Not your average bar! Excellent food and service. Went there for a last minute dare and was delightfully surprised. Duck with cranberries and pecans, yummy sangria. Next time I'm trying the butterscotch pudding read more

Tarry Tavern - Red sangria - New American Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Have been here twice now, first just for drinks and then for dinner. Surprisingly well made cocktails and the meal was terrific! A mix of classic American favorites meat dishes, fish and soups. Good wine selection both by the glass and bottle. Very attentive (but not intrusive) wait staff make the evening a delight. I would recommend reservations on a weekend night. Give this gem a try! read more

Very authentic Italian restaurant. The food was delicious and the staff friendly and attentive. We had the eggs in purgatory and chicken sandwich for lunch. The purgatory was spicy and much, the sandwich was pretty okay. There is indoor dining, as we are outside of nyc, and the staff make sure to take great precautions. We did brunch here, and it was great, but this is more of a dinner place than anything. read more

One of my all time favorite, this restaurant never disappoints. The Portuguese Octopus appetizer was fantastic. The Lobster Salad was light and flavorful. It was the perfect choice for a hot summer day. And I could not resist dessert. Their peach blueberry cobbler is to die for. read more

Tarry Tavern - Peach Blueberry Cobbler - New American Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

I love Tarrytown eateries so when my girls decided to meet up for a nature run with me at the Rockefeller State Preserve, I was happy to know we would be heading back to the village for lunch. We yelped a few spots and decided upon Tarry Tavern. I called to make sure they were open because their listing shows their hours as being 11am-noon which I figured is a mistake (mental note to contact admin). When we arrived, we were seated quickly. They were empty when we got there which is understandable, given the time of day and day of week. I asked for some hot tea since I was still freezing from our sweaty forest romp (that sounded sexier than intended). They have a nice tea box with a few flavours to choose from and I went with the Jasmine tea. They serve your tea in a personal kettle and I would suggest letting it steep for a few moments before pouring. I love that because you get more bang for your buck. As for the food, I went with their Kale and Quinoa Veggie Burger with White Cheddar and my friends both ordered the Cobb Salad. The portions are pretty big. When my burger came out, I was pleasantly surprised. It looked huge and came with a side of fries. I cut it in half as I do with all of my burgers. It smelled great, almost like stuffing and you could see whole white beans mixed in the patty. I usually don't order veggie burgers because they tend to be dry but I took a chance. Unfortunately, when I started to eat it, it dismantled completely. The mixture is terrible. It crumbled at first bite and just kept falling out of the bun the entire meal. I ended up having to eat it with utensils. It is very dry and almost tastes like it is made of cornbread. There was almost no kale in the patty and those huge, whole beans added to the instability of the burger. It is very poorly constructed, bland and definitely in need of a revamp. I ate half of it and most of the fries, which were good, out of necessity since we had just run and I definitely needed food on my system but I will definitely never get a veggie burger from them in the future. My friends both enjoyed their salads and I would be lying if I had a bit of FOMO because they actually enjoyed their food. I was a little disappointed but didn't mention it to the staff which I usually do but as I don't normally eat veggie burgers, this one may be what people like and also, I was in a bit of a rush and didn't have the time for a refire or a conversation about the menu. In my opinion, though, if you order a sandwich or burger, it should be expect to be able to be eaten by hand and if most of it falls apart and ends up in crumbs on your plate and lap, it probably wasn't prepared well. I'm definitely not saying that I'm writing off Tarry Tavern. I would like to visit again and perhaps try something off the menu that is more familiar. The menu looked great. The decor is very nice and quaint. The staff is very attentive and service was very much on point. My only issue is with that horrible veggie burger that may have been a mere menu experiment that needs a trip back to the drawing board. read more

See all

I thought the food was excellent. The staff were very attentive. I ordered a drink and the owner had to run out to get pear juice for it! I thought that was so very nice of him! I had the short ribs which were absolutely delicious and my husband had the duck which he loved. I can't wait to back ! read more

This was one of the best meals that both my husband and I have had. We came here from Long Island for a small overnight getaway. Came across this restaurant and we are so happy that we did. The food was extremely fresh and absolutely delicious. Drink selection was incredible as well. Our server, Joe, was extremely nice and so was Henry, the owner. Henry even drove us back to our hotel when we couldn't get an Uber back. I can't recommend this place enough! read more

See all

Excellent food, service and ambiance. I would definitely go again. Its small, attractive tavern.

Glad I ordered the grilled octopus and watermelon salad to close out the summer on Labor Day weekend. We visited Tarrytown on a whim and hoped the outdoor dining would be available. I loved that the town closes a portion of Main Street just for outdoor dining. Made the decision to eat much easier. A huge bonus for allowing dogs to sit outside with the owners. The bartender made a mean whiskey sour as I enjoyed it with my meal. Service was excellent and servers wore gloves and were attentive. read more

Came here for dinner with my family and the food was barely edible. The burger was dry, the mussels were small and not fresh, the salmon was cooked well but just ehh. Food had no taste and quality was poor. In total dinner cost over $125. Dinner at the local pizzeria would have been better and cheaper. Look elsewhere. read more

Returned to the Tavern to meet a friend who had flown in from Florida. She was staying in Tarrytown and I recommended meeting here. Even though it was a Thursday night the restaurant was still pretty busy. I remembered the "walking dead" Cabernet wine and had it again. It was just as delicious and bold as the last time. We ordered the burrata to share and it was perfectly served. The temperature and texture were pleasing to the palate. The solid exterior with the soft creamy interior in combination with the diced tomatoes on the side was pleasing especially on the table bread. It was obvious it was fresh and tasted as if it came straight from Italy. The entire staff caters to you and work as a team making sure your water glass is always full and you constantly have a fresh dish and silverware. Our waiter Joe was especially on point with making sure we had everything we needed while giving us ample time to enjoy our company. This time I ordered the duck breast served on the cranberry rice and my husband ordered the thick strip streak which was perfectly cooked medium rare as he asked and served with sautéed spinach and a potato gratin. The steak was plump, juicy and tender like an in bone filet. We were too full for dessert so just enjoyed another round of drinks. Joe sent over 2 desserts that were out of this world! An all American apple tart with vanilla ice cream and an Italian panna cotta which is a custard served with a fruit sauce on top. Couldn't decide which one we enjoyed more. Neither one was overly sweet and were the perfect end to our meal. Amazing how we found room for these 2 delicious treats. Well, I wasn't kidding when I said this was my new favorite restaurant. Guess I'll have to keep returning with friends until I've tasted everything on the menu. They just don't seem to have a bad dish. Don't think twice about a dinner here. You definitely won't regret it! 5 stars again!! read more

See all

1. Horrible service. 2. Disorganized wait staff. 3. Horrible manager/owner. Call him Mr. Grumpy. 4. Plenty of other restaurants around with better service and nice management. read more

Took a long time. Chicken was too thin. Only like crispy chip. Fries were soggy. Burger was too thick. Menu was only 2 pages. Not horrible. Not good. read more

Dining area wasn't open but we were seated in the brunch dining area. The service was impeccable, food delicious, fresh, top of the line. The variety wasn't what we expected based on website, but understandable due to covid. Would def come back anytime to try other items on menu. Tried the following: Roasted Beets appetizer - pistachios, date puree, goat cheese, greens, and roasted beets. Soooo good! New England Clam Chowder - sooo fresh and good Yellow fin tuna tartare - fresh and full of flavor! Handmade Riccota Cavatelli with short rib sauce - really good! Seared Maine sea scallops with squash farrotto - soooo good! Seared yellow fin tuna with forbidden black rice and carrot puree - the flavors blended soo well and the tuna was really fresh and cooked perfectly Braised short rib with cheddar polenta - really good! Warm chocolate bread pudding - great consistency but a bit too bitter for my liking. Bourbon pecan tart - sooo good read more

The service staff is professionally skilled at their craft, and they treat the restaurant as though each of them personally own the establishment. The food and wine knowledge, the proper placement as service wares, and a sharp dress is certainly appreciated and noted. Now let's get to the food: The kitchen is certainly the star here. There is a mix of modern and classic dishes with an impressive myriad of fresh, local ingredients. (How they curate so many different ingredients is puzzling.) This reviewer is in his late 40s, so I found myself on each visit, ordering throwbacks to the late 80's and early 90's, like a perfectly executed Tuna Tartare with the usual Pacific Rim or Asian treatments of ginger, soy, avocado and crunchy gaufrette potatoes. The Seared NYC was cooked perfectly with a sauce which otherwise comes overly-reduced in other places. On one occasion, I ordered the Chicken - perfectly seasons with salt, fresh herbs and olive oil and nicely dissected into perfectly cooked parts on roots veggies and sprouts! The Gnocchi were tender, pan-seared and swimming in a buttery sauce with crunchy peas. I had the fettucine on one visit with braised duck, bright paquillo peppers and olives - a dish that is sometimes made too muddles with stewed flavors, but this one bright with hints of acidity that made me crave more. On another cold evening, I had the best Ribolita ever- always a throw-away in a kitchen, simply to offer some sort-of soup, but this one had hand-made stock, a touch of tomato, and veggies that were nicely cooked and not too soft... finished off with salty parmesan and grilled bread, this was a meal in itself. There is also chicken liver dishes, Branzino with Raisins and Cauliflower (very sicilian), and Octopus that should be eagerly tried. (I cannot wait to explore the menu!) In summary, if you are visiting the Hudson River towns, you will find waterfront restaurants with Posh interiors and scenic views - this is not one of them, but cozy for dates. You could certainly book one of the higher end hotels or bed and breakfasts but that sometimes breaks the wallet. The staff in other places nearby are young and better-looking but at the expense of a poor service experience. And if you are looking for the best food in the area (from this foodies perspective) there is no other option than Tarry Tavern for its affordable, small=town charm, and skilled kitchen read more

Very rude staff. They just lost business tonight, which by the looks of their establishment, they sorely needed. Try not to be so passive aggressive to your customers next time if you want them to actually feel welcome in your bar... You're welcome. read more

The star decision was not an easy one here. On one hand, the service was excellent. We wanted for nothing. We changed tables and they were very gracious. The atmosphere was very nice. The simple facade you see from the street belies the charming interior, which I would describe as rustic elegance. The food had some high points: the roasted duck was great. The white sauce and carrots were good also. But the rice mixture was not to my liking at all. To the point that I made sure not one single grain was missed as I scraped it off each bite of duck! (Minus an entire star for that because it was half of my entree. Otherwise, an easy 5.) For starters we had Burrata Cheese, which alone was decent, but if you spread it on the table bread it suddenly becomes amazing! Not sure how that even works, but the persimmon flavor stood out along with the lovely creamy cheese, when before (aka no bread) the balsamic vinegar was really the highlight of the dish. In conclusion, I would definitely try it again and I would even recommend you go - just avoid the rice! read more

See all

OMG what a find this was!! This is no ordinary bar. The food is outstanding. With a party of 9, we ordered all different things.... beet salad, burrata, gnocchi, burger, duck confit salad, chowder, grilled cheese, children's pasta. Every dish was perfection. The service was also excellent. The restaurant was decorated for Fall and was comfortable. We look forward to returning here. read more

See all

Ate here again tonight; again, delicious! I had the branzini (it's a Mediterranean fish if you're not sure- I wasn't, lol). It was perfect along with the roasted cauliflower and sauce it came with. Before the meal, I had their wedge salad (minus the bacon; I'm one of the few people who isn't a fan of it!) and loved the blue cheese dressing. It's thick, but it's the "good quality, full-of-cheese" thick kind, not the cheap stuff. Come visit in Tarrytown today! read more

This is a wonderful place for an excellent meal. The name doesn't do justice to the quality of the dishes.

Delicious, savory slow cooked short rib with Polenta. Pan seared and succulent Octopus. Cozy and warm, right in the center of beautiful and historic Tarrytown. Great service, polite, gracious and humble. Westchester county still has the best of everything and always will. read more

We ate a late lunch here on January 1st after helping CAS and Gravy move into their new place. Wife began with chicken liver mousse with cornichon, pickled onion slices and grilled bread. Perfect! I began with the burratta cheese with beets and chopped nuts. Uh....perfect too! Her main was their mac and cheese which they topped with pulled pork. instead of the usual lobster. I didn't get to taste it but it smelled and looked great. I had the Tt Wagyu Burger with bacon-onion jam, white cheddar & hand cut fries. I can't wait to visit CAS and Gravy so that I can have another! Great stop for lunch! read more

See all

We came to see Kevin James at the Music Hall and stopped in for a quick drink. The place was small, but cute. It was a bit crowded so we squeezed into a spot at the bar. The bar tender suggested a house cocktail and it was delicious. Food was very good also. Must stop here again! read more

Went here for the first time yesterday and the food was delicious! Everything we ordered was flavorful and the service was great, starting with making a reservation! Thanks for a great meal! We ordered the octopus app (sooo tasty), fried green tomato, tuna tartare, swordfish, seared tuna, and bronzini. read more

Delicious food, friendly & accommodating service. Love the decor as well. An overall great experience!

Dependable long term spot with outdoor & indoor dining won us over for weekend lunch during Covid. Quick service & perfect protocols score them highest marks. Truly delicious satisfiying Egg Mains. Warm friendly staff. Thanks guys read more

We had a very nice, relaxing and romantic birthday dinner here last night. We loved the ambiance. This spot used to house a favorite, northern Italian place, but we figured we'd give Tarry Tavern a try. We were not disappointed! Our appetizer was a delicious warm octopus dish with roasted potatoes. It was delightful, with perfectly tender octopus. It would have made a perfect dinner! For dinner I had the Stone Church Duck Breast. It was tender, juicy and was exactly what I wanted. I wish I had photographed it, it was so artfully arranged with the vegetables. He had the NY Strip Steak, also delicious, and was quite happy with it. Service was excellent. Our wine pairings were perfect, and the owner stopped by to speak with us. I highly recommend this restaurant. We plan on going back. read more

My husband and I had reservations for 6 o'clock on a Friday evening, before a concert at the Tarrytown Music Hall. We were seated promptly. The atmosphere is cozy and warm. The waitstaff was attentive. My husband ordered the Pinot Noir by the glass and I ordered the the Malbec. Both were quite acceptable. The Malbec was smooth. I had the salad greens as an appetizer. I wouldn't necessarily recommend it. It was fine for me because I wanted something lo- cal and something healthy. But some of the other appetizers looked delicious. My husband had the parmesan crusted gnocchi with prosciutto as his appetizer. I had to sample a tiny bite. It was delicious, especially the cream sauce. The presentation was pretty as well. For my entrée I had salmon and red quinoa. It was very flavorful. I like my salmon cooked well, even though that is probably not the correct way to eat it, and it was cooked exactly per my request. My husband had the New York strip steak with spinach and scalloped potatoes. He said it was also very tasty. It was cooked perfectly. For dessert we shared the lemon ricotta tart. It came topped with strawberries and Milano cookie. It was as delicious as it was pretty. My husband had coffee, which she said was not the greatest, and I had peppermint tea. The entire bill with tax came to $114. We felt that was very reasonable considering we each had an appetizer, each had a glass of wine, and shared dessert. We've had much less for much more. We would definitely come back here again. It was delightful. read more

I would love to write a review. I called to make a reservation, and was told that they don't take reservations in October on the weekends. That should be stated on their website. As well, I asked if I came, do they put names on a list and he could not answer me. I was told that they are so busy, that you could come but he couldn't even tell me what a normal wait time would be. I said an hour / an hour and a half and he indicated maybe more, and couldn't guarantee I would get a table. I was willing to come and wait, but the gentleman seemed to dismiss that idea. I have never been so discouraged to go to a place. Good luck Tarry Tavern. I am sure there are other restaurants willing to be a little more accommodating. read more

Went for brunch with a friend and the food was perfect: the pumpkin squash soup was blended well and the Chicken Milanese salad was cooked to perfection. The chicken was cooked so tender I thought it was fish ! Only downside a little pricey but with quality comes price read more

Tarry Tavern - Chicken Milanese - New American Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Have been there numerous times, the food is good and so is the service. Haven't been disappointed yet. Recommended dishes: Roasted Beets & Mache salad, Chicken Liver Mousse, Roasted Potato Gnocchi, any of their soups, pork chops pretty much everything. Oh yes, there are two menus tavern and restaurant and you can order from both read more

Nice enough people, but sadly terrible service. The restaurant was almost empty and tables were left covered in garbage. Food was low average and overpriced. read more

Tarry Tavern - New American Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

We had a date night tonight at Tarry Tavern tonight. I recommend booking reservations as there were only seats at the bar when we walked in. The food was overpriced and only okay. I had the strip steak which was one of the more expensive items on the menu it had a good flavor but was too dry and over cooked. It was served with potatoes which were in a weird block like shape they were not very good. The spinach that was also served on the side was super super garlicky. I love garlic but this was way too much. I wouldn't eat here again. read more

I had a $26 steak salad that came with 4 small pieces of steak precooked. terrible. never going back

Wonderful food, creative but not pretentious, nice little venue, friendly staff, and nice and close to the Tarrytown Music Hall if you happen to be going there as we were. Parking in Tarrytown is no joy, but at least at 5pm on a Sunday we had no trouble. We had some delicious butternut squash soup and a mixed greens salad for appetizers, salmon and scallops entrées, and two just- right desserts. Nothing to complain about! Hope to eat here again soon. read more

Tarry Tavern - Atlantic salmon entree mmmm. - New American Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

Started off wonderfully!! Water never emptied, the two guys were very professional until an older lady (I can only assume the owner) came to our table, My friend and I were still eating she lifted the plates glasses everything mid eating and handed us the check and waited by the table for us to pay! From what I can gather it's a very local spot which is fantastic as staff knew most people by name.... But just a heads up to management... maybe don't sit "randomers" at regulars tables and rush them when said regular arrives!!! Just left a sour taste in our mouths and highly doubt to return but have already made plans to return to tarry town next weekend with a group as a lot of other places looked fun!! read more

The service was very good and very quick. The portions are a great size, and they have a good variety on the menu. It's a cute location for people watching. read more

Dropped by on a Monday evening visit when a number of other local restaurants were closed and had a really wonderful meal. Started with great cocktails and then shared 3 appetizers and wine. Great food, drinks, service, and atmosphere. read more

See all

This is a perfect spot to come with the family so come with the family I did! I had a burger with onion jam that was so amazing, juicy, and meaty, and I stole the blue cheese from my mom's salad to put on my burger, which I also loved. I replaced the usual fries with a salad because I'm healthy like that and also because the taste buds were in the mood to digest some leaves. Great choice. It was so balanced and I left full, but not roll-out-the-door full. I will gladly return to try other items from the menu. And your bathrooms are really nice. Nice job. read more

Tarry Tavern - New American Near Me - Tarrytown, New York

See all

Okay, this place is a gem! We were visiting from the West coast (staying in Manhattan) and took the train to Tarrytown...the atmosphere is quiet friendly but the food is amazing!!! Cauliflower soup, Stake salad (no meat for me) and mac & cheese with lump crabmeat though out. You will love it! read more

See all