Last night my kids came in from North Carolina and all they could talk about always when coming to Connecticut is Capotorto's Pizza. Their flight was delayed and when we went to call Capotorto's. We were four minutes over the 8:40 pm cut off. Speaking with the kind gentlemen, letting him know that all my kids have been asking for is Capotorto's. He said come on in. I was so appreciative that he stayed a little later. Satisfied my children's cravings and let us have a wonderful night together. Thank you. Capotorto's. Your pizza rate BEST!!! read more

Capotorto's Apizza Center - Now THIS is a pizza!!! - Pizza Near Me - East Haven, Connecticut

I absolutely love this little piece of East Haven. It absolutely represents East Haven and everything that makes it great. It has amazing Italian food, a sweet dessert section and hot chicken wings. The young employees there fit the culture perfectly. They are young, caring and nice. I have eaten here even though I typically take out. They have three little tables to eat at and a cute outdoor section to eat at. read more

See all

Great friendly service! Excellent food. Good prices... It's such a a nice place to have a good meal out on the terrace. You can bring your own beer/ wine. I love that. Their tomato sauce is so delicious. Their tomatos are from California...you can taste the difference. I'll DEFINITELY go back! read more

Capotorto's Apizza Center is a New Haven-style pizzeria that opened in East Haven, Connecticut in 2003. It was founded by Ralph Capotorto. The Capotorto Family plays a large role in Greater New Haven's rich pizza history. Family patriarch Antonio "Tony" Capotorto immigrated to Connecticut from Italy in the early 1960s when he was just 20 years old. After serving in the military, he decided to open his own pizzeria. Tony opened The Apizza Center in Fairfield in 1968 and he would continue to operate it for 3 decades. Tony's sons (including Ralph) worked there over the years and became talented pizzaioli in their own right. Ralph trained and worked as an HVAC technician for a number of years before he finally decided to return to his culinary roots. Following the closure of the original Apizza Center, Ralph decided to open his own and continue the Capotorto family legacy. Ralph's best friend Scott Hartley (who also worked and trained at the original Apizza Center) opened his own pizzeria, The Nauti Dolphin, in Fairfield in 1983. Younger brother Nick Capotorto relocated to New Mexico around 2000 and opened his own Apizza Center in 2020. My family and I recently sampled some pies from Capotorto's Apizza Center. My wife was the first one to sample their pizza her job ordered some pies from there for a work pizza party. She was really impressed with the pizza and a short time later she surprised the rest of us by grabbing some take-out. The pies that we all enjoyed were a "Plain Tomato Pie", the "East Haven Masher" (mashed potatoes made with heavy cream, scallions and bacon), and the "Route 80 Commuter" (classic white pie buttered with ricotta cheese & topped with grilled chicken, sun dried tomatoes, fresh garlic & just the right spice). Crispy crunch with a good amount of char, good sauce, and excellent toppings! We were all very impressed. We look forward to ordering their pizza again! read more

See all

I used to come here all the time. the first time I got food poisoning I didn't think much of it but the second i knew for sure it was because of their food. read more

We ordered a Large Sausage and Pepper pizza with a large house salad. I was told the price was $33 and some change. Well when delivered it was a cheese pizza and when I called back she said this is what we ordered which is not true. she had me repeat the order to her twice!! when I called back she was not pleasant this is the one time I wish the calls were recorded!! not to mention she didn't mention the delivery fee. I will never order again from this place. read more

Was searching for stuffed breads that were well made and tasted great! Tried several different restaurants and was surprised to find Capotorto's right down the street. Have ordered several times and have been pleasantly impressed! Good ratio of bread to ingredients, always fresh and ready on time! Everyone's taste is subjective, my family and I enjoy their breads and will continue to purchase them here! Happy eating read more

Ordered take out from here tonight. A small meatball pizza, baked ziti, and dessert. Everything was hot and delicious! Ziti came with a side salad and italian bread. We also had a hard time deciding on dessert but got a slice of resees pie and chocolate cake. The cake was dry/stale? But very chocolatey. Resees pie was delicious! read more

See all

My take on Capotorto's is that it is a hidden gem of an apizza spot. While in New Haven I wanted to try some apizza but Modern had an insane line, I'd already been to Franks (which probably also had a crazy line) and Sally's wasn't open yet. So, I started heading back home looking for an apizza place and luckily stumbled across Capotorto's. We ended up being the only people in the restaurant but that perfect. We decided to go with a medium sausage and pepperoni and it was great. Between the two off us we ate the whole thing. I also grabbed a chocolate chip cookie on my way out and it was excellent as well. I have a few gripes but they are relatively minor. They have beer but I'd like to see a better selection. It was pretty boring stuff given what is available in the region and they only had bottles. Something on draft would be nice. Also, apparently, they only get one TV station. I asked if we could change the channel and watch some football and that was a no go. But neither of these would stop me from returning. All in all, it was a great experience and I'd absolutely return. read more

Capotorto's Apizza Center - Pizza Near Me - East Haven, Connecticut

I was excited to try this place based off the Yelp reviews. We called on a Sunday afternoon which is normally busy time at most places and were happy it was only 20 minutes to pick up. We ordered our usual, two small pizzas one extra cheese one chicken cutlet and our go to fried mootz. My bf hated the fried mootz. The sauce it was in either had too much onions/garlic or garlic powder. I would have also preferred a more simple sauce. My pizza loving bf also didn't finish his small cheese which never happens. This one won't make the rotation. read more

I have ordered from there once before and was so disappointed I thought I would try again. The boneless chicken wings are definitely not real chicken and my daughter found 2 pieces of black plastic in her Italian wedding soup, my grandson slice of pizza tasted like cardboard. I'm done I work hard for my money like we all do and when I called not even offered a gift card or how about just saying can we make you something else. I would have not accepted but the gesture would have went a long way. Very unhappy and hungry customer. read more

the prices are f*kn insane for the quality i'd look elsewhere. east/new haven is full of places that don't break the bank on one gd pizza from here (respectfully). pasta w no protein over $20???? insane. read more

Went to order a pizza for pickup and was told that I had to pay over the phone or they wouldn't take my order. I asked why this was as I live on the other side of town and have never been to this place before. The snarky little twit replied that "someone from this number ordered something and never picked it up". Firstly, I just GOT this number, secondly, blacklist a NAME, a PERSON, not a number that changes users more frequently than an STI changes hosts. Lastly, if you're in the business of serving people, be a people person! The cost of one pizza versus a repeat customer and generated goodwill and more revenue is just good business sense! 20/10 would not recommend. read more

I would highly recommend avoiding this place. The food is terrible. It will make you sick. I got some food from there. They're bacon is like bacon, bits, burnt, and smoky. It's like the place. Can't afford to put a regular piece of bacon on your food. They have to use some kind of grated bacon, which will give you, an offset stomach that's for sure so if you eat at this place, beware that you will most likely get sick so I would highly recommend avoiding this place and this is coming from an Italian guy in East Haven, Connecticut! Also, if you get the pizza there, the dough is sometimes not even cooked all the way it's like raw dough and don't ever order a calzone from there. They are awful. I'm telling you right now. I would go to John & MariaGia Marie's skip this place. And when you order a sandwich from there and you asked for onion, they don't specify that they're going to grill and sauté it so when you get a sandwich that you're expecting raw onion, which by default it should come as raw onion and if they're not sure they should ask the person before they take it upon themselves to give you whatever they want to give you. read more

The pizza was very good, the restaurant is remodeled, the staff is great, the atmosphere is nice. Authentic Italian pizza, food, ice cream, and cannolis. Would definitely return. read more

Capotorto's Apizza Center - Pizza Near Me - East Haven, Connecticut

Went there earlier today (technically yesterday, now), since I was in East Haven for the day, and bought a large pepperoni pizza. It was okay. The sauce was a bit too bitter, but aside from that it was a pretty good pizza. The crust was good, the cheese was pretty good (if a bit lighter than I'd prefer), and it had a good amount of pepperoni on it. Not really anything special, though. read more

This used to be the absolute best pizza spot. Lately the staff is so unprofessional. I ordered through their online service and it took almost 3 hours to arrive. It was cold, and overcooked. STAY AWAY AND SAFE YOUR MONEY read more

During this difficult time, our family enjoyed a movie day today and we decided to order pizza. Always being our first choice we called Capotortos for a delivery. Long story short, 1/2 hour later 3 piping hot pizzas were delivered to our door by Zach, a very professional and respectful young man! Our family enjoyed the very best pizza we have ever had!! I would like to thank the Capotortos for their great food and their wonderful service to all the East Haven residents! read more

Placed a delivery order at 6:15. Was told an hour. It's currently 8:51 still no food. At one point, I was told the driver is outside my house. No one outside my house. When I called back, I was told the order was "lost" and the delivery guy "just left" ..... yup... still waiting. I feel bad for the staff. Where's the management? I understand staffing difficulties in the restaurant industry. But if you can't fulfill your orders, then communicate that. Don't tell me the driver is outside when the food didn't even leave the restaurant. read more

Can't believe I haven't reviewed this place! It's often overlooked due to its odd little corner location hidden among other little shops, but don't underestimate this place! The service is friendly and fast when you sit in, but we often opt for takeout or delivery. The decor inside is pretty bare bones typical pizza place, but I don't mind it. It has all the essentials. The pizza is awesome. Our favorite by far is the over the top pizza (Honey BBQ chicken, bacon, and ranch). The East Haven Masher is another favorite, but you really can't go wrong with any of the pizzas! Check them out on Uber eats, order online, they can't make it any easier for you to get their pizza into your mouth. read more

Nice amount of sausage and broccoli on the Pizza which was quite tasty! I'll order it and try the shrimp white one. The Chocolate Cake is dangerously good whew! read more

Food is great! The buffalo chicken pizza is my favorite! Super hard for me not to order here everyday

I have been patronizing Capotorto's for years. Tonight, I got the absolute worst pizza I have ever eaten. I placed an order for delivery and was told it would be approximately 1 hour. To my surprise, the driver arrived in less than 30 minutes. I opened a box of ice cold pizza not made the way I ordered it. To boot, the sauce was super sweet. Not their usual recipe. I guess that explains the quick delivery. What did you do, delivery a pie that someone didn't pick up!? I am beyond disappointed and will be looking for a new establishment. read more

Amazing pizza! One of my favorites in CT. I absolutely love eating it cold the next day. A must have if you are in East Haven.

For the first time we ordered a medium onion mozzarella pizza last night. We live close by to this business and decided to have it delivered. The pizza was top notch! It was still warm upon delivery! We will order again! read more

Always the best here , had the Foxon Park , perfect for a Friday Lenten Dinner .

Love their pizza but last nite I ordered the chef salad and was looking forward to the hard boiled egg, it clearly shows a hard boiled egg in it but never got one read more

I placed an order for a lg cheese at 7:21pm. I was told 45min, and it is now 9:10pm when the pizza arrived. I'm a regular customer, and tip well. I then called and spoke with the manager, Zack. He told me there was nothing he can do, and offered a free soda next time I order. I dont drink soda, and my kids needed to be in bed. The pizza is great, and I have never experienced this type of service from them before. So frustrating.. read more

I have no qualms about recommending Capotorto's. I order home delivery about twice a month and eat at their restaurant every so often. The delivery guys are very friendly and affable, and the girls working at the restaurant are sweet and attentive. Living around the corner from this place has multiple benefits, but I would not include weight loss in that category. What can I say? The pizza and subs are extremely tasty and mouthwatering, and the chicken caesar salad is amazing. I particularly love the Reese's pie for dessert but anything on the menu is luscious. If you want cannoli, it's yours and it's FRESH. There's also never a shortage of Foxon Park soda, which is great as I particularly adore the White Birch Beer. Any given meal is seriously economical as well. If you don't feel like shlepping to Modern or Pepe's, it's a rational decision to cross Capotorto's modest threshold and relish an authentic dining experience with standard Italian dishes that rival any of the New Haven giants. read more

I order from here at least once a week. They typically deliver sooner than the online estimate which is great. The food is always good and tonight I accidentally placed an order online for pickup instead of delivery, they brought out my order quickly with no fuss. Thanks! read more

Ordered pick up many times since moving to East Haven. Best pizza around ... like around the whole state. Friendly, quick and always made fresh and delicious!!!!! Love at first slice (cheesy, I know) read more

Capotorto's Apizza Center - Pizza Near Me - East Haven, Connecticut

Pizza is great, good for a casual night In. Pick-up was quick. Will be getting more from here in the future!

For shame I have not reviewed Capotorto's after years of enjoyment! Yes, it's far north East Haven, but the geography still commands darn good pizza if you're this close to the secret pizza Mecca of AMERICA. They're up to the task here. Price first. Four slices, two with toppings, two sodas with unlimited Foxon Park refills, and a big chocolate chip cookie. $14.90 after tax. The price is right here for a two person lunch. Service: I love the folks working here. Today she got our pizza quickly, offered to warm up the cookie in the pizza oven (GREAT decision, by the way), checked up on us regularly. Environs: 2 HDTV's, rudimentary seating, all the necessary pizza condiments, from garlic powder to red pepper flakes. Food: Excellent New Haven-esque pizza. A little char without overdoing it, thin but not unmanageable... tasty. It still boggles the mind how Domino's survives. Price difference is extremely minor, product difference is intergalactic. Will always go back when we're in the Foxon Boulevard area. read more

Never a disappointment. Since we get delivery that is no easy feat. Steak& Cheese wow!! read more

Always enjoyed the pizza till tonight I understand prices are going up but there prices are off the charts what usually cost about 45/50 tonight cost me over $75.00 when I question the price I was told prices are going ( which I understand) but I said I think that's a lot and the owners daughter said my parents work hard (don't we won't be going back there I think that's a lil price gouging on a community that is struggling read more

Been a long time customer. Ordered a pizza on Super Bowl Sunday, called back to change my order everything went down from there. Delivery time for 6p, made a call at 6:40p we burn it and now making another be there soon. Remember I called them. The pizza arrived at 8p. Did offer free soda & slice of cake. Then I noticed my account was charged $3 more than the receipt. I paid the delivery guy a tip in cash. As I informed the person in the phone I planned to do. I called to talk to someone about fee. The owner gets on and treats me horribly. Big attitude, questioning me as if I did someone something & was annoying them. Not an apology nothing!! Very disappointed - what a joke!! read more

Recently discovered this amazing pizza place. Fresh ingredients combined in just the right way create amazing pizza. My suggestions include the Over The Top and Clams Casino pies. Yum!!! read more

Great service. Waitress Christina was very nice and quick. What made our experience outstanding was our Over The Top pizza. Overall, a great experience. read more

Capotortos pizza is awesome! Pizza is as good as any you could get in New Haven! People are friendly

Truly a great find in the greater New Haven area. I travel a lot and eat at hundreds of places a year. This small yet comfortable restaurant is really a great place to eat. I stopped by here for lunch, basically on accident, about two months ago. I have since gone back a handful of times and have been satisfied every time. My work is literally a 3-5 min ride from Wooster Street in New Haven, And when it comes to a lunch slice....I go to CAPOTORTOS!!!. Although there are some of the greatest pizza spots in NH, that's no secret, this one is absolutely worth a shot. Doesn't hurt that the operators are really nice people. I agree that the negative reviewer must be trying to settle a personal score. I don't see any validity to that review and hope it doesn't deter others from trying this great pizza place. read more