Date of visit: May 30, 2025 All of the Bakers Square locations in the Milwaukee area have long since closed, much to my husband's chagrin. As such, we try to stop here on our way back from O'Hare since this seems to be the closest one now to us. Given how quiet it is, I can't imagine that this location will stay open too much longer; very few tables on a Friday night. We were greeted warmly and lead to a worn out booth directly next to another table (if the joint is empty, why not give us a one booth cushion?). Staff was friendly and relatively attentive and the prices were quite good--especially for Chicago. The food was just okay; my Honey Mustard Wrap was sloppily assembled and difficult to eat. I actually would have preferred there to be a little less food in it so it wasn't so awkward to eat. My friend's "steak" was really ground beef not steak, which was odd. They don't have coconut cream pie anymore, just coconut meringue which was just okay. read more

Bakers Square - Coconut Meringue - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

01/22/25 - We came here because I got a $10 gift card for my birthday. What we didn't realize is Wednesday is free pie day if you buy a meal & a drink. (No wonder there are so many people here) My wife ordered avocado toast w/a fruit bowl as a side. I ordered the skillet w/bacon, sausage, ham, potatoes, onions, peppers & cheese sounds good but unfortunately it was pretty mediocre. Ahhh the kicker. All the employees were wearing free pie Wednesday so inquired about that & sure enough I got a free piece of caramel pecan pie that was simply delicious. It's truely unfortunate that Baker Square is closing so many restaurants as their pies are so dam good read more

See all

Tomorrow being Pi Day, I thought it appropriate to pick up a few pies from Bakers Square. This location has a large parking lot (very active-- I saw squad cars with flashing lights and people running through the plaza) -- but let me say my pies were ready and waiting for me and the staff was very nice and helpful! Thanks! read more

See all

There aren't many locations left in Chicago but this one near Harlem-Irving Plaza (Otherwise, known as HIP mall) is a hit! Still serving the classics such as All-American Crush burger, as well as French Silk Pie (which is to die for and my personal favorite). Service always impeccable. Maria, our waitress, always paid close attention to us and knew the menu blindfolded. Bakers Square goes way back to my childhood being the place with a "Welcome Family" ambiance. Also note, not only must you try their pies but sit down and also induldge in it with their fresh house coffee! Bon Appetit! read more

The staff are always so kind and the pies are fresh and amazing. We love Baker Square!

Amongst Baker's Square locations, this location is a bit better than some locations that I've visited. One of the more standout features here is the decor. This is probably renovated a bit more recently as it overall looks a bit more modern and has more seating options (especially for groups) than I've typically seen -- along with distinct sections that help to keep the noise down. Service is fairly quick and friendly, where they also utilize technology to digitally track order and accept payment. It did take a little while to get the food, but it wasn't unreasonably long (I've recently been to IHOP and Denny's which have taken longer to prepare). Food was overall fairly good and value priced. Portion sizes were generous and the flavors were exactly as I expect from Bakers Square. Some items could've come out a bit warmer, but given that they allow you to create large combos of options -- I can understand how it can be more challenging to manage everything with many small plates going out at once. Overall, a solid Baker's Square option that's good for fulfilling your cravings for delicious baked items and breakfast for dinner. read more

See all

We came here for lunch after some errands in the area. Our food and service were both great! I had a smothered meat lovers omelet and my boyfriend had chicken fried steak. We were so stuffed so we ended up taking our pie home (Free Pie Wednesday = free slice with purchase of an entree and a drink). The man at the front (manager?) explained to us that there are only three remaining Bakers Square locations in Illinois. This location, Woodridge, and Palatine. He explained that Palatine was turned into a Village Inn and the only difference is a stronger emphasis on breakfast foods. Otherwise, it's the same menu, same recipes, same pies, etc. I was really impressed at how clean and bright it was inside. I would definitely come back here! read more

We love the Asian Stir-Fry; loaded with broccoli, red & green peppers, sauteed onion, snow peas, sweet mandarins, muchrooms, rice and absolutely delicious pieces of baked chicken. The service is always good, and we love our 10% senior discount. Today, the manager, Jose Flores, noticed that the propane gas at the Walgreens across the street was on fire! He grabbed the fire extinguisher & without thinking twice, ran across the street to put out the fire that could have become an explosion causing serious damage to the community's Walgreens. He is one of those "Silent Heroes!" So, good food, good service, and a manager like Mr. Jose Flores, that definitely goes beyond the call of duty! Stop by and shake his hand, and, of course, order something delicious...maybe even pie! read more

Still busy The manager is friendly . The sever was nice. It looks the same z It's a very talkative family place . Lit well to see your food . They still have enough pie choices Next time I'll go on a Wednesday for free pie Wednesday read more

See all

I had a craving for breakfast food, and a trip to Bakers Square fulfilled that craving. Their 4x4 breakfast is a great deal. For $12, I ordered chocolate chip pancakes, half of a Belgian waffle, sausage, and hash browns. It was delicious and almost too much food. This is a great value. Our sever was very nice. I highly recommend Bakers Square! read more

See all

Is this place good for groups? Yes, but ... Given advance notice, they happily accommodated our party of 13 at a large table in a semi-private nook and consented to separate checks (acknowledging this would take some time). It was lunchtime and there were already a fair number of customers when we arrived. On the negative side, there was only one server for the entire restaurant, and she also had to be busboy and cashier. Meanwhile, the guy sitting at the front desk did little more than greet and seat customers. When asked why he didn't pitch in and help, he said his job was supervisor, and per protocol it was the restaurant manager's job to assign and schedule staff. What total hogwash! (Hey, corporate management, didja know you're paying this guy to sit there and do nothing?) Oh, and the AC was on the fritz. But here's what Baker's Square did to earn 4 stars from me. First, our server "M" showed remarkable skill and resilience under pressure. She and the kitchen got all of our orders exactly right, and the diner-style food was really very good overall. My chicken fajita pita, though not quite a Rick Bayless masterpiece, was good enough that I would order it again; and the accompanying coleslaw was crisp and tangy. Most of my companions ordered basic breakfast fare. The egg dishes, bacon and pancakes earned high marks. Eggs Benedict was described as "among the very best." And of course, the pies were as enjoyable as ever. read more

Used to love coming here but the last time i went the service was terrible. We waited well over an hour for our food before walking out. The restaurant was not busy when we went so there was no reason why it should take that long for our food. When we went to leave the manager asked us if we were leaving because of the long wait for food and comped our drinks. They seem to be perpetually under staffed. Until they fix this I would avoid coming here read more

I went with my best friend and niece for a late sit down dinner to catch up on life. Coffee and pie were still a staple. The dinners were absolutely horrible. Thrown together, wrong items of food brought to the table, no water brought to the table. I felt my seven year old niece could have made a better preparation for us. The staff was nice and trained but I feel they are limited with the quality of resources they have. This use to be a popular location for a Bakers Square on the Northwest side. It still has potential but needs an Overhaul. For a corner restaurant on a Main Street, pass it up, or just do a carry out for the pies. It's the only thing this place has that's still edible. read more

I only order their French silk pie. It is the best and to die for! This is what my family's been ordering for 30+ years.

Wow, the size of the pie slices here is absolutely ridiculous for the price! We ordered four different slices to go, and every single one was shockingly small--nothing like the pictures in the menu. I remember when a slice of pie at Bakers Square meant a generous portion, but those days are clearly gone. If the quality and portion sizes were like they used to be, I wouldn't mind paying the price. But at this point, it's just not worth it. We won't be coming back. read more

Bakers Square - Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Slice - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

Unloved our visit to this place after a long absence. I had the chicken avocado melt and it was delicious . My sister had the stir fry and my brother in law had a burger. We were all happy. And the pie is still great. read more

When you're in the mood for a pie - slice or whole- this is the place to go. Never had the good but have heard it's good. Counter service is not very friendly. read more

After three random visits trying to get my hands on the banana cream pie, they were always out. On my fourth try, the woman at the front told me they were out again, but she offered to make it for me if they had bananas. I was thrilled and amazed that this was even possible at a place like this. Thank you, and I wish I had gotten your name. read more

Considering we were there at lunch today and as empty as the place was at 1pm, service was very slow. Sandwich was really small too. Coleslaw was OK. read more

Is Bakers Square Going out of business in St. George, Utah? The River Road 1450 South location is fairly new, but they skimp so much on the sandwiches, meat, cheese, lettuce, tomato and everything else, that it appears as though they have a cash flow problem and are trying to remedy it by cutting down on all the ingredients. They once had better food, so it's sad to see them going out of business. read more

You can't beat these pies. I'm only reviewing the pies. This is my favorite go to for my holiday pies. My favorite pies are the French Silk, Banana Cream Pie, and the Cherry Pie. They are fresh and so delicious! Highly recommend if you want something easy to pick up without sacrificing the taste and deliciousness of a pie. read more

the food is great and hot the service is helpful without being a bother and the pie is great read more

The French Silk pie was not pleasing this year for our family's Thanksgiving dessert they have cut back on their ingredients and added cheaper ingredients more pies for us. Service was good it was ghost town at this location. The place needs remodeling. read more

If you haven't been for awhile check it out, thoroughly impressed by the food for a fast casual place. Try the chicken pita/stir fry and chip steak. And don't forget the pie! read more

Wow, a throw back in time. This may be the only Bakers Square left. Ambience was ok 65+ age group. Food and service were good and prices reasonable. Serving mostly breakfast and lunch items. The French Silk pie was amazing. read more

Less crowded than another diner down the street so we went here on a Sunday morning. Most patrons were spread out which was good. My hubby ordered the Ultimate Skillet and I had the Reuben. My son had a kids meal. Overall the food was good. The server was good but we were never given water and at the end she disappeared for a long time before we got our check. She tells us that she can take care of it there but disappears again for a bit. So we all got up, paid by the door, and left. I'm glad we didn't need anything wrapped to go. read more

Bakers Square - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

See all

We use to frequent this location quite regularly when we lived in the area. we moved out of state but come back often for family and friends. Tonight we decided to have dinner here. I ordered my favorite Honey Mustard Club Pita. It was awful! There was no honey in the dressing at all, just plain creamy mustard! The processed meat was terrible. Not even sure if it was turkey on it. . I ordered fruit instead of fries and the pieces were half hard and half over ripe. like they had been frozen at one time and then cut into pieces. My husband ordered his favorite, the turkey dinner. Again instead of real turkey it was all processed meat. Awful! When we asked the waiter about it he said they changed vendors and everything is different. It sure is! And we won't be going back there again. When we asked for the bill he pulled out his handheld thing and told us what the total bill was and that he would be back to collect the money. No bill, No receipt and definitely no more business from us. I can see why it was EMPTY in the restaurant at 5:15, the height of a dinner hour. read more

Love their pies! I just hate the fact that there are not very many left. I love their caramel picko silk supreme pies, they lemon supreme, and the key line. In fact, I'll be headed to get another pie Friday, because I have to go to O'Hare airport. read more

Banana cream pie are the best when the have them in stock!! No one makes them better!!

Short and sweet :) We just got 2 slices of pie using a delivery service for Pie Day today and they were delicious. It was actually kind of hard to find a pie on Pie Day, so I loved how easy it was to get these from here. I would definitely get them again. read more

I called this location last minute on Valentine's Day to get a French silk pie. I don't recall the young man I spoke to, but he was extremely helpful, personable, and had great customer service skills. When I went to pick up the pie, it was already packaged and in a bag so I could pick it up quickly. Great job and great service! And, of course, the pie was excellent! Highly recommend the Norwood location. read more

Bakers Square is a really nice cozy place. We loved it! The waitress was really nice we loved the serves and the food itself was really nice. All of their staff was so knowledgeable, genuinely enthusiastic, and a complete delight! Family friendly & handicap accessible. Good place for breakfast anytime, lunch & dinner. There is a pie shop special. Good for a light meal that comes with a slice of pie. You can easily find their place in this area because they are also near to other popular place. The food was exceptional and it was cooked in a good time. Definitely will go back. read more

Food was good. Basic breakfast. BUT they did get my order wrong. Haven't ordered to go from here so will try it again to see if they make the same mistake. read more

My go to place for pie but im not sure if location matters. The apple pie from this location barely has any sugar on top. I thought it was just during the holidays when demand was higher and they had it in a sealed white box so i couldnt see the inside or quality to see if it was old or not. But just got this one recently and it looked like this. Very disappointed. read more

Bakers Square - Used to be my favorite because of the sugar on the crust . Where did it go? - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

The staff here really makes this place! We went in for take out pie slices and you couldn't ask for nicer or more welcoming people! We had the lemon meringue, pb cup, coconut cream and carrot cake. All were really good. I personally thought the pie was overpriced for the size you got...small slices. This was the only negative thought we had. read more

Bakers Square - Lemon meringue - American Near Me - Chicago, Illinois

absolutely amazing service! Dew the manager is a keeper! Drove over 90 minutes for a banana cream pie and she had just sold out! she saw I was upset and and said give her a minute and she would make me one! how wonderful is that! completely made my day!! thank you for the great service! this is why I drive to this location :) pie was amazing as usual!!! read more

Quality has really changed for the worse. Ordered a lemon meringue pie for Thanksgiving the pie was awful The crust was not flaky and the lemon curd was lumpy did not have the usual texture. I am very disappointed with the pie and I don't think I will shop here again. read more

Well it's sad that this relic of a restaurant which used to be "Poppin Fresh" in the 1980s for their pies and then called "Baker's Square" in the 1990s and after is just a former shell of what it is now and struggling plus covid of last year. There are only 2 familiar locations in Chicago land. The one on North avenue on Melrose Park Illinois and then this one up here close to Harwood heights/Norridge area. I had to head up to Old orchard mall and this was along the way next to other errands I have to do after Christmas but I was shocked at how the menu now is only two pages on a piece of paper which I didn't take a picture of. Nevertheless it was between this or Thai restaurant but the traffic was really bad and I was already hungry by the time I left for some other errand all the way in Elmwood Park. So far the food is decent or good. Nothing spectacular. The waitress or server I had was attentive. It's hard to give this four stars because of the limited menu than what it used to be but other than that it was decent I started off with a bowl of chicken noodle soup and garlic bread. The garlic bread was pretty delicious. I had the teriyaki salmon but I was disappointed at how much I got in regards to salmon and its sides but it was delicious I wish they would have given a little more salmon I should have gone for the fish and chips maybe and I was in the mood for some fish dish for lunch. I am planning to finish it up with apple pie ala mode. It was a tough decision for the pies because that is what the bakers square is known for in they have very good pies. My favorites are French silk, country apple pie and coconut pie. I ended up going for apple pie and was very good. Other than that I hope Baker's Square will still be around and we'll come back from its former glory but I highly doubt that. This and I hate to compare this to Denny's and IHOP are going to disappear in the world of breakfast and the casual American dining franchises I remember in the 80s and 90s. read more

See all

Try fighting me but I'm giving this location 5 well earned stars. Any of the items my partner and I have tried are consistently good, as is this red9 read more

Manager treated customers like dirt. Barked at staff Food was cold. Bathroom was dirty, had no towels for cleaning your hands. Don't go here read more