HORRIBLE!!! If you're looking to get a cold pizza delivered to you with a side of absolutely terrible and unprofessional customer service, this is the place. I recently ordered a pizza from here through DoorDash for the law firm I am employed in -- and mind you, I had mildly high expectations about this pizzeria as a first time customer, so of course I had the impression that the attorneys would enjoy it. There had been a large event taking place in the office, many important figures are showing up, but when it came to receiving and indulging in the pizza, turns out the pizza was ice cold. The attorneys were incredibly disappointed and dissatisfied let alone disgusted by the cold pizza. Not only does that look bad on me, but it makes this pizzeria look worse. What takes the cake is the complete lack of professionalism from the manager. I had called to make a complaint to which I was met with the manager telling me "I only make the pizza. if you have a problem with the pizza, call DoorDash", then hung up on me. So, I will say it again. If you're looking to get cold pizza, ruined expectations and equally horrible customer service. This is the right place. read more

Forever on the hunt for a NYC style slice here in DFW. The reviews were pretty good, AND they have pretty inexpensive lunch specials. I got 2 slices (pepperoni & mushroom) and a drink for like $8, Hubbs had the pasta trio lunch special for like $12, lasagna, manicotti and ravioli with a roll and a drink. He also added a small side salad for $3 I think. I asked when the pasta arrived if it was a garlic roll and she said it wasn't. THEN she brought us over a piping hot garlic roll (super garlicky!) The slices were alright, but nothing super special. of the three pastas, I liked the lasagna the best. It is a good place to fill up on the cheap. GREAT service. read more

See all

Amazing pizza! Their pizzas were so delicious! We did carry out and they were very fresh and hot! Menu offers great selection of pizzas!

Customer service responded to our disappointed review and stepped up to make it right. We all have a bad night. With their response, we will go back. read more

See all

The pizza here is phenomenal!! The crust is crispy, sauce is authentic and it does remind me of new York style pizza. I love that the owner is always there and service has always been great! When you walk in, its like youre taken back to a 90s style pizzeria, which I love. You can dine in or take out as usual. I truly enjoy the pizza here, it's incredibly filling and cheezy (if you get the cheese pizza). Overall I found my new pizza spot! read more

Brother's Pizza & Pasta - Italian Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

See all

Hands down the #1 pizza place in the area. The staff is absolutely top notch--friendly, attentive, and always welcoming. The food is as fresh as you'll find anywhere, and the quality is consistent every time. If you're looking for great Italian food paired with excellent service, this is the place. Highly recommend! read more

Salad was awesome. Garlic bread was awesome. We're waiting on the pizza. I'll give you a review in a little while on the pizza.Ambience was typical read more

The pizza, atmosphere and service are impeccable!!!!! The wife and I come here for lunch quite often. Food is always fresh! Service with a smile!! The owner is the best!!! I would recommend this place to anyone looking for these traits in a pizza place!!!!! We will be going there today for lunch as a matter of fact!!! YELLOW!!! read more

Great food! I got a Greek salad & added chicken- the chicken had so much flavor. The house made dressing was awesome. The service was very personal and attentive and you can tell this is a family owned business. I'm glad to have taken my family here while they were in town, they loved their food as well. read more

Owner is very friendly and the pizza even when first walking in smells amazing! Give them a try whenever you're in the area.

Had two Slices with small Salad, both very good, service was prompt and place was clean. I will go back.

Our goto to Italian restaurant! So glad we ended up trying it because their pizza and chicken parmesan has been so consistently good every time we have a craving for Italian. We accidentally went to the other brother's pizza location and IT WAS NOT THE SAME! The quality of this location is just soooo much better. Idk what they do differently but the flavor and texture is just on point. read more

Omg I love this place. Can't go wrong: large Pepperoni jalapeño with white sauce!!! Consistency *chefs kiss* pizza is always ready in fifteen/ twenty minutes and is piping hot- burn the roof of your mouth. Just a tip from a girl who loves to eat good food- don't door dash it, order for pick up. read more

I pray god continues to keep his hand over this business. The boss won my kid a toy from the vending machine and the service is unmatched. I created my own order and they were able to make it. 10/10 I've been 4-5 times and will continue to go read more

Brother's Pizza & Pasta - Such an amazing place, the boss even won my daughter a bear out of the vending machine, - Italian Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

I had got good pizza here years ago but last time is probally the last. The first thing I noticed was a backed up sewer drain smell that was enough to ruin any dining experience. The second problem was the loud spanish being shouted in the kitchen. The man had no idea how unpleasant it is to be forced to listen to. The large dead cock roach under the booth was the least problem compared with the smell and sounds. Any restaurant should smell appetizing, not like a sewer. They do not bring bread to the table either, too busy shouting in spanish. read more

We really enjoyed dinner here on a rainy night. Everything was good! I loved the salad. The staff was friendly and attentive. It feels like home in here! It is cozy and down to earth. The pizza really hit the spot and we would love to come back soon! read more

Brother's Pizza & Pasta - So cozy! - Italian Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

What can I say. A solid pizza place that serves pies or by the slice. Stars: 1 - Just go on a fast or eat dirt 2- Crazy hungry or someone else paying 3- Not bad and not great 4 - Yummy Yummy 5 - OMG! I ate my fingers too! read more

Passed by this so many times. A friend brought this pizza to a gathering and it was amazing. I go today to place an order , service amazing and pizza so damn good read more

So good, I had to double back the next day. I snapped some quick pictures, before everyone dig in. read more

See all

After a year of constantly searching for true, New York style pizza, I can happily report that I have finally found it! I made the mistake of constantly checking all the latest the magazine articles on people claiming to have found true New York style pizza. What a sham! Every five star review that I read claiming the pizza was authentic New York style was a complete farce. We ended up walking out on every place and getting a hamburger after because the pizza was so disgusting. This place is absolutely 100% New York style pizza! The slices are perfect, not too thin or thick, the right amount of cheese and grease, and perfect sauce. The garlic knots are incredible, too. I'm thoroughly disgusted that this place has not made it on any of the best pizza lists in Dallas because it is hands down the best we've had. (For reference, my husband is from Brooklyn and knows his pizza, lol.) read more

Brother's Pizza & Pasta - THIS is true NY style pizza! - Italian Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

Incredible little pizza & pasta place. Some of the best pasta we've had in a while, and incredibly friendly staff

I am surprised I am shocked that this restaurant where I usually come eat out with my parents. Their customer service is always 100% satisfaction, but not today the service at this restaurant was horrible. My parents had ordered a slice of pizza for themselves and and a salad and something to drink they got the salad and they got the drink, but they never got their pizza. They said that they waited over an hour to get any kind of attention or help and they noticed that they were serving everybody else that was in that restaurant besides them I think the owner had family members visiting his restaurant and having a good time, laughing and what not that they totally forgot about my parents and all my mom had to do was just them to refund her money back and for that I'm rating them one star! read more

We eat there on a sem-regular basis and have tried many things on the menu and have found what we both like the most is the white pizza with extra roasted garlic. The service is always exceptional and the Owner, his wife and the rest of the staff make you feel welcome and are attentaive to your every need, read more

Visited today, Sunday lunchtime, while in town and had a great experience. Got a warm welcome and very friendly service. We had Greek salad, and a selection of pizza slices, all of which were delicious. The pizza crust let us fold (New York style) without dropping any toppings. The fresh feta and homemade dressing on the salad were so tasty too, way above the normal sorry salads you get at most pizza places. Had some European soccer on the big screen, plus the decor and murals on the walls made it feel welcoming. Will be going back to try some of their pastas next time. I thoroughly recommend this joint. read more

Super friendly staff, nice place to enjoy lunch with the family. Prices are reasonable. Great flavor and plenty of food to share. read more

See all

I always see this restaurant in passing, decided to try it! We got the largest pizza with just cheese and the fettuccine Alfredo and it was so pleasantly delicious! We ordered it as delivery and it arrived in a timely manner with care. Would definitely recommend this if anyone is looking for a large pie similar to a New York style slice. read more

Decent NY style thin crust pizza. Undercarriage was nicely toasted and give a satisfying crunch when biting into it. Maybe a little too crisp as my cheese slice broke in half. Good CCS ratio (crust, cheese and sauce) but the pepperoni had a couple soupy spots that made the crust soft on the bottom. The outside crust has a nice crunch to pillowy inside contrast, reminded me of home made bread. Three stars due to the cheese slice breaking apart and causing an ingredient slide. read more

Brother's Pizza & Pasta - Cheese and pepperoni - Italian Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

See all

Absolutely delicious food!! Friendly staff. Great hole in the wall. I had the lasagna and antipasto salad. All homemade. Amazing experience

I wanted a slice of NY style pizza so bad. I ended up using Reddit (it's that serious) for an authentic NY STYLE PIZZA place in DFW. I came across Brother's Pizza by 75 and Spring Meadow. However, it's closed on Sunday. So I like a dummy assumed they had affiliate locations in Carrollton, etc. Yeah, no. Walked in and knew it was gonna be awful when they had one pan of pizza out with 3 slices and a calzone. No illustrious display of pies like most authentic NY PIZZA PLACES. So the guy grabs me a slice and puts it in the oven to heat. And the slicked back hair gentleman, mentioned in other reviews, rings me up. Pizza ready in 3 minutes. I got in the car and this is what I saw. Guys, he sprinkled more cheese on before putting it in the oven and didn't even let it melt. This is NOT NY STYLE PIZZA mozzarella cheese! And the sauce is disgusting. The crust is so awful. Like this is worse than Dominoes or Little Cesar. And honestly I wouldn't feed this to a dog. DO NOT CONFUSE this place with the Brother's Pizza and Pasta off 75. 0/10 DO NOT RECOMMEND!! read more

Brother's Pizza & Pasta - Cheese Slice - Italian Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

Can I say this is the best pizza in Dallas? Best I've had. This place is the real deal. The pepperoni is amazing. Also, the gluten free is king. Met the owner, good dude. Real good dude. Ambiance is just like the rest. read more

I order takeout from here for our pizza Fridays, the pizza is so well made and the quality of ingredients is excellent! The house Italian dressing is so delicious I can't order from here without getting a salad too! Fast service and always consistent quality! read more

From a neighbor, and I totally agree: Brothers Pizza 10455 N. Central Expressway Suite 104 Dallas Texas. 75230 I had the best pizza ever by far on Friday night! And I'll tell you why, it was made with kindness. Anyone who knows me, for my release from the week's stress I let someone else make dinner and clean up for me on Fridays. It's my pizza Friday, very important part to the well-being of my week and my life. I was making my normal call-in order to Brother's Pizza at the last call for take out. I got a message when I called that said "this number is unreachable"!! I panicked and drove to their location to find they had been without power excepting 1 generator-powered outle, internet and phone service for most of the week following natural-disaster level storms in Dallas. Turns out the owner had been making the dough by hand all week and servicing as many people as he could without the benefit of his machine. The owner, knowing how important my Friday pizza is to me made a pizza for me after last call for takeout. Amazing, what kindness! So if you get a chance, go get a pizza from Brother's. I'm sure they lost lots of business due to the power outage. I may bless myself with a Pizza Saturday! read more

Absolutely ... The Best... anti pasta salad that I have had anywhere! Pizza was delicious too. Very friendly people. My only issue was that they had Fox News on the tv.... Didn't need to hear anymore untruth's! Will be back many a time... enjoyed the food, and the ambience ! read more

The level of delusion it takes to rate this place a 4.6 is next level. I am throughly convinced that it only has a high rating due to the great service provided. With the very nice people that helped me it hurts me to give this place such a crappy review. I ordered a very basic cheese pizza which I picked up. Once I arrived it was hot and ready to go. The Italian looking dude in the back with slicked back hair just fit the part which ensured me this was gonna be great. To my disappointment this pizza couldn't have won a skating rink pizza cook off although it was very reminiscent of skating rink, arcade or bowling ally pizza. The sauce couldn't beat chef boy ardee, the cheese is lower quality than a lunch-able and the crust wasn't even as good as a Totinos frozen pizza. Dave Portnoy would have thrown it straight in the trash the same as I did. read more

Stopped by here and ordered a large pizza. This place is alright especially being in Carrollton. Mom and pop pizza place. It's a bit awkward inside. read more

I am so glad I decided to try this place today, definitely a hole in the wall for some authentic big huge yummy pizza. This pizza is definitely worth the money for the size (16inch) and loaded with cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausages, meat, and the sauce and other toppings. Strawberry swirl cheesecake was divine Must try! read more

Brother's Pizza & Pasta - Bigggg Works Pizza Sicilian and Strawberry Swirl Cheesecake - Italian Near Me - Carrollton, Texas

See all

Ordered pizza on a whim and wanted to try a new place. So glad I took a chance on brothers pizza, the pizza was amazing! Will definitely be back again! read more

Update 6/19/2020: I was in the area and gave it one more shot and I am glad I did. The owner was there and my pizza was delicious! Evenly baked, right amount of sauce and toppings. It bothered me to leave a poor review when more often than not the pizza and my experience is good. This time our pizza was underwhelming. I prefer a little more sauce and flavor. The crust also tasted inconsistently baked. It makes me wonder if they are under new ownership due to the lack of quality. Customer service was good. read more

The first pizza spot we tried in Carrollton - passed my husbands bar for thin crust and the topping selections. The last few times have felt like the dough changed a bit. But overall, still a great option for weeknights when we don't want to cook. They are always polite and the pizza is ready super quick. The only thing I wish they were more generous and even with the toppings - some times I get a slice or two that may have one lone piece of topping. read more

best pizza I've ever had, these guys and gals are great. Never had pizza this good , try them you will love it. the people there are great! I love their food.!!!! read more