As stated by my 4yr old son, "yummy pizza". We happened to find this place because Anthonys across the street was closed. It was definitely a pleasant surprise. The pizza is delicious. They are super clean. The staff is nice and courteous. Awesome place!! read more

Great pizza!!! Really friendly staff! Will definitely be back! It was delicious! Pizza tastes like real New York style pizza and the rolls are fresh and garlicky. read more

We ordered take out service on the phone was super to the point I would like to think they were just busy --anywho , was delicious , a bit too greasy for a Margherita but still delicious , they do it with no sauce ( we were surprised ) and just a lot of cheese ‍ read more

I ordered 2 Italian subs and they appeared to be right, but upon the first bite, I knew this sub was all wrong. First of all, it smelled terrible. I got a rancid smell/ flavor in my mouth and I had to spit it out immediately. I inspected the sub and to my disappointment, I found green/gray salami, smelly/old cappicola, and thick/slimy boiled ham. Uneatable. We called and got our money back. I washed my hands 5 times and couldn't get the stench to go away. So glad I didn't get sick. Stay away :( read more

See all

Third time eating here food is great. Service was great will be return to Fantasy pizza! read more

Fantasy Pizza - Yummy - Italian Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

Friday 1/22/2016 The weather was cold the rain was chilly but the pizza was fresh, warm and very filling! I grew up in New York I moved to Florida completey forgot how NYC-style pies are suppose to be. That was until I came here. I heard about the negativity in this restaurant received in the past. Don't worry I come with good news! Fantasy Pizza is under brand new management, has reinvented the way they cook the pizzas and the rest of there entree. I had the plain cheese pizza I am speechless I can't speak I'm still chewing this pizza! It's so much more then cheese on baked bread it really lives up to the NYC pizza name. We ordered the Roma from the Speciality Pizza. Roma comes with Spinach, Fresh Garlic, Fresh Mozzarella, Ricotta, and Parmesan. It's sauce free. We were given two slices of plain cheese pizza on the house! Thanks Wendy. The slices were almost the size of a house they were tall. You can actually taste the ingredients and the spices. The plain cheese was rich, savoury almost like butter, the crust was nice and crunchy. The cheese was flavorful. Like the plain cheese my tastebuds picked up the Roma's sweet creamy and delicious ingredients. It was all so yummy. We ate them on Pizza sliced plates! The establishment is covered in sports memorabilia going from jerseys to soccer uniforms. It's a pizza palace and a sports bar. Soon the restaurant will have new and improved material. Fantasy Pizza serves Wings, Salad, Pasta, Subs, Pizza, and Beer. You can buy any Sub & Soda for $6.99 until 4pm. If you leave a review on yelp you get there free famous zeppoles for free! There fresh right out of the kitchen, unlike the conditions of the weather it was hot and cold. Nice and cold on the powdered outside, heated bready goodness on the inside. I give Fantasy Pizza 3 out of 5 toppings. The workers and manager were friendly and kind. We will definitely be coming back! read more

See all

I've lived behind Fantasy Pizza for years and never knew what I was missing out on! The food is great! The pizza slices are HUGE! It isn't often that you find good old New York style pizza like this. You definitely get your money's worth of food. The customer service is excellent as well!! We will definitely be coming here more frequently! read more

Fantasy Pizza - Celebrating our FSA conqueror at Fantasy Pizza! - Italian Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

By far the best pizza place in Pembroke Pines feels like you in a New York pizza place . Great service and great pizza a must have place is amazing. read more

In my own humble opinion, NY pizza is simply the best. However, when I'm not in NY and I'm craving a slice, this is my go to place. Perfect thin crust, light on the sauce and heavy on the cheese. I usually stop in for the lunch special and I've never been disappointed. Good service, friendly staff and great tunes. Oh, and try the zeppolies, yum! read more

I'm a Ny'er and I'm telling you the pizza here is gooooood. Enough said :) OH! And they have zeppoles, zeppoles dang it! Amazingness.

By the slice or the pie NY pizza in Pembroke pines. They're a staple in the neighborhood, been in business for many years. Eat local don't eat from the big chains with their factory food. This is really good pizza go get your slice today. read more

Great food awesome pizza. The staff was very friendly. The best in Pembroke Pines. Well worth the drive...

Their margarita pizza is the best. Chicken wings and garlic rolls are also very good.

I went here for a quick lunch today. The service was sufficient and pleasant. It was quiet so my party could talk and not have to strain to hear each other. The food was delicious and well portioned. A quaint pizza shop with an extended menu. I will definitely go back. read more

Our first time at Fantasy Pizza, and I must say, we really enjoyed it. We ordered the meatball pizza and mild wings. The pizza tasted fresh and the crust was sooo good. The wing sauce was good also. The only reason I didn't give five stars is because the pizza could have had more meatballs and the wings were on the small side. read more

The wings are the best. Sports bar enviroment not crowed.clean neat and very friendly ..puzza is good and taste

My husband and I come here at least once a week. They have the BEST food and we LOVE the wings, perfect size and flavor. All servers are extremely friendly you'll feel right at home. Come and experience the best NY pizza taste!!! read more

This place has an awesome lunch special. Been coming here for a long time. Pizza and the garlic bread is a must.

This is a nice NY style sports-themed pizzeria. The dining room is spacious, and the atmosphere is laid-back. This was our first time, and our waitress was super friendly and helpful. They have family specials and also serve slices. The pizza is thin, big, and greasy - just the way I like it! The crust is nicely toasted and crispy, too. If you're not in the mood for pizza, they also have subs, salads, and pasta dishes. Do yourself a favor, I know it sounds wierd, but check out the bathroom. It's a hoot! read more

Fantasy Pizza - Half pepperoni, half cheese, wholly delicious! - Italian Near Me - Pembroke Pines, Florida

We ordered pick up. Hawaiian Pizza and Penne alla vodka. I have to say I was very disappointed. The garlic rolls were hard. The soup could of came from a can. The pasta was unremarkable and the pizza did not make me go ohh or ahhh. I was hungry too so it should of been easy to impress me. Amici's pizza down the street is 10 times better. Sorry Not a winner. read more

I walked in around 3:30 pm and stood at the counter. 3 employees were standing in sight, one was texting on their phone. I stood there for a good two minutes, no one even acknowledged me. So I walked out. This is not a review on the quality of their product. It's a review of their customer services which, in my case, was severely lacking. I hope you have a different experience! read more

L.OV.E This Place! Always Come For The Pizza! I Drive 20 minutes away just for the food. I have tried many different dishes and have never been disappointed! read more

My husband and I decided to order from Fantasy tonight since we were craving pizza and had never tried them. Worst idea ever. We asked for delivery and was told it would be 45 min. An hour later we called for an update and was told the driver left a while ago and he would be here soon. So we wait. Thirty more minutes go by and still no pizza. We called again and while we were on the phone the driver knocks on the door. Pizza okay, kinda cold, wings were ice cold and not so good. This was the first and last time we order from here. read more

It's okay Florida Pizza. It's better than Poppa John's, and fairly priced. Being that this place is literally around the corner from me, it was dissapointing that the pizza we ordered was cold, as if it had been sitting out for a while before they delivered it. It also took longer than an hour. Probably won't order from them again, though it wasn't bad. Maybe in a pinch, if we have people over or something. Otherwise, I'll pass. read more

Never again! I placed an order for delivery at 6:06 pm and was told 45 minutes to an hour. Pizza arrives at 7:50 pm. Cold and hard. No one even bothered to call regarding the delay. Not cool. read more

Fantasy Pizza you truly are my pizza fantasy! Muah! I love love love love love (again) love pizza!! And since I have moved to Miami from up north this is hands down one of the best neighborhood pizzerias in south Florida. We have tried alot of the pizza places and they've left a lot to be desired. You will not find any thrills, frills, or snoody nose up in the air would you like some sprouts, tofu and broccoli on your $20 for a small "pie" here. Just great ole American-Italian pie. They offer pizza, wings, salads, and all sorts of Italian dishes that I haven't even tried because I'm so stuck on the pizza and wings. There's also a pasta $6.98 lunch/$9.99 dinner menu where you get soup or salad, rolls, and your choice of noodle (spaghetti/linguine/penne). $4.98 Lunch, 2 slices and a drink. Nice! Their entire menu is online including coupons. My boyfriend and I have been ordering from here every weekend lately. Our order? A large pepperoni/sausage w/ an order of hot wings. The pizza pie they serve is delish and to perfection. The sauce? Tomato perfection! The pepperoni and sausage? Fresh, and thin sliced, the sausage has a nice lil kick just I like it (And no rolled balls of sausage here). The crust? Nice, thin, flavorful, a lil crunchy on the bottom. We also had the nice occasion of dining in last night instead of ordering delivery (45 mins). This pizzeria is a small mom and pop shop located in the Rooms To Go strip mall next to a ceiling fan store. If I hadn't received coupons at home, I would never had stopped there. The simple neon red sign doesn't look like they're serious about their pizza, but don't be fooled. The service is friendly too. They have sets of 4-person sized booths alongside the wall and a couple of small tables in the front. There's at least one HD TV set on the wall that was tuned to ESPN2 for Friday Fight Night. We chose one of the booths and were immediately met by an older guy (the owner?) who was very funny and nice. He took our order "the usual", you got our own drinks. About 20 minutes later, the wings were served piping hot (smoke coming off the hot sauce) makes my water just thinking about them this morning after. They're served skinny style, without all the thick, gross breading. The pizza came next, served fresh out of the oven and made our weekly delivered pie pale in comparison. It comes nice and hot upon delivery, but nothing compares to a fresh out the oven pie. We devoured everything (we usually have leftovers) and there was nothing but crumbs, a couple of crust ends, and hot sauce from the wings left. We almost couldn't after our gorge fest, but we had a movie to catch. They have maybe 4 dessert selections, and I wanted to try at least one, but there was no room. The jeans were already busting open. The only thing that would make this place better is if they expanded to a larger location and added waiters and more tables/ booths for a more private dining setting for nice date/family nights out. This place definitely serves better pizza than the ones that do. To the owners, maybe one day? Until then, a girl can dream can't she? I'll definitely be back again and again for my buffalo wings and pizza fix! read more

Had Fantasy Pizza a few times since my last review. Don't get it delivered. Great pizza if you eat it in house, but they apparently don't know how to deliver a hot pizza. read more

Quick delivery on a Saturday night! Friendly delivery driver! Spinach tasted fresh on the pizza! But the pizza was a bit doughy, maybe it should have stayed in the oven a little longer. And the wings.....yeah, they were pretty small, kind of underwhelmed after having read good reviews on them. Oh and only 2 really thin slivers of celery??? But they delivered really quick..... read more

I come to fantasy pizza often it used to be a tradition with my dad and brothers. Today I brought my boyfriend for lunch i was a little worried bc we were crunched on time but we were in and out in a half hour and the pizza was delicious as always read more

Chill sports atmosphere with friendly staff and great food! Not to mention the prices are awesome. Definitely recommend!

I'm sorry I just had to update my review from 3 stars to 2. I hate to do it because their pizza is great! But they never allow me to give their other menu items a try because their service is so poor! They are open until 10 & 11pm most nights and stop delivering at 8:30! And today Sunday they close at 9pm and they have no garlic rolls left and won't make anymore. Not to mention the phone was busy for almost 10 minutes, delaying my pick up order, since I know they won't dare deliver "at this hour" (7:45 at night) sheesh! Do I have to order at 2pm to get pizza & rolls for dinner time? I'm trying to like them but they just made it even harder again today. I just cancelled my order and they don't even care. Owner needs to step it up, what's good product if you can't deliver on it? Literally. read more

Tasteless, over-priced and totally misleading price points. Nearby place charges 8$ per large pizza, this one charges $15. And that pizza tastes like rubber. read more

This place is so yummy !!!! Homemade Italian food!!!! Great customer service and never a wait !!! Love this place !!!!

Great New York Style Pizza and awesome Chocolate cake! Clean seating area and open kitchen. Very impressed as it was our first time coming here. read more

Horrible ... Service was good but food horrible... I ordered thyme lemon chicken vegetables was like charcoal ... My boyfriends pizza tasted like they just defrozed it in microwave... Everything has the same seasoning ... Save ur money and time ... Don't go there read more

False advertisement- had a flyer saying $4.99 for 2 slices, 6 knots, and a fountain drink. NOPE! Then the nasty waitress denied it when I showed the flyer. Pizza is ok read more

The food is good but the delivery hours are wrong. Three times I have ordered 30 minutes before delivery hours end and always an excuse from "the delivery guy had an emergency" or " the oven is being serviced". Just adjust your advertised delivery times and provide the service as advertised. read more

Poor service. The young lady who took my order did not know what was on menu. I finally placed my order and after an hour wait they forgot the main entrée. I called and got a dry apology. Never again! Clearly customer service is not their priority. read more

We love this place. I ordered on line and my food was ready in no time. Pizza is absolutely delicious. 100% recommend Fantasy Pizza read more

Oh my this pizza place is my favorite in Pembroke Pines! The cheese pizza is amazing, delicious, and the service is really nice.