Cancel

Open app

Search

Square Pie Guys

3.3 (10 reviews)

Order Square Pie Guys Takeout or Delivery

Square Pie Guys Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Square Pie Guys

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Hilary L.

Hilary L.

Helpful 19
Thanks 1
Love this 13
Oh no 0

11 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 1
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Hilary L.

Hilary L.

Helpful 2
Thanks 1
Love this 2
Oh no 0
Photo of Kilo K.
0
281
19

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Tiffany B.

Tiffany B.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Joe C.
67
36
0

2 years ago

Business owner information

Photo of Genesis G.

Genesis G.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Square Pie Guys

You might also consider

Hook Fish at Proof Lab Beer Garden

Hook Fish at Proof Lab Beer Garden

4.2
(723 reviews)
1.4 mi
$$

I had Fish Hook before in San Francisco and got to try this location and the food is amazing!…read more I got the oysters, the ling cod fish plate, and black cod tacos and my favorite is definitely the ling cod plate. The ling cod is one of my favorite fish they have there and the rice and the tomatoes on the plates are delicious!!! I wish the staff here are more friendly and the food can come out a little slow, especially on the weekends. The staff mentioned that we would have to wait for 30-45minutes for the fish and chips so I didn't get it and I wish I could if I didn't have to wait that long. But overall I really enjoyed coming here for fresh fish options and a great place to come with friends!

Ambiance was super chill and inviting. Lots of outdoor, partially covered seating and a handful of…read moreindoor tables inside and by the bar. But the style of the restaurant left much to be desired. More below. The way this place works is: check in, wait to be seated, then once you have your table you can go stand in a separate line to order food and another line to order drinks. This aspect of the restaurant I think could improve it's a little clunky. 3 stars for this aspect of it. Wait on an early Sunday afternoon was 40+ minutes for 6 people to be seated. Luckily there's a cool surf/gear store next door to explore with tons of awesome items. As mentioned above after getting seated, it's another ~5-10 minutes to order drinks at the bar and ~5-10 minutes to stand in line to be able to order food. Then -20 minute wait for the food once ordered. All in all I don't think I was a fan of this set up. Fish and chips were okay/pretty good but nothing I would write home about. Oddly enough I think our table of 6 ordered five orders of fish and chips because we were that excited to try them out for ourselves. We've always wanted to try their S.F. location by the beach but it's always super packed. We also ordered a few Chips and salsa and guacamole. Salsa and guac were super bland, definitely would not recommend the salsa at all to my worst enemy. The beer selection on draft was extensive and bartenders were super friendly. Parking could be A LOT better -- we had to find parking all the way down the busy high speed road. They have their own small parking lot on site but it was packed to the brim. Originally I had this listed as a 4-star review because it truly is a nice layout and location with potential, but after writing this review I think it's more realistically a solid 3.5 star experience. Decided to keep the 4 to be fair because staff is super friendly and the layout and bones of the location is actually really big and nice, but it all just felt a little too clunky to be honest. Side note: kudos to staff who acted swiftly and super professionally to a super scary medical emergency that happened to someone near us at the bar. Paramedics had to be called and it was handled well.

Photos
View from outside (Sept 2024)
View from outside (Sept 2024)
Ceviche
Ceviche
Apple cider, dry

See all

Apple cider, dry
Tamalpie Pizzeria

Tamalpie Pizzeria

3.6
(445 reviews)
0.7 mi
$$

After a day at the beach, our gang decided on pizza. We found this place online, a few people…read morecalling it "the best pizza ever". Service was fine. Not smiling or welcoming, but attentive. Ambiance is 5 stars, fire pit, outdoor seating, great location. Good wine list. Menu is pasta, pizza, salads, and pasta. The pizzas are thin crust and "fancy". They feature things like feta cheese or carmalized onions. We all agreed that the crust was amazingggg. But it was so thin and floppy that ingredients just slid off. But here's a hot tip- the kid menu pizzas are totally full size pizzas, which the waiter failed to mention. So 1 cheese pizza could easily feed 2-3 little kids. We ordered one for each kid and went home with a TON of cheese pizza leftovers. The zucchini fries are tasty but served with an aoli that tasted like straight mayonnaise. Dinner for 4 , plus tax and tip came to $150. We're going with a solid 3 stars. An overall decent experience, but nothing to get too excited about.

A staple whenever I visit Mt. Tam/Mill Valley! Love sitting outside on the warmer nights, such a…read morecute and warm atmosphere throughout the entire restaurant. Service is great, food comes out quickly, and everything is yummy! The arancini is mine and my partner's favorite appetizer. The piña calmada is a great mocktail option for those who prefer not to drink! The pizza flavors are amazing! I would say the dough/crust is not as crispy and I know some people enjoy their pizzas that way. Make sure to ask for it well done if that's the case! Nonetheless, everything was perfect. Their chocolate chip cookies are to die for (make sure to ask for it warmed up).

Photos
Dinning
Dinning
Rigatoni pesto
Rigatoni pesto
Full bar with big screens!

See all

Full bar with big screens!
Watershed

Watershed

3.6
(290 reviews)
1.1 mi
$$

My friends and I managed to beat the lunch crowd when we arrived at Watershed at Mill Valley…read moreLumberyard, and we were able to be seated right away at a large table that fit all nine of us. Because we were such a large group, we ordered a couple of vegetable platters and pizzas to share. This also allowed us to try several of the pizzas, which helped mitigate the angst of missing out because all of the varieties sounded delicious. We started off with the vegetable platter, which featured roasted vegetables and squash served over a bed of lentils and seasoned yogurt sauce with toasted pita on the side. I love almost any roasted vegetable, and the yogurt sauce made everything taste elevated; I could have easily finished off the vegetable platter on my own, but I restrained myself to save room for the pizza. My favorite pizza had to be the Calabrian chile and ricotta pizza, which stood out with its sweet, creamy ricotta and the slow burn from the chile oil that lingered long after the last bite. The other pizzas were solid, although they were your more typical pizza combos (cheese, mushroom, meat combo). We spotted buffalo milk gelato on the dessert menu, so we ordered a round of scoops to finish off our lunch. The buffalo milk resulted in a creamier, silkier texture than regular cow's milk gelato (I think?), and it was very tasty!

What a cute area of Mill Valley we had the pleasure of visiting over the weekend celebrating…read moreFather's Day. Watershed can be found in the Mill Valley Lumber Yard, which also has a few cool shops, a toy store, wine tasting room, ice cream spot, and more. We made a reservation ahead of time and so glad we did because they were booked up for this special weekend. With beautiful weather, this spot was alive with large parties. Also, the World Cup was on and patrons were enjoying watching the game(s) inside too. If we were to come back, I would def sit outside with a group on a nice day. Outside there was corn hole and lotsa tables to enjoy a casual meal and vibes. Our party ordered a round of margaritas, and menu standouts included the burger, fried chicken sandwich (the paprika aioli is stellar), the kale salad (topped with chickpeas, quinoa, walnuts, and more), grilled cheeses for the kiddos, and the "Burning Love" pizza. There's a little bit of something for everyone on the menu here, and everything was so fresh, comforting, and just elevated. The meat in the burger was something to highlight, and I loved the thick cut fries. I would try a pizza on the next trip like the "Swim Club" served with Calabrian chile honey, or the "Peach Pie" because why not, it's summer! Service was okay, but it was also such a busy time of a day that everyone was just doing the best they could. All in all, highly recommend if in the area and looking for a lovely time/afternoon.

Photos
Full Bar with big screen
Full Bar with big screen
Hanger Steak Salad
Hanger Steak Salad
Watershed

See all

Square Pie Guys - chicken_wings - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...