We walked in on a Saturday night at 9:00, Yelp said they close at 10. No one was in the place & the owner said the kitchen actually closes at 9:00...what??? I have never heard of such a thing, we had to leave, his brother the chef said they would not cook for us! We will never come back, VERY poor customer service!!! read more

Great NY pizza! Would recommend sausage and pepperoni yum! Great combination. Staff has always been welcoming.

Amazing food and service. We talk about this place every time we go to the beach!!! We recommend this place to everyone. We ordered via phone and the place was packed when we went to pick it up but the service was super friendly and efficient and the pizza was perfect. read more

Not sure how this place is high rated. It's good but I wouldn't necessarily say it's great. I'm from PA, so my review may be a little biased. In SC, they call an Italian sandwich a Cold Cut, which is odd to me. I am very critical of pizza. I did grab only a slice and not a fresh pie. I thought the crust was a little on the burned side. Parking is a little tough here. I would definitely come back and try more food on the menu. I am curious if the sandwich rolls are brought in or if they are made in house. I thought the roll was a little too much roll. read more

We ordered take out last night (while visiting family in Surfside) ~ had high hopes for a local pizza spot. The home made crust was delicious , but the canned mushroom and olive toppings they used were so salty the pizza was inedible . Way too much salt, overall . read more

*****3.5 stars***** Ordered take out during the week and, although quite busy...the wait was about an hour, appreciated how the staff texted me when my order was ready. Started with an order of the buffalo wings, which were just okay. Cooked just fine, but could have used more buffalo sauce. The pepperoni pizza wasn't bad either. Slightly greasy, but came topped with a good amount of pepperoni. The sauce was a tad sweet, which I enjoyed. C seemed to enjoy his chicken tenders and french fries, but didn't really eat the fries as they were somewhat soggy by the time he ate them (the restaurant is only ~5 minutes from the resort). When I went to pick up my order, I saw why the wait was so long. The restaurant isn't very large and it was packed. If you decide to order take out, make sure you account for the wait. read more

See all

Cute little pizza place, you can see them making all the pizzas by hand so you know it's fresh. There's not a lot of seating so could be tough if it's busy. But the staff are friendly, the food was fresh. The pastas were good, but not a ton of flavor in the sauce. The garlic knots and arancini were great though, definitely recommend those! read more

Best NY style pizza we have had in Myrtle Beach area by a long shot. This is our go to place for pizza and we live in Market Common which has multiple pizza places close by. We go here a couple times a month for the pizza well worth the ride. read more

We got 3 pizzas from them for my birthday price location and taste was good will probably return again

Great pizza!Excellent crust just the right amount of toppings.Meatball,rice ball and Italian Wedding soup apps were great.

Good pizza and the staff is super nice. Parking can be difficult but well worth it. I went during my week stay. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Personal seafood pizza with clams, shrimp and white sauce...sooo good! - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Best pizza we have had in the area. Recommended by locals to us. Nice people. Small dining room, be prepared to get take out if it is a busy time of day read more

Hubby and I came here for lunch because we were craving some New York pizza (we're from New York) . This place was REALLY GOOD! I ordered 2 regular slices with a drink and my husband ordered 2 pepperoni slices with a drink. We gotta say, this taste just like New York pizza. We were both very impressed. Prices were a lot cheaper than what I expected. Service was great. Would recommend this pizza place. We DEFINITELY will be coming back again when we're out here next time. read more

Good experience. We went in thinking we would have a pizza, but when we saw the menu we quickly changed our minds. We all had variations on pasta, and all were fantastic. Meatballs were really well made, chicken was seasoned well. Sauce was excellent, not too sweet. Our servers were all friendly and knowledgeable. It was a trying night for them, it was busy with large groups. They handled it with grace and kept up with all tables. We will be picking up pies from here in the future, but the dine in experience was great too. It's a nice place and the people were great too. read more

Great service, delicious food! We ordered the garlic knots and they were amazing! Definitely made from scratch. The marinara sauce...oh my goodness. De-licious! We asked for some extra to dip our pizza in. Don't pass up this opportunity! Our waitress (thank you, Dana!) suggested it and she was not kidding. Wowzers! We ordered two pizzas. One normal crust and one Sicilian style. The thin crust was perfect: crunchy and tender. The Sicilian was the bomb! Fluffy and thick with a crunchy bottom. Just thinking about it makes me want to go back again. The price was great! We spent a ton of money eating out during our vacation and I wish we had discovered this place earlier in the week because you get great food, great service, and reasonable prices. We will definitely return next time we are in town. read more

See all

Not my style of pizza! Tasted like old dough! Not much flavor. Got home and my 3 meat pizza was cheese On a positive note very nice staff. read more

Ordered a large, plain cheese pizza for the kids and it was DELICIOUS! Pizza was large 16 inch, had a lot of cheese, just the right amount of sauce, and great thin NY style crust. It was devoured in minutes of bringing it home. We will definitely be ordering from here again. We returned to sit down for dinner and LOVED everything we ordered. Chicken and artichoke entree was delicious. The cheese calzone was stuffed and cooked to perfection. The cauliflower crust pizza was also delicious. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Plain cheese pizza - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

Its the name matching the experience for me . This small mom n pop pizzeria was exactly what my family was looking for in terms of smooth service , family friendly atmosphere, and most importantly fresh HOMEMADE Pizza. I'm determined that their sauce is homemade as well because I honestly wanted to dip my pizza in it and I never do that . And let's not forget to mention how cheesyyyyy our works pizza was. I usually will pick though and take some stuff off ( very picky) but I had to fold my pizza in half to keep everything in one bite. They also gave complimentary garlic knots which was so nice of them and I definitely will be back when we return to the resort . read more

See all

We ordered a regular and Sicilian pie and the garlic knots. Both pizzas were delicious, a nice balance of sauce and cheese. I had high hopes for the garlic knots, but the were hard and dry. I would definitely return for the pizza. Also, I called in my order and the order taker and in-person customer service was awesome. read more

Excellent pizza and excellent service! This will definitely be my go to pizza spot when I'm in Myrtle Beach.

If you are a person of color, be warned that you ARE NOT welcome at this place. You WILL get stared at when entering the restaurant, it's not just you. Expect to get treated very poorly and ignored. If I could give it 0 stars I would, instead, I'll give them feedback on how to treat customers of all races. Very disappointed places like this exist in 2024 and they will NOT be getting any of my money. read more

Total disappointment tonight. I have eaten here before and the pizza was great and the wings were good. Ordered a meat lovers, garlic Parmesan wings and barbecue wings. The pizza looked and tasted old. The crust was hard and very chewy more so than what it should have been. The garlic Parmesan wings were absolutely the worst wings I have ever tried to eat. I think they were old too. Rubbery and soaked in oil. But tasted horrible. So bad I would not eat. My wife is still mad and hungry too. Rather than just post a bad review I called and asked for a manager. Speaking she said. Met with nothing but excuses. The worst part she asked if I was a local. Which I will assume if I was she may have offered a refund or partial refund and once I said no, well we have had no complaints and the locals love them. Flat out horrible food tonight. On a positive note the barbecue wings were enjoyable. The only reason I gave 2 stars is because I have ate here before and it was a lot better. As management you should have responded with anything but not excuses as to I am not used the way your food taste. As a matter of fact it was butthole bad! I will not return here for another shot because it was that bad and management did not seem to concerned about it. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Hard and old - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

See all

I might drive 3 hours just to eat dinner here. It was amazing. I ordered the rice balls and pizza. My 100% Italian mother in law had been wanting rice balls and was visiting from out of state. I told her that I ordered some and she kind of rolled her eyes like they'd be subpar. Let me tell you, she was pleasantly surprised. The we're freaking amazing and we fought over them. I will be going back here every time we're at the beach. Ten thumbs up from us. The employees are amazing too! read more

After we got tired of eating turkey for Thanksgiving! They were our saving grace. Great customer service

We have previously eaten here and enjoyed it. Stopped by tonight with plans to order carry out. Your menu is not posted anywhere online, or if it is it's certainly not easy to find. Would've loved to just call in an order for carryout. The MOMENT we stepped into the building, we were screamed at about putting a mask on. No time to even get the mask out and put it on before the screaming began. This cost your business money. We are a family of six and likely would've spent a minimum of $100 on a meal. I know these are trying times for everyone but rude and hateful is never a good look. We'll be eating elsewhere tonight and will NEVER return to this establishment. read more

Hands down best meatball sub I've ever had, everything about it was top notch. Cheesy bread also great, that marinara sauce wow that stuff is amazing!!! Can't wait to go back and try some more stuff! read more

They said pizza would take an hour. Not a problem for a busy Saturday. Placed the order for 1 pepperoni pizza and an order of garlic knots. Got there after an hour and they said it would be 5 more minutes. Not a problem, but noticed there were only customers at 2 tables so it didn't appear to be very busy. WAITED ANOTHER 50 MINUTES FOR MY 1 PIZZA AND GARLIC KNOTS!!! Pizza was fine but not for a 2-hour wait. Garlic knots were mid AF. read more

I have only had the eggplant parmigiana and I loved it. The people are warm and welcoming, I will try the pizza but what so saw walking by as I waited for my sandwich looked great. read more

Being from NY, I will say that this is the closest to NY pizza I have had anywhere!! Thin crust but not drooping from the weight. We had a plain cheese pie and a pepperoni pie and they were both awesome! The service was friendly, courteous and very quick. The food came out quickly and fresh ! I'm on Myrtle Beach numerous times throughout the year and will definitely make it a point to eat here !! read more

I loved this place! The pizza was so good! The subs are amazing as well. I am hooked. I will be returning. Everyone was really nice and the food was amazing. read more

Excellent slice of pizza. Also, veal Parm sub was very good! We went there twice during our week in Myrtle Beach.

Everything we had was very good. Best pizza in Surfside and very friendly service to go with it. Try the cheesecake too!

Got two pizzas a salad and a sub. So far it's been the best in the area. Everything was great

They serve up a popular Italian menu.Unfortunately for me, their sauce has way too much salt in it for anyone on a low sodium diet.

Stopped by based on the other reviews. Pizza was great - good taste and not greasy. Wings were also excellent. Service was also good and food came out pretty fast. Would definitely go here again. read more

Absolutely the best Italian food in the Surfside area. My family went there for years and loved it. Food is super fresh and taste like a small slice of Italy. Really close to the beach, so a good spot to come to after a long day out there! read more

Would have been 4 stars for sure if the server had not scolded my family for "wasting" the black olives on our salads. We didn't know the salad came with black olives and were not asked what we liked on our salads and none of us like them so perhaps you should not put them on salads unless you ask the customer first. Also, the tomatoes were barely ripe so if you are so concerned about your made to order salad, take more care in it's preparation. Can't see how it's waste when the salad isn't complimentary, we did pay for it. I could have asked for a box for them and just thrown them out at home. So with that rant over, the pizza here is delicious. Would love to try the other Italian dishes, so if I recover from the scolding before we return to the beach later this year, I may do that. read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Personal Pepperoni Pizza with Onions, Peppers and Mushrooms...Devine! - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina

(9/28/2019) got to the beach for a week-long vacation and first night is usually an order of takeout (who wants to grocery shop or cook after a road trip??). Took about 7 tries to get through on the phone, constant busy signal, but finally did. Phone staff were friendly and efficient. Order came exactly as promised 45 minutes later. Ordered Pepperoni, Hawaiian, and a Cheese. There's only 2 sizes, large or personal. Pizza was thin crust, toppings rather sparse. Def, very greasy, the entire surface of the pepperoni was covered in a pool of oil. Was described as "decent" pizza. Also got 2 hot hoagies, Steak Combo. Nice crusty toasted, fluffy long roll, quality and tasty, but sparse filling. Prices were OK, delivery is convenient. read more

See all

I have ordered from here twice and both times my order has been wrong. I had family in town they wanted steak & cheese subs. Their menu has steak&cheese and steak combo. There is nothing on menu that says what comes on or what options to put on a "Hot Hero" sub. Steak combo to means sandwich, side and maybe a drink. I ? what it was, steak n cheese with peppers , onions mushrooms. I asked if we could have them with lettuce, tomato,fried onions , mayo and hot peppers and repeated back to her couple of times to make sure they knew what we wanted on them. Also ordered a pizza which was very good and it was made correct the subs on the other hand were incorrect. They had green peppers, mushrooms and fried onions and very little meat. So disappointing. I called them to advise order was wrong for my second time ordering. She got the ticket from kitchen and read it back to.me she had it correct kitchen did it wrong. I asked what the were going to do for me she put the Myra owner Rebecca on phone she apologized I asked what she was going to do for me this is the second time my order has been wrong she said she would give me a $5 credit. I asked for a free sub she said she could not do that it was not her policy mind you this the owner saying this. She obviously does not care about her customers as she should to make them happy . I will go back to get my $5 credit for something definitely no a sub though . And it will be the last time I go there. I did customer service foe a long time and good customer service is making sure your customer is happy. read more

This place has good food but don't bother to go here when it's packed on a Friday night it took them 37 mins to push put to pasta entrees and a cheese steak. If you don't mind waiting it's not bad but service wise is terrible! Update: get my check and they actually charged $2 more $1 more on the cheese steak and $1 more for wings there menu was never updated pretty wrong on there part and didn't even offer to give the actual price! read more

Surfside Beach Pizza & Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Surfside Beach, South Carolina