No utensils included, no straws for drinks included, my request to not include any pork/swine/pig derived food items was totally IGNORED thus I had to discard the food which contained pig. Order specified bbq sauce, it was not in the package when delivered. Waste of my money and time. I'll never order from here again. read more

We ate here for the first time yesterday. The wife and I and the ribeye steak with their potatoes. The streak has an excellent flavor and was a really good size. The potatoes were really good as well. The server was awesome. High energy, knew the menu, and made some great recommendations. She was super friendly too. I was surprised by the variety of their menu. It is more than just a BBQ and steak place. The owner came out and talked with us to see how the meal was going and stated their salmon was really good and even provided a sample of their ribs. We will definitely be back to try other items on the menu. read more

Best seasoning ever. You go through the drive-thru, order 35 min ahead via calling in. Date night - 2 rare 6 oz filets rare 2 loaded baked potatoes Extra bacon 2 salads with honey mustard and ranch Seasoning on the steak is the reason you go here but the other part is when you bring $60 of meat home and you can microwave your potato= melting the salt+Butter+shredded cheeses+bacon mixture(yes thats the order) you put 45secs-1:00.... Steak: is no point in eating it any other way. The steak has this house seasoning particularly unique to stonemill. That plus always cooked how i order which is rare not medium rare and not leaking blood like it was meant to be a dipping sauce. It's Thick like i like my women {{tip $5 at the drive-thru window every time and you will be taken care of down to tied bags with the easy open one tug knot. Mkay? }} OK this part is he all right to the whole experience when you get home you make sure you eat your steak with your fingers yes date night you and your person sit on the couch Netflix chill and you pull the steaks apart like it should be eaten Of course you have to clean your finger nails afterward it's called caveman style you can't do this in the restaurant. I don't know if all filets should be eaten this way and frankly I do not care because I probably will never go anywhere else. Why would I want to eat steak while wearing pants answer that, people. Thank you Stonemill. Bbq my ass lol read more

I really do hate to complain.. but this had to be some of the worst food I've ever had. I ordered nachos with chicken on the side, but half of it was chicken covered in spicy white watery stuff atop of stale chips..not to mention the fact I got a side of mashed potatoes and gravy, and they were both instant... it tasted like powder. I was actually excited to order food from here after reading reviews.. welp. I ended up with no food, lol... read more

We like this place a lot... like the decorating, the staff, and the food... It is closed on Sunday's, which is sad for after church dinner, but I do think the staff should have that day off. Like all the food so , just go and try it... read more

Ordered the sampler to share and the spinach salad for lunch. So tasty! Meat was very tender, love the 2 BBQ sauces! Clean atmosphere with really fun decor. Is that a chuck wagon I see in the balcony? Reasonably priced and delicious. Friendly service. read more

Rare Mom&Pop family-run BBQ and steak joint is a nice break from chain stores. Very nice custom building with many statues and awesome 2-sided fireplace. BBQ ribs are meaty and tender with just the right amount of smoke. AYCE on Tuesday is a must. Side items are tasty, especially the Stone Mill potatoes as gratin. I really like this place and thing you will too! read more

Food here is legendary. I was in town for a work trip and a coworker recommended them. Its the only chicken fried steak I've ever had in my life that was tender enough to cut with a fork. The portions are huge. Service is friendly. Just wish they had a location here in Texas. read more

I ordered via Grubhub while in town for work. I ordered the smoked turkey and thoroughly enjoyed it. The portion was generous and the flavor was on point. I would recommend to others! read more

Ate here for lunch the other day. One of my rules of thumb is that if a restaurant has spent a significant amount of money on a theme and decor the food will typically suffer. Stone Mill BBQ falls into that rule. The decor is very nice and seems pretty pricey but the food and service itself is nothing special. Had the pork loin sandwich with the potato salad. I found the pork loin rather dry and the potato salad was nothing to brag about either. Some others at my table had sliced beef and said the same. Service was spotty, server was nice enough but for a place that wasn't near filled up she could have been more attentive to drinks and condiments. Not a bad place if you like rustic decor but not really a good value for the money. read more

4 star restaurant with 2 star execution. This review is based on the BBQ only since we did not try anything else on the menu. First off the place looks really nice from the outside and then you walk in and it's like Daniel Boone Vomited up all the décor. Anyway, the service was good, are waitress was very nice and knowledgeable about the product she was selling. Warm bread and honey butter immediately to the table, you've got to love that stuff. Caesar Salad in a BBQ joint, not so much, but it was good they make their own croutons which again were very good. Now to the Q, the Brisket was good but way over cooked and all the bark had been cut off. I'll never understand that, most cooks work so hard to get a perfect bark and some joints just cut it off and toss it out. The brisket would have been good if it was in a sandwich covered in "Head Country BBQ Sauce," which apparently is the house secret sauce. The Pulled Pork was again very good but the execution was not there. The pork was over cooked to the point of that, mushy crock pot style pork Nanna used to make. I call this Faux Q no real smoke or smoke ring just cooked meat covered in BBQ sauce, which reminds me I actually never saw a smoker and trust me I looked. I'm pretty sure they've probably got one. The Pork had obviously been setting in some type of warmer container with all the fat and glaze so you have fat running all over the plate. In moderation this is not bad this was too much. Baby Back Ribs, very good they were probably the best thing we ate that night. Good color, light glaze tender fall off the bone ribs, just like everyone enjoys so much. Hickory wood was light and not overpowering good spot to get ribs. However, they are very proud of them the price was high for the overall quality. I don't know that I will have any reason to go back. There are too many other better BBQ joints within a couple of miles to waste time with just OK Que. read more

Stopped for the night in Broken Arrow while road-tripping between Chicago and San Diego. Our motel concierge recommended the place, and it definitely beats the garish McDonald's signs. The place was nearly empty and we were seated right away. Our server seemed extremely disinterested but whatevs. Everything was prompt and she didn't screw up our order. Sister and I both had loaded baked potatoes piled with beef brisket, which was an unexpected surprise. It was yummy. I ordered the appetizer portion of chicken strips, which were just meh. Very, very dry. Dad had some 4-meat-a-palooza entree. The Wagon Wheel maybe? He seemed to like it. Fries were good and didn't need salt. Don't know as though this is the type of place I'd waste my money ordering steak. Weirdly enough, this place appeared to have a drive-thru. read more

Great server and authentic food, but not perfect. We came here to use a Groupon for four filets mignons, but came with 7 people, so three of us ordered from the menu. I wanted some barbecue, so I got a three-meat platter with hot links (great), chopped brisket (little greasy), and bologna (great). All 4 of the steaks that were ordered at our table seemed to be cooked about one step past where they were ordered, so keep that in mind. The server was very good, very attentive, so certainly can't complain there. I lived in BA for several years after this place was built, but never went there. Now I finally have. May not be the best in town, but it was worth it for the trip. read more

Ordered the Ribeye and wish I tried some BBQ instead. Not a very good steak. Service was pretty poor, that small town simple feel. read more

This is One Of Broken Arrows Unique Gems A Great Quiet Beautifully Decorated Classy Place to Enjoy A Great Meal Great Quality BBQ at A Very Reasonable Price The BBQ Sliced & Chopped Brisket Is Outstanding Stone Mill Potatoes Are The Best read more

The Committee could not agree- Mountain Lodge style? Dining Room at Summer Camp style? Hollywood Hero style? Is that supposed to be Indy Jones and an Orang? Over-priced, mediocre food....bizarre atmospherics. read more

This place is a jewel for BBQ in the Tulsa / Broken Arrow metro. My wife and I grew up in Tulsa and come back to eat here every time we come to visit family. Meats: I could tell you the ribs are so good they don't need BBQ sauce. I could tell you the pulled pork is to die for. I could go on about the sliced turkey and brisket..... but I wont.... just go have a plate of BBQ here. Sides: There is one side you must always get; Stone Mill Potatoes..... they are epic. In addition to those they have the normal sides all would expect and live at a BBQ restaurant: okra, green beans, baked beans, etc..... read more

We had not been to Stone Mill in years. We heard a good review from a friend and thought we should check it out. Food was decent but nothing special. The issue arose when we received our ticket. We noticed several up-charges and meals were more expensive than listed on the menu. We asked our waitress and she went to ask. She came back and told us that due to rising costs they added extra charges for chicken and turkey. She was nice about it and mentioned that she also did not know. We then asked how we were supposed to know that before ordering our food, and she mentioned something about a sign on the door. The sign was a single piece of paper completely full of text, and mentioned the supply chain issues and that prices may have changed. It did not explicitly state for what or how much. We asked the manager why it was not listed on the menu but received a snarky glare instead of an explanation. She did not make an attempt to explain or even hear us out. Overall for five of us at dinner, the extra charges were more than $10 extra than we expected to pay before tax. We can confidently say that they lost us as customers not for poor food but terrible customer service (from the manager) and for false advertising. read more

We have eaten here several times and it has been acceptable, this time the food was cold, and the service was mediocre. read more

Stone Mill BBQ and Steakhouse - Checking out Stone Mill BBQ in Broken Arrow - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

Everything was very good service food great, atmosphere was a little Bransonish but clean 2 ribeye steak dinners salad potatoe and 12 oz steak for $40 read more

Stone Mill BBQ and Steakhouse - Ribeye and hand cut fries excellent - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

My husband and father in-law both had all you can eat ribs tonight. When we get the ticket there the charge was not the same as the advertised price. Me and my daughter shared the catfish. It was fine. We got an extra side. Call me strange but $2 for a little bowl of green beans is a little high. Don't worry we will be going back. We don't go very often it's just a little expansive for our pockets at times. read more

We love Tulsa! For many reasons, but its amazing choice of BBQ joints is one of them. Tulsa has a tremendous selection of amazing BBQ, from fast food to gourmet and literally everywhere in between. This was our second time at Stone Mill BBQ. I could not recall the first time, but our party of six insisted that we had been here before. I guess my lack of memory is testimony to this unremarkable BBQ joint. Wow, where to begin... My wife and I ordered the two meat combo, pulled pork and sliced brisket. For some odd reason both were sopping wet with water. Both pooled in their own water. Now, juicy is one thing but the meat was wet, literally wet. Secondly, they were flavorless. With all the amazing BBQ in town, its amazing to me that this place survives. Many of the Yelp reviews of Stone Mill BBQ note the atmosphere and the decor of this place. While easy to describe, it is rather difficult to explain. Think Rain Forest cafe but poorly done and dusty. There is just about everything hanging from the ceiling and clinging from the walls, life-size pirates, an orangoutang, fish, more monkeys, ship memorabilia and everything in between. Some of the items were clearly made professionally while other items can be purchased at Walmart in the stuffed animal department. Why this place is called "Stone Mill" yet the decor is "low-budget movie meets pirate island" is a mystery. A big disconnect but perhaps I am missing something. While others (kids mainly I presume) probably look around in awe (the good kind), I am in awe (the bad kind) at the energy placed into the odd surroundings and the huge miss on the food. read more

This is, to me, the best bbq restaurant in the Broken Arrow/Tulsa area. The turkey breast and brisket dinners are my favorites. I love their bbq sauce, also. I easily give it the five star ratting! read more

BBQ is Awesome! Staff is very friedly and kind, we found our new date night spot!!!!!!!!

We love this place! The food is great. The dining room is great for family dinners and the bar area is great for dining and drinking while watching a ball game. The décor is very interesting throughout the restaurant. read more

The meat here is great. Just nothing else. The service sucked and the quality of food for the price is outrageous! Took over an hour to get 2 brisket sandwiches and a baked potato, which cost closed to $40. If they stuck to just the meat it would be fine. Also the bbq sauce is Head Country. Seriously? Make ur own sauce. read more

It's amazing how different people's experiences can be. I thought the inside was a little much decor-wise, but everything was very clean. There are a couple of TVs in the main dining room. The decor is very "pioneer" - lots of fake plants, deer heads, a stuffed mountain lion, that kind of thing. I'm not really a big fan of that kind of scheme but the animals were hung pretty high up, so it's not like I had to stare a dead deer in the face or anything. And like I said, everything was very clean - no dust on the decoration and the floors were spotless. As others have mentioned, we started off with a couple of free rolls and honey butter. The rolls were just okay. Nothing special, but warm and fresh. The honey butter was delicious. I ordered a three meat platter with pulled pork, pork ribs, and sliced briscuit, with baked beans and cole slaw for the sides. The briscuit was just okay. It was a tad dry and flavorless, but was great with the BBQ sauce. I thought the pulled pork was fantastic - I definitely saw a smoke ring and the texture was great. The pork ribs were amazing. Both of the sides were really good. The beans were a little sweet for my taste but still had a great flavor. The cole slaw was fresh and creamy. My fiance had something called - the wagon wheel, maybe? It was a house special with various types of meat on an open faced hoagie with a large serving of fries. He wasn't impressed with the quantity of meat but said everything tasted good. I stole a couple of fries and they were super yummy. Service was very good. The server (Amanda) answered my questions and made sure our drinks were never empty (or even low). She didn't hover and ask, "Is everything okay?" a dozen times, which I prefer. I hate it when I can't just concentrate on my meal and conversation because the server won't leave me alone. So I'd give her an A+! read more

We've been here a few times already. Have yet to be disappointed. Great food! Nice & attentive servers. Had the baby back & brisket. So tender!!!! Wife had baked potato, massive! Delicious! Cocktails tasty! Never been crowded that we had to even wait. Don't pass this place up! read more

Clean place, above avg BBQ. I had ribs, polish and pulled pork. Ribs were tender but bland, pulled pork was pretty good. Worth a visit but Not a top notch BBQ place! read more

Sub par food. It's pricey and has a drive through. The stone mill potatoes are good. I haven't tried the steak yet.

We lovingly call this place Stonehenge. We love the ribs and the Stone Mill potatoes are the best ever. We found this place when they catered an event for work. We've been hooked ever since. Great BBQ and great people. read more

The meat was good. Service could be better. Baked potato was warm, the butter never melted.

Food tasted great, service excellent! Peach and cherry cobblers. We ordered loaded baked potatoes with pulled pork and brisket! Rolls were delicious! Yum! 1st time here, used Groupon. Meals for 4. Nice environment, warm greeting, enjoyed our Sunday lunch after church. We will be back :) read more

Good BBQ been eating here for awhile.

While the grind on the polish was too fine the brisket was tender and the pulled pork was excellent as well. I enjoyed the baked beans with each bite of meat and had to order a second bowl to make it come out even. The house special chocolate cake warmed with ice cream is a must save room for desert. read more

Stone Mill BBQ and Steakhouse - Three meat combo with baked beans and baked potato. - Steakhouses Near Me - Broken Arrow, Oklahoma

We have lived here for over 9 years, and for some reason, had never tried this place. Tonight we decided to. Glad we did. It's a nice atmosphere, the service was excellent, and the food was great too. It's not noisy and chaotic like most of the chain steakhouses. I ordered the ribeye with baked beans, and my better half ordered the steak k-bobs and mashed potatoes, and we split our meals, so that we could try both. Both were cooked just as we ordered, medium rare, and were delicious. Both the steak and the k-Bob were very flavorful. We'll definitely eat there again. Maybe try the BBQ next time. read more

This is our absolute favorite place to eat BBQ. Pulled pork and brisket are both outstanding and the French fries have a great "homemade" taste. We have always ordered BBQ to take home, but this week we got a steak inside. The food was outstanding and the service was perfect. Our waitress took great care of us without being too intrusive. Would recommend Stonemill to anyone. read more

We used the Groupon for the baked potatoes and our sons ordered off the menu. Everything we had was very good and the service was excellent. The Groupon was for 4 baked potatoes, 4 drinks and 4 cobblers for $36. Well worth the price! read more

My partner and I came here with a Groupon for two loaded baked potatoes, drinks, and cobblers. We ordered half pork/half beef loaded potatoes. Mine wasn't very hot (though my partner's was) and there was very little sour cream, but the overall taste was OK. Nothing special, but certainly not bad. We had cherry cobblers for dessert. The cobbler portions were small. The cobbler I received consisted primarily of crust with very little cherry filling. My partner's was the opposite. The service was good, but the food wasn't worth it even with a Groupon. read more

The food and service was terrible. Ordered an appetizer just to have it brought with our meal. The "bbq" if that's what you wanted to call it was cold and tasted terrible. I think Rib Crib would have been a better choice. read more