Finally made it to Frankie & Anthony's during a wing walk and it was a good vibe. The place feels like a classic pizza joint but with a cool sports bar energy (perfect for catching a game). I specifically came to try the Honey BBQ and Mango Habanero wings. The Honey BBQ had that perfect sweet to tangy ratio, and the Mango Habanero actually had a decent kick without being overwhelming. Definitely worth ordering if you're looking for something other than just a slice! Great spot for a chill dinner or late night bite. I'll definitely be back for the rooftop, pizza, and a drink when it's warmer! read more

See all

Great atmosphere, great food with good portions and great prices. Very good staff , friendly and courteous. read more

I usually come here to sit outside to study and have a slice. Is a very cute little pizzeria with amazing views of white plains. The staff are great and the food is even better. We definately need more people to come visit this place. You wont regret it read more

See all

I'm so glad this place is open! I love their pizza and drinks. I've been here a few times and love it! The staff is friendly and helpful. They always have pizza ready to go. And, they have a good variety of rolls, calzones, pizzas, and more! I love their bar and seating area. The indoor seating area is surrounded by windows and is very scenic. They also have an outdoor patio that is very nice as well. I look forward to stopping back in and trying more of their food options. read more

See all

I've been eyeing City Pizzeria since they opened in Downtown White Plains a few months ago. I'm wary of pizza (and Italian food in general) in Westchester, but that usually doesn't stop me from trying it out so I could get an accurate assessment (and possibly find something good). Anyway, I was in the mood for pizza and thought this was a good opportunity to check this place out, so off I went. The space that CP resides in has been a few things since I've lived in White Plains - I think it was an Asian spot, then turned into a seafood restaurant, and now pizza. I've actually never been to any of their predecessors so this was truly a new experience. I opted for takeout - they use a third party app for ordering and after a short while my order was ready. I decided to pick up in lieu of delivery so I got a sense of the interior - it's smaller than I imagined with nothing really outstanding in terms of decor. It looks like they tried a little to make it charming but it didn't come through IMO. So what did I get? While they offer full pies, I got some slices and an order of meatballs in order to get a good sample of what they offered. I decided on their margherita, white, and hot honey pepperoni slides. The fundamental properties of the slices were pretty good - the crust was thin and the cheese-sauce-topping ratio was correct. They were not the most flavorful slices in my opinion, but comparing to other pizza spots I've been to in Westchester I have no complaints. The only thing that made me scratch my head scratch was that they put broccoli on their white slice; when I placed the order it did not indicate that topping. Also FWIW the hot honey slice wasn't hot at all. The meatballs were pretty good - good consistency and the sauce was better than I expected. Service was good, my food was ready by their promised time and the staff was friendly. Overall, this doesn't compare to NYC slices but I thought City Pizzeria put out a solid offering regardless. I wouldn't be against returning next time I'm in the mood for pizza. read more

City Pizzeria - white, margarita, hot honey pepperoni - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

We came across Frankie & Anthony's City Pizzeria while staying in White Plains and heading to Target. We decided to stop in and try it--and I'm so glad we did! We ordered a half ham, half pepperoni pizza, and it was delicious. The thin crust had a great crunch and was full of flavor--exactly what you want in a New York-style slice. The garlic knots, however, were a letdown--they were burnt and not tasty at all. Definitely something that could be improved. The restaurant is nicely decorated and has a cozy vibe. Service was okay--we had to flag someone down even though it wasn't busy, but they were friendly once they came over. Overall, it's a solid spot for pizza. read more

See all

I don't live in NY, but I've concluded that there's just something special about hanging out at a New York pizzeria. City Pizzeria hits that vibe perfectly. I ordered a margherita slice and an Arturo's Special slice, and both were delicious. Sad that I won't be able to come back here regularly, because I want to try everything. Actually, I can't promise that I'm not going to grab a dessert after I post this review... read more

City Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

The place is very nice inside. The service was friendly and quick. And the pizzas were great. Yasmin was great.

Tried City Pizzeria in White Plains and really liked it! The pizza was fresh, with a nice thin crust and just the right amount of crisp. I had a couple slices -- great flavor, good cheese-to-sauce balance, and everything tasted homemade. The staff was friendly, and the place has that relaxed, neighborhood pizzeria vibe. It's a solid spot whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering a pie to share. read more

Had the fried calamari and hot honey pepperoni pizza. Both were great. Calamari was seasoned well - salt and garlic - just right. Pizza was really great. Crust was thin and crispy. Considering the honey and oil from the pepperoni, it stayed crispy and didn't flop when a slice is folded. (The pizza wasn't too oily, just mentioning that typically pepperoni is oily and soaks the crust) read more

See all

Unbelievable perfomance at city pizzeria yet again, sausage and peppers hero was just insane to say the least. Sad Holly couldn't make it, grace was a great server and my New York friend drank my water, flashback to my previous review for those who have been following along. Very tasty atmosphere, the lady at the front who stopped in helped with that along with my former guidance counselor. read more

Great food! Server was so friendly! Pizza was delicious and recommend the fried calamari and clams Oreganata, delish! I will definitely be back! read more

The best Veal Parmesan in the state.... PIZZA is 9 out of 10 Las Vegas style interior, you have to see it to believe it! very unique, comfortable and OUTSTANDING garden for outdoor dining under the stars. Definitely a hidden gem in White Plains. strongly suggest to check out their Instagram. citypizzeriawp read more

See all

We were a group of six dining. Nowhere on the menu or in the restaurant they disclosed that there was a 25% service charge for "larger groups". They also did not disclose at any time a cash discount vs credit card surcharge. They just brought the bill and said the computer added the fees. Just be warned and check you bill carefully. Food was overall average. read more

Don't know how their pizza is ... it's probably good. This ain't about the food but more how their business is ran. I ordered a pie and pizza roll for me and my son and there was a discount that the restaurant was promoting on door dash it took about 3 dollars off lol. I then go back to check on my order and it was canceled. I call to find out why and was told "we don't give discounts"... but yet on door dash they are promoting it. They must be new here cuz it's a million good pizza shops in the area... 3 bucks you cancel my order lol... fuck em. Shit look burnt anyway lol read more

City Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

The pizza was good! Favorite slice, my husband said, was the plain. It was crispy and flavorful. I had a bit of the grandma and a white slice. White slice was very good and grandma was delicious also. There is a nice bar inside and there are booths, tables, and it has a private vibe to it. There is also outdoor seating for a nice weather day. Service was good. I would return! read more

City Pizzeria in White Plains nails authentic Italian vibes and killer service (Ricky!!). Warm, attentive staff, standout apps like those addictive Italian caramelized wings and hearty chicken parm that's crispy, cheesy, and saucy. Fresh, flavorful, generous portions. Loved every bite! Highly recommend! read more

Had the 18" chicken bacon ranch pie. Awesome. Light thin crust with plenty of bacon and chicken atop. The staff is super friendly and very considerate of the guests desires. From Mike the GM to Taylor working the guests and Eric making those delicious pies. Y'all gotta try the cannolis if ya come here. These cannolis are slices of heaven. The filling just melts in one's mouth. read more

City Pizzeria - Promo during football season...must try. - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

During a tech stop the team and I stopped by for some pizza based on Yelp's recommendation. Once again, y'all did not disappoint! The salads were entree sized and very fresh. The 12in pizzas were big enough to provide leftovers with a perfectly oven baked hand-tossed trust with equal parts crunch and chew. I opted for the buffalo chicken pizza and it was firing on all cylinders! Tender chicken chunks, perfect heat from the red hot with just enough blue cheese to be complimentary yet not distracting on the palette. Over all a great meal and looking forward to next time! read more

Some coworkers got together for Pizza Party after work & we chose City Pizza. What a great choice! Good food & attentive service. It was so good I went back a couple of weeks later to enjoy some takeout. Oscar provided great customer service & worked to make sure my order was just liked I wanted. read more

City Pizza is our "Go-To" place for our White Plains Performing Arts pre-show beer and pizza. Service is always the best and you will never go wrong with any item on the menu. read more

Everything was wonderful. We were at the White Plains Performing Arts and looking for a good meal, boy did we get lucky finding City Pizzeria. We were seated quickly, bread was excellent, and pizza ( pepperoni ) was excellent also. Not sure I'll be in the area, but if I am will absolutely stop in. read more

We went on Friday 4-11-25. The food was average. The waiter was good. We were a group of six and when the bill came they added a 25% service fee. This was not disclosed anywhere on the menu and it was a hassle to have it removed. 25% is an extremely high service fee and if a consumer wants to leave that much it should be my choice. We had it removed and still left a tip but found this experience off putting. I'm really not sure we will be back. read more

Went there yesterday to celebrate by son's 11th birthday. It was awesome!! The service was great, we got a table in the main area. We had the pizza, penne vodka, pin wheels, buffalo chicken roll, garlic knots, and their famous meatballs - a real variety of what was on the menu - and all was excellent. One of the owners, AJ, came over to welcome us and make sure everything was going well. That personal touch is rarely found these days. Our server Carlos was super nice, patient with all the kids, and did a great job. We finished it off with singing happy birthday and the home made tiramisu that is 100% worth getting. This was actually our first time here and we are excited to return soon. They even have outdoor seating for when the weather gets better. read more

Pizza was excellent. Thin crispy crust.. sitting outside on a beautiful evening.. top notch service! It's an obscure location .. I hope it lasts! Go get some !! read more

First, the waitress upsell us on the pizza. We wanted a slide or s have a 12" and she said 12" is just personal. It came out with 8 slides there. We could have sharing one, ending we took one with us. The meat lover was not what I expected. The pe peperoni was super sweat. Everything took a long time. It took them a while to bring the pizza and took a long time for her to box our pizza or bring us the check. Then you looked over the counter. She was ta lking to the chef or walking around. She ended up bring the check after another 5 minutes but the pizza was still box... -ing.... not there yet ... lol... She also took more than 10 mins to return the credit card... definitely not coming back. read more

City Pizzeria - meat lover - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

Great spot in White Plains. Indoor and outdoor seating. Great wait staff. Much more than just pizza - although the pizza is great. Crust is thin and crispy! read more

City Pizzeria - Specials - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

See all

Fun evening! Everything was delicious. Great for family gatherings. Excellent service too. read more

City Pizzeria - Delicious pizzas - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

Woah guys...this place is absolutely flavorful! We stay at the Camria Hotel a lot for work and dear God I am thankful to have room service in restaurant form! I believe they're quite new but they have it together from the sweetheart who took my order to the doll that delivered it! Vodka pizza; vodka sauce on pizza like what? Heaven. These pinwheel things that are great for a snack later or when on the move! Caesar salad with the honest portion of Anchovies, finally a place that does that! Tiramisu will be gone by the time I finish writing this ! This I will be my staple when in town! read more

Ambiance: great atmosphere at City Pizzeria. Frankie and Anthony are welcoming owners who revamped this restaurant to give it that homey, restaurant feel. They have an outdoor patio and bar that will be great for Sunday football. White Plains needed a place like this that's within walking distance to my apartment! Food: The salad pizza slice was delicious with a balsamic glaze and Gorgonzola to die for. The hot honey slice was excellent too. We got the volcano meatball and it was huge! Great food. Great company. read more

City Pizzeria - Bar area - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

I sat at the bar and was able to catch the happy hour. $5 draft beer and some food specials. I tried the wings and pizza. Both were hot and tasty, plus the price was right . Service was great at the bar. I'll be back! read more

We just had dinner here tonight. Renzo (I think that's his name) was attentive, the pizza was delicious, and the ambiance was what we needed (great music but not too loud to hear each other). When our sodas came out we didn't like how flat they were and Renzo took care of it straight away. We would absolutely return to this restaurant in the future! read more

Not a great experience at the new City Pizzeria in White Plains. Unfortunately for them the pizzeria is a bit tricky to find as it is on a second floor entrance above Chipotle and next to Planet Fitness. I ordered two slices to go, One Margarita and one "Arturo Special". The Staff was careless and inattentive, they gave me a pile of dirty napkins which I left there and the pizza was luke-warm. The Margarita slice was lacking flavor but the Arturo slice had good components. Sad to see because the vibe in the restaurant looks great, well built and designed. However for $15 for two slices and a seltzer it was not worth it. read more

$6.00 for a slice of not very good pizza won't go back I read some of the other reviews they should be all one star there are better choices in WP read more

Second time here and did not disappoint...again. Delicious thin crust pizza. We were a party of about 12 . We enjoyed the perfectly thin crust pies. Delicious Margherita , Pepperoni and Meat Lovers. They also have the best fried calamari , non greasy, fresh and non chewy, perfect light batter . Friendly and lovely service . We had a wonderful waitress.My 85 year old dad raved about his eggplant parmigiana. Cannot wait to go back ! read more

What a beautiful spot! great addition to White Plains. Went for some food & drinks with friends last week & was very pleased. Super nice bartenders & servers as well. I hope more people learn about City Pizza! read more

Best staff, great food, great service. There were so many TVs that had all the games on. We had so much fun here!

Bartender Riccardo was great, cool atmosphere and solid pizza. Worth a stop, sat at the bar and enjoyed our evening. read more

City Pizzeria - Italian Near Me - White Plains, New York

A welcome addition to downtown White Plains. Pizza was great, thin and crispy crust the way I like. The vodka and buffalo personal pies are delicious. Only had one appetizer, fried calamari and was hot and delicious, would order again. My new go to pizza joint. I need to try the other items (entrees and pasta). read more

I was wondering around and found this place for an accident actually, but I was amazed by the quality of the food and service, highly recommend for anyone, the ambience it's amazing, they really made me and my wife like home,,,come check it out read more