They are "old school" when it comes to their pizza, "FAT burgers" and chicken wings, which is a GOOD thing! Everything is tasty and the owner (AJ) is very friendly. I also love that he employs a lot of youngsters, helping the local economy. I try to stop by for takeout whenever I can, and so should you. read more

The only place to get pizza ! Fast friendly service.delivery people are nice...people taking order on the phone are nice..

Everyone is super nice. They seem to be the only pizzaria that can get a sandwich correct the way I order it. Always delivered when they tell you it will be there. Pizza is excellent, cheese steaks are great. The owner was also generous enough to donate to my daughters preschool. read more

Absolutely dry and unappealing. Fairly burnt on the bottom and came after an hour wait even though im a five min drive from their store. Hopefully they change their store enough for me to be convinced to go back and order again. read more

Love AJ's pizza!!!!! Love ordering from Butler and Pompton Plains. The food is amazing and the staff is really nice. The meat lovers Pizza is delicious and happy I decided to try something different. read more

GREAT FOOD AT A BETTER PRICE ++== I have been eating at Ajs for years and i have yet too be bored their menu is constantly upgradeing the new dinners and subs amazing the pizza always great the best in the area (new jersey) when the online menu came up just another addition to the greatness that is Ajs pizza Liked: Food, Service, Atmosphere, Value, Pizza AJ's Pizza is a family owned pizza & Italian food restaurant located in Butler, New Jersey. Our dough is rolled fresh daily and our zesty red sauce is made in house and seasoned daily. Founded in 1990 read more

Ajs Pizza, Thank you for catering our 75th birthday party!!! The food was delicious and the service was way above expected...Your prices were reasonable and the portions were very generous... Thank you again for everything. We look forward to using you again. Prior to hiring you, we researched other surrounding pizzerias, by far your prices were the best........Thumbs up to A.J. & his staff. Thank You, The Krattiger's read more

Food sucks never order from again. I ordered a sausage roll to be delivered it came but no sausage just pepper an onion. they told me they would send me a new one but they just blue me off and closed up shop. read more

The only complaint I have for AJs pizza is that I ordered a pie extra crispy and it came black on the bottom burnt. Extra crispy does not mean burnt. This is the first time I ordered from any pizza place and never got an extra crispy pie burnt. But the time before this that I ordered pizza it was great. read more

Let me say something. Customer service is a very important issue when ur in the food industry. Doesn't matter how good your food tastes, when your attitude is bad, no one is going to want to come back. Improvement is definitely needed this facility. A simple greeting when a customer walks in is a basic and read more

I think because this place is so busy they really slack on quality. It's not what it used to be and definitely a last resort.

Decent pizzeria food, but forgot part of my order two times in a row after taking twice as long as they said they would. The food is ok but not worth that hassle. read more

Don't waste your money!!! Pizza 1 in Haskell blows them away. We moved here 2 years ago and were dedicated AJ customers because they were quick and easy,(bonus online ordering) spending on average $100/week (middle aged travelling professional couple w no kids) They think they have it locked down!!! The food was mediocre at best, pizza was just nasty...try Coney Island pizza if you like wood fired....YUM!!!!! The last straw was a hero we ordered and the bread had to be at least 3 days old (btw, never order whole wheat heros....seriously stale) We called, even went down in person....nothing....over a $10 sandwich they cost their business $5,200. read more

Absolutely best place to eat! Their options are limitless and the staff is extremely helpful. I had the Chicken Tomesto, it was so delicious, I felt like asking for a job so I can continuously eat their food all day. The waitress Victoria was also fabulous. She answered all our dietary questions and attended to our every need. She was sweet and funny. Finally a great waitress at an amazing place. Then the cherry on top was the fact that their bathroom was clean. You know a place is spotless if their bathroom is clean! If your in the area try this place!!! Pizza is to die for and my fiancé's sautéed broccoli and mozzarella was scrumptious. Love this place, what a gem! read more

I have eaten from this establishment many times and this review will be a combination of those. For pizza, this is a good thin crust pie with decent cheese, sauce, and crust. Sandwiches run big and for most people the small size will be sufficient or the large to two meals. Pasta is average but not displeasing. Eating in at the restaurant is casual, service is pleasant and attentive without any big problems. Delivery is prompt with no issues experienced. Take out is also available. Parking may be problem since there are few spots on the street. read more

Very good delivery in the area and they are sure busy every time we see them drive by. Sometimes it takes them 40 minutes for the delivery, but I can't entirely blame them because of the terrain and the mountains in the area. The Pizza is good and they have a really huge menu. I always order from them when I have company over. read more

The food is always great! Casual dining experience at affordable price. Staff is great - very friendly!

We order from here at least 3 or four times a week. Pizza, chicken parm, penne and vodka sauce, shrimp scampi, and their Apple craisin salad are our favorites!!! The girls on the phone know their job well, are polite and focused. Owners are hard workers and very friendly. Delivery guys could not be nicer!! Always consistent and always great!!! read more

Pretty reliable delivery and consistent food. An easy go to when you don't know what else is for dinner.

love their food and customer service. been using them for years and now i'll continue to do so. wish the app. still had an option to include a tip though... been order less bc i rarely have cash on me. read more

I moved to the west coast recently, and this is one of the places I miss. This is not the place for plain pizza, but it is absolutely the best place for penne vodka pizza. I'm telling you, there is nothing better than that penne vodka pizza!! And their garlic knots are fantastic too. read more

AJ'S pizza is our absolute favorite pizza place to order from. The pizza is so delicious and their sides are great too. Almost never disapoints us - sometimes when we order the food might taste a little different than usual or there isn't as much buffalo popcorn chicken or calamari or something. But almost every time it's absolutely deliciously perfect. We order from there a lot it's really good. read more

I have ordered catering a few times in the last month. DJ has been so helpful with all the ordering. Every time they set up and food was delicious! Definitely recommend for catering. Great job! read more

So here is why I rate AJ's as a 1 star place of business. My wife and I have spent plenty of money ordering in the past from AJ's and my review is not about the food. It is about the service. Normally we have had somewhat of a pleasant experience but then there was today. So we were being helped by a girl named Angela who according to her manager Dan is a 19 year old girl. Don't know why that mattered but ok. Anyway we have a phone that we know has in the past been told our volume is low. So I go through my order which totaled around 55 dollars. I inform Angela that I will be paying with a credit card. I proceed to give her the numbers. She tells me it is invalid. I then say no problem let me read it again and then proceed to speak louder so she can hear me which I believe is the problem. I get through giving her the numbers at which she tells me "sir, you don't need to give me an attitude." So that is my issue. I was nothing but polite speaking up because I wanted her to make sure she had my cc numbers was told that I was giving her attitude. I explained to her I was only speaking up because I did not think she got the numbers because of the phone. She explained to me that she felt I was giving her attitude. No "Oh ok I am sorry I did not realize that" That would have been better. To continue.... I then asked to speak with her manager. Dan is his name. Dan, apologizes, says he will reprimand her but then says sir she is a 19 year old girl. Ok, So Dan because she is 19 am I supposed to give her slack because she is 19 and is allowed to give a customer attitude. So folks believe me coming from a person that works in an industry that is customer service related do not order from this establishment. Or at least until management gets older representatives to answer the phone because obviously if you are 19 or younger it is ok to give your customers attitude. read more

I've been ordering from this place for a little over a year now. They have excellent food and insane portions. I usually get the same order, chicken parm with vodka sauce, but once in a while I vary it up. I have never been disappointed. read more

Excellent food, staff friendly, BYO clean reasonable priced food. My new favorite.

Good pizza and dishes. Their wing needs some work. They definitely use good quality cheese and their sauce could use some more spice. Everyone has different tastes. I just read the other reviews and people are so funny with their comments! Its just pizza people... The owner is very likable and friendly. read more

I will never place an order for mussels from AJ's ever again. Most pathetic order of mussels I've ever gotten from anywhere I've eaten. Their pizza isn't bad but don't waste your money on the mussels unless you like a small overpriced portion. Anthony Franco's in Butler is a much better choice for a mussel order. read more

Ordered delivery for a cheese pie, mozzarella sticks and a calzone. It took 2 hours and 15 minutes and everything was cold. Receptionist is extremely rude and gives terrible customer service. Never calling this place again. read more

Sometimes you just don't know what you want for dinner. This was the case, with me, on Tuesday night. I called AJ's and Lu answered. This guy was UNBELIEVABLY helpful! He took the time to help me choose something for delivery. And the choice was exactly as he promised. The delivery was on time and the food was GREAT. You will not be disappointed with AJ's. . read more

I called in 40 minutes after my order was to be delivered. They said it hadn't been made yet. I've been a very consistent customer and they lost my business. I understand bad nights but this is completely unreasonable. read more

Been there numerous times. Their pizza is perfect, and the other dishes I've had have been really good, too. Service is courteous, friendly, and fast. I've recommended it to family and friends. read more

Love AJ's! They have so many options on their menu. My favorite is the Greek gyro with zucchini sauce. The appetizers are def worth getting. They have mac and cheese balls that are to die for! Wings are awesome too! read more

They are rude and take way to long to deliver. By the time the foods arrives it is not hot or fresh and their pizza is not great.

Arguably the best pizza in the tri-state area. While its not the cheapest pie you'll find, its the best. They are always busy because everyone knows the facts - AJ's is tops. I recommend pick-up, though, for this reason. read more

house salad = iceberg lettuce, some olives, one hot pepper, 1 tiny slice of provolone couple of slivers of carrot, just enough dresing to dress half the salad = 6.50? time to find a new place. read more

I've been a patron for years probably 5 to say the least sometimes ordering multiple times a week. I place an order online because when I called I was put on hold for an extremely long time, no biggie it happens on a Friday .. However I place my order at 7:27pm awaiting patiently for my food over an HOUR later at 8:35pm that's when I get a call saying they are out of what I ordered .. Are you kidding me???? OVER AN HOUR AFTER I ORDER I get a call that the food I ordered is not available that makes me so infuriated when I've worked for 10 hours and just want a decent meal in a reasonable time frame. None the less they don't even offer something comp'd when my food should have been delivered by the time the associate CALLED. Honestly this just pisses me off because they know how often I order. You've gotten a few strikes from misplaced orders, wrong orders, taking extremely long times to deliver but this tops it. read more

when u order on the phone prepare for the girl answering to waste ur time and repeat the order up to 3 times. wat u do when someone is ordering is shut up and listing. but wat this girl did i order the pizza i moved on to my sub but she was talking over me about the pizza. just shut up and tell me when im done she priocedded to d that all the way thru the hold order. then the girl wanted me to waste more of my time as she repeated it ANOTHER FING TIME i dont have time to waste shut up write the order down then repeat it once when im done THAT SIMPLE. OH AND GET A NEW PHONE THAT GIRL SAYS SHE CANT HEAR ME. read more