I wasn't looking for transcendence. I was just looking for lunch. I had just escaped ShopRite with my provisions and remarkably my sanity when a craving for a cheesesteak announced itself like an inconvenient truth. There I was, standing near a place called Slice of Brooklyn, which sounds like a promise about pizza, not about beef. But geography, as always, won. The door handles were spoons. Not metaphors. Actual spoons. A relic from a frozen yogurt past that refuses to die. Inside, the decor felt like a dream someone had after eating too much tiramisu. Dresses on walls. The nose of a Vespa. A cheerful sign that said Ciao as if it were purchased from a Bed, Bath & Beyond in some Venetian suburb. Teacups and playing cards dangled from plastic greenery that had never known sunlight. I accepted all of this. A young man took my order. Efficient. Unmoved by the universe. He said fifteen minutes. It was ten. A small victory for truth. Under promise, over deliver. At home, I opened the box and found abundance. Meat, peppers, onions, mushrooms. No restraint, and all high quality. A quiet miracle of sharp provolone had appeared without being summoned. It was fresh and it was right, and it provided an Instagram worthy cheese pull if only I were into such things. The bread held its dignity. Toasted properly. No collapse, no tragedy. Was it the best cheesesteak in the area. No. There are specialists for that sort of thing. But it was better than it had any right to be. Better than many places that try harder and achieve less. Four stars. Not because it changed my life. Because it did not disappoint it. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

Wanted lunch, but chose sides. The atmosphere is themed, "Alice in Wonderland." I must say there is so much to look at while waiting for our food. Ben, our waiter was there and as usual put a smile on our faces. We chose, Calamari, Bruschetta, a side salad, a bowl of Pasta Fasul and a slice of pizza. We also bought Mocktails, which I had the Strawberry Shirley for the first time and was very good. After eating decided to walk it off. After ordering all that food, it was under 70 bucks for two people. Not bad at all. Can't wait to go home for a little nap! Thanks again Slice of Brooklyn, you never disappoint. Ciao. read more

See all

Strip mall pizza &pasta with outdoor seating. There is table service if u want to be seated. Nice decor comfortable and clean. 2 plain slices that were a good size. First impression was cheese! It didn't disappoint cheesy slice so expect some grease. Crust was thin but not as crisp as I like. I didn't expect that since it has the wood fire oven. The sauce was fine. Nothing stood out in the sauce. No fountain drinks you grab whatever is in the fridge. I like my drink on ice. What was unique is the dessert bar. It has coffee drinks and desserts to choose. Adds to the atmosphere and experience. I would try one night to go out for coffee and dessert. I like the atmosphere but the pizza was just good. Not enough for me to say this is my place for takeout. Do like it for dining in. read more

See all

Slice of Brooklyn used to be our go-to take out pizza/Italian food in Hamilton. But their quality and service has degraded. On our most recent order I arrived at the time my order said it would be ready and still had to wait an additional half an hour for the pizza meanwhile the entrees I ordered became cold since they handed them to me 30 minutes before the pizza was ready. When I pointed out the entrees were now cold I was told I should microwave them when I get home... People that walked in after me and ordered in-person received their pizzas before me even though I had placed my order online. After 45 minutes from the time I had ordered, the pizza was finally ready but when I got home we discovered the dough was uncooked and inedible. I don't understand how after 45 minutes the pizza was not fully cooked. I called them up and they said they'd credit me for the pizza but it's been two weeks and I was still not credited for the pizza that went in the trash can. Very dissapointing. We will be sticking with Marcello's Pizza Grill from now on. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Large pizza is only 15" - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

I have ordered a few different "pizzettes" all of them have been stellar. The hot honey is my favorite! I had another with ricotta and sausage which was also SO good. The nutella stromboli is delicious also! All of these things are way bigger than single person sized! Personally, I could definitely share the pizzette, it is loaded with flavor and toppings so halfway through I am usually done. I have only been inside for pickup and I have no complaints! read more

Not sure what the story is at Slice of Brooklyn. Smells great walking in, and the visuals are stimulating with front of house pasta making area, circulating gelato table and attractive pizza display separating customers from kitchen. Yet, there were no Italians running the show, and no hairnets and spotty glove use by the staff. Friendly they were, and helpful. I was there for takeout, although the dining room looked inviting. I ordered an eggplant parm sandwich which came with fries. It was ready about 15 minutes later, packed into a cardboard recyclable box and white paper bag for ease of transport. It had a pleasing heft to it as I carried it to my car. Opening it on the kitchen table about 20 minutes later, I beheld a large foot long plain roll stuffed with thin layers of eggplant with a heavy red sauce covering over a layer of melted parmigiana. Looked great. Had to squeeze the end of the cut sandwich together to get a corner of it into my mouth. First bite was promising. The sauce was thick with good flavor. The melanzone was lightly floured and plentiful. It's taste was of American eggplant; not overly flavorful, but satisfying. Not much cheese in comparison to the nightshade component, but that was okay. The roll while large, had little taste and was soft rather than offering any crunchy texture along its ridgeline. The fries were generically generous, but not worth the caloric intake. Slice of Brooklyn has promise, but aside from the store atmospherics it really needs to up its game in the bread and quality control departments if it wants to be true to its namesake hometown. read more

See all

Slice of Brooklyn looks, sounds and smells like you're glad you live in the pizza capitol of the world. The place oozes authenticity. However, the atmospheric foreplay ends there. An absolutely brilliant looking Sicilian pie reveals an absolutely underwhelming taste... not bad but not exactly the supermodel I was expecting. I suspect I'll have to settle for the girl next door. Three very plain Jane stars. read more

Just found out about this place and was anxious to try it out since I love pizza growing up in New York. Reviews and pictures were a little concerning because I hate well done (burnt) pizza and some people said theirs was not cooked all the way through. Thankfully that was not the case when my friend and I went. Tthe two pies we got were cooked perfectly and delicious. We had meatballs on half and sausage on half. The pizza sauce was flavorful the dough was a nice New York style and you can see the glistening on the top of it. Not sure if the add olive oil at the end but delicious. Definitely worth the effort to go and try out will definitely go back again. Ivan the manager came out to talk to us afterwards because we had a lot of questions before we ordered at the counter, very friendly guy. read more

See all

The urge to try out a new pizza place led me Slice of Brooklyn. They are apparently an offshoot of Marcello's in Bordentown, which I've been meaning to try out as I've heard good things. We got the house made garlic bread (2.5/5) to start off. It was definitely a unique preparation, so I'll give them credit for trying something different, but it was not something I'd recommend. It was really greasy & extremely heavy, and not in a good way. The garlic aspect of it was ok, but the the bread was unmemorable & slightly over cooked, and along with all the grease, it made us not want any more after trying it. I couldn't make out all the different styles of pizza on the menu. The Big Ben (2.5/5), which was described as a hand-stretched thick Sicilian pizza with cheese blend, sauce, parmagiano, basil, & olive oil jumped out at me, so I ordered it despite the price tag of $25. I thought it'd be something unique worth the extra cost. Sadly, the taste was not all that good. The tomato sauce was probably the best part of the pizza with cheese being merely average and dough unremarkable. Perhaps wood-fired pizza just isn't my thing. I honestly wouldn't order either of these 2 items again if I were to return. There's too many good Italian eateries & pizzerias in the Hamilton area, so probably won't be back at Slice of Brooklyn, but will stick to something simpler like a standard plain pizza and garlic knots if I were to get food from there again, or perhaps one of their sandwiches. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - House Made Garlic Bread - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

I ordered a Sicilian from here for the first time and It was so good I actually called the place to thank them .. also 22 weeks pregnant so almost nothing even taste good and this was by far the best Sicilian I have ever ate in my life living in New Jersey & my family agreed .. the pizza was super cost effective as well and fed my family of 4 with plenty left over! (Side note, as an Italian I'm very much particular of sauce & the sauce on this pie was actually amazing and they don't skimp at all .. you could actually taste the "homemade" in it .. super impressed! Great customer service as well! Highly recommend! read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

Great food, the ziti was nicely cooked and the "cruisin the strip" pizza was fantastic. Quick service, nice appearance. Will def be back read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Cruisin' Da Strip - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

This is my go to spot for pizza. Their garlic knots are also off the chain. I recently learned that they also make their own Gelato and pasta! I love lemon ice from Rita's Ice, but they haven't had any lately so I was happy to see Lemon Gelato and just had to sample it. I ended up purchasing a cup to go because it was so good. From now on I will be getting my Lemon Ice fix from here. On my next trip I plan to check out their Homemade pasta dishes. Last time I had Homemade pasta I was in Italy so I look forward to checking it out and will update my review once I get a taste. read more

See all

IF YOUR PLAIN PIZZA ISNT anything but amazing you already know everything is going to be gross. tried it 2times. never again.before got the grandma pie. so garlicky & soggy. the got a plain slice had absolutely no taste. & was nasty. i never like to put a business down but come on at least get a plain slice right. read more

Ordered take out tonight. Decided to go for the Southwest salad and an old fashioned Brooklyn square Pizza. Salad was decent. Lots of spinach. Good amount of avocado. The cilantro lime vinaigrette didn't have a lot of flavor. Was mostly just olive oil. The pizza was very good. The only thing is when you get to the middle slices and there's no crust. Lol. But nice and thin. The sauce and cheese ratio or very good. Would definitely like to try other types of pizza, as well as the wings. read more

Was disappointed tried to order their periogie pizza. The girl told me I couldnt, its only when they make it for slices. I asked are you sure its on the menu and last week i was told i could order a personal periogie pizzas she said no you can't. So I picked somethining else went there to pick up my order asked her when it will be back and showed her where it was in menu. She said yeah we do have it i was having a problem with my system... i think she might of been new, but why would she not ask anyone and just tell me no especially after I told her it was on the menu and are you sure... kind of rubbed me the wrong way since we order from there alot. Very disapointed really was looking forward to it. read more

Menu looks pretty good. They have many different options to choose from. I ordered the pesto caprese panini. The food was ready really quick, so this is great for convenience. The bread was very fresh, the chicken and and all the toppings were also fresh and tasty. It came with some french fries which had the perfect amount of crunch. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Chicken pesto caprese panini - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

I pretty damn close to being a fan. And I'll definitely be back to sample more items. Even though the young gentleman who got my takeout order ready told me this is not a chain, the menu reveals that they are affiliated with Marcello's of Bordentown. I wasn't really in the mood for a whole pie, although some sound very interesting( that's you pirogi pie..;)) luckily some are available as slices. I was in the mood for a steak sandwich, and also ordered a side dish of meatballs. I find them a useful gauge when testing the waters. Once inside I added on a slice of the grandma pie for another time. The slice case looked great, many options for just grabbing a quick bite. The other case contained sliders that were made with large garlic knots. They looked amazing and are priced at 3 for $15. Dried homemade pastas and takeout sauces are also on display. My car smelled great riding home and I couldn't wait to dive in. My enthusiasm was slightly dampened when I opened the box to find a very small specimen. This was half of the size of my fav local shop, which is ironically close by. In my confusion and slight disappointment I didn't get a photo. I also should have measured, I'd say it was 7 inches at most. But on the plus side, it was very good. Great homemade and crusty bread, tender steak, and nicely cooked peppers and onions. If the meat had been filled to capacity I may have been less critical, but it was not. I'd really like to get this again, but at $13 and nothing else included, this was too expensive. The meatballs were better priced at 3 for $8 with good sauce included. I really like them and had for another meal. I'd get again. The slice was good too, very good crust and same sauce as balls. For a whole pie I might go with a Trenton style tomato pie or one of the unique ones. The interior is fast casual, probably not a place to BYOB but I'm sure it's allowed. They've only been open a few weeks and their grand opening is this weekend I think. I hope the size of the sandwich was a glitch, and that customer service gets a bit friendlier. Food wise I'm pretty much a fan, but pricing and attitudes need a little work perhaps. 3.5 Yelps read more

See all

We were visiting my brother in hamilton twp. And he told us about this great pizza place. So we went and being originally from Brooklyn, slice of pizza represents Brooklyn very well. Probably the best have had since we've been in Jersey. Thank you guys. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Slice if Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

"The pizza is amazing, and the customer service is top-notch. The ambiance and cleanliness both get a perfect 10 out of 10."

First tried them in May 2022 and it instantly became our family go-to for Friday pizza and wings. We've literally ordered 10 pies in one day for a party at all times of the day and all were perfect. However, since 2023, we've ordered every Friday with increasing disappointment each time. Pizzas come burnt, along with overcooked garlic knots. Wings are over cooked and don't come with much sauce (honey sriracha). Food is too expensive to be bad. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Overcooked - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

They just opened up and everything was delicious. I don't think the location does this place justice. We got an Old Fashioned Brooklyn pie (square) and it was great. Crust, sauce, and cheese were on point. Also had the Chicken Parmesan sub which was flavorful. The staff was great and gave us an extra cannoli! They also make there own pasta in house which is a plus. I definitely recommend trying this place out. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Slice of Brooklyn Old Fashioned Pizza (square) - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

This is my 500th review, and I'm excited that I'm writing it for a restaurant that I really enjoyed! I got the Hot Honey pizette (personal pizza) delivered to my home, and even after being partially exposed to the elements on the drive over here, it was still delicious. Crust was great, sauce was very tasty, and all of the toppings hit the spot. I'm excited to come here in person to sample more food! read more

Stopped in on a whim and very glad I did. The options were incredible from traditional to Chicago style plus sliders and desserts. The staff is incredibly helpful and professional along with Friendly. The only slight negative are the prices are on the higher side but you get what you pay for. Will definitely be returning. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Buffalo Chicken Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

We frequent Slice often and the food is never anything less than spectacular. From the salads, to the sandwiches, pasta and pizza ...all of it...fantastic. We also love that you can order your fave pie in a personal size. Today we grabbed the square Brooklyn pie and holy sh@t! We didn't want it to end it was that good. Service is always first class, shout out to our fave counter worker who rocks that epic fro! They are quick to serve and are responsive to your questions. If you aren't sure what to do for dinner tonight, go here! You will not be disappointed. read more

The pizza is good, the paninis are fine, the fries mediocre, and the desserts junk. Seriously, I paid $8 for a strawberry shortcake and got a container with 80% low quality cream with a bit of strawberries and a tiny bit of soggy cake. That's a rip off, and I threw half of it in the trash. The "cheesecake" doesn't look much better. Real shame, I was excited to finally find a pizza place with good dessert options. read more

The food is great. Love the pick a pasta and sauce deal. Only negative is that its very hot in there in the summer

MORE LIKE A SLICE OF FINGER NAIL!!!! I couldn't be hungrier after working on a hot humid typical summer new jersey day. It's late afternoon As I'm sitting out back poolside of our luxurious new jersey estate and my beautiful wife surprises me with two slices from A SLICE OF BROOKLYN. In a frenzy having to go to the bathroom "soooo bad" that she had to go into this establishment to use their facilities and then felt obligated after relieving the horrific urge she purchased two slices of the brooklyn and cuban slices. My first bite into my soggy, limp, disgusting Brooklyn slice that I didn't even care of the appearance because I was so hungry I'd eat a leather shoe I started gauging as something sharp got lodged into the back of my esophagus. I regurgitated the greasy bite of the brooklyn slice into my 1,000 thread count serviette and once upon further inspection I realized it was a FINGER NAIL THAT WAS CHEWED OFF AND IN MY SLICE!!!!!! Now all jokes aside because I'm a joking they, I am furious!!! OK seriously now, A SLICE OF BROOKLYN I realized that you the owners have nothing to do with this disgusting situation I only hope the finger nail culprit is reprimanded. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - A SLICE OF THE COOKS FINGER NAIL! - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

Good pizza, not amazed by it. However I believe that counter guy should wear a hair net or a hat. Long hair should not be allowed behind the register without a covering. read more

Little place with a ton of flavor. Pizza was cooked to absolute perfection. Tons of varieties to choose from as well as sandwiches. I will definitely be returning here and you should 100% visit and see it for yourself read more

I feel the need to add to this after enjoying another quality dinner at slice. They now serve empanadas which are beyond incredible. The service is spectacular and you always feel so welcomed when coming in to eat! read more

My kids wanted to try this new place and we ordered pizza, pasta and salad for pick up. We were disappointed, the salad was placed inside the bag together with the pasta so the warmth of the pasta made the salad green soggy. The pizza was burned. Pasta is good but they can improve their marinara sauce because it taste like it came from the can and just got heated up. They have a lot of room for improvement. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Burned pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

See all

So I went back and ordered some fresh slices... it was so delicious. My 1 year old would not put the pizza down. Fresh homemade sauce. The (I think it was sicilian or deep dish) crust was buttery and crispy. Everything was delicious and the stuff is super friendly. I'll definitely be back read more

Ordered on 9/24/21- Was meh. Ordered the Sicilian with extra cheese & pepperoni. No extra cheese on the pie. Pepperoni was better than most places as they use the discs. Too many items on the menu- do a few items & do it well js. I'm not sure why 2 Hamilton police officers were outside as if working security lol- waste of taxpayer funds. I would not order again. read more

Came here the other day and I have to say, it's phenomenal. Upset to see the low ratings, but once I read them, I verified they aren't valid at all. To the person complaining about having a warm salad, good. That's what happens when you order salad from a pizzeria. To the one complaining about Hamilton cops being outside is a waste of tax payer money, they human. They're allowed to eat and take breaks. 5 stars across the board here. read more

I am from Brooklyn. The food was like eating cold left overs. Massimos is always fresh. Never ever would i eat waste my money at this place. read more

I put an online order in at 11:30 for a 6pm pick up for a Brooklyn pie with mushrooms and extra cheese. Some slices have no cheese. For the $2 upgrade, please give me what I ordered. read more

Slice of Brooklyn Wood Fired Pizza & House Made Pasta - Extra cheese?? - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton Square, New Jersey

Have been here twice - once for dine in and once for takeout. Both were great experiences. Everything is really fresh and tasty. We have had the pasta, pizza, sandwiches, salads, and apps and honestly all were fantastic. The Old Fashion Brooklyn Square pizza was the best I've had around and this area makes some great Brooklyn pies so that is saying something! When we dined in the service was very polite, efficient, appreciative and they even gave us free dessert samples which were incredible too! Definitely give it a shot - we will definitely be back - we want to make sure they stick around!!! read more

Excellent food .Customer service incredible. When. I received wrong food they delivered it to me 20 minutes away and added extra goodies to my dinner read more

We ordered takeout and they got our order completely wrong. We called them up and the person we spoke to had a really bad attitude, tried blaming us for the mistake, but eventually agreed to redo the order, which when it arrived was literally tossed at us by the delivery driver, the pizzas were burnt around the edges and cold, so they went in the trash. Such a shame as we really loved this place, never had an issue before, will never go back there again now, luckily we have plenty of other great pizza places in the area. read more

I was excited to check out this pizza shop when it first opened. I love a good wood fired pie. Hubby and I ordered on two different occasions pizza. I couldn't have been more disappointed. It was not at all delicious. My issue with the pies was that it had Parmesan cheese on it. My fault for not noticing this on their menu. No pizza from any other local pizza store has Parmesan cheese on it. Armed with this knowledge the next time we ordered pizza we had them hold the Parmesan, but even then, the pizza was not good read more