Ordered calzones tonight......and they were delicious. Love their ricotta cheese. Not the first time we ordered from this location. They are super nice when you order and even when you pick up. read more

We recently moved to the area and have been looking for a good mom and pops type of restaurant and this is definitely it!! NY calzone was amazing and huge! Also got to try the garlic parmesan wings which, dare I say, are even better than WingStop. For sure will be coming back! You can tell everything here is homemade and well worth the wait, although we dined in and there was hardly a wait. Great customer service as well :) read more

Awesome pizza and wings..delivery was a little longer than expected and cheese slid off the pizza which is why I didn't give 5 stars.

I only ate there once didn't taste like New York pizza to me I will try again maybe I went and got a bad pizza

We love this place!! Great pizza and wings! We used to only order from Barros but this place blows them out of the water, is a small business, has better hours of operation, and is truly better in every way. read more

I ordered for delivery and they never showed up this is the 3rd time this has happened

Amazing everything! We love the pizza, but the calzones are our favorite. We order delivery and it is always still too hot to eat. Definitely the only pizza place we order from. read more

We just moved into the area and thought we would try this place. It is totally awesome. We ordered pizza and wings. Everything was delicious and they delivered it on time, just like they said they would. read more

You know, I never give food places reviews, but this place just has amazed me since the first time I stepped foot in the restaurant. They are always very pleasant no matter who I speak to. The food is really GOOD! Prices are great and I can just say its always just a pleasurable experience eating at Don's. read more

Ordered a pickup order 15 minutes to close. Not only was the staff friendly and welcoming, but the food was as good as always. I have eaten their food multiple times before by delivery. The service is fast and friendly and again great food! Great establishment, great food, great people! read more

This place is by far the best pizza place Ive found in Arizona whenever I stay in town I surely come here and eat a slice of pizza and lasagna customer service is really great pizza looks really fresh love this place read more

Don's NY Pizza in Peoria - Pizza Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Great pizza place! Family friendly, delicious food, clean restaurant, nice staff! We will definitely be back and use for delivery from now on!!! read more

First time trying out this place with my fiancé and we LOVED it! We got the white pizza deluxe, some BBQ wings, mozzarella sticks, and garlic knots. And everything was AMAZING! Employees were really friendly too! We definitely will be back! read more

Amazing food and service. Consistently good food. You can totally tell the sauces are homemade

Average pizza. Didn't like the wings. Service was decent, and they got us the food quick. Just didn't think it was very good.

We have been coming here for over a year and have never been disappointed. Owners are always friendly and food top notch. From pizza to wings, salad and subs we have had almost all of it and all of it is fantastic. Support this local family business! read more

Seriously the best pizza in the west valley. The staff is always so nice and the food is always fresh and delicious! Highly recommend!!!!

We went here tonight because my daughter wanted to based off the good reviews. Well, I have to say this place is just average. I've definitely had better. To start off the bread or knot rolls need a lot more of that garlic butter sauce because they had absolutely no flavor. The wing sauce on our wings was watery. Finally the pizza came. It was ok. I felt like it also needed some more flavor. The wait was about 40 mins. The staff was friendly. I would just suggest using more flavor or garlic. read more

Great pizza fast delivery service they went above and beyond they said my address is not their zone and they still sent it out Awsome people there read more

First time here had the NY supreme. So good!!! Lightly crispy crust and so much flavor. Staff was super friendly and place was clean. Will definitely be back. read more

UPDATE : they responded to me and told me I was gypsy , like how rude is that ? And then demanded I delete the review or they will never deliver to me again, as if I needed their days old pizza . They couldn't even apologize for their rude service , and then instead became more rude. Never have been so disrespected in my life. read more

2nd time here and customer service has been amazing they are so friendly and the food is amazing, this has become our favorite pizza spot.

Ordered Sicilian style margarita pizza last night. Ouch!!! Sauce and bread flavorless!!! I've had better gas station pizza. However previously ordered calzone and philly steak sandwich and they were quite good read more

We get delivery from Don's a lot. First time leaving a review. Everything had been amazing. My daughters always ask if we can get "The good pizza". That is what they call it. But hubby and I love love love their wings. They are simply the best wings we've ever eaten. I look forward to pizza/wing nights. read more

I am old Italian Momma from NJ living in Peoria Az and I didn't think I would fine Italian food that I would make as good as my own and my mothers but I did ! You will not be disappointed with their menu... their taste or service ! I highly recommend that you should order in or deliver it out ... anything on the menu is great! Enjoy Mangiare ...Mangiare read more

I decided to give Dons NY pizza a try since they we're so close to my house. When I went to get my pies there was a hostess a waitress and the guy cooking the pies behind the counter. Nobody even said hello to me which I thought was rude. I had to tell the waitress what I was there for.The pizza was kinda bland nothing to right home about.Kinda pricey too the total came to 28.00 dollars for 2 large one topping pizzas.Don't think I will be eating there again. read more

We drive all the way from surprise for Don's pizza!! We moved here from NYC 4 months ago , not only does it taste like home the owners are super friendly. Love love the pizza! Crust crunchy cheese gooey and sauce tangy yet sweet. Grease check ! Just like Brooklyn pizza. The best we have found for AZ read more

My usual pick up location is Camelback but today I was closer to the Peoria location. Waiting for my order was a pleasure. I stood there basking in the aroma of my hot wings being prepared. The food never disappoints. My family is having a small birthday party and our guest will be feasting ion Don's NY Pizza & Wings!!! I also want to add that the owners were very welcoming and even helped me carry my order out to my car! read more

Found this pizza shop thru yelp. We were out of towners visiting a friend and looking for local and good pizza. Don's NY pizza was awesome. Price was good and pizza sizes were amazing. The taste was great and I loved the crust. Zuchinni was good but not my kind of breading. The girl behind the counter was super sweet and helpful. Shop was clean and had lots of eating seating. read more

We ordered a calzone, fried zucchini, fried mushrooms, and a chicken parmesan hero. What came was a calzone, fried zucchini, fried mushrooms, and a chicken linguine dinner. The lady misunderstood us I guess. So when we called then up. They brought the chicken parmesan hero out for free. Even though we offered to pay for it. That was very nice of them. Thank you Don' s NY for your excellent costumer service. read more

A month and a half ago, we ordered a pizza and from Don's on Peoria and pleasantly surprised with a very hot sausage and mushroom pizza along with a half dozen medium hot wings with celery and blue cheese. We rated our experience a 5 star and because we are so close, the pizza was delivered very quickly that was very hot and well made. Tonight 12/13, we experienced just the opposite. With the correct number she said we ordered a large sausage and mushroom pizza with (6) Med. Bone in Chicken Wings with Blue cheese dressing and celery sticks. The order was changed to a medium pizza and the rest, the same. What we ended up with was a tasteless pizza very short on tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese. The pizza was delivered promptly but was cold and the chicken wings were cold and mild. The Pizza Wings were very mild and cold as well, We had too many flaws to give it higher rating, hence the reason why rated it a 2 star and even that might be too high. read more

The Pizza was pretty good, NY style pie. The Garlic Knots- not the best in town, kinda bland though the dipping marinara sauce was pretty good. They have very nice service, friendly folks. I loved that they are from Brooklyn. read more

This pizza is FANTASTIC!!!! The crust (which I don't normally like) is so delicious, they don't skimp on toppings, and the staff is so accommodating! The white pizza is the best I've had outside of the east coast. My mom has a dairy allergy and is able to get really great pizza without the cheese. They always pile on the toppings for her Highly recommend this place!!! read more

Best pizza in town, as authentic as a NYC pizza gets out west! Great food, great ppl.

Great food and price. For Peoria this is over the top pizza. Not a lot of good places to eat in this area so give it a shot. Plus the staff are nice and helpful read more

Best pizza and wings I've ever had in Arizona, everything was so delicious! Will definitely come back again and again!!!

Best food on the west side! Every time we've eaten there, the food is delicious. Pizza, subs, calzones, outstanding! The price, a little on the high side, the quality of the food makes it worth it. Give the place a try. read more

This place is amazing. Good fresh food. Great people and they deliver to their Neighbors.

I would rate this 2nd best in the Valley next to Spinatos. Good service, fresh toppings, great savory sauce. No complaints.

This is the best pizza I have had in a long time. I don't even like thin crust pizza and my fiance ordered Ny style thin crust and it was by far the best thin crust. Their ranch is perfect too. It is some of the best home made dressing I have had. Not bitter or watery like some places. I can't wait to try some wings next time or a calzone. read more