Pizza looked great. Crust was too soft as each slice bent down from the bottom edge to the edge of the crust. The edge crust was the best. Tomato sauce very bland. Cheese lacked flavor. Sausage was good. Pepperoni was ok. Pizza crust slippery undercooked under the cheese. Good presentation but product disappointing. read more

Chicken and wings deal....solid. good crust with a very good tasting sauce, cheese blend, and toppings. I'm usually skeptical of pizza place wings, but these are as good as you'll get from most places. You won't be disappointed with your dinner from Stevie's. read more

My husband and I walked into the pizzeria and immediately smelled REAL pizza. We are native NYers and typically can't find good pizza out of the NE. These are real NYers with great pizza, garlic knots, wings, etc. So glad they are here! Liz read more

I ordered delivery from here and the pizza was very disappointing. I called and asked what the difference was between a large and super. The girl said large has 8 slices and the giant had 12slices. Literally that's what it is, you pay $2 more for them to cut it into smaller slices. The slices were not even two inches wide, I've never seen a "slice" so small. We are from New York and you would never get served a pie like that unless you asked to cut it for kids. And they would never call that a giant sized. It's a large sized pizza. I also asked for ranch on the phone and the delivery guy didn't have any. Called to complain and the manager was very rude. I give it two stars because the taste wasn't bad but wasn't great and delivery was fast. We will never be ordering from here again. read more

Stevie's Pizza - Slice size for a "giant" sized pizza - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

I always like trying new pizza joints whenever spotted Stevie's was delicious to say the least, customer service was excellent the delivery driver "Cubs logo on back window" was very pleasant to deal with my pizza and wings were absolutely amazing only small complaint would be that the pizza was slightly warm most likely from the drive which I understand since they delivered kinda fat cant do anything about that but overall 10/10 Thanks guys I'll be having you in the future!! read more

I had such an awful experience. I've never been here before or had their food. I ordered through the phone for pick up. I was rushed to get my order in and the lady tried to hang up on me before I could even ask for the total amount (since I don't know the total with tax). I went by to pick the order, was greeted fine. I tell this balding older man I'm here for a pick up. He asks, "The two pizzas?" I said yes with a salad. He then cuts me off mid sentence to say, "yeah yeah whatever." He goes to the back to get the salad so I look through the menu one more time and he comes back to tell me, "move where I can see you." I will never come here again. This serve was down right awful and what made it worse, I was with my 6yr old brother and he had to sit through and listen to this. The pizza is not even that good! read more

I really have a good experience- always delivery. Their marinara is amazing. I get extra for the crust to dip! I've never had anything on the menu that wasn't yummy and the delivery guy is super friendly. I trust him. He always comes with big orders and he walks it into my kitchen. Super great and friendly neighborhood establishment! read more

Our favorite pizza place!! When we first moved to vistancia we fell in love with stevies and three years later we still come atleast monthly. Pizza is always great and the staff is amazing and super friendly. read more

just moved into a new home and wanted to try this place out, pizza was good, pasta 5/10 and they charged us for 6 ranches and didn't give them and didn't give us our side of garlic knots. we tried calling and they wouldn't pick back up. read more

The owner, one of the nicest guys your ever going to meet. Anyways the food top notch best pizza place around for miles. I would definitely recommend the calzone and the family calzone is humongous read more

Pizza is ok. Stopped in for lunch a couple of times and they offer decent lunch specials. Surprisingly they offer a slice of pizza with any toppings you want. Normally for a slice, pizza places have limited options. Come to find out they take a basic piece of cheese pizza already baked and throw some toppings on it and toss it back in the oven instead of it being fresh and baked from scratch. Ultimately it had zero flavor and tasted like leftover pizza that had been heated several times. I ordered spinach topping and it wasn't fresh spinach but out of a can! Just weird. Owner isn't particularly friendly either so I most likely won't be back. read more

I ordered the chicken and broccoli pasta. Comes with a side salad and garlic knots. I asked for the side salad hold the onions and black olives and wanted ranch. When I got home my salad had black olive and Italian dressing! The chicken with broccoli and pasta had NO alfredo sauce!! NONE! My gosh never was I so disappointed!! It was not like it was busy. I was one of maybe 4 customers11.00 for pasta? And no sauce was not the way you want to come home after work. read more

Wings were really good! The salads are pretty good too, and they have "good ranch"! Good ranch (meaning not oily) is hard to come by. Plus they deliver. I've read other comments about delivery being slow. I had No problem with wait time for delivery, don't wait till you're starving to order then get mad because you don't get your food instantly. read more

Stevie's is our go to delivery pizza restaurant here in Vistancia. We are not a big fan of chain restaurants, especially when it comes to pizza. Stevie's has unique pizzas like the cheese steak pie which is one of my favorites. If you're in the area we recommend stopping by! If you Live in the area and want some great delivery pizza, we recommend them as well. Not only is their pizza delicious, but their wings are excellent as well. read more

Whenever I go over to my grandmas we order Stevie's, I've been eating them for most of my life and I love pizza but this pizza is just amazing! I suggest this place cause you can get the best pizza for a good price for the size and there is just more than pizza! The owners and workers are really caring about their customers and are so sweet! If you know me you know me! read more

Worst Customer Service!!! Having ordered from here for over 8 months, Stevie's pizza had a mix up with their system that left us waiting over 90 mins for our food. They waited for us to call to find out that they delivered our order to the wrong address. In the mean time the gentlemen that spoke with us told us "screw you, I have other phone lines ringing, so do you want the pizza or not?" That was the justification we received when making a legitimate complaint. We will never be back, we will make sure that our clients know all about your treatment to your customers, a simple sorry would have sufficed! read more

Delicious highly recommend!! Great staff super friendly, good people, food is amazing, and prices that cant be beat! Love the ricotta cheese pizza and there hand made canollis read more

I get pasta (chicken parmesan, beef ravioli, spaghetti & meatballs), and sometimes it's good but sometimes it's bad. When it's bad, it's always because the pasta in each of the dishes is very undercooked. It seems like it's about 50/50 (undercooked vs good), and when it's undercooked it's inedible. I stopped ordering from Stevie's, but I'd definitely order again if they fix the pasta issue. read more

We had been generally happy with Stevies Pizza, I don't know if there has been a change in management or what happened but lately they have become really terrible. They mess up at least ever other order and when you call to tell them they are incredibly rude about it. Today they messed up on out delivery order I called and was met by nothing but speculation by the owners wife, who questioned literally everything I told her then hung up on me. My wife called back and talked to Steve who proceeded to tell her, very agitatedly he would resend the order then hung up on her in mid sentence. When I called back I spoke with Steve who proceeded to yell at me over the phone about not hanging up on his customers and when I said I wanted a refund he accused us of "probably eating half of the pizza already" which was a complete fabrication. Buyer beware, I know Vistancia residents don't have very many choices when it comes to delivery, but the complete lack of respect and mediocre offerings to correct their own mistakes has left a bad taste in our mouths. read more

Pizza and wings arrived on time but... Pizza was soggy and flavorless, cut into huge pieces chicken wings were dried up and not tasty at all I would not recommend this pizza or wings at all read more

The pizza, wings, and broccoli roll were very tasty. If you are in the mood for delicious NY style pizza, then you will not be disappointed at Stevie's in Vistancia! read more

best gluten free pizza ever! a must have :) this place is clean and staff is super friendly! Best NY style pizza!

This pizza truly sucked! It would be an epic fail in NYC or any other corner of the galaxy. It was under cooked and the crust was gummy. I ordered a supreme and vegetable. When I opened the boxes there was no discernible difference between the two. $50 for two karge pies delivered and tip. Frankly, I would have been happier with some Tostinos party pizzas. I guess this is what happens when you live out in the ass end of Maricopa County. read more

Just tried Stevie's for the first time today. Wings were just okay but the pizza is excellent.. Delicious sauce! Also much needed in this location. read more

Pizza was ok. Nothing great nothing terrible. We were shopping at the Safeway since we're visiting and stopped in for a bit. Ehh

This place is completely operated by the owner. He makes a great pizza and works hard for his customers. There are great lunch specials here. read more

Super disappointed. Pizza was bland and tasteless. Beer labeled as shock top was not that. Worker was rude and pretty short with customers. read more

Great family owned business. They made us an outstanding Italian sub sandwich on a toasted bun. The restaurant is clean with multiple TV screens to watch your favorite sports team. They also do pizza and salads. read more

Great service, great food. Love that this place delivers now. Only recommendation is to offer more gluten free option.

This review is on one menu item only. I have ordered their wings on several occasions. The very first time I ordered their wings, they were the best wings I had ever had. Fresh, crisp, and their wing sauce is the best ever! Love the sauce! Unfortunately, in the 10 or so times I've ordered the wings since (always to go), they are soggy and gross (but the sauce is still good and I have no problem eating them!). I can only assume that the wings are cooked earlier in the day and reheated upon receiving an order. I assume this because I'm always quoted 15 minutes for my pick up time, but when I show up five minutes later, they are sitting there waiting for me. Stevie's, make these fresh and I'd eat here at least once a week. Until then, only when I'm desperate or am craving your wing sauce. read more

Three times a charm? Not at this location! First time in, customer service was terrible. The two girls taking orders at the counter complained the entire time about how swamped their were on a Tuesday night and didn't even greet us when we came in. Second time was a little better, but they change the style of their fried mushrooms than it was the first time we had them. Last time I will go there was last night unless their management changes. I have ordered the pizza and wing special, extra large with two toppings and a side order of fried mushrooms, 30 bucks. This time I just ordered the special extra large two topping pizza with wings with no side of fried mushrooms, price 30 bucks. It didn't make sense to me and I asked the girl working the counter, who was really sweet, how can it be the same price if I didn't order the extra items of mushrooms, she couldn't figure it put. A older man with a white mustache tried to justify the price by saying he put extra wings in my order, which he lied about. I told him the math didn't add up and he proceeded to get mouthy with me telling me, as I am walking out the door, to give him the pizza back. I am all about supporting local business but this manager needs to learn math and customer service. I will not be back anytime soon! read more

Best pizza in the area, and personable staff. It's as close to East Coast pizza as we've found since we've lived in AZ. My in-laws always request Stevie's when they visit. read more

We brought a large group of girls in for dinner and we were treated so nice! The service was wonderful and the Pizza was delicious! Love the crust! We will definitely be back with our families! read more

Pizzas delicious! Staff is very kind and helpful! Highly recommend and I'm not gonna lie I'm a food snob!

It's a decent, quick pizza spot. Would order again, if I was in a bind. Otherwise, I would rather spend another 20 minutes in the car.

Their pizza is so good! We went the night before we headed out to Disneyland. We live in Vistancia and usually stop at Safeway once a week. This was the first time we tried this restaurant and it was delicious! The guys who were working are really friendly. it looks like it'd be a great place to go for pizza and beers for football season. read more

Has become my go to pizza place while out towards Vistancia. Even worth traveling to if I was farther. Pizza and wings are great.

Tried Stevie's for the first time as we are new to the area, actually new to Arizona. Had the bones-less ckicken wings, an antipasto salad and then a pepperoni and sausage pizza. All the food was quite good. The salad was fresh with lots of vegis and not just lettuce. The pizza is New York style so you have to like the large pieces and thin foldable crust, which i love. This reminded me of my favorite pizza, John's in NYC. While not that, it certainly was a very good pizza. Lots if toppings and a reasonable price. There is a very minimal charge for delivery. Will definately go there again. read more

I have been going to Stevie's for 3 years now. They have great Pizza, but so much more. Great Lasagna, Chicken Parm, Ravioli, Spaghetti too. Excellent sandwiches ( Cheese Steak, Meatball, Eggplant and Chicken Parm.) I eat all these different things and I am there very often. I have recommended Stevie's to many friends who live close to the store. Great prices and great food and they are very willing to customize your order. No negatives here. I very rarely give reviews, but do yourself a favor and try Stevie's. read more

I tried the buffalo chicken pizza! Amazing. Definitely one of he best I've tried on the west side.