The Smith
Order The Smith Takeout or Delivery
The Smith Photos
Business Info
THE SMITH ATMOSPHERE
You might also consider
Recommended Reviews - The Smith
Start your review...
Reviews With Photos
The food, service and vibe was great. I kept it simple, 2 French 75s and avocado toast. I usually go to the Lincoln Center location but this was a nice change of pace.
Fun spot to grab drinks after dinner! Over all a great experience we sat outside the line for another bar wraps around the block so just was a little weird, people were just standing outside next to us to our table, but not the bars is fault. Tried the Caprese martini and cucumber cooler will definitely be back to have dinner!
We came here over the weekend and the food was so good! We both got a burger and truffle fries with some drinks and everything was absolutely delicious! The truffle fries were so good and appetizing, we ate it all super quickly! The place is huge and has ample spacing for a lot of people to sit and eat. However it definitely does get crowded, so we sat at the bar and it felt so much better. The service was really good and we got our food and drinks super quickly!
Came here for a quick and super rushed dinner at the end of the night because we had drink reservations to get to and this food was absolutely delicious. Because we were rushing, we decided to order a quick impossible burger which was easy to eat and chug down. Fries were FIRE! Our friends ordered entrees and they looked SOOOOO good and couldn't stop raving about them. Everything looks fresh and delicious. Can't wait to come back and enjoy the hype of The Smith, especially for brunch! All this to say, that even on a rush, the food here is amazing.
Great service. Great food. Gluten free options. They were meticulous with our allergy food order. Very comforting. The drinks were lovely. We had Gatsby and Bloody Mary. Miso Salmon was a bit salty but yummy. The signature burger was delicious. A great option for a meal when you are in the city
Location is very cool. Inside or outside on the broadway is amazing. The personale is very gentle and sympa I had a beer and The smith burger and a is very delicious. Service is good. Take a little bit to long for the food but is summer time and is quite full. Nice location. I will go back for sure.
Ambiance is nice, but LOUD. Great place for larger parties, so the noise makes sense. I don't think the wait staff is inattentive, but they cover large areas, so it just takes them awhile to fulfill requests. Mac n Cheese hands down was the best dish I ordered. It was perfectly cheesy, with a delicious crisp cheese layer on top, gooey cheese inside, and served at the perfect temperature. I ate half of it before touching anything else. The chicken nuggets are made from dark meat and are tender and juicy, but do not have much flavor without the Asian sauce. The shishito peppers are cooked perfectly, but I didn't love the mayonnaise-esque sauce they were smothered. The flavor of the peppers was so good with just the spices that I scraped as much of the sauce off as I could. I would go back to try the burger that everyone writes such god reviews about!
Love this location of The Smith. The restaurant layout is so cool and open. It was a super cold day so I ordered some coffee, which was decent. The table ordered the Calamari and the roasted tomato soup as starters. The Calamari was tender and flavored well. The soup was okay, I wasn't the biggest fan of the cheese but thats just a preference. The fish sandwich was so fresh. The salad on top of the chicken was so seasoned so well. The food overall, was good. My waiter was so sweet and brought me a chocolate chip cookie for my bday! It was a great day!
Overall, I enjoyed the Smith. The atmosphere is very lively, the service was great, and the food pretty good. I know they're known for their cocktails, but after 3 days of drinking at every meal, I was boozed out. I loved that they keep bottles of sparkling water at the table. I was downing it I ordered the pasta with short rib and my daughter ordered the vodka rigatoni with added shrimp. While I liked both, both needed salt. I'm not someone who typically salts my food beyond a recipe. I don't even own a salt shaker. But our pasta was a bit bland. All that said, my short ribs were cooked perfectly. I never know if I'm going to regret ordering short ribs because sometimes they are chewy or stringy. These were "melt in your mouth" perfect We couldn't help but order chocolate cake before we left. It's a love of my daughter's. I took several bites. Layered with mouse and topped with ganache, it was quite decadent. I couldn't have eaten the whole thing. --too rich. But really delicious. Very shareable.
The chopped salad is incredible! Will definitely order again! Service was a little slow but they were PACKED!
We were looking for a brunch spot that could seat a large group. This place came up and it was opentable accessible. They have ample seating both indoor and outdoor! They have lots of unique brunch specials. The one that caught everyone's eyes was the vodka sauce eggs! It comes with 2 baked eggs and a creamy vodka sauce. It also has some spinach on the side to add a little healthiness to it. They start you off with a table side bread and butter while you wait for your meal. I got the rancheros. It has beans, avacodo and jalapeños to add a little kick. It was a little excessive on the cilantro taste but they have a homemade salsa that balances it better. The kids enjoyed the butter pasta, and the macaroni and cheese was also devoured. Other kids loved the fluffy buttermilk pancakes. The bathroom is downstairs which is a little annoying but they have a cool little photo booth and neat shared vibe. The service was nice and fast and pretty attentive. The prices are not too bad for a nyc restaurant either.
My friend recommended The Smith as a NYC must try. We came after our hyrox event and were famishes so stakes were high. I got the citybird mocktail, oysters, and the prime rib pasta. The oysters were scrum, a bit on the pricier side but can't really complain about a good oyster. I loved the pasta. I'm not usually one to order pasta out but our waiter recommended it and he did not fail me. It was the perfect al dente and the ragu was rich and meaty. My friend got a burger with truffle fries and she enjoyed her meal as well. The interior was pretty and could easily be a casual dinner or something more. I appreciated our server's recommendations and knowledge of the menu. The service was quite attentative, with other servers also stepping in to help refill waters and clear plates throughout dinner.
I have mixed feelings about The Smith, but three stars feels fair -- maybe even a touch generous. We booked a table for eight for a family brunch to celebrate my wife's 40th, so expectations were (understandably) high. Let's start with what they absolutely get right. The ambiance is fantastic -- very 1920s, F. Scott Fitzgerald energy -- and it works. The interior design team clearly put serious thought into creating something transportive and polished. It feels intentional, not accidental. The cocktails? Genuinely phenomenal. The Oaxacan Sunshine was a standout -- bright, balanced, and memorable. My wife's Frozen Pool Party tasted like something straight out of a Death & Co. mixology finals round. Creative, refined, and just plain fun. The food was also impressive. The menu strikes a nice balance between healthier options and indulgent brunch staples, and everything we ordered delivered both in flavor and presentation. Which is why it's frustrating to say the service didn't live up to the rest of the experience. We were seated at a table set with visibly dirty dishes -- traces of butter still on the plates. I quietly mentioned it to the server. He inspected them, said nothing, removed them... and never brought replacements or acknowledged the miss. No quick apology, no "we'll fix that right away," nothing. It made me wonder how dishes leave the kitchen that way, washed by one person, set by another, without anyone noticing. It felt either like a simple mistake or a breakdown in attention to detail. And on a milestone birthday brunch, that lack of care stands out. The Smith has the atmosphere, the drinks, and the food to be exceptional. I just wish the service matched the level of everything else.
Stopped by for a quick bite and glad I got there at noon! Because by the time we finished there was a huge line out the door and many of the tables were filled! Ordered the veggie bibimbap, came out in a hot stone bowl mixed with loads of veggies and egg on top. Delicious! Would absolutely order again. Overall get there early if you want to get a table for lunch! read more
Went for dinner tonight. The place is very nice and also in a safe part of the City. We were staying just across the street at the Broadway Plaza. Inside is very loud and a little too much for us older folks. We chose to sit outside and it was a perfect spot to chat and also people watch which is always fun. The food was very good and even though a $26.00 burger and fries is a bit on the pricey side. I would do it again next time. read more
11 months ago
I had this place in mind as a popular place for brunch with lots of reviews, and was glad to secure a table for my party of 7 for a Saturday girls' brunch. Everyone had to be present to be seated, but even so it took a bit to be brought to our table. Our server was a bit spotty with coming to our table and was hard to find when we needed her to place an extra order/drink and ask for napkins/the check. The portion size was pretty decent, but it is on the pricier side for brunch. The eggs benedict didn't have the usual bread/carb for its base which was interesting, but it was still filling. Very, very spacious! Vibe was a typical American restaurant. There are more restrooms in the basement. read more
1 year ago
11 months ago
2 years ago
2 years ago
10 months ago
The Smith never disappoints. The atmosphere hits that perfect balance of lively and welcoming--you feel the energy as soon as you walk in. The standout of the night was the shrimp scampi. It was absolutely fantastic: perfectly cooked shrimp, bright flavors, and a sauce you'll be thinking about long after the meal. If you're looking for a spot that delivers both great vibes and seriously good food, this place is an easy choice. read more
Deep menu, the food quality ranges from fair to excellent, depending upon what you order. The oysters and seafood tower was superb, very fresh, and the sauces that accompany it were delightful. Fabulous Wait staff. read more
2 years ago
10 months ago
2 years ago
Friday at 8:20ish we were walking looking for restaurant and we had a small 14lb dog with us so needed something with outdoor seating . Got seated fast outdoors ... Waitress was very good, attentive and I wish I knew her name but she was tall with reddish brown hair as I recall... Party of 4 that included 2 adults me & bestie, daughter and dog.. The calamari was amazing appetizer. Dinner we Shared the Mediterranean salad with shrimp which was a good size, Salmon dinner and dessert hot fudge sundae that I'm still dreaming about ... lol Everything was yummy and definitely a must try in NYC !!! read more
2 years ago
Great food, and great service! The kids ate all of the burgers which rarely happens. The salad was phenomenal. read more
4 years ago
Had a great time at the Smith. Made a reservation online for 8:30 on a Saturday and seated promptly. It was particularly busy as it was the weekend but the service was exceptional nonetheless. We started off with the complimentary bread and butter. I then ordered the Mac and cheese and The Smith Steak with chimichurri sauce which was absolutely amazing. My friend ordered the Gatsby ( which was highly recommend) and a burger. Although they have multiple locations which I have been to, I think vibe in this location is great and unlike any other. I definitely recommend making a reservation beforehand as it can get pretty busy! read more
I am a huge fan of The Smith! I've been to other locations but have never been to this one. I normally get the normal benedict but decided to venture out and get the Johnny Benedict this time. I am sooo glad I did because it was absolutely delish! The Johnny consists of a cheddar jalapeño cornbread which sausage and tomato hollandaise sauce which was totally different. I felt that it activated taste buds I didn't even know I had! I paired it with an espresso martini which was also very delightful. This location is huge compared to the other locations I've been to. There are plenty of tables inside and outside and I was surprised it was pretty empty for brunch on a Saturday. The service was also great. I can't wait to come back! read more
For a chain I thought it was fantastic! It hit the spot!! My mom the spaghetti bolognese and it was excellent! My sister and I split a steak with salad and the meat was very good. We also had dessert, a hot fudge sundae but it had blueberries hidden inside which was not disclosed and not good. Also we asked for the bill to be split and good thing we checked because they DOUBLE charged us!! read more
1 year ago
This place is great. I got the calamari, oysters, and burger, and all of them were so impressive. Great ambiance and service too. I'll be back next time I'm in NYC! read more
3 years ago
I typically don't like brunch spots, but this really surprised me! I got the apple salad with chicken added, and all the flavors were super on point. The chicory, which I find often way too bitter, wasn't too strong at all, and provided a really nice crisp to the salad. The vinaigrette added a really nice tang, and contrasted well with the sweetened pecans. The gouda also wasn't overpowering for being goat milk based. The chicken was quite tender as well, which I really appreciated! Service was nice, but honestly a bit slow at times. We sat for ~10-15 minutes after finishing before our check was brought to us, but a minor detail in an otherwise great experience. Will definitely be back if I ever want a light lunch! read more
Unfortunately it was underwhelming. Would not recommend the espresso martini - should have known better because it was made with cold brew. Got the Benedict Johnny, and the cornbread was actually jalapeño cornbread which was not included on the menu. They were surprisingly spicy and I couldnt finish the small $22 skillet. Not the best choice. I'm glad my husband enjoyed his breakfast, specifically the potato waffle. He also got the wake up call which was named perfectly. Cute large restaurant and nice staff. read more
2 years ago
I love this restaurant its the second time ive been here. Everything was perfect. Alexander was an amazing waiter read more
2 years ago
Business lunches at The Smith are great. Kale salad is my go to. Service is quick and the level of noise is moderate. You can hear each other speak. Been going here for many years. Highly recommend. read more
3 years ago
2 years ago
Went to grab some some appetizers but the dessert was the best thing ever. Definitely coming back for the calamari and the dessert options. Excellent service and I like the ambiance. read more
4 years ago
After happy hour my 2 coworkers and I were starving. Instead of waiting for 30 minutes for a table we sat at the long high top which is shared with other patrons. For drinks we ordered a basil lemon drop and a lychee martini. Both drinks were really good. My basil lemon drop was really. It was refreshing and not sweet. I had the Mac and cheese, my other coworker had the ricotta gnocchi and the other had the smith burger. We all really liked our meals. My Mac and cheese was so good and really filling. I tried a gnocchi and it was tasty. I love the interior of the restaurant. Service was great and everything came out fast. I'm tempted to come back this weekend. read more
Dependable place for terrific service and food, they really know how to keep a crowd coming again and again! There's a reason this place (and its sister locations around the city and around the country--just looked at their website) have been around for years. They take traditional American dishes and give them a slightly elevated and sometimes seasonal spin, enough to distinguish them from your average meat or pasta dish but still retaining enough of--and keeping tight control on execution for--the original preparation to feel like comfort cooking. At 6:30pm on a Wednesday evening I came with a party of 6 with reservations. There were about 30 people waiting in the entrance area to be seated, no small task but also no problem since the restaurant is very large. The staff needs to be flagged down to take names though quite on top of the situation so we were able to be seated within 10-15 minutes of arriving, even though the remainder of our party hadn't yet arrived. Once seated our waiter came by with menus and came back to take drink orders in a timely fashion. Once the balance of our party arrived it took a bit of time to order since the restaurant was bustling though once we ordered food started coming in about 10-15 minutes post order. The honey crisp apple salad $17 was tasty with the bits of apple adding a sweet tartness that paired well with the apple cider vinaigrette. Another vegetarian friend ordered the burrata $18 which comes with overnight tomatoes and eggplant, a terrific interpretation of this classic. For mains a few ordered the chicken pot pie $28 which they all declared fantastic. I had the shrimp tagliatelle pasta $29 which came with squid ink pasta and chopped shrimp which I felt were just slightly overcooked but plentiful. The Smith burger $26 looked like a proper hearty burger and came with a good amount of fries. For dessert we shared the hot fudge sundae $14. The drinks menu consists of a variety of wines (by the glass or bottle), beers, and cocktails. Being a workday we skipped cocktails and did a glass of cab, malbec, pinot, a couple beers. Everyone enjoyed their drinks as well. Additional notes: The restaurant is able to accommodate food allergies if mentioned prior to ordering. They have a martini happy hour 3-6pm on weekdays and after 10pm. They were able to split the bill between 6 cards which we appreciated. read more
Attentive service, huge variety of drink and food options, and a nice modern interior. What more do you want? Had a work dinner here recently and it's funny I remembered walking into this spot on a whim years ago and that I had a great experience then. Well it was the same this time as well. The burger is excellent, perfect proportion of bun to ingredients to meat. Served with nice and crispy shoestring fries. For drinks, I had the spicy boulevardier - apple bitters really made this unique - and a blantons neat, but they have a huge list of drinks to whet your whistle. Check out The Smith. Definitely seems like one of those spots where you can order anything off the menu and not be disappointed. They are locked in the groove in terms of food quality, service, and an excellent space to take a load off and break bread. read more
The Smith was suggested as a meet up spot by my friends-I objected because it was far closer to where I was staying than where they lived but they insisted so I appreciated their efforts at accommodating me and made the short walk around the corner to meet them and their kids for Saturday breakfast. Ok, it was brunch but with two kids it's not really. Anyway, we got seated quickly-which is something to be said when it's a party of 5, two of them under drinking age and the non-couples were actually brunching. Our server was good, I was definitely impressed. He was quick to address us, was polite to the kiddos and rattled of his specials asked us if we wanted drinks and when we were hesitating he graciously let us have some time. He managed to come back at what seemed like the right time and we ordered. I got the Shrimp and Grits and I wasn't expecting a whole lot. I mean, The Smith is one of those places that was always 'good enough.' I was surprised by the size and number of shrimp, and how it worked in. I also had a beer and then easily ordered another. I have to say, my visit here definitely made me think that The Smith has stepped up its game a bit since I lived in NY. Maybe that's why they're expanding into other cities pretty rapidly. read more
This is a great spot for a work lunch, in and out within 1.5 hours, the service was very timely and the atmosphere was busy but not so noisy that you cant have a conversation with coworkers or friends. They had some great menu options for those looking to stay on the healthier side but also some other comfort classics that we enjoyed. The food was an 8/10. The sauce with the Brussel sprouts was tangy and great, the chicken sandwich and fries were also pretty good but they didn't have ranch!!!! My part also really enjoyed the salmon and the different salad options. Overall great place, I would definitely go again, and hopefully try to drinks selection. read more
6 months ago
The best vegetarian banh mi I've ever had! It had the same flavors and texture (you know, that crispy toasted bread with a medley of veggies and soft meat), as a traditional banh mi sandwich. Even the Shirley temples were elevated. The service was excellent and ambiance cool. Think old school New York restaurant with heavy wood and black/white cafeteria-style tiles on the floor. This place was bomb and I will definitely be back to try more items on their menu. read more
2 years ago
I thought the brunch I had with my group was excellent. Espresso martini to start and the breakfast sandwich were super delicious. My party had some food allergies and the staff and manager were super great about ensuring there would be no issues and that was so appreciated by my friends. Thank you for your hospitality. read more
Considering that we went on the Sunday before Christmas, we were seated quickly enough, despite the fact that they were getting slammed. The shrimp and grits kind of had a northern twist to them. They were very cheesy, and the grits themselves were not very coarse almost a little soupy. The Caesar salad with the salmon was delicious. The lettuce was crisp, and the salmon was fresh and nicely seasoned one star off in the ambience department, it was extremely loud and difficult to converse with my party and patrons were seated very close together. Other than that, The Smith delivered a memorable Sunday brunch in NYC read more
1 year ago
More info about The Smith
1150 Broadway
New York, NY 10010
Flatiron
Directions
(212) 685-4500
Call Now
Order Delivery
Start Order
Visit Website
http://thesmithrestaurant.com
Full menu
Hours
Payment methods
Food & Alcohol
Services
Indoor Amenities
Outdoor Amenities
Other Amenities
From the Business
More Info
Health Score
The Smith Reviews in Other Languages
Ask the Community - The Smith
Hi is there a private room for about 50 people?
Not that I've seen. You should call and ask
On weekdays (M-F), until what time do they serve breakfast? Do they also serve brunch, if so what time? Thanks!
I would call and ask or look at their website.
What time is brunch served till on a Saturday?
Not sure; opens at 9:30 an till 1am I believe. Great place, phone # (212) 685-4500 enjoy!!!
Do they have any area good for a semi-private party? Maybe a 15 person bridal shower brunch to make a reservation for noon on a Saturday?
You'll be fine if they're not already booked!!! Good luck.
You might also consider
Why does Yelp recommend reviews?
72 reviews that are not currently recommended
The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.
9 years ago
8 years ago
3 years ago
9 years ago
10 years ago
7 years ago
2 years ago
3 years ago
9 years ago
3 years ago
7 years ago
1 year ago
5 years ago
2 years ago
7 years ago
2 years ago
1 year ago
9 years ago
8 years ago
