I just called to order a Giant size pizza at 7:05pm. The employee who answered the phone answered saying pizza, salad and wings are available for pick up. I asked to order the giant pizza since it was still pizza. However, the employee said only the traditional NY pizza was available and the largest size was XL. I get it, the giant size takes a while to make and it's an hour to closing. Tip: the employee said that they stop taking orders for the giant size pizza at 7pm. If you want to order the giant size make sure to order before then. read more

I love their pizza and their calzones! It's so fresh and the service is pretty good! It is a smaller shop with only two tables outside but it's still worth a stop to take some pizza home read more

Hands down the BEST pizza place in the area! I'm no pizza or Italian pizza expert but if I were to visit Italy, I'd imagine pizza to taste like those made here. To be honest though, I haven't tried all the other pizzeria's in town but Your Pizza Stop has ranked the best in our family when compared to a couple others we have tried. What's the point of trying other pizzerias when you already know Your Pizza Stop as the best food!? Outside of the food, service is always spectacular. Always nice and courteous. I've never had an issue other than ones I've made myself and even then the food still shines! The positive reviews here are legit but if you're skeptical, just give the food a try and see for yourself. Pretty sure this'll be your new fave pizza spot! read more

See all

So, I decided to order their pizza online,,,,, was I disappointed! It was supposed to be delivered at 6:35 pm,,,,, I waited till 6:50 till I called and they said they were waiting for a driver from Door dash to arrive. Didn't get my pizza till 7:05, and it was stone cold. The pizza itself was ok, needed to be heated up again. But just to warn you if you order online there's a good chance it won't be delivered on time! read more

Your Pizza Stop serves some very good New York and deep dish Chicago style pizza. We ordered one medium NY Cheese and one Extra Sausage and Garlic deep dish. Both were medium twelve inch pies. It may not be Ray's or Giordano's, but they were both very good and worth the trip. Four Stars and we'll be back next time to try their Sicilian. read more

See all

I like the food it is really good. I always order from there but today I was disappointed by the Manager. I have had pizza delivered with no problem and today I was told I was out of the area I explained to the young lady who has taken my order before and she asked the Manager in turn I heard her tell her to tell me This was the last time and Charged me extra. Her tone sounded rude to me. I still ordered but her attitude (Manager) was uncalled for. read more

Hi just tried Your pizza for the first time and was not impressed at all. Got a calzone and I Judged it on 3 Veribles Sauce, cheese, Dough. All 3 were very Subpar, not great at all my opinion but at 60 yrs old I believe to be a good one. I'll never try anything to do with pizza and but to be fair I'll try there sandwiches. See if there worth giving another review. Let you know read more

I went to Your Pizza Stop this afternoon.My first time. I called and placed my order. I was pleasantly surprised to actually talk to a human being. When I picked up my pizza, they were so friendly. When I got home I dug in. It was the best pizza ever. read more

I like to give credit where credit is due new to Perris and seems like we had a lock down regular pizza spot in Nuevo called Marcelo's until we realized the second time going back that it's unsanitary u have employs using the register touching money with open wounds then going straight back to cook the pizza without washing hands . So we left that spot and that was that . Now to get on the pizza spot subject place looks clean . Pizza gas. Bomb honestly everything taste fresh and the crust was very fluffy you could tell the pizza was freshly made because it took me 15 mins to get home and eat and it still tasted fire . Wings are great to but the pizza out of this world . Your pizza spot is the TRUTH . read more

I hate to report, but the deep dish pizza I received was burnt from one end. Our lasagna order came cold. As if they took it from the freezer and heated it, but took it out to soon from oven. My first time ordering from this place and I regret to say that I am disappointed and they will no longer have my business. read more

Your Pizza Stop - Cold Lasagna - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

I don't want to leave too bad of a review because their food is good and delicious. But after returning to Menifee after 5 years living in a different city this was the first pizza Place I called. No big deal that they were an extra 40 minutes for pickup time but they kept saying well that's what the delivery ticket said when she told me 30 minutes over the phone. Took an extra 40 minutes all together about an hour and 10 minutes. Then when I got home I had barbecue sauce not buffalo sauce on my wings never ordered that in my life all three people around me when I ordered it on speakerphone heard me say buffalo sauce. Again the lady argued with me saying over and over over that's what the ticket says. She offered to remake them for me but it's not worth my time and money to leave and go all the way back to the pizza store to get some buffalo wings for my kids. I rather just not return because of the lady's attitude. I even asked for extra cheese and pepper if she gave me one extra cheese. She's kind of a smartass that works there read more

This pizza is so good!! Highly recommend you check it out. Honestly some of the best pizza I've ever had & it seems to be family operated which is definitely a plus! I didn't get a picture - literally because we all scarfed it down hahah Next time I order I'll add a picture read more

I can't believe I never knew this pizza spot is so close to me. It's so good! My family wanted deep dish pizza, so bad. We ordered a Chicago style pizza, Sicilian pizza, pizza bread, jalapeño cheese bread, a calzone, and wings. Nothing was a disappointment and you can't beat the price. Delicious. They don't skimp on toppings and for the Chicago style the toppings went all the way to the crust. I didn't get to take a picture of the jalapeño cheese bread because it was devoured so quickly. Over the phone and inside the establishment, the employees were very kind and friendly. It's embarrassing that I thought only chain pizza restaurants were near me. This is definitely my go to spot for pizza from now on and I love that it's a mom and pop. read more

See all

Nice people but there is absolutely nothing "New York style" about their New York style pizza. Gonna revisit the menu next time out(they have several options that look interesting ) but they really should remove that tag from their NY style pizza and just call them "regular slices and pies" because they were basically thin crust Mountain Mikes. Not bad but your basic Cali pizza w no hints of any of the NY tristate flavor unfortunately. This is really just a warning for fellow native New Yorkers looking for a taste of home not a taste of disappointment. Maybe I'll try the Calzones next time read more

Your Pizza Stop - Maybe Upstate "New York style" from some gas station but that's not how it's done anywhere in the NY metro. - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

The meatball sandwich is good. Pizza is mediocre. Like it was homemade, but in a bad way. Soggy after a short while. It looked like it was missing ingredients. They ran out of parmesan cheese. The kids and service there are nice though. Will be looking elsewhere for pizza. Think the good reviews are coming from nice folks supporting community business which is nice, but I believe in giving people a heads up. read more

Placed my order 2 days before my event to pick up at 5:30 pm and am here to pick it up right on time and when I arrive, they tell me my order is still in the oven. Not a good start to my first visit here. I hope the pizza is good, because the service is not. Gave them a good tip for poor service. Next time, no tip. read more

Best pizza in Menifee . Fresh toppings. Cool hole in the wall sandwiches are great too

We've tried this place a couple of times before but the last 2 times were not great at all. We thought that maybe the last time they were having an off day but today was worse. We decided to try the deep dish and for the price I was expecting it to be amazing! $28 for this pizza and it was thick flavorless dough that was not cooked thoroughly, literally made my stomach hurt. The cheese and sauce were scarce! We also decided to get wings and asked for them well done and we had to come home and put them in the air fryer since they were practically raw. I think this will be the last time we try this place. I was really hoping to have a good pizza place close to home. read more

Your Pizza Stop - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

Authentic, delicious, good service, and you get points towards future purchases. Support local the big chains are just selling poison. Best in town and they deliver. Come on! read more

Looked for a place that served deep dish pizzas near the Menifee area and this popped up. My family never had deep dish pizzas or calzones before, so I ordered some. Online ordering was straightforward and easy. They gave me an estimated pickup time. The only thing I'd recommend as well is to have some notification when the order is complete and ready for pickup. The food was so delicious and at a fair price! So happy to have found this spot. My family rated it 9/10 for taste, quality, and price. We'll definitely be stopping by again! read more

See all

My family and I have ordered from this establishment on numerous occasions. However, today the spaghetti had a very sour taste and was for lack of a better word horrible. Although we certainly did not finish the dinners the amount that was eaten was enough to make us sick. My family is experiencing gastrointestinal issues after consuming the spaghetti. We ordered the spaghetti with meat sauce, dinners, not the spaghetti with meatballs. read more

da yum :D twy it awesome staff and good price and cute little shop :3 i keep coming back its so gewd read more

Your Pizza Stop - big ass Calzone so yum wtffff - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

See all

We ordered 2 day ahead of time. Perfect. Pick up at 5:30. Get here at 5:30, oh your pizza is in the oven. 10 more minutes, maybe. So much for the pre tip. Never again. Punctuality is not in the picture. read more

Great pizza spot ! It's nice to get good pizza with good lasagna and meat balls too. Great local spot to help support a family owned business if you're in the area you should definitely try it out. read more

I called for a pick up order. A Chicago and a Hawaiian. Only request was to go to the edge with sauce and cheese on the Hawaiian. Was quoted 30-45 minutes. I arrived in just over 20 minutes and our food was ready. If i arrive at the 45 minute quote our food would have been sitting for almost half an hour. That's not very fresh, That why we pick up our own food. The place smelled amazing and we could I't wait to get back for pizza. The Chicago looked great but the sauce on top was almost dry. I'm use to being able to dip the crust in the sauce on top for some bread action but that didn't happen. It had a very good. The the Hawaiian is a different story. Topping looked great but when we took a bit it was dry. No sauce. I open the slice to see if they used a garlic butter or a white sauce or even a herbed ricotta. Nothing, What we did see way a slight pink color on the crust and the i realized they used a pastry brush or just the back of a spoon to "sauce the pizza". I call back. When I said I have an issue the wonder full mod of being called hun from her on the phone completely changed. She asked if we could bring it back but I said we we in for the night and really didn't want this to go one for another hour to go and comeback. I said would it be possible for some king of credit because we paid with a card. The lady, maybe her mother was in the back listening to our entire conversation. She then joined in and said that I first must send a picture of their pizza to their personal phone. I said great. It will be there in moments. I to the pick then immediately hit redial. The lady answered and said that it looks to here the "could have been sauce on there". I said mam these no tomato taste, it's a light pink. She then offer to give us a 25% discount one the one pizza. I said thank you that's cool. Then she add that I would never again be comped or discounted any food in the future. Where did this attitude come from. I told her we are travelers and would probably never be acknowledged in this immediate area. She then piped up them maybe I rethink that discount. I repeated back to her what she just said and she said yes and hung up on me. 50 years of In food service has been my life. We love supporting local placed and hate chains. I must say they both turned into total bit€he's when a customer called with a concern. I know food cost it very hard to attaint but don't compromise your products quality. out two pies cody $44.00 that's not cheap. But they are cutting corners and got called out, very politely and these "broads" went East coast nasty in their tone immediately. If these are the owners I very disappointed in how they deal with a simply food issue. I wish I had brought it back to them in person. If they spoke to my face the way they spoke to me on the phone, Those pizzas would have been smeared all omer their cash register and windows. You customer service it total bullshit. You both spoke about of your asses. I hope you can be grown enough to see just how much you both can affect your business. You have great rating but Karma is going to bite you in the ass for how you treat your guest. Thank a customer service class on hospitality. You're both pathetic. Hope you both have a great day. With I could attract the picture of that disappointed pizza. Have A great day and try not to be assholes to any of your guests today. That one step at a time. read more

Your Pizza Stop - Where is your tomato sauce? What your portion size. 1 Tablespoon per regular pie? and our Chicago did not look like the picture. - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

I've had their regular pizza and it was the best in town. I was craving Chicago pizza (see previous review) and it was the best I've had in Cali. Tonight my wife wanted to try their Sicilian pizza and I figured no way this won't suck. THEY PROVED ME WRONG! I fully endorse this pizza place. The service is always amazing, the staff is always friendly and the Za is a solid representation of what you'd expect. Nice work to the owner and the team. Never sacrifice what you're doing. Good quality food is hard to find. Keep it up. Chef to Chef, cheers! read more

Great pizza, great value. We love their crust and sauce. Nice to support a small business

My husband found this place one evening after our girls finished their gymnastics in the same shopping center. It's located behind Vons. This place is small and the employees are always nice. They take phone orders, which is what we do so we avoid waiting for the goodness. It's basically pizza to go, but makes for an awesome family dinner at home. This is great pizza! We usually buy pepperoni pizza and garlic cheese bread and it's delicious! The pizza is always consistently cooked where is melts in your mouth. They don't skimp on the cheese or the pepperonis, which is why it's a bit greasy, but it doesn't take away from the amazing taste. 2 large pizzas and the garlic cheese bread cost about $35. read more

Your Pizza Stop - Large pepperoni pizza and garlic cheese bread. More bread comes with order, but we started eating it before picture was taken :) - Pizza Near Me - Menifee, California

Very good pizza however cheese was pretty salty tasting. Crust was good! Looked that it was stuffed. Not original Chicago deep dish style.

Lasagna was burned all the way through. Sauce tasted like they bought the absolute cheapest canned tomato sauce they could find and did nothing to make it better. This was the absolute worst lasagna I've ever had--just the worst. If I could rate it negative 10 I would. read more

I have a business down the street from this pizza place and most of the food around here you have to go to Newport to get. I stopped in a few weeks ago to get a pepperoni pizza and the food was so fresh and delicious I was so happy I found this place. The customer service was outstanding the girl at that the front remembered me, was so kind and helpful! I've been in customer service for years and she made me feel so welcomed. Stopped by today to get a Greek salad and I'm impressed. So delicious, this will be my new go to for my healthy days and pizza for the opposing days lol...if you pass on this spot your missing out!!!! read more

See all

The pizza at Your Pizza Stop is amazing. We try to have pizza once a week and this is the only pizza my family likes to eat. The people at Your Pizza Stop are super friendly and always take a minute to say hello. I highly recommend Your Pizza Stop read more

My wife and I love the pizza here!!! We always get a classic pepperoni pizza. Always consistent, always delicious, and and always our favorite. 10/10 recommend read more

It would have been great if the girl at the register hadn't sneezed into her hands and then immediately grabbed my pizzas and handed them to me with those same germy hands she didn't wash....ughhh ... read more

I've only had the pizza, thin crust, and the antipasto salad, carry out. Both were very good. Everyone working here is always nice. Been coming here about five years and never been disappointed. read more

Great tasting pizza. Lots of salad variety. I like the amount of topping on the salads (lots of olives). Fast and friendly delivery.

Great pizza! Always delicious with hearty portions of toppings! Our go to place! Floppy pizza is my favorite and this place gets it right!

Food was excellent! We ordered both garlic and cheese bread, Spaghetti with meatballs, and a Supreme pizza. Everything was delicious, New York style crust, great quality. Delivery was a bit slow, but to be completely fair it was lunchtime on the weekend and we live out on the edge of their delivery zone. We will definitely order from them again, I would just recommend taking the possibility of a long delivery into consideration when figuring out what time you should place an order. read more

Best Pizza in Riverside County, they know what they are doing here. Don't sleep on this place!

Pizza is amazing every time. We love to order from here. It's hard to find a good pizza place that isn't too expensive.