Excellent! We came here for dinner on what was apparently their second night of having dinner service and it was great! We ordered the ricotta with focaccia for our appetizer which was amazing and then for dinner I ordered the bolognese while my boyfriend ordered the roasted chicken. Both dishes were spot on! I was shocked by how juicy and flavorful the roasted chicken was! Another big factor for me was that it felt like one in only a very small handful of restaurants we found in downtown Montauk that was both moderately priced and also very cute. read more

Alimentari Beach - The bolognese. It's hard to tell but it is a very generous portion! - Italian Near Me - Montauk, New York

Pizza was good , meatballs not like home, so over rated. Waiter was good , waitress who was helping terrible, bringing out our meatball appetizer after main course arrived she handed over to us and put it on the pizza plate . They need to get it together for these prices. read more

The pizza here is very good! Wow! I was actually suprised how good it was. We got the pizza with burrata on top and it was very delicious. My only gripe is that the burrata was cold on top of the hot pizza. Other than that, it was great. Service was sweet during midday lunch. read more

No wait for a table at 5:30 on a Saturday. We sat outside. The outside seating is weird though because part of your party is expected to sit on a bench that's attached to the building. You wind up being higher than everyone else in your party. Service was seriously lacking which made for a rather unpleasant dining experience. We got our two spritzs but a glass of wine was forgotten. Took a good 5-10 minutes to finally get our waitress. She seemed to be covering tables inside and out. They really screwed up and brought our appetizers with our main entrees. There was barely enough room on the table for everything. The whipped ricotta comes in a bowl with pieces of bread. You don't taste much of the ricotta but either was it was very good. The bread is fantastic!!! I think this is one reason my mom ordered the Italian sandwich again (not her first time here). The calamari was okay. I'm not a fan of the sauce; it's kind of bland. The sauce on the shrimp fra diavolo tasted the same just with some heat to it. Can't say I was crazy about the dish. I also barely ate it since I just had appetizers. While I didn't try the pizza my dad got I'm glad it didn't turn out like the guy's sitting next to us. The crust on one of his pieces was completely burnt, pure black charcoal. From other reviews this seems to be an issue. read more

See all

Our 1st night in Montauk and we had to get pizza, so delicious!! We so enjoyed the meatballs & the shrimp w polenta... staff was great!! And we loved the vibe the open space of the restaurant felt very inviting! read more

I love it here. Everything is good. I like the way the place looks, the staff is great and the food is awesome.

Alimentari is an excellent spot by the beach to grab a sandwich, pizza, and a curated selection of market goods. They're open late, which makes it convenient after a long day of activities. I love their burrata pie - it was delicious. Their crust is the best part - it's light & crispy and perfectly charred. Will deff be back to try their brunch pizza :) read more

Alimentari Beach - Burrata pie - Italian Near Me - Montauk, New York

Fresh delicious food! I enjoyed the harvest salad fully of veggie goodness as well as the roasted parmesan mushrooms. I also appreciated the causal, but very night atmosphere. Others loved their Italian Sandwiches. I suspect everything they serve would be excellent. read more

We ordered all appetizers! The meatballs, whipped feta with bruschetta and crispy artichokes. Turned out to be excellent recommendations from our server. Meatballs were light and very tasty. Whipped feta was unique and different. Crispy artichokes were good but deep fried. Not a negative but a little oily. Thought I was in the mood for pasta but enjoyed the not so heavy alternative. read more

Descent place to eat in montauk. Food descent ,service is good too and the outdoor sitting is pretty nice read more

Alimentari Beach - Calamari - Italian Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

One of our favorite places in Montauk! Amazing service, food, location, and atmosphere! We booked a celebration of life luncheon here fairly last minute and they were nice enough to accommodate us. Our family and friends raved about the food... whipped ricotta, calamari, Caesar salad, penne bolognese, Italian sandwiches, and clam pizza... everything was delicious!!!! Can't say enough good things. We always love coming here but the entire staff made our event extra special for us and we'll never forget it read more

Stopped in for a glass of wine and an appetizer. Split a salad and Arancini. Delicious! Good service too.

This place is totally under rated ,great Italian food, amazing pizza, and they have a ricotta dip with the bread which is out of this world, sit outside order pizza, have a glass of rosé and watch the crowds go by, highly recommend read more

Excelente service and wine. We had the clam pizza, pepperoni pizza and the hearty and delish lasagne. The calamari melted in your mouth!! Unreal and so good. read more

We got the whipped ricotta and calamari for starters. Both delicious. I would go back just for that whipped ricotta. I had the AB Italian sandwich and it was one of the best sandwiches I've had in a long time. Friendly staff. I love the big windows that look out onto the street. read more

Best place to grab lunch or dinner in Montauk! Chic ambience, amazing pasta, pizza, wine & spritzes

Wow! Hidden secret! Local Vibe and Food I haven't tasted since my Italian Grandmother fed us out of her basement kitchen. Pizza-crispy (charred bottom), airy, chewy crust. High quality cheese w/ fresh basil leaf Meatball-you can almost taste all the ingredients pork and beef with a aged Parmesan Crispy Artichokes-in a tasty sauce they call Romesco Arancini-fancy word for the most delicious herb risotto rolled around goooey creamy lioni mozzarella and garlic aioli. Calamari lightly breaded and fried w/ basil aioli Wonderful hot freshly made cannoli's lightly drizzled with local honey served with a perfectly made cappuccino. The Partner Gianni was so kind and welcoming and is in love with Montauk....a genuine person, extremely knowledgeable and warm Very excited about the sit down service! Welcomed addition. Already planning on ordering takeout. Oh, old Montauk prices were a surprise. Will be back read more

Alimentari Beach - herb risotto creamy mozzarella Meatballs...aged Parmesan Crispy marinated Artichokes Calamari- crispy in a basil aioli - Italian Near Me - Montauk, New York

Wow is all i could say. Food is amazing here at Alimentari Beach. Its priced right for great quality food. The decor of the place is so cute and sits alot of people. The service is on the money. Best service in montauk especially the waitress Natalie. She serves you with a beautiful smile and never messes up my order. She suggested the pizza and it was like grimaldis pizza, if your from brooklyn you know what im talking about. The lasagna was also a big hit. I will definietly be back soon and tell my friends and family. Sorry no pics. Good looked and tasted to good. Next time i promise. read more

Excellent. Penne bolognese Taste homemade. Capresse salad very fresh and lightly dressed.

OMG! So good. My old fashion was so delicious. I only had an appetizer but it was a good one. Whipped ricotta with a fig something and garlic confit. And lots of doughy bread strips. Totally go. You will not be disappointed. Friendly, open, inviting. And right in town. read more

'Audacity' is the first thing to come to mind when opening our to-go order. Instead of making a new pizza, you send me and my kids home with this crap? We live in Montauk year-round but unfortunately we won't be dining here ever again. This place has noticeably gone down hill since their head chef left for greener pastures. read more

Alimentari Beach - Congratulations, you cook pizza? - Italian Near Me - Montauk, New York

Went twice... time number 1 was great, great service, great food, had a great time sitting outside time number 2 (3 days later) was ok, service was not great and waited a while just to get a bottle of water, food took forever (even for having the same amount of people as before), food was pretty much the same. Overall good food and ambiance but mediocre service read more

This was such an overrated restaurant! The food was disgusting and there was a piece of PLASTIC in my food!!. I bit into it and almost chocked!! The service was HORRIBLE! They made us wait an hour for our simple order of pizza and a small pasta dish. We were already seated with a glass of wine, placed our order at 8 and by 9:30, we still didn't have ANY food!! Meanwhile, two couples arrived 30 minutes AFTER us, were seated next to us and got their food immediately and even finished their meal while WE still waited. Summary: we waited almost 2 hours for a meal. Service was terrible. At no point did the waitress come get and say hey, so sorry, thanks for your patience, your food will be out soon. I do NOT recommend this place at all! Avoid. Go anywhere else! read more

Food was absolutely delicious! It was a long wait on a Saturday night but was worth it

This place is gahdamn amazing. And one of the owners Gary is the absolute best. I could close my eyes and point to things on the menu to order and I'm confident it would all be 10/10. Montauk needs more great dining options like this. Get the spritz. And the espresso martini. Just get it all. read more

Super cool joint in the core of Montauk. Ordered an almond milk Cortado and liked it better than the one I had the day before at the left hand coffee shop down the street. Also ordered two little Italian pastries which were delicious and perfect for an afternoon coffee snack. This place does pizzas, has a bar and espressos. That's like 3 of the best things in the world. Would come back. read more

Alimentari Beach - Italian Near Me - Montauk, New York

See all

Absolutely best pizza from East Hampton to Montauk - No question. My wife and I came the day after Thanksgiving and enjoyed the whipped ricotta appetizer and a pepperoni pizza along with some great wine and bourbon. We'll absolutely be back. read more

We went to montauk during off season, and this was one of the few places open, and im so happy it was. The food was really good and fresh, balanced flavors. The service was a really good as well. The restaurant itself is beautiful, quaint and inviting. read more

See all

Very lovely place but I wasn't really impressed with the food. I ordered spaghetti pomodoro which was just alright, I've made my own better at home. The wine was decent and the bread was okay. Nice waitstaff, but food was also overpriced, typical of the area. read more

Tldr: Decent pizza if served within the appropriate window for food eating. If you eat here don't sit outside. You'll get better service inside. Went in for some lunch. Ordered 2 pizzas for 3 people upon the cashier's request. That was probably the right call so I'll give him that. He then said we can take a seat outside and he'll "come find you guys outside" to deliver the pizza. We took our seats outside and waited... and waited... for our pizza. Which never came out. I went inside to find out pizzas which no one was available to help me out. So I went back to my seat. I contemplated a little more then eventually went back in to speak to someone. To no surprise another lady was in my same position... waiting for a pizza. Alas a savior from the kitchen comes to our aid and asks us what we need. We say "pizza" he comes backs with our pies which to no surprise are COLD. I take the pizza and go back to my 2 hungry people. We ate the pizza, it was decent but I was upset. No hospitality from the man and cold pizza. Eat outside at your own risk. read more

Absolutely incredible. One of the best restaurants I ever experienced. Gianni the owner is so kind and so amazing. Next level food and such a good atmosphere. Really, really recommend read more

Quality food. Taste great. Had the Vodka pasta. Would be nice with some bread to mop. Family shared a pizza. Both were delicious. Actually they loved the pizza. Desert was zepplies with cannoli cream. Popcorn size. Very tasty. Chill relax type of place. Cafe style. We enjoyed it. Staff was great. read more

Had the AB Italian per the waiter's recommendation and shared that and a Harvest Salad with my wife. Both were excellent and reasonably priced. Comfortable, casual place that's open and bright inside with a huge array of windows looking out to the public square. Outside seating is available. Good stuff! read more

Just had one of the rudest experiences at this establishment. The blatant disrespect and disregard of the host left me and my friend in shock and drove us to leave immediately. Throwing down menus in front of our faces was the last straw. Not sure if this was racially motivated, but we will never be back. read more

If I could give 10 stars I would. Sydney was just the best - she sat us so seamlessly, walked us through her favorites on the menu and made us feel right at home. read more

Never brought water, had to ask for it. When we ordered a second round of drinks, we waited over 25 minutes. Food is not good. We had 2 pizzas and several apps, 2 pastas. Pizza was good but expensive for such a small pie. pasta sauce on spaghetti (pomodoro) and lasagna was absolutely horrible. Tasteless! The meatballs were burnt. Also had zero flavor besides the burntness. Better ofd going to Pizza Village up the street! Been going there 8 years and it's the best! read more

This restaurant was fantastic. The service was excellent. Friendly waiter. Attentive but not annoying. The food was delicious and satisfying. Prices were reasonable. My husband said "this was the best spaghetti and meatballs I have had in my life. And he did 77 years old! You must try this place. It will not disappoint Jim and Nan Hayes Visited No ember 3 202: read more

Service was great !! Excellent food! Lasagna and pizza- awesome! Will definitely be back! Great vibe! read more

Don't come here hungry has to be the smallest amount of pasta I've ever been served in my 60 years of living and for pasta that looks like they made it the mircowave . Pretty steep prices on top of that much better options trust me read more

Nice addition to Mtk. Food and Service very good. Music was blaring but they turned it down upon request. THANKS. Hate screaming instead of talking with my dinner companions. The table next to ours thanked me for asking...... Mystery is lack of high chairs? This, for the most part, is a family community so would think a high chair would be available. Suggestion. Get a couple of high chairs. read more