Absolutely the best place. Food is so delicious - we have tried almost everything on the menu. All…read moregreat. Go to dish are the lamb chops and the chicken parm. Appetizer must in the sautee shrimp and calamari. People there are also the best.

Very nice looking restaurant with decent attentive service for the most part. The food selection…read morewas limited and it was just okay. There was a salad on the menu that had charred romaine lettuce, with marinated artichokes and reggiano cheese. I asked for just plain romaine and they poured olive oil and lemon on it. They didn't char it and it was still $25 for a plate of lettuce. The bread was tasty and came with butter loaded with too much garlic - the whole place was overrun with garlic as a matter of fact. The baby chicken was okay but not great and quite tiny which was fine. The dessert choice was limited to things that were all creamy and rich. We ordered gelato and it came to us like a bowl of soup - melted. The server didn't seem to notice and just put it down on the table. It was my birthday and my husband asked for a candle for the dessert but they didn't bother to remember. They did remove the charge for the melted gelato after I mentioned it. Since it was my birthday and it was expensive - and a bug came in from outside and landed in my hair it was a little disappointing. The bug was not the fault of the restaurant - it flew in from the parking lot where the outdoor tables were set up.

If you haven't tried the Vodka Pizza at Mario's yet, you are seriously missing out! It is…read morehands-down our favorite spot in town. The sauce is perfectly creamy with just the right amount of kick, and the crust always has that ideal crunch. What really sets Mario's apart, though, is their exceptional customer service. The team here truly goes out of their way to make sure their customers are happy. It's rare to find a place that cares as much about the experience as they do about the food. We're customers for life--thanks for the amazing meal! Thanks for taking care of us! Mario's is our favorite pizza!!!

2-16-25. Stopped in for lunch because I had an errand to run…read morein the immediate area. Ordered a chicken Marsala slice and a regular slice. Both were very good. My friend had a Sicilian slice and said it was excellent. Plenty of seating in a comfortable and casual atmosphere. Staff was very friendly and they had quite a large selection of specialty pizzas. Prices were reasonable.

Cafe al Dente has reopened under new management and they are wonderful! Had my B-I-L,s 75th…read morebirthday celebration there yesterday and the food was great and the staff top notch!

Went there for a 50-year reunion with about 40 people. Very accommodating, most important the food…read morewas absolutely superb. Nice parking and reasonably priced.

Had no idea Oyster Bay was so fast to deliver to Syosset... in 30 minutes or so we had an…read moreEverything pizza delivered... feared the worst because I ALWAYS pick up.. Under the weather had to default to delivery... this Everything Pizza arrived hot and with tons of delicious toppings.. bottom crust a bit dark... but better than raw for this heavily topped pizza... Delivery man was energetic and friendly. Nice vibe all around here. Would get again.... Thanks for the perfect stay at home dinner tonight.

What' a disappointment. Sometimes you have to give a place a few times before you are ready to give…read moreit up. Time to give up on Mana Mia's. The food is average. The pizza looks and tastes under done. But worst of all the counter staff is rude. About the only positive thing I can say is at least it's easy to park there.

We stopped in for lunch on a summer Friday afternoon…read more Sandwiches were A+, top tier, could not have asked for anything better. Staff was very nice and considerate, too! Vibe was good, comfortable, TVs just showing art work which was nice. It was clear this business is doing a lot of different things for their community and their customers. Will be the planned lunch the next time we are in OB.

Very pleased with this recent find. I searched for a pet…read morefriendly place to eat lunch and The Audrey was top of the list. Excellent service, great food on the outdoor patio. My Lobster Roll on a toasted bun was a best ever, my other half's tomato and mozzarella on a ciabotta bun was delicious. Out appetizer, which was chunks of baked bread with hummus, olive, and straccatellla (I know spelled wrong) was a generous portion and delicious. And most of all our precious Sadie enjoyed her afternoon out! We look forward to returning!

Grabbed breakfast at this store. Because we are still in this pandemic we were required to wear a…read moremask before entering. Bayville Deli makes amazing sandwiches. They make sandwiches to order. And the soft rolls they have are awesome! They carry sodas, water, tea, and other essentials. Not a lot of room when you have to social distance but it was worth the wait! Wish I had time to try their pizza. I'm sure it's great.

When I was young, I used to go goto Bayville a lot. They had an excellent arcade, for those who…read moreremember. So being back in town, I decided to try some eating. "Bayville Deli & Pizzeria" is a combo, you don't hear about a lot. Pizza, deli are two different businesses, and for good reason. It's not easy to mix. Inside it's a decent size. It's a bit dated, but I love that it offers seating for guest. At the counter, the staff were very friendly. They took my order and went to work. Once I got it, I sat down to eat. However, when you want an egg sandwich, you expect a couple things. For starters, cheese should be melted. Second, they should add more ketchup when you ask. So my experience was underwhelming. I wish it could have been better. I love Bayville, but some parts are not always how we remember.

Ralph's Pizza is an absolute gem. Hands down the best veggie pizza I've ever had--piping hot,…read moreperfectly cooked, and you can taste the difference because they roast the vegetables before they go on the pie. Total game changer. The slices are insane, and the grandma pie is equally incredible--crispy, flavorful, and done just right. Honestly, this is the best pizza I've had on Long Island. Must try. Do not sleep on this place.

My go to spot for pizza in Bayville for decades. They have a delicious NY style slices. The…read moreingredients are fresh, the pizza is delicious, and the service is fast. The restaurant itself has very old school pizzeria vibes. I love it. I recently discovered how good their chicken sandwiches are. I can't believe I've been sleeping on those for so long! And they have Italian ices for dessert!

Ordered a plain cheese pizza pie to pick up. The guy over the phone told me the pie would be ready…read morein approx 20 mins. Fine. Got to the restaurant ambience seems decent. I picked up a large plain pie for approx 24$. The pizza wasn't to my liking. It was flavorless, probably cause the pizza sauce wasn't authentic - the cheese mediocre and the pizza dough didn't have that New York City/Bronx dough taste. I like my pizza Neapolitan style. Neopolitan pizza is my favorite with fresh ingredients for dough and simple but tried and true pizza sauce. This place was disappointing. I disliked the pizza taste here. Maybe try the other Italian dishes here, cause this pizza is NOT tasty. Adequate parking in the parking lot.

Y'all (as in my Long Island folk). If you have never been to Gino's...RUN!…read more This spot has become my absolute favorite over the last couple of years. Myself and my family can seriously not get enough. Whether you order to-go or dine in, expect amazing quality and generous portions. Anytime I am back home on LI from Boston, and especially when I have a non-NYer visiting, Gino's is first on our list. It is the definition of New York Italian food. Everything is so fresh, rich, and flavorful. You can tell that everything is made from the most quality ingredients, from the cheeses to the sauces. My personal must-orders: fried ravioli, drunken rice balls, Tortellini Cotto, buffalo spring rolls, cold antipasto, and a half pepperoni vodka grandma pie. Pro tip: I'm obsessed with adding hot honey or balsamic glaze to nearly everything, but honestly, Gino's dishes are so flavorful you won't need a thing! Note: if you have leftovers they will stay good for days!