Atmosphere and service were decent, as we were greeted by the manager who asked us to let them know if anything was not to our liking. Sadly, the pasta primavera and the Admirals platter both failed to impress. The fried food was quite dark due to cooking in well used oil, and the pasta lacked flavor and was limp. I generally like most restaurants I go to, but must say, I do not recommend Smith's Boathouse. read more

So a group of us decided to try the Boathouse this evening after hearing wonderful things. I have to say we were not disappointed! The staff was friendly and very helpful. We met the owner when he stopped by our table to check on us and most importantly the food was amazing!! The fish and chips was perfectly cooked. Crispy and not a hint of grease. The scallops were amazing with the bacon marmalade and ginger sauce. If you're a fan of Salmon you won't be sad it was cooked wonderfully and the Chicken Oscar was super. Portion size was perfect, the house white French dressing is unique and the clam chowder is awesome. We even had room for dessert. We got a variety at the table so we could all taste. The Highlander Grog cake, white chocolate raspberry cheesecake, and cherry creame brûlée were all the perfect ending. You don't want to miss this local treasure. read more

We were visiting family in Troy. What a surprise to find this nice restaurant in this small town. I had the scallops and would definitely order them again. My husband ordered the fish and chips and they were crispy and not greasy - he loved it. Our companions ordered the shrimp scampi and the ribeye (with blue cheese) - both really liked their meals. Service was excellent - would recommend you asking for Damion when you visit. read more

Smiths' Boathouse Restaurant - American Near Me - Troy, Ohio

Our meal and service were both incredible! My husband had steak with scallops and I had the salmon with broccoli and a baked potato. Both were perfect! Our server Lori was awesome. On the pricey side but worth it for our anniversary dinner! read more

Excellent menu. The salmon is delicious as well as the scallops. Locally owned which is always a win. The view outside is fantastic!

I was so excited to try this place, but we were rather disappointed. Pros: Beautiful location & the decor inside was really nicely done. The owner came around and introduced himself, which was a nice touch. Cons: 1. They were disorganized & couldn't find our reservation. 2. The menu, plating style, captain's outfit, & music were terribly outdated and like walking back in time. We joked that we felt like we were on an old episode of the Love Boat. Menu items included things like beer cheese fondue, stuffed mushrooms, items prepared Oscar style, rice pilaf, & asparagus with hollandaise sauce. Just things you saw on menus 20+ years ago. 3. Server was not knowledgeable about menu or food preparations, but they are all new, so I can let that go. 4. We ordered scallops & salmon. The food was okay, but not great. Salmon & asparagus were overcooked. Scallops were okay. The bacon jam was the highlight of the evening. In short, if you really miss old throw-back menu items and are okay with average food, you'll like this place. It is such a beautiful location, so I really hope they work to modernize the menu & perhaps hire a better chef. read more

We went for the first time last weekend and we're going back! Great food and service on a crowded evening. We loved the large selection of drinks and the wine list was large. I will get the Caesar salad table side next time we go. read more

A very nice restaurant. If you like seafood then this place has it. Service is great and the employees are very knowledgeable. The entire place has been remodeled along with the entire outside surrounding area. Prices range but overall it is pricey. Nice place for a quiet dinner with that special someone. read more

I would absolutely love to tell my fellow Yelpers about my dining experience at the Boathouse, but I never actually got far enough in it to actually eat. We made an 8 o'clock reservation, but after a few minutes we went ahead and called to move that up to 7:30. At this point it was 6:30. A gentleman possibly named named Aaron(?) told us it shouldn't be a problem... Well, apparently it was. We arrived at 7:15 for our reservation and proceeded to wait... and wait... and wait. We watched other people get huffy over their 45+ minute waits and thought "why bother taking reservations if you can't fulfill them in a timely manner?" I still have no answer here. After waiting over a half hour for our drinks due to a computer problem, we then waited over 45 for our table. Finally, after the small "waiting corral" was empty of all other hungry guests besides us, we finally asked a THIRD time about how long it was going to be. We were greeted with the news that we would be seated for our 8 o'clock reservation shortly. Brakes screeched, records skipped, and we explained that we in fact had a 7:30 reservation, supposedly changed... at that point enough was enough and we did not stay, but went down to La Fiesta and had a wonderful meal right away. So, here's my advice to the Boathouse: 1. don't bother with reservations if you aren't going to bother to keep accurate track of them or make them affect the wait. We were absolutely not the only people who had to wait a ridiculous amount of time for our "reservation". 2. Don't tell people who ask you how long that "it will be just a few minutes" or "we're cleaning you a table right now" because we were told both even though we were apparently there at the wrong time for our reservation. 3. If you plan to go to the Boathouse, pack a snack for the wait (unless you know some guy there named Larry because as we witnessed, that will get you in right away). read more

Smiths' Boathouse Restaurant - American Near Me - Troy, Ohio

It's such a nice atmosphere and the service was great. They take care of you from beginning to end. The salad and the ribeye were terrific. Pro tip: get the potatoes. What a treasure in Troy. Will be back read more

OMG THIS IS THE BEST FOOD EVER!!! We had the brunch. Friendly staff. They definately deserve 5 stars.

I love Smith's Boathouse! The beer cheese appetizer and the French onion soup are two of my favorites. But the absolute best is the table side Caesar. It is amazing and we would literally come back just for it! read more

I absolutely love this restaurant. I had the New York strip and it was very good. The atmosphere, owners and staff were wonderful. We had the beer cheese and really liked it. We are so happy to have Smiths Boathouse in Troy! read more

Lovely setting, fantastic brunch, and nice menu options. We've enjoyed going there for date night or with the family!

With the weather that day being absolutely beautiful, I made sure to make reservations. Dinner on the patio was more than awesome. We had several items on the appetizer list. The French onion soup, shrimp cocktail, mussels, shared by hubby and myself, followed up by the most beautiful cheesecake I've seen! Take the time, make a reservation, and make sure to say hello to Larry the owner. read more

Fabulous meal. As a patron with a culinary background I must say Smith's Boathouse always delivers. The entrees are well prepared, delicious, and presented with style. The special I enjoyed tonight was indeed special...a panko-encrusted walleye accompanied by perfect sides. I encourage everyone to try this homegrown, hospitable and upscale restaurant, of which Troy is so proud. JHR, Troy read more

Incredible view, service and food. Smiling friendly service all the way through. Highly recommended. You will nkt be disappointed!

Best seafood around! Great atmosphere and the service was second to none! Highly recommend Smiths Boathouse.

Amazing service! Food is expensive but worth every penny. Best quality of food I have had. Try the homemade house salad dressing. Very unique dressing :) read more

The bus boy. I believe his name started with an A. Was very rude and I think mentally handicapped. He wouldn't stop sucking on crayons and sniffing his fingers. 10/10 would go back! read more

Wife loved her scallops but I ordered a hamburger and specified that wanted it a little bit pink It was the worst burger that I have ever received in a restaurant. Totally overcooked. Make sure you stick to high end stuff. Bit expensive for what we received. read more

Took an hour before we got our first drink. Almost 2 hours before we got food. Salmon was overcooked and dry. . Scallops were undercooked. Servers were fantastic. read more

Loved the water view and outdoor dining option. Inside was very noisy for dinner and a drunk loud bar patron and his equally drunk and loud wife kept wandering into the dining area disrupting the patrons who were there for a dining experience. Felt the management should have addressed this as it was obviously disruptive to those who were there to eat without having Otis the town drunk and his wife standing in the middle of the room guffawing. The service was average. No offers for beverage refills - had to ask. Also, our server forgot to bring the cole slaw that came with my fish and chips. The fries were very good but the fish breading tasted bland. Shrimp cocktail was good. The others at my table were very pleased with the scallops and their sides. The desserts were disappointing - they looked amazing but tasted stale and our cake was dry. One in my party ordered a medium rare steak that was cooked medium. I was disappointed since I expected more for the prices. read more

Brought our family of 6. Everything was excellent from the appetizers to the desert. Good sized portions and good presentation. The owner stopped by to introduce himself and check how everything was. Very personable. We will definitely be paying them another visit soon! read more

The food was amazing. We brought our teenagers here while visiting Ohio and surprised by how everyone's food was delicious. From the calamari (crispy flavorful breading), to the special grilled swordfish with potatoes au gratin (thin sliced layers in creamy sauce and crisp crust). Recommend the water lily to drink and beer cheese appetizer plus table made Ceasar salad. read more

Poor service. Ticket "was lost" and had an extremely long wait from salad course to entrees. My husband's side was cold and the risotto side I ordered was served after the entrees since it was not ready yet. Risotto was under cooked when it did arrive. The owner came and sat with us to say he was sorry for the long wait time and asked if our food was good. When I mentioned that the risotto was under cooked he said thank you and got up and walked away. We were disappointed with the food but the way Mr. Smith treated us ruined our entire evening. read more

The quality of the food is only out shined by the customer service. The owner is hands on and ever present...hint order the Caesar salad! We highly recommend this restaurant to all. read more

Nice restaurant near the Miami River in Troy. The table side Caesar salad was great along with the steak that was cooked to perfection.

In an attempt to take my mother out for a nice dinner on Christmas Eve, I called to make a reservation. She's in a wheelchair and I wanted to make sure we could get a table. Not only was I told that they weren't taking reservations, but they also didn't have anything easily accessible for a wheelchair. Sorry for my inconvenience. Is this even legal? read more

Phenomenal. We were both extremely happy with our meal, the atmosphere and our server. Great local option for seafood and steak/prime rib, especially on a date night for parents with young ones or anyone looking for a nice place that has more character than a chain restaurant. Would definitely recommend! read more

Went for Sunday Brunch with a large party. Brunch buffet was average at best. Would not recommend, there's a Big Boy down the road. Save time and money. Pro Cheap mimosas Quickly refilled buffet Omelette station Buttermilk fried chicken!! Con Omelette station had kale, but no ham. I can't be the only person to eat a ham and cheese omelette, can I ? Seems like quite a bit of the items are not made from scratch. Logistics were horrible, buffet tucked into a small corner room, thus not giving servers room to refill steam tables without elbowing between customers. Buffet line stretched down a side hall blocking bathroom access. Many items on buffet out regularly. Priced as high end with white tablecloths, but staff who expect you to move out of their way while walking between tables. They automatically add an 18% tip for parties of 6 or more. Maybe they warn when you make reservations? But I didn't make them, another person in our party did!! Dessert offerings very sub-par. Perhaps thawed? read more

Service was deplorable, both with the hostess, or lack of one, We had a reservation. Second, while waiting at the bar, bartender right in front of me ignored me while waiting on others and finally the lady next to me when her drink was delivered took pity on me and said the bartender, "this lady would like a drink also". I had waited 20 minutes while the bartender took care of other walk up customers. He obliged reluctantly and then when time to pay I had to ask firmly to pay for the drink. NOTE: the bar only seated6 people. Very small space. Food was okay, nothing great. Table side service equally deplorable. Server friendly. But the service for a table of 4 was not good at all. Items missed on the order, delay in bringing the wine ....very poor service. Our tab over $300.00 and we won't be going back. read more

Love the atmosphere. Views of the river and interior decor. It was my birthday and I ordered a steak, cheesy potatoes and asparagus. Sides were very good. Steak tasted old and spoiled. I could not eat it. Did not complain since my friend paid for it. I wish I would have said something. The bread was too dry. They should offer some meals that are less expensive. I will try them one more time before I write my review for a magazine. read more

3.5 stars. Dessert menu lacking and not freshly made on site. Food was good but for the cost the atmosphere was not to scale. Something about dropping a hundo for dinner and sitting next to Bubba in his Nascar shirt just didn't do it for me. read more

It was my moms birthday. We wanted someplace different that we hadn't been to, a new experience. There were 6 of us total. The two tables put together was cramped and we were elbow to elbow. I got shrimp cocktail, which was good. Four of us ordered filet mignon, medium, with baked potatoes. Every filet came slightly charred on the outside, barely, if at all, pink on the inside. In other words, pretty much well done. The waitress apologized and took our plates back, so we then had to wait, again, for our meals. Our steaks came back out, medium done. Good right? Wrong. They brought our steaks back out WITHOUT the baked potatoes. We ran out of baked potatoes said the waitress. What happened to the baked potatoes that were on our plates, we asked? We threw them away! So, no baked potatoes on a weekday, around 6pm. We were offered au gratin potatoes. They were HORRIBLE, inedible. So, yep, filet mignon, by itself! Yummy. The guy who brought out our cake did not improve the situation any. He was not friendly, and barely offered a smile. He acted like it was a bother to cut the cake. Trust me bud, we didn't request your presence. We get our bills and nothing was taken off nor did we request anything taken off. We will never go back of course, nor would any of us recommend this place. It was a shockingly bad dining experience and the only thing that made it momentarily better was the delicious birthday cake from THE CAKERY. read more

First...food was great. Everyone in our party of six loved their salad, entree, and dessert. BUT they need to resolve the reservation issues. There were three parties ahead of us who did NOT have reservations. We did. We were given the option of being seated right away or waiting ???????? We asked to be seated and we STILL had to wait for the three parties without reservations to be seated. It was all so badly done. I made the reservation in my name. The owner, Larry, came over and shook my husband's hand and was just too too jovial with him and never even spoke to me or acknowledged me in any way. Very off-putting behavior. The waitress was beyond bad. She messed up the drink orders, the salads, the entrees, the desserts, and, as you can probably guess, the checks. Plus she REEKED of cigarette smoke. read more

I'm a New England native born transplant to Southern California. Came to Ohio for business and wanted to have a nice sit down meal. We waited a few minutes for a table but that usually means food is good and people enjoy the atmosphere, I was right the food was excellent, portions just right so you can enjoy desert as well. I hope I get to come back and enjoy another meal. Larry was a gracious host. read more

We walked into a quaint and warm atmosphere with friendly staff to greet us. The food was created masterfully with attention to detail. Warm rolls were served while we waited for our entree. We had the best fish and chips around; crunchy on the outside, tender and flaky on the inside. Reasonable prices for a very special meal in a special place. The location has a spectacular view of trees, fountains, and riverscape which we enjoyed while we dined. read more

Two of us had supper at Smith's Boathouse a couple nights ago, on a Wednesday. We did not have a reservation, but were seated within a few minutes. Our server was pleasant. We both enjoyed the food, although my companion thought the salmon was just a wee bit dry. We plan on going back to try more of the items on their menu! read more

Excellent food, enjoyed the ambiance and the waiters professional but fun attitude. We will be back.