Really enjoyed our visit to Broadway Diner in Baraboo. The classic diner atmosphere feels cozy and welcoming, and every dish we ordered was genuinely great. The staff was friendly and on top of things. It's a smaller spot, so plan to get there early, especially on busy mornings. A fantastic local diner experience. read more

Broadway Diner - Cinnamon roll French toast - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

See all

First time here. We were on our way to the Dells and hungry for some breakfast. The place has a nice retro feel to it. The stainless steel diner has been well cared for and updated enough to make it more comfortable for staff and customers. There are some tables out front and two different seating areas inside (it's bigger than it looks). All the cooking is done behind the counter, where you can see it all happening. It can be a bit noisy as the metal spatulas hit the grill, but you can still have a reasonable conversation. It's a busy place, and the servers are efficient, with a no nonsense approach to taking your orders. The menu is large, with lots of traditional favorites (no avocado toast here). There were two pages of breakfast items, and it was a tough decision. We ordered a number of different items: corned beef hash, pancakes, and potato pancakes with eggs and sausage. It did not take very long to get our food. Very good portions, everything was plenty hot, and all flavorful. Everyone was happy with their choices. The corned beef hash was not the kind you get from a can. It was large, fresh pieces. The pork sausages were plump and well seasoned. The poached eggs were perfect. My only complaint: I ordered my potato pancakes extra crispy, but they didn't seem "extra" to me (extra extra crispy next time). The regular pancakes were good, but not fluffy enough to be "excellent". A very nice place for breakfast, and somewhere we would return to. read more

See all

What a unique experience in Baraboo Wisconsin. It felt like stepping back in time. This beautiful nostalgic 1950s type diner is fantastic. It is small, but we had great service and a great breakfast. Not to mention the aesthetics. If you're looking for a great little breakfast place that offers a unique experience, you found it here. read more

See all

Wouldn't return, I really wanted to like it I did, from the outside super cute. Inside cramped and loud. I don't even mind cramped and loud per se but then my Bloody Mary wasn't great. Weak. The mix was like tomato juice nothing to jazz it up. I had the eggs benedict it was just kind of flat, the hollandaise lacked seasoning and flavor just tasted like blah. My husband said the same of his meal. Which I can't even remember what he had it was so forgetful. The homemade bread was the reason I gave one star for the effort. Not good. Won't be back. Oh and the ham was so thin there is no way it could get any thinner. read more

Broadway Diner - Eggs Benedict - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

Driving through Wisconsin going home to Wheaton, Illinois from Eden Prairie, MN, my hubby had me search for a highly rated, yet affordable brunch place along the way. Broadway Diner is a little off the main southbound highway, but when I read the story behind it and some positive reviews, I really wanted to try it out. How cool is it that this is an actual old time, well used diner from the East Coast that was transported to the Midwest and restored to its original beauty! Frank Sinatra era music played pleasantly in the background. Very happy and friendly wait staff wearing black shirts that said "Body by Bacon" greeted and served us. I loved the hollandaise sauce atop the Farmers Market Benedict Scramble I ordered, and that it came with a side of fresh fruit. My husband's Corned Beef Hash was a bit salty for him. Coffee wasn't as robust as we like it, but not bad. All in all, a very pleasant experience. read more

See all

Fast service and friendly wait staff. Food was served hot as should be. Clean and nostalgic.

Who would've guessed....a delicious, juicy ribeye steak and eggs at a 50s style diner! But yes! And it was a very good steak. Not one of those thin breakfast steaks but a real ribeye! Hash browns perfectly seasoned, buttery and crispy! And a homemade sourdough toast to top it off! read more

Broadway Diner - Cinnamon toast pancakes with cream cheese butter!!! - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

See all

A rather simple diner with great prices. Staff were friendly and the food was basic, but good. It was very busy, so, I'd guess it's popular with locals. You don't come across many like this anymore & it hit the spot, as nobody wanted to cook. read more

See all

Very cool 50s themed restaurant car sort of diner. Clean, small, and intimate. The best thing about this diner was the service. Our server was so friendly and attentive with a warm smile. At the end of the meal everyone was playing along with dad jokes and riddles. The food was fine to good. My only gripe was the toast had the texture of stale bread that was toasted it crumbled in your mouth immediately. At the end the server asked about a cookie and if we wanted it warmed up. It was delicious. Next time I'm in town I'll try that large cinnamon roll! read more

Such a cute spot with a vintage diner feel! The service was excellent and so was the food! Definitely need to come back here!

The atmosphere (diner) was great; our service was less than pleasant and the food (unfortunately) was rather non-descript.

What a fun old school diner great breakfast pleasant atmosphere with good service at a reasonable price

I love coming here, especially with out-of-town guests! Great portions and savory food.

Great ..ambiance is good, service , food is tasty , would go again, price is affordable.

I loved my Broadway Diner experience - every bit of it. One of the stars is for the dedicated preservation of a wonderful vintage diner but without being over the top - great job. I was thrilled to find multiple breakfast hash combinations, I chose the corned beef and it was top notch. Big bonus: homemade bread toast! Add plentiful coffee and friendly staff and it's a real winner. read more

After a long motorcycle ride, we looked forward to having a late breakfast/lunch at the Broadway Diner in Baraboo, WI. We were disappointed and will never return. The menu advertises "homemade" bread for toast (not so) and the hashbrowns had been kept 'warming' on the grill from an earlier time (they were petrified) - I saw them there when we arrived. The hashbrowns we ordered had been hacked off that awful mass and were inedible. After hacking off our portion, the cook threw the remainder out. When I pointed out the awful hashbrowns, the waitress said, "We like to serve them crispy." Clearly, no one gave a damn. The bathroom door and knob were black with many dirty hands going in and out. Overall, the food was awful and the restaurant wasn't clean. read more

This was a just a stop for breakfast on Tuesday while driving through heading south... We had no wait, booth was clean, and our server was very friendly and attentive.. We both got omelettes which were very generous in size.. they had multiple options in bread which I got the English muffin and my husband got the white which was very thick and incredible light even with toasting... the hashbrowns had a very nice fried layer like hashbrowns should.. No complaints with this place.. the cinnamon rolls look amazing but didn't get one read more

We always make a point to hit this diner when we're in town and it never disappoints. It's so cute inside; you feel like you're traveling back in time and it's so welcoming. The servers are always friendly and attentive, and the food is served quickly. I've never had a bad experience here, and this one today was great. I usually get the veggie omelette with one pancake on the side. Super tasty and filling; carries me through doing all the touristy things and I don't need to stop until dinner. This time I tried some bacon... and I usually hate breakfast meat, but this was awesome. Not sure where they get their bacon from, but it's thicker cut and has a great flavor. Extra crispy too! read more

Broadway Diner - Veggie omelette, fresh baked bread, pancake! - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

Ambiance - perfect for a diner Service - good Food - excellent (including the coffee!) My wife and I had breakfast this morning at Broadway Diner, and we were very pleased. We are outside on the patio, but inside ambiance was *exactly* what a diner should be: small booths and a counter overlooking the griddle. I ordered the Southwest Benedict Scramble, and my wife had the Portabella Benedict Scramble. Both were fantastic. An added bonus: some diner coffee can be bottom-rung, but Broadway Diner's coffee was rich, dark, and flavorful. We would definitely recommend for breakfast! read more

Broadway Diner - Portabella Benedict Scramble - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

See all

Next time you're near Baraboo, be sure to stop by. The menu is limited to breakfast and lunch, but what they offer is all excellent. The diner is open from 9 until 3. We were driving home from The Dells today when we decided we needed to grab some breakfast. We were impressed with the selection of eggs and omelets, but you can get what you crave individually, a la carte, including oatmeal and fruit. There are also a nice number of sandwiches (both cold and hot), along with some salads for those watching their figures! The entire staff is fast, efficient, and really good at what they do. Debra was our server - friendly, helpful, and really attentive to our needs. (Thanks again, Debra!!) It was fun to sit near the prep area watching the cooks. These guys know what they're doing. With each new order, they went to work immediately and got it out and ready to serve FAST! Can't say enough about the Broadway Diner. We will definitely return the next time we're driving through. read more

Maybe the best diner in America. Classic in every way. Great food, cool interior, nice people.

This little diner was an absolute treat to come to. A group of us went while celebrating a bachelorette and this was our first stop to the day and we couldn't of started in a better place. The food was AMAZING and that fresh baked bread.... YEAH GET IT ! Get all of it and run it is amazing! And they have amazing merchandise for sale but you're gonna have to go to find out what it says it's soooo worth it ! read more

See all

Baraboo resident here, this is a fun place! We come here every once in a while for the diner classic look, usually when family or friends are visiting because people like the charm. Pros? Reasonable prices for large portions & a variety of sweet and savory on the menu. The interior and exterior are really fun, I believe they packed up this diner & transported it from the east coast (???) & brought it to Baraboo. Very cool. Cons? It's very loud & very cramped. It can be difficult to hear the person you're sitting across from, so we tend to have a hard time having a conversation, especially in the front area. If you want to speak with people, see if you can grab a seat in the back/side area. The service is friendly but very rushed, although that's to be expected in a place that's always busy. The main reason we're not here on the regular is because of how greasy the food is in comparison to other little breakfast places & diners in the Baraboo area. I love the French toast on their homemade bread but eggs/hashbrowns/bacon/sausage is asking for a stomachache. Like I said, we still pop by on occasion & it's always busy, so they're doing something right! read more

Very busy which is good. Seated in back room, incredibly noisy . Felt like sitting in a tin can. Very loud elderly we were like in every conversation. Not pleasant . Soup good & great salad. However. Carrots shredded were all dried up. Not good. Blue cheese dressing good. Hubbys French Toast just had no taste. He loves his French toast. Doubt we will be back. Crowded in everywhere. We tried, our 3rd time. Sorry read more

Broadway Diner - Chicken Noodle Soup Side Salad - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

See all

First of all this place rocks in ambiance, epitome of a fully restored 50's diner. Service is amazing and I just had the best BREAKFAST SANDWICH ever!!! I added pickled jalapeños to mine. It's called Broadway Breakfast sandwich. So it. That and a mimosa was hitting the spot for me. I'll be coming back this week. read more

Broadway Diner - B'Way sandwich - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

See all

The service was good but the food was not very flavorful. I ordered the Monte Cristo and the French toast was dry.

Good food and good service. I'll be back when I'm in town again!! A traditional diner. I sat at the counter, I recommend eating there! read more

Excellent breakfast and lunch selections. I wanted both but opted for breakfast. The hashbrowns were well seasoned and cooked perfectly. We also had great pancakes with a side of bacon but some of the food came out cold/lukewarm. I watched our server wrapping utensils while my plate was waiting at the window for a while. They could do better with their timing. Most people in the area just left their mask off after sitting down and few put them back on when leaving. The staff was wearing masks. Prices aren't bad and it's a cute spot. Worth a try. read more

See all

Breakfast tacos were amazing Pancakes too Service was very good. Highly recommend read more

We stopped in for the third time. This time we entered through the handicap ramp and side door. Just inside of the door the seating srea splits into a "L". Sign says to register with hostice. No one around. Stood there a few moments and decided to seat ourself, there was no one waiting to be seated. Once seated, we were ignored by two waitresses thst were serving the 6 tables. Finally asked andvwere told we were not registered! Finally got served...!!! read more

Great little diner. Food was very good. Service was excellent and it was very fairly priced. Would absolutely eat here again. read more

Broadway Diner - Front - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

I loved this place! It's like stepping back into the 50's when you walk through the door. We were greeted immediately upon entry. We were seated quickly even though they were fairly busy at 7:15am. The diner itself was beautiful and clean. They play popular 50's music over the speakers. The waitress was friendly and attentive. The food was delicious and came out quick. I got the chicken and biscuits. Hand breaded chicken tenders made upon ordering. The chicken came between 2 cheddar biscuits and was covered with bacon gravy, 2 eggs on the side. My wife got the Wisconsin cheddar biscuits and gravy which came with sausage Pattie's, eggs, and a generous portion of hash browns. The children got "Mickey Mouse" pancakes. All around great experience. We can't wait to come back! read more

See all

I greatly appreciated this diner! A lot of the small town Wisconsin breakfast diners make me feel overly full and weighed down, but this leave me feeling satisfied and light. I got the farmers market Benedict without cheese, and it was lovely. They did a sun-dried tomato hollandaise sauce, and it was so yummy. We were able to enjoy the food and the location because it felt like we were back in the 50's! Cute booths and you could watch the cook make your food. They have a parking lot and handicap accessible ramps to get into the restaurant. The server was very attentive and nice - we will be going back if I'm near Baraboo again! read more

Broadway Diner - Farmers market Benedict - without the cheese - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

See all

I know some Yelpers ignore 5 star reviews, looking for a realistic viewpoint, but this diner is fantastic- for real!!! Great food, great service! Additionally the weather is beautiful today so we are sitting on the patio enjoying the beautiful outdoors. It Doesn't get much better than that. read more

Broadway Diner - Portobello Benedict- I added the sriracha but it's not required-truly delicious on its own. - American Near Me - Baraboo, Wisconsin

Good foid service was ok. Could speed it up a bit. Prices are gettung out of hand. Specials are good deals.

One of my favorite places to eat when I go back to Baraboo to visit family. I've had breakfast, lunch and dinner and all have been delicious. Often diners have pretty weak coffee; not the case here. This is a pretty small place, so you may have to wait, but totally worth it. read more

See all

Such a cute place for lunch or breakfast! We were visiting the area and had to try it out. We were seated right away, with a friendly server snagging our drink and food order right away. The menu is extremely reasonable! You can't beat a huge breakfast for 8.99! The ambiance was that of a 50/60s diner and I loved every inch of it! They were playing oldies and even had photos from the area's history, courtesy of the historical society It will be a spot that we bring our daughter back to for sure, she will love it here! read more

See all

Excellent food! The hash is our favorite. Reasonable prices. Nice wait staff. Very busy place, go at an off time or be prepared to wait. We will be back. read more

Service was quick and friendly. Can't complain at all about our food- my classic burger was good and the monte-crisco sandwich was delicious. The coconut cream pie was especially great because they don't sweeten the whipped cream, so it was perfectly balanced! I'll also call out the coffee, which was good and strong. If we lived in the area we'd be there multiple times a month, but it'll be on our list of places to return to whenever we're in the area! read more

One of my favorite places to eat in Baraboo! The hash browns are AMAZING. I get them every time!