Delicious food and service. Not great ambiance, but the food made up for that. Extensive menu and everyone was very happy!

Stellar experience here. They weren't making slices this late in the evening, so the guy made me a mini-pie with 2 slices worth, had it ready in the blink of an eye. Top marks, chill place. Not pretentious, just good food that nails the New Haven style. read more

Town pizza is a place you want to go for great pizza burgers salads and yummy lamb off the spit!!!! A nostalgic place . This is a old school small family restaurant that's been around for 40 years !!!! The owners are kind gentle honest caring people and funny I recommend Pizza Fries are yummy burgers are legit n huge and all of the Greek dishes are real comfort foods. Try this place out !!!! read more

Town Pizza Restaurant - Classic CheeseBurger and Fries . Perfect fresh bun - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Moved from CT in 1991. Have been a Pepe's customer since the 1970's. Back home for family event. Ordered two medium pies ($48!!). Upon arrival for pick up was summarily directed to The Spot restaurant next door. I understand it is a Pepe's restaurant. It's been there for years. It is not the Pepe's I expected. Pies were ok but not the Pepe's I remember. Why do they not ask you or tell you when ordering? I saw other takeout coming from within Pepe's Disappointing - to say the least. Won't happen a 2nd time for sure. Sally's and Modern are close by. read more

Great sauce! Had a Calzone, and a Pizza slice. Both were too thin, but very tasty! There sauce is PERFECT, and I will go back. Just hoping they add a little more doe to their pizza & calzones. read more

Owner of Town Pizzapreparing Valentine'sbags for Yale college students holiday treats Many small businesses and family owned restaurants have been hit sooooo HARD during these unimaginable circumstances. This guy and his wife work so hard everysingle day just to keep open. Doing all the jobs basically on there own just to keep the business afloat, like so many out there struggling with the same circumstances please support your local restaurants. This place has been here since 1987. When I was a kid I used to go there and get the biggest slices of pizza with my mom after coming out of clay class at Audubon Street neighborhood music school. They still have the biggest slices of pizza just like they did back then and it's only $5.50+tax for TWO&OMG U CANT FIND THAT ANYWHERE ANYMORE AND IF U DONT SUPPORTER U NEVER WILL AGAIN Please support them their food is awesome. It's not like the mainstream restaurants nowadays with small portions and process type taste this is homemade great size portions for your money with personal touches you will not get that anywhere except for small family-owned restaurants. #supportlocalrestaurants read more

See all

Stumbled upon Town Pizza while on my way to a museum. The service was okay. Nothing extra from the waitress just bare minimum service. Didn't even get a water refill. Pizza was pretty good. It was a really large slice. I ordered the pizza and salad lunch combo. Salad was just an average house salad. This place was okay but after reading more reviews, I should have tried the pasta instead. Also the customer restroom is terrible. You have to walk downstairs to get to this creepy restroom. read more

Town Pizza Restaurant - Cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

First time and last. Didn't feel welcomed, felt rushed to place order. Too pricey for the portion and quality of food. Steak and cheese sub was bland, size small and thin for the price, only 4 tiny pieces of tomatoes, and the steak looked/tasted like fake steak ummm from the store. The pizza slices were bland as well, more dough than anything else, and sauce was sweet like store Ragu. It definitely didn't feel as if we were eating from a real pizzeria. Do not recommend. Next time, I'd give Costa Pizza a first time visit. I'm pretty sure they will be much better. read more

AMAZING PIZZA!!! Owner is super awesome and staff is great. I got the chicken/broccoli and it was obvious the chicken was actually legit, roasted and shredded chicken, not some frozen processed chicken. I have had plently of pizza in my day, and I always love coming here when Im in the area read more

**I am unsure why this place is in YELP 2x? But here is my review**** As said by the previous reviewer, this place is NOT to be overlooked. I can't believe I have been coming here for well over 3 years and never reviewed or even checked in. Oh well here goes nothing! The inside of this place could use a re-vamp but seriously who cares when the food is so good. I have never had the pizza, just salads, wraps and gyro's and they are ALL amazing. The portions are HUGE especially if you dine in, they almost give you family style salad portions. They are all fresh and made to order, and they even have a all you can eat salad and soup bar located on the top level. All of the local people and workers in the dt area always frequent this place and it really is the "go to spot" for lunch! If you have jury duty, it is a great place to go for a quick meal if you have to be back to the courthouse. I love this place and I go 1x every 2 weeks :) read more

Town Pizza Restaurant - a plate of salad and a bagel - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

The spaghetti and meatballs here were saucy, well seasoned, and overall very filling. They come with a salad and complimentary cheesy garlic bread. Overall I was very satisfied with what I ordered, and I would definitely come again to try more of what they have in their menu (which is A LOT). Great service too! read more

Town Pizza Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Great pizza! And very friendly. All the other restaurants wouldn't let my daughter use their bathroom, and town did. Thanks

Great pizza ... super friendly staff . I would recommend this place to everyone . On a cold day the hot food was just what I needed. They even let me stay longer till my ride came to get me as I live in Middletown .. GREAT PLACE read more

Wi-fi? No. Televisions? No. Trendy decor? No. Hipster crowd? No. Great pizza slices? Yes! You will be forced to talk to whoever you brought in with you. I know, crazy concept to look up from your phone or phaplet. Do you even know what your girlfriend looks like android/apple boy? Admittedly, this place is kind of depressing. If it was not for Yelpers, I probably would not have ever gone in. Was here from 7:30 to 8pm on a Friday night, and I am the only one that has walked through the door. The store front is not very welcoming, and the interior may not have been renovated since the 70's, or 80's. All that aside, the two pizza slices and a soda for only $5 was great. Note: This review is ONLY about the pizza slices. I dont take stars away from eateries, unless they are dirty, or hire idiots. This place was clean, and had a very nice older lady taking orders. Cmon yelpers, give this place some love so they can have more than one customer at 8pm on a Friday night. read more

This place is SO GOOD. We got the chicken kebab plate with the Greek salad and dolma (grape leaves). The yogurt sauce it came with tasted fresh and bright. The kebab was freshly made, juicy, and well seasoned-- it tasted like home cooking. The meal was healthy too with a lot of good veggies. This is a great place to grab lunch or dinner. The portion is generous with two large kebab. I will definitely be back!! Staff were also super friendly and inviting. read more

I love Town Pizza- incredibly nice owners and great food to boot! Always speedy service for takeout, too. Would recommend to all my friends!

I'm blown away, and also saddened. Blown away by the amazing food I've received here, and saddened that I spent so many days just walking by. The outside of this restaurant is non-descript, and nothing really says, "hey you, come inside for an awesome meal". However, once you take that step through the door, you're greeted by the wonderful aroma of roasting meat, crispy pizza and fresh cooked meals. I didn't come here by choice, my first option was closed, so I decided to give it a try and I'm glad I did. Day one was a Gyro. Juicy and tender, with a perfect fluffy pita. Topped with fresh vegetables & tzatziki. It didn't automatically come with feta, which I was a little bummed about, but the sandwich was fantastic. Ask for feta if you're a fan. Day two (of course back-to-back because it was that good), was the lamb platter. I'm not sure what prompted me to order lamb, since i'm not a huge fan, but this place has me wanting seconds & thirds... Paired with a delicious greek salad, and some lemon flavored rice. Tzatziki & pita for dipping. This is a new office favorite & i'm happy it's close by... read more

Was very happy to find this hole-in-the wall pizza joint (one I never visited during my bright college years, that's for sure) after a morning at the Peabody. No-frills, thin crust pizza, decent hoagie sandwiches, and large salads. Tried a number of things: pizza, eggplant parm and buffalo chicken grinder. All were serviceable (though the grinder was a bit greasy), and the pizza was a really pleasant surprise. Thin, crispy/chewy crust and good ratio of topping to crust. But tomato sauce tasted like it came from a can - sorry! Still, my better half said it tasted better than Pepe's. Blasphemy, I know. Service was more than pleasant, especially given the large crowd I was with. Lovely waitstaff and nice guy making the pizzas. Thank you for being so nice to us! Parking was fine. It was a Saturday and I got metered parking right in front in an hour space on Whitney Ave. They do ticket aggressively (go New Haven cops), so beware! read more

Delicious offerings. My wife insists I pick up there whenever in the neighborhood. Friendly and social people wHo work hard. Fair prices!

This is not the most attractive decor for eating in But, the food is really consistently excellent. Their catering is teriffic. Based on a strong recommendation we had Nick supply us with a pizza picnic for 25 in Wooster Square park. He gave us two teriffic salads lots of pizza pies in all different varieties (including,believe it or not, a delicious mashed potatoes and bacon white pie),drinks,cookies,a table all delivered. Our international group is pretty sophisticated and couldn't rave enough. Good food, good services and lots of smiles from Nick Bravo read more

Manager was very rude!! Needs to improve his customer service!!! The wife which who was the one doing all the work was very nice !!!

This place is so good. The waitress was very attentive, and very kind. We were seated in seconds, I ordered the buffalo chicken pizza and it was amazing, the crust was thin and perfect. The cook and the waitress are amazing people and very humble. read more

Note: This is only for take-out slices of pizza. I've never had lunch here, and from reading the reviews, sit down experiences seem better. That being said, I had a seriously negative experience. Stopped by here on a weekday night at around 8:30. Ordered a slice of pizza to line my stomach during the rest of my walk to East Rock. Mind you, I've never thought one could have a 'bad' slice of pizza-- but I experienced it that night (and i was slightly tipsy too-- so it would've been hard to meet a pizza I didn't like at that point). Anyhow, this could be due to the fact that new haven pizza (perhaps due to the thin crust?) never seems to travel well. everytime I've gone to Modern's or sally's, the pizza the day after is a sad shadow of its fresh glory. This is what this slice I ordered tasted like. It was really greasy, soggy, salty-- almost impossible to eat with your hands). And honestly, it just tasted like grease. I didn't finish it-- it wasn't worth it (I think maybe one of the few slices of pizza I have ever thrown away). The workers there seemed really nice, and I'm sure actual pizzas and full meals (that they can prepare individually for you, instead of re-heating) are probably way better; but I will avoid getting individual slices from here. It was kinda scarring... read more

Always a great experience when you go to Town Pizza. The servers are friendly and the food is great. I have yet to have anything that was subpar because the owner, Nick is in the kitchen and I doubt he would send anything out that wasn't right. read more

We ordered some vegetarian pizza from Town Pizza for student group meeting today. The delivery was fast, the pizza was warn, and it tasted really good! I think this might be the best delivery pizza that I have ever ordered in new haven. read more

We both had shawarma - chicken for me and lamb for the husband. Both were very good - fresh ingredients, perfectly prepared. Great service! If I were a local, I'd make a habit of coming here. Reasonably priced too. read more

Town Pizza Restaurant - a plate of fries and a sandwich - Pizza Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Thought the food is going to be terrible because of the interior, but the staff is great, super friendly. The pizza is pretty good too crispy crust good bbq sauce, will definitely recommend. read more

New Haven isn't exactly the city that never sleeps -- thus, when visiting a friend, our options for semi-late evening food seemed fairly limited. We stumbled in here and it was empty. A nearly toothless woman took our order. The pizza was somewhere between okay and not really all that okay, HOWEVER they gave us this little appetizer thing -- kind of like a very thin crusted pizza crusted with olive oil and garlic. And it was by far the highlight of the meal. read more

This review is mainly for Town Pizza's lunch options. The pizza is pretty mediocre (sauce is too sweet, and I wish they complemented their strong Greek menu with actual Greek pizza instead of a weak attempt at a thin crust), but the salads and other menu items are great. I usually like to have lunch at my desk so I can get some extra work done, but Town Pizza has a soup and salad bar buffet on weekdays from 11-2:30, and I've come to look forward to the days when my friends who work in the immediate vicinity can meet up for lunch here. The salad bar is wonderful - fresh lettuce mix options with the usual salad bar fixings like bacon, hard boiled eggs, and assorted veggies, plus really good grilled chicken, buffalo chicken, tuna, stuffed grape leaves, quality housemade croutons, pasta salad, fruit, and cottage cheese. There are two soups (sometimes three) to choose from, and an assortment of rolls and stuffed breads. Today I had a big salad with all the fixings, chili, rolls, and stuffed bread - all for just under $8. Prices are great all around, and portions are very generous whether you eat there or order takeout. This isn't a place I would drive out of my way to if I weren't already in the area, but I'm very glad that it's within walking distance for me and available for my regular lunch rotation. read more

Delicious, fresh, high-quality food, generous portions, and very reasonable pricing! The staff is very friendly & attentive too. Not fancy, but a great place for a casual meal or takeout. I work nearby and often get the Greek Salad to go. Warm, freshly baked rolls & garlic knots too - totally worth eating carbs :) read more

oversalted BBQ chicken pizza, OK tomato basil. I liked the thin crust, but the dough itself wasn't that good. better than i expected though since i hadn't heard of this place before today. it reminded me of pizza at kitchen zinc read more

My favorite pizza place in New Haven. One of the things I will miss the most from just having moved away from there. The people are welcoming, nice, and it feels like true family-owned restaurant. The owner is friendly and always said hi to me. The pizza is yummy and has a good bread to cheese ratio. Their jalapeño pizza was great. read more

Don't let the exterior fool you, this restaurant has excellent food inside. After leaving Manhattan, I thought I'd never find a restaurant/diner with such variety. The Greek specialties are delicious, and the burgers are not greasy at all. You can substitute French fries for onion rings, and that's a big plus. Along the same strip of Whalley Avenue, restaurants come and go, and Town Pizza Restaurant has been in the same location for nearly forty years! read more

I only get chicken Cesar salad from here but it is the best. i usually do take out as well. The portions are big and the ingredients are fresh. The chicken is grilled and has a delicious charcoal taste! Ask for their rolls too! read more

We stopped by to grab some quick takeout one night. The young man in the front was so friendly and helpful. The older gentleman who I think might be the owner was also very nice. We ordered a small pizza and a veal parm w spaghetti. The portion was huge. The food was good. It even came with a salad! read more

Such a good find on Whtney St. Best Greek food in New Haven in my opinion. Terrific Greek Salad. Souvlakis, gyros, and the mousakka are really really tasty. Their other menu items equally well prepared and delicious....hamburgers for example. Service is good and servings are ample. I get Greek dishes often in their places and Town is the best so far in New Haven. read more

I love this place! I come here at least a few times a week. Staff is friendly, food is delish what more can you ask for? They have so many different things on the menu. Give them a try! read more

Came in for a slice and and drink and was very pleased. Waitress was very charming as I sat at the counter for my quick bite

Food here is excellent I have eaten here a few times now I have even ordered small pies to take home and freeze for the day I can't make it down there, 15 mins in the oven and it's great. I have had other meals there and they are great as well, the Greek salad is amazing, there is a nice choice of beers including some local ones. It is like the old neighborhood pizza place. You can't go wrong !!!!!! read more

Amazing food and wonderful people. We have visited three times in three days, and both the breakfast pizza and wraps have been amazing. They clearly use very fresh ingredients. This is my new favorite restaurant for both delivery and takeout. read more