When they first opened it was 5 stars, better than Andrews. Recently their Quality has gone down. Especially when ordering a pie. Pie is soggy and floppy. garlic knots no flavor. Need to go back to day 1. read more

They are decent. Not great, but not horrible. Just dont order delivery from them. Slooooooowwwwww AF! Makes you not even want the food anymore read more

Ordered a few times and the results were inconsistent. Yesterday, I ordered a regular cheese pie thru UberEats and received a "frankenstein pie." Eight individual slices that were reassembled into a pie. Soggy and completely unacceptable. If one orders a whole pie, that is what you should receive. read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

We were at juniper park and got hungry and decided to try this place out. We went on a saturday afternoon and was able to grab a table inside. The slices were huge and really delicious. The veggie slice is def my fave. Service was A+. After you order they bring your food to your table. The owners dad just happened to sit next us and offered to get us a cup of ice and straws. When he was leaving he even offered to throw our trash. We really appreciated it. Def will be back. Highly reccommend! read more

See all

Ordered a pie and specifically wrote not well done, the whole bottom Of the pie was black, burnt. Almost as if it was intentional. Zero stars read more

Neighborhood pizza joint serving serviceable slices and pies. Narrow entrance to order and pick up with some seating in the back. Came on a Friday night around 6pm and they were slammed with orders. It took about 40 minutes to get our 2 pies tor pickup (from what they said on the phone was a 25 minute wait). They are courteous and did apologize for the wait time which I appreciate - rare in a Queens joint. They may need to figure out a better system behind the counter for their weekend rush. Roughly $52 for 2 pies - a veggie pie and a regular cheese pie with half pineapple. It was about $28 for the veggie pie we ordered that was alright. I liked how the veggie pie included breaded eggplant in addition to the usual broccoli, tomatoes, and mushrooms. A plus: they do have pineapple as a topping (a hit with my kids) which is rare these days. I added a star because we want to support local businesses. This is a standard Queens pizza place. read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Vegetable Pizza Pie - breaded eggplant was a nice touch - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

I ordered a pizza for delivery an hour later I still didn't receive my pizza I called and they forgot I live right down the road. I will never be calling them again because now it's too late to get any food. read more

I'm only a fan of their pepp. pinwheels and their chicken cutlet sandwiches with lettuce, tomato & mayo. What I don't suggest is their Philly Cheese Steak hero. I ordered it with lettuce, tomato, mayo & cheese on a hero with fries and their free can of soda meal online. The meat taste so gross and it's barely even a dark color. I couldn't even take more than 2 bites so I just ate their fries. Next time I'll just stick with what I usually get. read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Philly Steak Sandwich French Fries Can Soda(Coke) - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

They have a wonderful special on Monday for their cheese pizza. It's usually 19 but is down to 15 for the day. Can't beat that price. However as for the pizza itself, it's okay. The dough is extremely chewy. You will legit get a jaw workout eating this. The sauce is sweet and the cheese is just regular cheese. A little oily but not much. Garlic knots are chewy as all hell and barely have any garlic flavor so you're just eating dough. Worth it if you're having a pizza party on a Monday and wanna feed a ton of people but otherwise it's meh. read more

I ordered a sausage roll at this establishment. It was not good at all. There was barely any sausage, so they might as well call it a cheese roll. This was the last time I called this place. I would not suggest it at all. read more

For starters .. $27 for 2 regular , 2 Sicilian , and 2 grandma slices .. total of 6 slices .. .. food was blah .. the grandma and Sicilian were doughy and flavorless .. the regular was just ok .. greasy .. overall i was so unimpressed by this place .. won't be coming back read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Doughy flavorless Sicilian - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

Ordered the baked ziti and the Italian salad. Guys were friendly, the order was ready for pickup in 10 minutes. Ziti was pretty good, salad was fresh. Two kinds of dressing included, I enjoyed both. The very generous section of sliced bread was really good! Paid $18 total, got a lot of food. Good food, good value. Mighy try a pizza next. read more

See all

Middle Village has a handful of praise worthy pizzerias. This isn't one of them. It's been open for a while. During their opening weekend, I stopped in and they were swamped. It seemed they needed to sort out the new business and work out the kinks. I ordered two regular slices and a canned seltzer; the total was 10.50. The pizza is average and didn't have enough flavor to justify the hefty price. It wasn't bad, just not terrific. read more

Wow ! Great Place ....Great Pizza ! You have to try the Pizza Here .. I had the grandma slice and I was looking for my Grandma in the kitchen , a must try .....Probably the best you will ever have . It was Good Friday so no meat I went with the Sfringioni pizza Honestly the best of the best ! Italian music in my ears and the Met game on the tv and probably the best pizza in town ! read more

there slacking off and it's no good at all I opened the pizza box and it's disgusting.... cheese everywhere & not well done at all that I asked for it's been tasting like crap no more I'm taking my business somewhere else read more

Eliot Pizzeria - slacking off i opened the box it's gross cheese everywhere not well done that I asked for it's been tasting like crap taking my business - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

Pizza! Pizza! Simple but delicious. A nice ratio of cheese to sauce. Crispy bites. Delicious. Not much to review as it's just a slice of pizza, but a good one! It won't knock your socks off if you're an NYC native, but you won't be disappointed either. Capiche? I'd highly recommend! Get you some! read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Yum. Regular Cheese Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

See all

Spinach roll was pretty good. I didn't try anything else. I wanted something quick and not super filling. This did just that. I'll definitely come back and see what else they have to offer! read more

Great pizza! The undercarriage was impeccable and both slices had a nice crunch without being burnt/slightly blackened anywhere. The vegetables on my slice were fresh and the kid up front was very nice and friendly. Threw in two Zeppoles on the house and made a specialty slice to my liking. I'd definitely recommend! Clean bathroom as well! read more

I absolutely love this place, food is always so fresh and delish!! The staff warm and welcoming! Look no further :) read more

I ordered from this place via the Slice app, where it has an overall 5.0 stars with 500 ratings. So I had high hopes. I ordered the sausage calzone and an Italian salad. The description of the calzone says it includes red sauce, but when the order arrived - no red sauce. I contacted the Slice app support and they said that red sauce has to be requested. There's no place to indicate that, unless you write it in yourself under "special requests". The Calzone itself was pretty mediocre - not the worst, but certainly nothing among the better ones I've had elsewhere. Definitely lacked a sufficient amount of sausage. The description for the Italian salad includes onions and "of course pepperoncini!" which is what makes an Italian salad an Italian salad, right? Well, my salad didn't include those either. I do contact-less delivery, and the delivery guy seemed pretty curt. Just dropped the food at the door without saying a word. No response to my cordial "thank you, have a good night." Just a very unsatisfactory experience. Also seeing that on Yelp this place gets nowhere near 5 stars is pretty telling (of the pizzeria, but maybe of the Slice app users too). read more

Food is great. Love their specials. Service is speedy. The ambiance is nice if you want to sit outside and enjoy a slice of pizza or if you stay in. read more

Food is good. Service is great ambience good always always there on the weekends to get some pizza for my patients.

The food is amazing! Always consistent the flavors are amazing!We enjoyed everything we've had! Everyone is friendly and the food is delicious ! read more

I ordered a small Caesar salad with grilled chicken and it was delicious!! The best part is the chicken was warm!! Who likes cold chicken on a a cold salad. The dressing was creamy. Perfect amount of food. Solid prices. Total was 9$ before tax. The staff is friendly. Will be back! read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

We decided to try this place again after it was renamed. Not sure if that means there are new people there but I was not really impressed. Why one star? Because I was the lucky person in my family who ordered a veal parm, resulting in food poisoning. Thankfully I only ate half of the sandwich because who knows how much worse it would've been if I ate the entire thing. It was very fun, as I spent the next 12-24 hours puking my guts out. No one else in my household got sick, so all I can say is avoid the veal! read more

Pizza is really hit or miss! I've had great slices here, but there's no consistency. The good: they're generous with their toppings and they are high quality. And the guys behind the counter have always been friendly to me. But the crust often has issues, it somehow manages to be both burned or charred on the bottom and limp. Other times it's thin and crispy and perfectly cooked. read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Mushroom and plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

Pizza here is very average and make sure if you like cheese on you pie to order extra cheese.

We ordered a family pack. It came with 1 large cheese pizza, a house salad, fried cheese sticks, garlic knots and 1 liter of soda for $40 which is a good deal. If you wanna topping on a pizza it costs extra. Still a very good deal. Everything tastes good, friendly neighborhood pizzeria. read more

Very great Arancini at 4$ a pop/ball, nice and crispy. Pizza is good too very classic nyc crust and great flavor on the sauce. Loved the Pasta Carbonara, good portion for price under 10$. Has small wine options for dine in and some beer. Great guy at the counter, very laid back and courteous. Space is small and clean, cute place for a stop when in the area. Def recommend. read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Arancini, delicious with marinara sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

See all

Very tasty ,excellent service,very nice ambiance.We recommend everyone. Thanks you very much.

So lets start with something nice.On Fridays...Andrews makes this amazing special slice. No tomato sauce...but carmelized onions with breadcrumbs.......I cant get enough of it. Furthermore...their grilled calamari, is delicious. But their obnoxious and rude delivery guy, will ensure that I NEVER order from this place again. The last time he came to deliver into my building, with NO MASK...I called and told them to stop sending him. But tonight, he calls me from downstairs...says he cant seem to find a spot ( there are spots all over my neighborhood)..and says I have to come down ( despite the fact that I am sick in bed, with my robe on). So I let him know he'll have to wait....and when I get downstairs, I tell him that it's not cool to make a sick person have to get dressed to come down for a delivery. Well he looks me in the eye....and tells me to go fck myself. I'm sorry.....fck YOU Andrews. Not cool...and will no longer be patronizing you. read more

Visited on a Tuesday about 3:30 PM. Gentlemen greeted me upon entering. Was serve very quickly, although pepperoni slices were a bit too oily. Nice spot to grab your goods and go. Plenty of seating, and a restroom. read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Pepperoni Slices. - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

New owners. Food is very good. I've had almost everything there and is great. Service is excellent. Friendly atmosphere. So much better than prior owners read more

Never sorry when o order from Andrew's. Pizza is delicious, both regular and Sicilian. Also his calamari and shrimp are very good with delicious sauce and good amount of pasta. Excellent meatballs. Plenty of bread given. Fresh salads and very good soups which are great now that it's winter. Very nice lady named Margie delivers and always on time and with a smile! read more

Find me a better tasting or better smelling Sicilian in Queens. This is thick, the perfect amount of crunchy and the perfect amount of sauce and cheese. Out of this world good. read more

Eliot Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Middle Village, New York

Ordered the mushroom and pepperoni slices togo with a can of coke for $11.25. Nice crispy crust, liked the pepperoni slice better. The mushroom slice tasted like the cheese was different. Overall great pizza spot I would come back to try different menu items. read more

Very disappointed. We called to inform them we got the wrong food and the delivery man came back, took the part of the order that was wrong (which I'm not sure is safe during COVID) and gave us a pizza that was not fully cooked so we had to put in the oven to finish cooking. We were still missing one of the items from our order. When we called to tell them this we were told they were "busy" and we never received it. With so many better pizzerias in this area I would expect them to be nicer to their customers. Unfortunately, my family and I will not be back to Andrews after how we were treated. P. S. They came back and took the wrong order back that we already opened despite COVID protocols. read more

Whenever I picked up my order , the guy behind the counter that make the pizza , never have a mask on . Please for the sake of safety due to COVID -19 , please follow the CDC guild line! read more

This is one of my favorite pizza places in my area. They staff is incredibly friendly, the food is well cooked and the flavor is superb. I came in here once to find an owner who has been here well before I was even born. You can clearly see that he is a seasoned pizza conissure who knows a good slice when he makes it. I actually witnessed the owner remove pizza out of the case because it hadn't looked right. I was pleasantly impressed hearing him speakiing with a customer he obviously knew and said: " If it looks funny to me I take it out, the pizza never usually stays long, but sometimes it happens and I gotta take it out, I don't feel right selling it" I knew a slice to hold me over until dinner was not an option, I left with a Snapple and came back four hours later and bought dinner for my family The Pizza sauce was not sweet, or spicy, or old or salty. It tasted like tomatoes, garlic, and olive oil. Which is what sauce should taste like. Everything was cooked evenly and the dough was risen well. It was not awful or chewy. It was soft pillows of Sicilian semolina dough that was blanketed in sauce an cheese. You will not suffice with only a slice. read more

See all

Went in for a slice today. Never tried this place before but the slice was yummy. Not the best slice I ever had but it did the job. Good sauce and cheese. Nice crust. Thanks I would come back read more