I have ordered pizza from this establishment several times; each time saying never again. Let me explain. Pizza is a personal preference. Some people do not like a lot of sauce. I do, but Coley's pizza seems like crust and cheese. Little flavor. Little oil. Perhaps I should ask for extra sauce and that would improve their pizza for me. The employees are friendly, the restaurant looks very clean, and I've never gotten sick from eating there. But as a New Jersey transplant, it's just not favorite pizza. read more

Love Coleys. They have the best tasting hot sauce for their wings. Delivery is always on time. Happy with their pizzas too. Only pizza place we get deliveries from. read more

Not good at all . No flavor , don't know what else to say . Taste like a cheap frozen pizza. Don't understand the no flavor with the veggies I got . I did not get any meat on mine. . read more

Always fresh, fast, friendly and tasty! Love some Coleys pizza and Dali-lama wings. Hits the spots every time

Las pizzas son súper rica hay que pedir doble triple de queso para que sea más rica me encanta

I've been reading post from other people saying how good they are. Went in today, ask how their meatball parmigiana was. The lady told me that they are popular. Great, was excited to have it, Was I ever let down, it was mostly sauce? They cut the meatballs in half. Who does this anyway. I do not recommend this sandwich. Cutting meatballs in half . read more

Thank you for the "free dessert" birthday coupon, however it was useless and does not state that it is only for items $5 and under so it wasn't honored for my order even though it doesn't say anywhere that the coupon cannot not be applied if you choose a desert other than the $5 ones. A discount was not even offered for the amount of the coupon, but instead I received a "there's nothing I can do". As some one who's family frequents often, I believe there should be more done in situations like this to make us feel as if we are valued customers. read more

Better recent experience. Large cheese delivered with no contact. Fast hot and good quality. Will order again from this local shop!

I don't want to over sell it, but this is the best pizza in South Florida! It's New York style and crazy flavorful! Even just their cheese pizza is so much better than anyone else. My favorite is the Grease Lightening. Try it. If you like pizza and you like garlic, this is the place for you. Oh, and their customer service is so much better than any other pizza place. They look you in the eye as soon as you walk in and communicate clearly. read more

Coleys pizza is a tradition in my family. We've been enjoying their delicious pies for years! Finding a great pizza spot is like finding gold! Just recently ventured out and tried their gluten free option and WOW! So good and still very flavorful! A spot that I'll definitely continue to order from as long as I live in this area. read more

Quite literally the beat pizza in West Pines/Miramar. If I could give my stars I would. My friends and I order from Coleys on the regular. The prices are reasonable. You'll never want to settle for anything else. Their vegan options are great too! read more

Coley's Pizza - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

I recently moved from West Pembroke Pines 10 miles further east, but I will still make the trek back to pick up Coley's. Their pizza is always a hit, and I love how they always seems to make thinner slices so I don't feel bad eating more their wings are also delicious and we love the Dali's Lama flavor. They also have gift card giveaways on their IG pretty frequently which are always fun to enter! The icing on the cake is they are a female owned local business, which I always love supporting!! read more

This is the best pizza ever! We love the wings as well with the Dali Lama sauce. Always a great experience taking out here!

Cooley's has good pizza and salads. That is all that I have had from them. The pizza on Wednesday is just $7.00 large and you pick it up. Great when you are in a rush and need to feed the kids eat a salad and get the kids a whole pizza to eat. Is a great suggestion if you need to get a quick bite and dont need to rush. read more

Definitely my favorite pizza spot. Not sure what they do to this pizza but it's the perfect balance if quality crust, marinara, cheese. Of course I add other toppings but can easily just have plain cheese pizza and be happy. This is my pizza spot. read more

The pros: the pizza was extremely large. It was also very cheesy and pretty tasty as well. Cons: I wanted the Chicago style which is typically deep dish but it wasn't deep at all. The garlic rolls were a wee bit dry. Overall, it was pretty good. I would eat there again. read more

Used to be super fire but now it's low-key below mediocre , both the customer service and food quality been suffering . Breaks my heart t leave this review but it is what it is read more

Oh Coley's it makes me sad to have to update my review to reflect our experience on Friday, but I have to be honest. We usually order pizza from Coley's because we love it. The pizza is usually amazing and it has become a tradition in our family for pizza Fridays. Unfortunately, this past Friday we ordered Coley's and were completely disappointed. Our pizza came in super late and apart from that it was burnt. The pizza on top was basically black and I am honestly surprised that no one caught that while placing it in the pizza box. When we tried to eat it, it was rock solid in some parts so we basically had to throw most of it out. Anyway, they also did not even cut the pizza in slices making it very difficult to pull apart. Thankfully, we ordered garlic breads and at least those was good. Needless to say, we will be holding back from placing orders from here anytime soon. read more

Food was awesome and the service was great. Great place to go with the family and have a great meal. Prices were affordable and the service was on point. read more

Tonight just horrible super soggy Edgy veggie. Pizza. We order this all the time and this is just yuck. Heating up in oven doesn't even help. $27.50 for pizza that is like you are just eating toppings. Only outer crust wasn't like doughy. Husband called to tell them but they just don't care. Don't think we'll be ordering anymore. Pizza took way to long rest of order was cold too. Try to support small businesses but if they don't care, what do you do. read more

Great pizza, good location excellent service. Just like New York pizza. You have to try ordering read more

Awesome food and service - ALWAYS! My kids will only get take out from here. Few times a week. Good thing they are athletes! Also, all the ingredients are super fresh and they never skimp on anything. If you have leftover pizza. When you heat it up, the mozzarella oozes like they just made it! That's real Pizza! No fake cheese here! And they get to know you by name. Love that. read more

See all

Best pizza in Pembroke Pines friendly staff and delicious foods. Must come here for lunch and dinner everything is delicious

Best pizza and wings in town! You're missing out if you've never tried them out. There's other great options such as salads and sandwiches.

By far, the Best of the Best pizza on the West side of I75 in Pembroke Pines .specialty pizzas are a must and never forget some garlic rolls as well. read more

Great pizza! Always consistent, delicious and prepared super fast. Coley's offers both traditional pizzas as well as many specialty custom named pizzas. Coley's has a few inside tables and a nice counter/bar for a quick lunch. I would consider this eatery to be primarily for "take away" orders. They also offer a rewards club that you will earn points on that can easily be redeemed for money off future orders. Give Coley's a try, you will become a regular like us. read more

Good weekday pizza spot for when you are on the run and don't have dinner planned out at home. Pizza can be hit or miss so I always make sure to ask for it to be cooked a little longer. Wings are very good as well. read more

Such a fun casual spot for good pizza! Good deals: 2 slices any toppings and a drink for $8. They also have free ninja turtle, Pac-Man, and mortal combat arcade games. Would've posted a photo of my pizzas but forgot to take one they were so good. read more

Coley's Pizza - Arcade games - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

See all

The best pizza in South Florida. You won't be disappointed. They have excellent speciality pizzas. Crust is crispy, toppings good quality, and sauces very tasty. read more

My favorite place for pizza and they were in the news for perfect score from the health department!

We ordered a few pizzas to go from here and were happy with the results. I've heard that they have the recipe from Baci's Pizza which is now gone. They don't have a brick oven but their pizza is nice and crispy with lots of cheese. It was a hit with the kids, especially the extra large size the offer. They have pizza specials on Tuesdays. The staff were very friendly and helpful in ordering and picking up. Now I'm getting hungry. This week I'm ordering Coley's! read more

I rarely write reviews by sitting in the restaurant cause i like to give them a chance to change the first impression, but this place started bad and has been getting badder by the minute. 1st its empty at lunch, never a good sign. The girl at the register was playing with her phone and actually told me to give her a mi the while she finish texting or doing whatever she was doing. Now I'm sitting waiting for my food and they are screaming in the kitchen, and not about food! I tried the cheese pizza and the garlic rolls, the latter were delicious. The cheese pizza was ok, nothing to rave about. The prices are pretty good. Would just recommend takeout or delivery read more

I feel like I'm missing out. There are so many rave reviews here on Yelp AND this is the only local pizza place my parents will order from. Maybe I just consistently order the wrong things but I've just never been wowed by Coley's. I think it's, ya know, "fine" but my family seems to absolutely love it. Despite our disagreement on the food, we can all agree on one thing - Coley's has gotten weird. I remember coming here with a ton of my friends after class ended during high school. We usually came at least once a week and we always looked forward to it. This was at least 4-5 years ago - when Coley's first opened. I remember enjoying it more back then and thinking that the staff was really friendly and cool. In the more recent past (as well as when I went to pick up my family's order last night), I've walked in and was basically ignored for a few minutes. They have probably six or seven people behind the counter who are clearly meant to be doing different tasks. I could understand if the staff was busy or doing something else (and you'd be able to tell - they have a totally open kitchen) but most of the time I've seen them playing around or texting and then finally realizing a customer is at the cash register. This doesn't necessarily kill the experience for me but I can understand why it would bother some. As far as I'm concerned, I just want to get my order and go. Unfortunately, sometimes it's kind of hard to "get your order and go" here. There have been countless times when I've shown up - a half hour after placing my order - to have to wait another 20-30 minutes. I'm not sure if this is a testament to how busy these guys are or how inefficient it is to tell people "it'll be 30 minutes" when it's really much longer. The food itself definitely isn't bad, which accounts for all three stars on giving here. If you've got the patience, I think it's worth it. The prices are reasonable and they definitely are very giving when it comes to toppings. I don't think it's the best pizza I've ever had but I don't think there's anywhere else nearby that blows it out of the water. So, for now, I'll appease my family's desire to keep ordering from here, but I'm definitely on the look out for something more. read more

Coley's Pizza - Chicago Deep Dish with Sausage, Onion and Mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Came across this pizza place on my way to Publix and wanted to grab a quick lunch. Although I ordered a Greek salad at a Pizza place, the salad was really fresh. However, I sat down to eat and could not help but noticed how grimy and sticky this place was. The windows were smeared, the tables were not clean, the floor was gross and I even saw a couple of dead bugs. I still finished my food, but I did want to get the heck out of there as quickly as I could. I think some time spent cleaning, this place can actually be a really cute spot to come grab some food. I saw a sign that they offer cooking classes for kids on Saturdays, I love that, but they should get some cleaning done. read more

Coley's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Tastes like a delicious New York style pizza. Big slices with the crust formed just right. The cheese and the sauce blend well to give a few little drops of grease but not so much that you feel grossed out. The inside is nostalgic for ninja turtles and arcade games from the 80s and 90s. They have a rewards program that earns point with every order you make. This place is a hidden gem for anybody from up north who complains about not being able to find a real New York style pizza. read more

This place is great. The food is fresh and awesome! The owner, Nicole, is very nice and she makes everything in-house. She'll be tossing pizzas and talking to you at the same time. We have eaten here 3 times, once on a a week night, once on a weekend night and the third time on a weekday afternoon. They are always busy! A sign of good food. We've had the subs.... The eggplant parm ($6) 8"sub was amazing, the bread is nice and warm, soft on the inside and toasty on the outside. My husband had the philly cheesesteak ($7.50) and they use great tasting meat, lots of onions, peppers, and cheese. Now for the bonus, they have Curly Fries (only $1 more added as a side for the subs)!!! we always order a side of their homemade medium wing sauce. We like spicy food, but the medium here is the Hot anywhere else. So be careful. The pizza dough is amazing, the sauce is so yummy, it has Parmesan cheese in it. Now to the mozzarella.... Good and fresh cheese will stretch and it will not be chewy, here Coley's hits a home run, so flavorful. We had The Edgy Veggie pie ($15 for the 14") and it had tons of Fresh vegetables, and this pizza looked way bigger than 14 inches. (I put a photo up, check it out) Today we tried their pasta. The spaghetti and tomato sauce ($7). All their pasta dishes come with 2 amazingly airy garlic rolls and a side salad. What a great deal. I took 1 star off because each time we've come the tables have been dirty, they need to pay more attention to that. They do come and clean them when you ask :) And because the pasta was a little over cooked (in my opinion) and the sauce was lacking flavor. We had to add lots of pepper flakes, salt, garlic, oregano and Parmesan cheese to make it taste better. We did tell Nicole about it and she said that she'll be happy to add more flavor to ours if we remind her when we're ordering :) NOW THAT'S SERVICE!!! Check out their menu, I put pictures up. read more

See all

Pizza is great!!! Always cooked to perfection. It is worth the money. Do not try to stretch your money by buying from the Pizza Hut, Dominos and Papa John's. My son used to work at one of these locations and said that they still cook their frozen dough and even if it has an expired date. read more

I've ordered from Coley's a handful of times. I've had no complaints in the past but today's order was just different. I ordered the Edgy Veggie: Crust was overcooked and undercooked at the same time. The bottom was burnt but it was wet and slimy in the middle and the veggies were tasteless and looked old. The tomatoes looked so old, they were see thru. I had asked for extra garlic but I think I got NO GARLIC instead...I mean except for what's cooked into the crust. I also ordered their DEEP DISH: this was a first for us. We'd never had THEIR deep dish before but I've always been curious to try it. I've had plenty of deep dish at other restaurants before but their version??? It was just as thin, if not thinner than the Edgy Veggie we had. I'll post pics and you tell me if you see any difference in the thickness. I called and the young woman told me that this is THEIR VERSION of deep dish. Uhhhh...a deep dish served with THIN crust is your version of deep dish? I'm so confused right now!!! I asked, "Are you SURE?" I just couldn't believe that this wasn't a mistake. Well, this one tasted just a tinyTAD BETTER than the Edgy Veggie, as far as flavor goes, but not by far. My daughter, who LOVES PIZZA didn't even ask for a second slice. No one did! No one went back for seconds. No one! That's a first! I have $36 worth of pizza in there and no one wants to finish it. Coley's has been pretty consistent but I don't know what happened today. This pizza was pretty bland and not good at all! read more

Coley's Pizza - Edgy Veggie (same thickness as the so called DEEP DISH??) Tasteless as well. - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

See all

Good service. The only place that I would order takeout pizza from these days. Fast Delivery.

It was one of those nights that no one could make a decision on dinner. So we checked yelp and Coleys was the closest and had great reviews. We had a large Stromboli and I must say it was delicious! The staff was great and very helpful for us first timers. I definitely recommend this pizza joint. read more

Coley's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida