Frankie&#x27;s NY Bagels

What a waste of $20. for a fruit-pie, which was mostly crust with very little fruit filling, which…read morewas tasteless for a fruit pie. Don't bother buying these fruit pies. Go elsewhere and get your hard-earned money's worth. You'll see that our suggestion hits the mark completely. BYOF ... bring your own fruit if you buy this fruit pie ... you'll know then you are really eating a fruit pie and not one that hides any fruit beneath it. If the fruit made as part of the pie was visible, think you'd scratch your head and say "where's the fruit".

Amazing women owned wholesale bakery. Love their whole line but especially their pot pie and…read morechocolate silk pie. 10/10!!

3" chocolate cream-less pie

Flavor First, Gluten Free Always!

See all

8" lemon meringue-less pie

Bayside Farmstead Café

4.5(143 reviews)

5.6 mi

Passing thru as tourist. Seriously the best coffee and breakfast we have ever had! Great service as…read morewell. Highly recommend.

Excellent food options (and what a sizable menu!) The coffee…read moredrinks are really good as well. Ample sitting room inside. Parking is a little rough, but not debilitating. Food came out quick even for our party of 9 and was hot and fresh!

Really cute cottage Cafe selling simple menu items, coffee and tea

Veggie Frittata

See all

Mimosa of the day!!

Brick & Fire Bistro

4.3(1.2k reviews)

2.2 mi

My husband and I were on a road trip and staying in Eureka for the night and decided to eat here…read morefor dinner, which also happened to fall on Father's Day. The place was pretty busy at 8pm and we sat outside since we had our pup with us. I ordered 3 oysters as an app. I had just read that Humboldt Bay provided a large percentage of the oysters consumed in CA and NV so figured I should order some since we're so close to the source! I was surprised when I slurped it down and it was warm but they were delicious and the sauce on top was very flavorful. (That was my fault for not reading the description well enough; I'm just accustomed to eating oysters chilled) For entree's, I went with the Polenta Veghie lasagna and my husband ordered the Italian Mac n cheese. Both dishes were very good and very filling. I loved the crust of the polenta and the eggplant and cheese filling was delicious. The staff was very friendly and helpful and I was impressed with the coziness and warmth of the interior. Great spot for dinner, I'm glad I chose this restaurant!

I was visiting Eureka and decided to check this place out. So glad I was able to try this…read morerestaurant and the delicious food they serve. My wife and I ordered the Italian Mac and cheese, beef bolognese, seafood soup (almost like a cioppino) of the day , and mushroom cobbler. All dishes were amazing and so flavorful. It was hard to pick a favorite but the beef bolognese and soup stood out to me. Our servers were so delightful and incredibly friendly. The ambience is great too; lively and homey. If I am back in town this is the first place I am coming back to. I wish I had this exact restaurant in my area!

05.24.25

Roasted Local Oysters

See all

05.24.25 exterior

Babe's Pizza-Pasta

3.8(360 reviews)

1.1 mi

Tasty pizza. Fresh salad bar. Great service. What's not to love?…read more I understand there are pizza preferences. Babe's is medium-thick crust, perfectly baked, topped with just the right amount of cheese and speciality toppings, flame broiled to melt and lightly toast the cheese. You won't need a pack of napkins to eat one slice, and the toppings will stay aboard the whole time. Plus it's delicious.

My son was craving pizza and pasta for dinner so I found this place on Yelp. It's located in a…read moreresidential neighborhood away from the main business streets, but kind of near the local zoo. Babe's gives me mom and pop Shakey's vibes. There's a big party room for meetings or parties, and a game room with arcade games off to the side - accessible by stairs only so my son couldn't go in. In addition to pizza and pasta, they have sandwiches, calzones, and a fresh salad bar, not a ton of toppings but enough of everything I like to make me happy. My family and I ordered a large pizza w/ half sizzling bbq chicken & half Babe's Combo, a spaghetti and AYCE salad bar. The pizza was amazing, I loved the bbq chicken and the crust was super yum. Even my husband commented that the pizza was good and he doesn't usually make comments about pizza unless it's really bad. However, the spaghetti was missing some salt/herbs so it was bland for my personal taste. Salad ingredients were fresh, and I went back about 3 times as my family kept wanting more. The best part about Babe's was the people working here. Everyone was nice, but especially the lady who took my order, she was so so nice! Actually honestly, everyone I've come across in Eureka has been so friendly and kind, from the gas station, to the Target...it's been a great experience interacting with the people here. But the lady at Babe's just made my day, and unfortunately I didn't catch her name, but Babe's is so lucky to have her! There needs to be more Eureka kindness in this world.

Game room

Combination Calzone

See all

Babe's Pizza-Pasta

Tandoori Bites Indian Cuisine

3.8(497 reviews)

2.2 mi

It's one of our favorite places to eat. Food is amazing. I always go for mild the Grands of course…read morego for hot. Never disappoints.... Serving portions are very generous. The servers are friendly and efficient. Reasonably priced.

Unfortunately very disappointing. I'm hoping it was just a bad day…read more The curries were not flavorful at all. Almost tasted watered down. The rice was lukewarm and hard, like the water ratio was off when cooking or it had been sitting there wait awhile. The portion sizes on the curries were tiny. Credit where credit is due. The meats in curries were tasty. But it felt like digging for gold. For about $16 bucks a plate, I was pretty disappointed. I'll have to try it again and see if it was a fluke.

Assorted appetizers with chutney and tamarind sauce

See all

Falafelove

4.9(142 reviews)

5.4 mi

I'm so happy I finally went to FalafeLove! The staff were friendly, the service and food were…read morequick, the atmosphere was beautiful both inside and out. Best of all the food was fresh and delicious with flavors and colors that really were such a wonderful treat. An easy 5 I will definitely be back!

This place will change your life. I used to sling Falafel in two separate establishments and people…read moredon't realize: there's a lot that can go wrong. Others have mentioned the small size of the falafel balls, but that's kinda the secret sauce here. The smallness makes it so you can have an extra crunchy outside, with a just done enough inside, that is still moist without feeling underdone. Any larger and you'd have a weird mix of crunchy on the outside tough on the outer half and not done at all in the center. If they were smaller, they'd be too tough through and through. I also feel compelled to mention the depth of flavor achieved by the babaganoush. This is magical. Now, I make my own baba at home, so I know how difficult it can be to get the balance right. This place has nailed it. The hummus is divine and bursting with flavor. The tahini is gorgeous. The flavors of the meats (I tried both the chicken and had an à la carte side of the lamb roll) -- they have managed to make them completely complex--you get the feeling that they slow cooked it all for hours...locking in juicy smokiness that will make you say mmmmm and fill yourself ridiculously full because you can't stop eating it. Nor would you want to. On a personal note, as an Ashkenzai Jew, who has been very unfortunately landlocked in the worst place for our people: Southern Idaho for 2.5 years, this place felt like a breath of fresh air. Speaking of which, the open air patio in the back with plenty of flowering plants, overlooking the water, is such a fun yet tranquil setting. The guys are so kind as well, and made me feel like family. Just walking in and hearing the music, I felt uplifted. And then talking with them...just felt like chatting with old friends. They are simply crushing the hospitality piece. Don't sleep on FalafelLove.

They have specials not on the menu

First time visiting, won't be our last! two falafelove plates with various sides and homemade pita, all great!

See all

Quaint storefront, blink and you'll miss it!

Erlei's Bakin it

4.9(30 reviews)

3.2 mi

To be honest I've never had a good cinnamon roll from a restaurant or store. They're always dry,…read moreand not glazed enough. However upon entering this hidden gem, I found my one true love--CINNAMON ROLL GALORE and now I'm a changed woman. The store itself is quite hidden behind Big 5 on Broadway. Nothing could stop me from finding the gooey cinnamon dessert so I went on a quest to find Erlei's and upon arrival I was invited into a sweet quaint cafe with lovely decor and sweet beverages. A sweet woman greeted me and patiently waited while I felt quite indecisive...but the glint of a glazed cinnamon roll caught my eye--and I made my choice...the choice that CHANGED MY LIFE The first bite sent me straight to heaven....and I don't think I'll see cinnamon rolls the same ever again... The spread of pastries and treats included cupcakes, quiche, scones, an abundance of various muffins, and the most epic cinnamon roll I had been dying for.

We had really delicious and obviously homemade cinnamon rolls here. We bought a few muffins to go…read moreand they were delicious as well. We will be back for more!

Our avocado, cilantro, cojita scones

Our Danish and turnovers

See all

Cinnamon rolls, coffee cake and more!

Ginger Restaurant

4.0(106 reviews)

2.2 mi

Driving through Northern CA and did not expect such a filling and fun meal…read more This spot is definitely a Chinese, Korean, Japanese fusiony spot that I did not expect to find here. We ordered the Chinese Style Lamb Stew, Cheese Corn, Kung Pao Vegetables, and it came with a side of banchan. Every single dish here was absolutely delicious and piping hot! We ended up ordering a second plate of banchan because it was so good. The daikon radish had the most satisfying crunch and the others- cabbage and bean sprouts were very well pickled too! Cheese corn was sweet and honestly a good pairing with the very soury/ pickled soup. The kung pao vegetables would have definitely fooled me if I wasn't told it was mushroom. The batter holds on the oyster mushrooms just like chicken does. Well seasoned. Service was very impressive - there was a single waitress serving lots of tables. She had amazing recommendations and really seemed like she knew what she was doing. Very kind and attentive the entire time. Would love to return.

Súper disappointed. We have come here several times and usually really enjoy our food-- I don't…read moreknow if today was an off day or we got too experimental but we were shocked tonight. The pan fried chicken dumplings were from Costco, the spicy beef ramen left much to be desired and had an extremely dry egg. And then my friends chow mein came out half way through our meal (they forgot), had no veggies and was sweet?? They kind of attempted to fix it, so we were willing to let things go. That was one thing, then as we were waiting for them to pick up our card to pay, our server, Mira, loudly complained to her coworker about us sending the food back and how we were "pissed" (we weren't, until she started almost yelling about the situation to her coworker). Extremely unprofessional. Makes us second wanting to return in the future.

Inside

DELICIOUS

See all

Humboldt Smokehouse

3.8(399 reviews)

2.6 mi

First off the owner was there and did a great job explaining their menu and gave my husband a…read moresample of pork belly. Which he said,"was delicious!" He ended up having a pulled pork sandwich with coleslaw. I had burnt ends brisket with the baked beans & Mac & cheese. Everything was very good except the Mac & cheese. It wasn't bad just not as good as everything else. It doesn't look like much but good and service was great!

I ordered my sandwich, paid, and a lady gave me my sandwich. I was walking out and a guy employee…read morechased me outside and accused me of not paying for a meat plate combo!? I told him I did pay and he insisted I didn't. After I told him I got a sandwich not a plate combo he said "oh" and walked away. No apology. This was hurtful and unnecessary. The sandwich wasn't even good. There was literally only one other guy in the store I don't know why I was blamed.

Interior

See all

The Greene Lily

4.0(429 reviews)

2.7 mi

Rolled into The Greene Lily for a Sunday morning breakfast @ 9am…read more My crew of 5 were greeted by staff minutes prior to opening time. Staff here aims to please with coffee and water being poured routinely throughout the breakfast. My table had a highlight of orders to include the 2x2x2, Chipotle Benedict, Backwoods Benedict, and my Chicken and Waffle Sammy. Prior to ordering breakfast you must try the beignets! Fresh, tasty, and hott! Not only was the service excellent and food tasty the historic building this restaurant sits within makes for a unique dining experience. 5 stars! I'll be back.

The place is cute inside but it's overpriced sub par food at best. I paid $50 for two BLAT and the…read moreavocado was brown & tasted like it had expired. They barely put anything on the sandwich leaving me with 50% left over just plain bread and they couldn't be bothered to put mayo on the bread themselves so half the sandwich fell apart in my process of trying to do that myself. Their "local coffee" was brewed terribly as well, bitter with a weird after taste. Don't waste your time eating her, drive to arcata if you want something worth that kind of money. This meal tasted like it should have cost half that price.

The bar area, very quaint.

Bacon and potatoes

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

2 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cody H.

164

8 years ago

Illeagally sells retail, and only has a permit to sell wholesale. Terrible owner who abused their employees and unsafe conditions. Stay away from Frankie's, they are bad buisness read more

Dylan R.

3 years ago

It takes too long to get food. The donuts are good. read more

Frankie's NY Bagels - bagels - Updated September 2026

People who viewed Frankie's NY Bagels also viewed

Don's Donuts Pizza & Deli

4.1

(227 reviews)

Originally I intended to grab a pie at another restaurant but upon arriving I found out that place…read morewas no longer in business and this ended up being the next place nearby. It's conveniently located near the town square. Upon arriving I noticed a person cleaning the storefront window. Then I walked in and noticed how clean the establishment was floor, tables and condiments bar. Even the donut case seemed spotless. The donuts looked amazing, I just couldn't pass up getting a few. I had a half pepperoni and half combination pizza and it was not greasy or soggy. Headed out to the dunes to watch the sunset and eat pizza. Best way to finish the day. Super friendly staff, smiling the entire time.

Donuts. Donuts for da cheap. Pizza for da medium. Perfect place after getting shit facedread more

The Donut Mill

4.7

(88 reviews)

Please indulge me as I review The Donut Mill using two hypothetical donut situations…read more 1) If I get anywhere near this place I'm like an old satellite that's lost the ability to avoid the Donut Mill's gravitational pull before my face collides happily with a pile of donuts. 2) If my doctor tells me that each donut from The Donut Mill will cost me an hour of my life, I will choose to leave this earth with a mouth full of donuts and a smile.

This place is amazing. We always look for a donut shop when roadtripping, and this is our favorite…read moreby far. The shop looks a little run down on the outside, but the taste of the donuts makes up for this 100x over. So light & airy, and the Apple bear claw was to die for. The price was even amazing, $12 for 6 really big donuts. If I am ever in the area I am definitely going back!

Happy Donuts Express Asian Food

3.6

(119 reviews)

I havent been here years never thought the donuts were special. Though I haven't visited in person…read morein about 5 years until this morning, I recently had their apple fritter a week ago which a coworker had brought in to work. It left a very waxy film in your mouth unlike donut mill which makes exceptional apple fritters. I assume they use some solid frying oil like shortening or something. But the real reason for leaving this review is as I came in. I asked for a round glazed cinnamon roll. It was 6.95. An apple fritter was 6.95. A dozen donut holes was 5.95 a glazed donut was 2.95. Are you absolutely out of your mind? The donuts are so mid tier and youre charging more for that filth than a local bakery does for their pastries. Absolutely out of your minds. We would always make fun of this place because the lady would be so obnoxious and always be like and then and then and then what else what else you want what else you want and then what else you want. Like nothing I want one donut that's it. Thank god she wasnt there this morning and it was some other gentlemen. I gladly told him I didn't know donuts were so expensive and I walked out. How does this place still exist a dozen regular donuts are 40 dollars

Worst Donut Shop Experience of My Life. Stay Away. I don't…read moreeven know where to begin. $37.50 for a dozen donuts. Let that sink in. When I had the audacity to ask what justified that price, the owner didn't just fail to answer -- she turned immediately hostile, became openly rude to me, and then tried to enlist other customers in the store to gang up on me. In a donut shop. Over a price question. Rather than addressing my concern professionally, she attempted to drag strangers into the confrontation -- what should have been a straightforward conversation between a business owner and a paying customer turned into something embarrassing and hostile. A business owner who responds to basic questions by belittling customers and stirring up conflict has no business running a business. On top of that, the store itself was visibly dirty. Cleanliness is non-negotiable when you're handling food that people put in their mouths -- it's the bare minimum. The hygiene standards on display were deeply concerning and off-putting. This place deserves zero stars. If you value your money, your dignity, and basic food safety standards, do yourself a favor and drive right past it. I will not be returning.

Hole In the Wall Great Sandwiches

3.7

(225 reviews)

My longtime sandwich go to!…read more The name says it for itself. It is a small hole in the wall. I love the updates they have done with the place. Not only have they added a fence but they have added two benches aside from the long wooden bench.

Pretty standard sandwich shop. Sandwich was standard and the bread (from the local Brio Bakery) was…read morequite good. Meat quality seems fine and there is a good ratio of meat to veggies. The cheese used was quite good. I thought it was expensive compared to other places, $17.25 for a fairly standard sandwich. Staff was nice and friendly and there is a picnic area to eat outside their small store. Overall: 3.6/5

Central Sandwich

4.2

(131 reviews)

Immediately was welcomed when I walked in by the friendly and down to earth staff. Our sandwiches…read morewere made exactly how we ordered, they tasted fresh and were delicious. Definitely would recommend to anyone looking for a good deli sandwich!

I think this is the best sandwich place in Humboldt County! I love their roast beef on a dutch…read morecrunch roll. Perfecto. It isn't easy to find dutch crunch and other shops in the area don't come close to Central Sandwich's quality. It's worth the drive to McKinleyville!

Pile High Deli

4.3

(59 reviews)

Reuben is very tasty and piled high with hot pastrami. The staff is friendly, helpful and very…read moreefficient. Good place to stop for a delicious sandwich. L

Awesome deli that we stopped at during our roadtrip! We got the mortadella sandwich on Dutch crunch…read moreroll and muffalatta sandwich on sourdough both of which were piled high and filling. The Dutch crunch roll was so good, I haven't had it elsewhere! Service was quick and easy and we were able to customize our sandwiches with toppings and the works. A good grab and go stop that was clean and convenient.

Ramone's Bakery & Cafe

4.1

(57 reviews)

The best of Humboldt with the best prices Every drink is…read morehand crafted 10 out of 10 Plenty of parking

My favorite place for treats ever! The chocolate decadence torte is perfection and every other item…read moreI have had from here has been delightful. All locations are great!

Brio Breadworks

4.5

(33 reviews)

Wow. Just wow. So good!!! Do not visit or pass through Arcata without stopping in at Brio…read more I had the herb and cheese omelet and it was phenomenal. The chef here understands eggs and I'm here for that. Nothing worse to me than eggs that are overcooked and my omelet was expertly prepared, removed from the heat and allowed to finish cooking with its own heat. And the herbs added were delightful. This came with a multigrain toast and that was also very good. My dining partner had a breakfast sandwich on a toasted croissant and enjoyed it very much. It came with 2 eggs, prepared to your request and a generous portion of ham. The latter, I'm told, was the best ever, from anywhere, while my plain coffee was lovely. The staff here is very friendly and helpful. There is table space inside and outside. On the morning we went, it was still a bit cool outside so we stayed indoors and felt comfortable especially since the doors were open. I must try some of their other baked goods the next time I'm in Arcata - they all looked glorious!

Bread is delicious. Knocked a star as attendent stop talking when I was giving information and did…read morenot respond

Ramone's Bakery & Cafe

3.8

(41 reviews)