It's been many years since I had pizza here. I heard that…read morethey changed things around, So because we're in the area and hungry for pizza we decide to stop.Our margarita pie was delicious. The sauce was top-notch and we will be back!!

My gf and i decided to dine here for dinner on a wednesday simply looking for pizza. This place…read moreseemed promising from the outside but upon entering it was immediately apparent this place is just a simple pizza joint. I read some older reviews and learned the previous owners had a horror themed pizza joint that many visitors enjoyed but i guess the new owners changed the vibe to something more casual. Service was on the slow end but to my knowledge staff was either short or it's a small team and overall the service was good no complaints there. But now we get to the food and it's neither good or bad just.. right in the middle with the middle being.. standard. We shared one large (16 inch) Pizza with Mushroom on the whole pie then getting one side sausage and the other broccoli and a side of 'pizza fries' that were ordinary unseasoned fries topped with a mess of Pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese. It wasn't inedible but i can't say i'd order it again. the pizza was good woth the sausage being pretty decent and the mushrooms being very bland and that's because they're from a can, i use to make pizzas for a local pizza joint i get it so i won't flame the flavorless mushrooms. The crust was surprisingly crisp and delicious, it's very rare i finish my pizza crust i usually just give mine to my gf but the pie was alright. My biggest take on nicolosi's is the prices. pizza is expensive i get it but honestly the price for the quality is slightly off and i say this with experience from many different pizza places on both the east and west coast. would come back for a pizza in the future.

My New Place has redeemed their shameful service with much improved quality of service. The buffalo…read morechicken wrap is now fantastic and doesn't come in soup form. My son gets their California cheese burger and says it's delicious

Me and the wife got a grandmas pizza. It was very good and fresh. Great amount of cheese without…read moreordering extra cheese. Topped with fresh tomatoes and basil and garlic oil. Good price and served in good time.

The driver was super sweet and very polite…read more Ordered pizza, half plain, half pepperoni and wings. This was the best pizza I've had since leaving New Jersey. Decent crust, nice flavor to the sauce and a good amount of cheese. The wings were phenomenal!! Good crunch on them and the blue cheese sauce was delicious.

Loved. It. I could eat that pepperoni ALL DAY LONG. It was so delicious. Exactly what we were…read morewanting and looking for. We've tried several other places and they don't compare. I will say, be very careful with the Buffalo chicken pizza. I'm a Buffalo fanatic; I love everything Buffalo. I love spicy. I've been searching for the perfect Buffalo pizza and this would've been it but holy hell...this was SO SPICY. It's a great pizza, don't get me wrong. It was super good. But wow. It is burn your mouth, need glass after glass of milk, take a break after 1 slice, SPICY. Great price for the 2 pizzas too. I was honestly expecting it to be over $45 considering the speciality pizza but it was only $32. Pretty good! *we ordered pick up

A hole in the wall shop in the middle of Alpha. Walked in for a quick solid bite, left wanting to…read morego back. The staff was friendly, and it seemed like a local gem. We sat down and it felt empty at first, then you blink and the place was packed. Seemed like the popular local lunch/dinner spot. Tons of menu options, great food and a home-cooked meal feel. Gave off a "homie" vibe. Would definitely recommend stopping in if you're in the area. We ordered the cheese fries, turkey sub, and a cheesesteak... raving reviews on all three!

So the 5 years I have been living in the area with my girlfriend. We have always ordered online…read more This is the first time we actually sat in there to eat. Just like the customer service when I pick up my food is amazing. Our server was amazing. Jist a great, friendly environment to enjoy good food. Usually, we order a large pie or personal pizzas. Bit I ordered the baked gnocchi and she got a chicken sandwich. The food was delicious. We didn't wait long at all for it. Hot and tasty. We could not have been more satisfied.

After many recommendations I stopped in to Pino's in Easton to try the Sicilian slice. I waited 15…read moreminutes because they were getting another one ready to go into the oven and I wanted it fresh. The slice and a 20oz soda was exactly $5. This was far better than the last place I went (I want to say it was Georges) where dozens of people claimed it would be the best I ever had. Good amount of cheese, the sauce had good flavor, nice crispiness to the crust while the center was still airy and light. I definitely would say that the Sicilian slice at Pino's - Didn't Suck!

Pino's pizza is among the best pizza I have ever eaten! We ordered a medium cheese pizza with…read moremushrooms and pepperoni - Yum! We will be back again

I've been eating at Pies On for over 35 years. Their food is consistent because the recipes and…read morequality of ingredients hasn't changed. This has been my go-to spot for steak sandwiches and hoagies for decades. Their pasta dishes are solid because their homemade sauce is fantastic.

I was there for my second time yesterday and had the toasted cheese steak with sweet peppers and…read moreonions. I also had a slice of their pizza. The food is awesome when you can fold a slice of pizza and pick it up and it doesn't flop down that's when you know it's good dough. The cheese is delicious. The sauce is delicious. The workers are extremely friendly and when you give them a comment, they appreciate it. Can't wait to go back. The pinball machines, the bar and the pool table makes a dining experience more enjoyable. You could even burn some calories and after an hour go eat some more.

These guys are great!!! I called when they opened and requested if they make a 2 and 1 for me, for…read morea friends 21st - and they were so sweet to accommodate the short notice request! Also, they were so kind and charged less than I expected for the size of the pie and when I asked why, they said "cause you're getting less pizza for the cost"! What?!! Who does that!!! Most businesses would somehow manage to charge more for a request, but these guys are so generous and kind that they said yes to making this happen last minute, and because there is "less pizza" cause of MY request - they were consented about me having less to eat, so they charged less the size of the box they had to use and what that size pie would have cost! Who does that!!! Them, clearly! Thank you! :) Appreciate yours better guys. Also, the pizza was yum!! And the birthday boy was overjoyed!! :) it's the little things! ;)

It's the real deal NY style round pie. Home cured ingredients and love. The classic chicken wing…read moretossed in the mango habanero is dynamite. I ate ten, with no shame. Excellent pizzaria

The most unprofessional experience I have ever had in my life. I wasn't even a patron here and the…read moreunprofessionalism reached me. Their delivery driver who drives the Red Honda passed me at 50+ mph on Dumont road, not to mention with double yellow line. He then proceeds to cut the corners like he's driving a race car at dangerous speeds in close proximity to a residential neighborhood, Greenwich Chase. I observed him turning into the plaza by Home Depot still driving erratically, and blows through the stop sign by the Home Depot, all of this while not using a blinker, going at least 30+ mph at this point through the parking lot. I followed the car as, I was right behind it, and lo and behold....he delivers for Bella. I went into the restaurant to make a comment about how he drove. As I was leaving, after telling the workers what I just encountered, he rolled his window down and was screaming profanity and insults at me from across the parking lot as he's driving away. The words I will not specifically mention here. Just a hint....Words that started with F's and B's. Not to mention there was a child in my vehicle, who unfortunately had hear his profane language and was visibly shaken from what had just happened. I grew up right down the road from this place on 519, and my family has been in the area for generations. Our family has been patrons for over 15 years. I have never in my life been so appalled by someone's behavior. I am extremely dissatisfied with how this employee carried himself. I have had family members that have worked there in the past few years, and it was not like this. It is a shame this is who bella has working for them. I will most definitely be taking my business elsewhere after this experience, and I'll be sure to tell my friends and family the same. I am sorry to have to leave this review, but I couldn't fathom the acts of the delivery driver. Especially knowing the reputation they have had in the Stewartsville area for a long time as a good local business.

My family gets pizza here almost every week during the summer. My brother lives and breathes off…read moretheir buffalo chicken pizza. I have to say it's pretty good, the few times my brother let me try it (he takes a whole pie to himself). We recently tried something different this weekend and got the chicken calzone and spinach roll. Spinach roll isn't something I would try again, but I'm glad I tried it. It's very watery if that makes sense. However the chicken calzone will be something I will get in the future. Great service and restaurant!