Excellent pizza. Old school, east coast style. Lots of choices for toppings, reasonable prices, good service.

The Sicilian pizza here is amazing. This is definitely our new pizza place. Management and staff are very helpful and friendly. read more

Your Pizza Stop - This is a pic of the Sicilian. It's 2" thick. Awesome pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

Best pizza in town without a doubt. The owner and employees are always super nice too!

Great pizza, I feel it's only underrated because of its location maybe. The employees are very friendly, I think it's probably the best pizza in town read more

Best pizza in the area.... always fresh and ready when I order to go. The staff (especially the owner alway great service.) I will literally drive 40 minutes one way to come to this place. Prices are great thanks guy's keep up the awesome work. read more

We had them delivery three pizzas to our house last night. We were very happy with the quality. The crust was anove average and the sauce was really tasty. They are not stingy with the toppings. We will be ordering again for sure. read more

Finally got the chance to try this spot and it was a great choice. Good alternative from the main franchises. Big slices, cheese melted to perfection, good flavor of crust, just overall good. read more

All I have to say is WOW!!!! Me and family ordered from your pizza stop today. We all had different items. Panini's, Calzones, Sausage in meat sauce. If I had the option to give them 10 stars for the taste alone! Very polite and customer service. I swear I'm never returning to cardboard pizza from dominos. This place will always receive our service and we will let everyone know to try them out !!!! Your Pizza stop rocks! read more

Drove 10 minutes for them to be closed early. "Just for today" was what they said on the phone. They did offer to still make our order but we declined. Stay open posted times! People drive to your place going off the times you have listed. read more

the best pizza in menifee hands down and locally owned! super friendly service, everything is amazing E V E R Y T H I N G!

A gem tucked away in a small strip mall by far the BEST pizza I've had in Sun City / Menifee area we will definitely be ordering from here again we were pleasantly surprised. We ordered the Extra Large Supreme Pizza with easy sauce and wanted a crispy crust, all I can say is Yum it was cooked to perfection fresh, hot and delicious the mozzarella cheese was absolutely outstanding, we will be trying other items in the near future. read more

I LOVE this pizza place. The pizza sauce is so good and always tastes fresh. They are not greedy with their ingredients at all. I don't usually like pizza crust but their pizza crust is so simple and crunchy and good. I love their cheese. Everything about this pizza place is great! The pizza taste better than other places I've had, even better than Upper Crust pizza. The staff is extra friendly. My favorite pizza place! read more

Good local pizza place. A much better alternative to Dominos. We will definitely try again here. Want to try their deep dish Sicilian.

Great pizza. The people working here were really nice. I ordered two pizzas, both ready within 15 minutes. The prices aren't terribly high either. Would definitely come back :) read more

Best pizza in Menifee! We are never disappointed, DJ, the owner, is a super nice guy and always a pleasure doing business with! The meatballs are outstanding, especially when you get them on your pizza. Thanks for the great pizza DJ, from yolanda and jeff. read more

Quick delivery and good pizza. Definitely will eat there again. Dominos gets old so this was a great find. Prices are reasonable and reflect the pizza created. read more

Try the meat balls! Best pizza you can find! Get the supreme ! Dj is awesome and super friendly! read more

Overall a little on the pricey side. But it's absolutely fantastic. The pizza tastes great and the atmosphere of the place reminds me of small pizzerias from New York. Easily a 5/5! read more

I found this place on yelp and so far it's the best pizza in Menifee! Totally recommend this place and definitely will be back.

I've ordered delivery twice from this place on busy nights and had pizza at my door in an hour. The deep dish was great! Crispy crust on the outside and thick and chewy on the inside. It was really good, but I would've liked a little more sauce and cheese. Maybe that's hard to accomplish with a thick crust, I don't know. We also had nice cold Pepsi delivered. The driver was very nice and the person who took our order on the phone was very professional. I think what makes this place better than most is their crust and fresh ingredients. Way better than anything else in the area. read more

The BEST pizza ! I always get XLARGE Special Supreme w/ side order of Hot wings .. never disappointed with my orders ! And always fast delivery read more

Was super underwhelmed by the pizza after reading all the reviews. It was good, just not amazing like all these reviews say. I'll probably return just cause the location is convenient for me, but the taste just isn't as great as everyone is saying. However!!! The pizzas are big, so that's a plus. One other weird thing, and this is just my preference.. their ranch tastes and smells weird lol Anyway, the food is worth trying if you're in the area. read more

Good pizza and the breadsticks were ok to me but my children loved them. We look forward to trying other choices on the menu.

I love pizza. I can eat pizza all day as long as someone promises me that I will not gain weight. I've been looking for a pizza place, around this region, that isn't a franchise for the longest time ever! Just a mom and pop shop that will satisfy my cravings. And I eventually did! I yelped (obviously) and tumbled across this store. I did a take out order over the phone; large whole cheese. The person on the other side was polite quick and easy to place an order with. Later I realized he's the owner. I walked in after 5 minutes I placed the call. He told me 10-15 minutes but I was close by so I just went in since I didn't mind waiting for a bit. As soon as I walked in he informed us that the pizza will be out soon with a smile! yes! That's all I need on a long shopping day at the mall. It came out sooner than I thought, I asked for crushed peppers, and he again smiled! and said "sure sure!" This is why I go to mom and pop shops. Not only was the pizza good, even though I am not anywhere near being Italian, it felt like home food. I would definitely get all my pizzas from here from now on! Thank you :) read more

Hidden deliciousness lol I don't know why we waited so long , but anyone in the area must give it a try when we want pizza we now only go there read more

Don't bother. Regardless of the positive Menifee postings about this place delivering TO MENIFEE, they don't deliver to our area. Funny, through the OBVIOUS language barrier, the gentleman who answered the phone KNEW he didn't deliver to our street,but after four times of giving him my address, couldn't find us on Google.......Really?? But he knew that we were like "10 miles away" (actually we're 5.3 miles!) So sorry, you just lost a lot of Friday night deliveries here for a LARGE family who LOVES occasionally ordering out for a good pie. The pies look FANTASTIC, but I guess our family will never know. read more

When i first called i orders the special 2 large pizzas. I asked the guy on the phone of the driver would have change for 100.00 he said yes. I also asked I f they can throw on packets of Parmesan and plates. When he gave me total he was charging for the cheese so I said no thank you. Received a call from driver he couldn't fine us when he did he didn't have change at all! Not even for a 20.00, no cheese, no plates, not red pepper flakes...when we opened the pizzas both looked like the drive took a quick left turn cause half the pizzas had the toppings on one side. Dough was soft and soggy. Won't be ordering from them again. read more

The consistency of their pizza is on point! When you order the same menu item every time you want it to taste the same every time right? They treat you family for sure! You get what you pay for and if you want a good pizza get it from here! The hero sandwich is fire too. You won't be disappointed read more

Pizza sucked thin soggy no sauce, all the cheese came off with one bit and boring salad

Great pizza our favorite place to order from. And their wings are good they got the best ranch to!

I'm from New York and I have to say this is the best Pizza place in sun city well worth the money. And I'm very happy to be the hundredth review, out of all the places I've been out here this one is well deserving of the five stars. Thanks for the great food guys keep it up. read more

Amazing pizza and amazing prices. Best pizza in town by far. I highly recommend this pizza joint

Great pizza , the flavor slaps you in the face is that good I'm glad I found a legit pizza to eat with my wine

Awesome food and service! Our go to pizza place. Best pizza place around. Deep dish is good as well as the regular crust. Always get one of there delicious salads too! read more

Guy was super nice and asked multiple times if he could offer us anything else to make the meal better. We ate there(a few small tables). Calzone and lasagna were both very good. If I lived closer I'd come more often. Love good family owned pizza spots. read more

Ordering by phone was a pleasant experience. Staff was friendly by phone and in person. Had a calzone and garlic cheese bread. Lots of cheese. The sauce had a good flavor and not too garlicy. read more

I love this place. The prices are great, and they have Pepsi products. I found this place when a nearby take and bake chain store screwed up my order and tried charging me 3x what it should have been. I drove one block over and saw this place with their $8.99 special and have been hooked. I order from here once or twice a month and would rather drive to go pick it up than order from the other pizza chains that are closer (and grosser). Pizza Stop pizza tastes and looks hand tossed, the dough tastes better, the ingredients look and taste better and the price is MUCH better. They always give me great service and accurate ready times. This last time I came I saw a large family outside at the tables enjoying the food and conversation (a big PLUS in my book) as well as 3 people inside working away cleaning and prepping. The older man promptly acknowledged me and finished up directions to their delivery driver and then happily served me. Is it THE BEST pizza in town, well no, that belongs to a sit down restaurant nearby. But this place IS THE BEST DELIVERY/TAKE OUT pizza in my town and I will happily give them my business as long as they continue to provide the same quality/service. read more

Tried this for the first time the other day and their pizza was great! Costumer service was exceptional as well! My whole family enjoyed it and we will be coming back! read more

Quick and delicious. Great prices for authentic new York style pizza. My favorite spot for pizza in Menifee.

Outstanding pizza, you know, I understand that the Big Box spots have these 5.99 and 7.99 pizza deals, but nothing beats the process Your Pizza Stop embarks on: All fresh ingredients, I saw workers in there cutting veggies and making fresh dough. Great wings, cheese sticks, and the Antipasto was inspiring. Support your local businesses, and make this spot Your Pizza Stop ( pun intended ) read more