It was our first time at Vintage & we had the best time. From walking in the door & speaking to Dana (the hostess), she was fantastic & so pleasant to sitting at the bar with Cami. She was so sweet, and clearly experienced at bartending. Our martinis were amazing (see pic below). Then we had dinner & served by Mardean. He was extremely professional. He knew the specials off the top of his head and never even wrote our order. He was so kind & present. He answered any questions with solutions and nailed it all. We are not from the area and we were so impressed with everyone and the entire staff. The food was delicious. Not one complaint whatsoever. We highly recommend Vintage to anyone in the future. read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

See all

Traditional steakhouse. Food and service was great. We celebrated a birthday and they made it special. Will definitely return. read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Filet Mignon Oskar - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

Made reservations for a Saturday at 4, we were promptly seated and our waiter, Walter I believe was his name, came by to explained specials then gave us time to look over the menu. The inside is very charming and cozy. I was a little chilly so recommend a sweater lol. I had the watermelon feta salad & it was very fresh and crisp. As my main meal I had filet mignon & it was 10/10. Cooked just the way I asked. The side I ordered was enough to share at the table, they were all great. Dessert time came and it was my father's birthday, they gave him a complimentary piece of cheesecake & they sang. Very sweet people here & I can't recommend this place enough. read more

See all

Came here with my fiance to celebrate our anniversary! The reservation process is seamless through OpenTable; we managed to score a resy 2 days out. We came a little before our reservation time & were seated promptly. At 6pm on a Saturday, it was already packed! We were both craving a really good steak, and vintage prime delivered. We ordered the burrata caprese to start, the tomahawk for 2, roasted corn, and sweet potato mash. Service here is great - they kindly split our burrata in 2 without us having to ask! The tomahawk is the star for sure - it was cooked to a perfect medium, seasoning was spot on, and the crispy onions were sooo good. Steak sauce is reminiscent of Peter Luger's steak sauce, but less vinegar-y. I'm not really a steak sauce gal, but it paired well. The corn was good, but could've used either a bit of salt or acid to enhance the flavor a bit more. Sweet potato mash was also good, but nothing to write home about. Towards the end of our meal, we were comped a dessert for our anniversary celebration! So sweet! Ambiance is cozy, & great for both couples and groups. It looks like vintage prime is a favorite for celebrations - we saw 2 birthdays and 2 other anniversaries! Prices are super reasonable for a steakhouse. read more

See all

We had dinner last night at Vintage with our adult children & adult grandchildren & spouses . The food was excellent& service by Mario was even better . Vintage never disappoints . A memorable evening . Thank you . read more

Amazing food and experience!! Host and waiter made us feel like valued customers. All of our meals were made to perfection: tube steak with crab meat, lamb chops, and mini/regular filet mignons. Know that the mini mignons are actually a good size! Perfect way to celebrate an in-law's birthday :) read more

My husband and I enjoyed a wonderful meal for our anniversary! We were able to make a reservation the day of and were seated at our choice table right away when we arrived. We started with a bottle of Barolo, which was delicious. We ordered Blue Point oysters for an appetizer and they were amazing. We each ordered filet mignon, which was cooked to perfection, and shared creamed spinach & lobster Mac & cheese- huge portion! We ended the meal with Creme brûlée (complete with a candle for our anniversary), I had a chocolate martini and my husband had an Irish coffee- both were delicious, we finished every drop! Our server was perfectly attentive & friendly. Would definitely return & recommend! read more

See all

Food was delicious. Ambiance was cozy which is exactly what we wanted on a chilly fall evening. Service was top notch! We had a great night and will come back!!! For dinner we ordered and split everything. Portions were big I couldn't finish!! We had the beet salad, lamb chops and Chilean sea bass (special). The bartender (Ashley) was so sweet she made great drinks! I tried the strawberry basil martini (this is something I never do) it was perfect not too sweet. The espresso martini was delicious too! We made friends at the bar, it was a really fun night. Thank you!! read more

Came here with my husband for our anniversary. We wanted a place with great steak and this did not disappoint. We usually go to Insignia and get a tomahawk and a few other things, this ran about the same price, maybe slightly less. The food was amazing. Our tomahawk was perfectly medium rare, and the sweet mash and roasted veggies as sides were delish. We each had a drink, I had a glass of wine and my husband had a pumpkin beer. Something I need to mention is Bobby our server, and how great he was. He never made us feel rushed, was funny yet personable yet very informative. He truly made the whole experience and it's a place a definitely adding to the list of places we will come back to! read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Tomahawk - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

Great food, good vibes, good times! This place is a really nice restaurant. It looks small but its food and atmosphere certainly make it a big hit! Service was very nice. read more

Never let's me down. Been going for many years. All facets are on point. Atmosphere, food and service.

We went to Vintage Prime on a date night (our first time ever going here), and had an excellent experience. We made a reservation well in advance (although I don't know if this was absolutely necessary, but we figured doing so provided peace of mind, especially going on a Friday evening). The French onion soup was amongst the best I've had, and their filet mignon was perfectly cooked, tender, and delicious. The wait staff was very friendly and attentive, and clearly very experienced in providing exceptional service. The restaurant is pleasant inside, with nice ambiance. We went on a chilly winter's night, and there were no drafts nor excessive heat, very comfortable for dining. The front desk staff was also very friendly. We'll definitely eat here again. read more

Five stars for this fabulous steakhouse! My husband and I dined here this past Friday for the first time. It was in a random spot near a strip mall, but the atmosphere was super welcome when we went inside. Bigger than expected, too! Our waiter, Marvin, was excellent. His attention to detail and constant check-ins were appreciated! I ordered the sparkling cosmopolitan as my drink. It was very unique and a flower was placed in the ice cube. Nice touch! We ordered fried calamari as our appetizer. My husband wanted to try the Thai sauce but I prefer marinara, so Marvin suggested bringing out both for us to dip our squid in. What an awesome idea! I ordered the strip steak with red wine reduction sauce and my husband ordered the filet mignon gorgonzola tidbits. My steak was cooked perfectly and the sauce was deliciously sweet. My husband loved his tidbits. The fries we ordered tasted a little weird. I probably wouldn't order it next time. For dessert, I ordered the chocolate cake with chocolate gelato. It was filling and delicious. I highly recommend Vintage for a night out and hope you're all lucky enough to get Marvin as your waiter! read more

See all

Waited 2 hours for appetizers and they weren't even good. Food was overpriced and ambience was bad

Had never been here but an opportunity came up as we wanted to celebrate my pop's birthday. He loves a good steak and I had heard that this place was outstanding. The reports don't dissappoint. The service was excellent and the steaks were amazing. I loved that it was not too loud and clubby- very elegant but not fussy. Seared perfectly and cooked exactly to order. One person did not want steak and got the Chicken Parm- what a pleasant surprise he said it was one of the best he had ever had- Who would have thought that possible at a Steak House. The sides were ample and excellent for sharing- we got the mushrooms and onions and the brussel sprouts. The waiter was so thoughtful and brought out a dessert with a candle for my pop to celebreate his special day. That was super nice. I think this is my new favorite Steak House on Long Island... read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Pop's birthday! - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

The ambiance is very pleasant, the service was amazing, we were visiting from Florida and had just come from a funeral and were hungry. We entered and asked the lovely young lady if we needed reservations, she replied " yes, but for how many? " we stayed it's just the two of us and we were looking for a nice place for dinner, she kindly said " wait, let me see if I can fit you in"; a few seconds later she seated us at a very comfortable table. I also didn't mention it was frigid cold out! My husband ordered a steak medium rare and I had the special which was a 20oz lobster, sliced in butter and garlic and a side of creamed spinach, enough for two. Both meals came out perfect and absolutely delicious. This is a small place but a "don't miss" restaurant. It was worth every penny and my cocktail was fantastic. When on Long Island again I would go to St. James to eat here again. read more

This steakhouse stands up to any that I've been to on LI or NYC. I had a prime NY strip steak that was cooked perfectly and creamed spinach. There was a solid char on the outside of the steak that concealed a delicious, pink inside that was buttery soft. The sides at the table included mixed roasted vegetables and mashed potatoes that were all big enough to share among the 3 of us. read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Perfectly cooked NY Strip Steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

Great ambiance, very popular, but not noisy. Very elegant interior. Ordered the porterhouse for two and the lobster mac and cheese- both very delicious!! Service was super friendly and attentive too. Will definitely go back. read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Porter house for two & the lobster mac and cheese - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

Ambiance was nice. Food was delicious very good steaks and cooked well. A very good steak house. Highly reccomend this one if your looking for a great steak. read more

Best steakhouse ever. Never disappointing. Friendly & efficient staff. Great shrimps & crabmeat cocktail appy's, wonderful cocktails & delicious sides.. Really outstanding & definitely worth a visit.. read more

I'll keep it simple. We had reservations on a Friday night. Blonde lady at hostess stand, completely lied to us. If you're not a regular, you will wait forever, as others who walk in 20 minutes later and get seated before you. We left after 30 minutes and I will never return. Went to Insignia, and was taken care of with class. read more

My husband and I had a lovely dinner with friends at Vintage Prime Steakhouse. I love the cozy feel of this restaurant, and the fine-dining food was DEELISH. I highly recommend for special occasions. read more

Came for my boyfriends birthday and was a little disappointed. Not my favorite steakhouse Apps were delicious! - Lamp chops w/ Greek salad and taziki sauce 5 / 5 - Burrata with prosciutto 5 / 5 - Service was very very slow 3 / 5 Steak sauce arrive when I was finished with my meal and my boyfriend was almost fully completed with his steak - Truffle fries were served cold and I didn't notice much truffle ( I really love truffle fries too ) 2 / 5 - cream spinach (first brought out sautéed spinach and had to wait for the correct order 5 / 5 - Halibut special with risotto and pesto.... I think it was rice instead of risotto ? It want firm like regular risotto ‍ 3 / 5 - Cowboy Rib eye steak server said it was the most flavorful steak on the menu. It was okay... but I certainly wouldn't say it has a lot of flavor 3 / 5 Wasn't impressed and was a bit disappointed and embarrassed that I chose this place for someone else's birthday read more

See all

I have been an avid Vintage customer for years, and I can confidently say this is the most consistent and simply my favorite restaurant. A must is the freshest seafood tower you will have (don't forget to ask for mignonette). A big misconception is just because it's a steakhouse, you have to get a steak. I am telling you, their specials and other items are worth a try. Service is always impeccable and will always refer them for a special occasion. read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Seafood tower for 3 - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

See all

Best steakhouse on Long Island A true aged steak not drowning in butter and cooked to perfection Wait staff very attentive but not hovering over you. read more

Came here for Anniversary dinner. We had reservations and were seated right away. The ambiance is classic steak house decor and we thought it was nice. The only "issue" was it was super loud to the point my wife and I had to shout and or struggle at times to hear each other. We ordered French onion soup and the Thai calamari for appetizers, although my wife modified her soup to have no Bread because she has celiac. Both were delicious and flavorful. For Dinner we ordered the Tomahawk steak for two, mashed sweet potatoes and roasted vegetables. We had to get sautéed onions because crispy onions are not GF. The steak was cooked to perfection and was awesome. The sides were also good. They brought us complimentary cheese cake which was nice and throughout our meal the service was good. read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Tomahawk steak - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

Not really sure this place needs another review.... It's not like mine will help it any more than any others have. I've been to many steakhouses, both here and in Miami. The big ones, Luger, S&W, Sparks, Morton's... etc.. Vintage is about the finest one I've been to. I've been here twice with my wife and both times it has absolutely exceeded expectations. They're known for their French onion soup which we ordered last time and was spectacular. This time we opted for a burrata salad and shrimp cocktail. Both were exceptional. The shrimp are beyond jumbo and ice cold. As if the were just caught, in the morning and cooked that night. We ordered the porterhouse for two and got it medium rare which was spot on. You get it on a hot plate so if you want it done a little more, you have a minute or two to lay it down and cook it some more, and it comes with a nice "au ju". Seasoned well, and you can tell it was aged perfectly. Sides were mushrooms and onions (sautéed with scallions as well, and pan roasted corn (mixed with some red peppers). All delicious. To end it, we split a crème brûlée which was classic. Caramelized top and creamy/custardy inside. Our waiter, Mario was terrific! He was built for this. His presentation of the specials were amazing and informative, as he spoke with inflection and made you really desire what was being told you. The decor is what you'd expect at a fine steakhouse. "Vintage". Highly recommend for a "New York Steakhouse" experience without traveling into Manhattan. read more

I've been to several steak houses and Vintage is one of our favorites!! The food is always cooked to perfection. Desserts are always a yummy treat at the end of an excellent meal. This quaint restaurant is perfect for a date night, or celebratory meal with the family! We will most certainly be back!! read more

Steaks were delicious! Service was great and prices were reasonable for a steakhouse. read more

Vintage Prime Steakhouse - Filet Mignon - Steakhouses Near Me - Saint James, New York

I started with oysters, tuna and grilled lamb chops. Ended with Porterhouse for 2. Great place in Saint James. Been here a long time. Saturday night , nice crowd. But why close the bar at 10:45pm on a Saturday night???? read more

See all

I'm going to update my review because my GOD. Has Vintage proved themselves to be quite worthy. The beau and I came to celebrate my birthday a few days later with it just us and I have to say Vintage definitely pulls out all of the stops. I am so glad this is a local gem within minutes of home. We split the following: - A bottle of Duckhorn Merlot: which we almost finished and wound up taking home to finish - Thai Calamari: by far our favorite Calamari EVER! - Burrata Caprese: again by far our favorite Burrata. - Filet Mignon for Two: served medium well as last time the medium was a little under cooked for us. The medium well was just perfect. Served with grilled asparagus and mashed potatoes. But this time we subbed out the mashed potatoes for a twice baked potato. - Side of Lobster Mac and Cheese: stupidly good. Again no room for dessert but maybe next time. We will continue to come back to our little hidden gem. Thank you for treating us like royalty Vintage. We appreciate you! read more

Out of all the steakhouses on Long Island, you can certainly do better. However, it's not bad. The steak is decent and cooked well. The decor is dated, the steak, while good, wasn't special. Also the Thai calamari was a bit soggy. For the price, go to Paces. read more

I have dined at Vintage personally with family and also for a work dinner. Both times I was not impressed with the food service or atmosphere. The steak was cooked as ordered but had zero flavor the sides were nothing special. Overpriced mashed potatoes and vegetables For the work dinner with 13 people. There was 1 waitress to help 13 of us. We were seated in such a small area and a curtain separated us from the main dining room. The reservation was made knowing it was professional gathering and the amount of people . It was extremely loud you could barely hold a conversation with the person seated right next to you. So it was impossible to have a conversation with anyone else at the table. I chalked it up to maybe it was too much for one person. My personal experience (which I thought would be so much better being there was only was 2 people) was even worse. Our waiter was so inattentive and rude!!! We ordered drinks and it took forever to get the drinks. We placed our order and waited nearly 65 minutes for our food. During that time not once did the waiter come to ask us if we wanted another drink. I had to flag down another waiter walking by to ask for more drinks. The special was a pork chop with hot sauce and cheese which my better half ordered and I got the filet mignon. The filet was cooked to my liking but bland and not juicy at all. The pork chop was disgusting. You couldn't even eat it!!!! The waiter never came back to ask how the food was if he had he would have realized the pork chop had two bites out of it. The sides again were nothing to talk about masked potatoes I make better ones at home. Spending close to $400 and having to leave a gratuity you would think the staff would be more attentive to you and the food so much better. For the price and advertising as a high end steak house you would think the service and food would be top notch. I will never recommend or eat there ever again. Oh also the woman's bathroom was disgusting and smelled of dirty mop water. If you want to eat mediocre food have terrible service and spend a fortune by all means go to vintage. But if you want a great meal for that kinda money i recommend going elsewhere!!!! read more

The mashed potatoes tasted like boxed, had absolutely no cream and no butter and were extremely dry. The corn side tasted like canned corn. Ordered two filets ordered medium rare one was under done and one of them was chewy. This should not be the case at a steakhouse at this price point. read more

Another St James gem. How could one suburban town have so many great restaurants. As with any steakhouse, it's expensive, but it's prime stuff (no pun intended). First the French onion soup was fantastic. So so good. My wife and I got the porterhouse for two and it was presented so nicely. I loved how it was cut for us. The ambiance is blah and not steakhouseish. They had upbeat pop music. I would expect jazz or easy listening. Anyway, another gem, highly recommend. read more

Dinner was amazing, ambiance Is very quaint you feel like you're in somebody's living room. It is always worth the ride to the North Shore and does not disappoint. Always get the filet and the temperature is always a perfect medium or medium rare depending on what you orsee (I don't do well done steaks, the oysters are perfect and the salads are fresh...I even liked the cheesecake that they gave us for free because it was our anniversary...The staff are friendly and knowledgeable and always go above and beyond to make you feel important, Whether it's a free drink or a free dessert or a sample of an appetizer they always just go above and beyond to make you feel like a celebrity. Bought several friends gift cards here and they all enjoyed the meals as well 5/5 stars after over a half dozen times eating here read more

Wayyy overpriced. So many flies all around. Broken ac vent. Food meh, ambiance awful. Service tough couldn't understand waiter. Never going back. read more

We had my mom's birthday dinner here and had a great experience. Everyone enjoyed their meals and the servers were very good, attentive without being all over you. Personally I had the bone in rib eye and it was delicious. read more

This is a nice spot for just about any occasion. The food is great and the service is professional which matches up well with the price point. The dining area gives a great first impression but the overall atmosphere takes a bit of a hit due to how loud the place gets. I'm not sure if they've tried addressing this but they absolutely need to hire an acoustic engineer or at least invest in some acoustic art pieces / panels. This wouldn't keep me from coming back by any means. The food was outstanding. We all ordered steak and a side. Each steak was prepared as requested and the sides were better than expected. The home fires and roasted vegetables were really good and the asparagus was excellent. Definitely recommend. Enjoy. read more

See all

Great upscale steakhouse for those special nights out. Service always on point and the food delicious. Intimate seating allows you to hear your dinner guests. Small bar when you walk in only accommodates 5 or so which can be an issue if you arrive early looking for drink. Overall you will not be disappointed with the food, staff or experience here. read more