this in the end since I want to try more flavors as possible. I don't know why, but ube flavor seems to be gradually fading in China... Blueberry Cheesecake: The initial taste was a rich, sweet cream, with a refreshing hint of blueberry tartness in the aftertaste. It's pretty good, but honestly, it's not particularly outstanding. Banana Peanut Butter Chunk: The staff recommended this signature dish, and it once again made me realize how subjective taste can be... It's on the sweeter and saltier side, with a very strong flavor, but more importantly, it has a noticeable artificial banana flavor.

    I'm already planning my next visit...YUM! First time here and it did not disappoint! I'm so glad I…read morefound yummy homemade ice cream at a family owned spot. There's so many yummy flavors - it's hard to choose! I ultimately went with the rocky road (my classic favorite) and the cheesecake with rainbow sprinkles (because why not!?) and enjoyed every bite! I think the rocky road could've used more marshmallows but that's my personal preference for my favorite childhood fave ice cream. Service was great and allow you to try a couple flavors if you're unsure which is great as not all ice cream spots makes the flavors the same! It's only street parking so get ready to search for that when you come to visit - but it's worth it! And read street signs so you don't get towed or ticketed.

    Photos
    Dulce de leche - Abocado gelatto
    Dulce de leche - Abocado gelatto
    Indoor area
    Indoor area
    2 Scoops of Black Sesame & Ube in a Fresh Baked Waffle Cone

    See all

    2 Scoops of Black Sesame & Ube in a Fresh Baked Waffle Cone
    Dulce de Leche Bakery

    Dulce de Leche Bakery

    4.5
    (396 reviews)
    3.1 km
    $

    The cake here is very good! Super moist, and the frosting is light and fluffy when ordered fresh…read more Unfortunately the 2 cupcakes I got, both alfajores and the chocolate covered one too were stale, like super hard and dry. So get anything fresh, like made to order cakes or things you see come out right when you're there. Otherwise you run the risk of getting old stuff, which sucks that they don't manage that at all. On a Sunday afternoon lines moved quickly and we were able to find seats. This is a cute cafe that offers plenty of savory items and lunches, plus drinks like matcha, cakes, pastries and cookies. There is also a bathroom! The women behind the counter were all nice and patient with my questions, they also kept the line moving and were quick. I had high hopes for the Alfajores as this is an Argentinian bakery but unfortunately the ones given to me were stale. The cookie was very hard. Also the Dulce de leche was too sweet and burnt tasting to me. I also got a chocolate covered one and the cookie in that was also hard and dry. The strawberry croissant was amazing. Never had anything like that before. Not too sweet and very flaky. It has a ribbon of red on the outside which gives it a unique look. I would love to come back and try savory items. I'll continue to stick with the cakes and croissants for desert and make sure it's fresh!

    DDL is elite. They have it all. Fantastic pastries, cakes and sandwiches. Great coffees. Spacious,…read moreclean and cozy seating. Friendly and helpful staff. Super affordable prices. I've never eaten anything that I didn't like. My faves are: milhojas, breakfast croissant sandwich, and any and every cake with dulce de leche filling. I only tiny, minuscule complaint I have about this place is the lack of signage for the pastries and cakes. It would be nice to know what I'm looking at without having the ask. Absolutely zero gatekeeping here. Please everyone keep patronizing this establishment. I need this place to continue to exist in my hood.

    Photos
    Tres Leches Slice (~$6)
    Tres Leches Slice (~$6)
    Chocolate Layer
    Chocolate Layer
    Inside

    See all

    Inside
    Rui Tea

    Rui Tea

    4.5
    (112 reviews)
    0.7 km

    Peach season is back and so is my favorite peach drink…read more The Peach Cheese was full of big, juicy peach pieces. You can really taste the difference when drinks are made with fresh fruit. The Pineapple Bobo with coconut milk was another good one. Pineapple and boba worked surprisingly well together. Black Grape Cheese is still my go-to. I always get it with no sugar and it's honestly not sweet at all. Mango Sago is my husband's favorite. Even with no added sugar, it's still naturally sweet because the mango is so ripe. For fresh fruit tea in JC, this is still my favorite spot. Get the seasonal fruit drinks while they're available. And you might get lucky and see the cute guy working behind the counter.

    more like a 3.5 out of 5 stars. i was in town for a business trip, and this place wasn't too far…read morefrom my hotel. I walked here about 30 mins before closing, and it was empty. Heads up, this place is extremely small, i don't even recall any area inside to sit. Think all orders here are for to go. When i arrived, i order via a kiosk and the person making the drink was able to make it fairly quickly. ended up getting a mango sago drink. most boba places i go to now, i typically order a version of a mango sago drink. guess i'm in my mango era. overall, decent place to get your milk tea / boba drink.

    Photos
    Pineapple Bobo (Coco) (New) 菠萝啵啵椰(当季新品)
    Pineapple Bobo (Coco) (New) 菠萝啵啵椰(当季新品)
    Coconut Mango. 4 stars. Insta/Beli: @amei_eats
    Coconut Mango. 4 stars. Insta/Beli: @amei_eats
    Inside

    See all

    Inside

    Shortbread Society - desserts - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...