So excited to have tried this place! Being gluten and dairy free it is always challenging to go to an Italian Restaurant but I had nothing to worry about here! There are so many options and the owners Stacy and Chad are super accommodating and made some alterations for me! First there is gluten free bread for me to eat, so no more longingly looking at my bf while he gets to eat the bread on the table! I dipped it in their red sauce, and it was delicious! He got 2 garlic cheesy knot things that are homemade on site, and my bf said it was the most amazing garlic bread thing he has ever eaten! I ordered the shrimp cocktail, super good and fresh and then I ordered the bolognese with gluten free pasta made with no dairy, it was delicious. I appreciated that the gf pasta didn't come in pieces, it held its own! My boyfriend ordered the chicken parm dinner and the stuffed mushrooms for his appetizer. He loved them both! Really enjoyed the sauce. I can't wait to come back, as you can see by their menu there are so many options for a gf/df girl like myself and I appreciate that so much. read more

Fusilli Restaurant & Pizzeria - Gluten Free Pasta Bolognese (no dairy) - Pizza Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Best Food very clean place to eat and Management was very nice good place to eat and reasonable Prices read more

Fusilli Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Miller Place, New York

See all

We were glad to see them back. Four stuffed heroes, a sicilian and house special pie brought smiles to our family. Everything done on time too! Good things happen to good people. read more

We recently got Fusilli for the first time since they've been back in business. As we remembered, the pizza was excellent- nicely cooked with delicious cheese toppings, and a crisp crust. And our kids enjoyed the chicken tenders and fries, which had generous portions. read more

Can't really say much about the cuisine because after an hour long wait at the table we left as not even a refill was offered to our beverages nor did the appetizer land anywhere close to us. This was the second visit and the other tables were frustrated but we could not wait any longer. They say the third time is a charm but we are done . read more

Just got a text... Thank Goodness you are BACK! I hope it's all your great cooking artists and stand-up personnel! Cant wait to order your Grandma's Pie again! Whoever took over and changed names was aweful! read more

Love the food. Best in the area. Dining room decor and ambiance is great. Excellent service.

Pizza is good, but the underside weirdly smells like a damp basement? Seems like maybe the boxes are stored somewhere damp. I've gotten multiple pies since the reopening and it has happened each time. read more

I ordered a stuffed artichoke francese (which I've ordered from them for a few years now...they're awesome). Tonight I got this....covered in tomatoes?! When I called I was told it was made as a courtesy because it's no longer on their menu. Whaaaat?!?! read more

Fusilli Restaurant & Pizzeria - I have never had francese drowning in tomatoes. ‍ - Pizza Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Try The Broccoli Rabe and Chicken Panini or a dish of broccoli rabe and chicken YUM!! have had their vodka pizza, which is also very good, and a few of their different pastas . Good stuff! The food overall is delicious and the Owners are lovely people read more

I ordered among other things 2 rice balls. one had one whole piece missing from it. when I called they tried blaming it on the DoorDash driver. read more

Fusilli Restaurant & Pizzeria - Food from Fusilli in Miller Place, delivered 10 min ago. It was probably dropped on the floor and than delivered. - Pizza Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Grandma SliceFagioli Soup Pizza and soup came out piping hot and just delicious!! I have asked my husband to come here a few times and we finally got here. He can't believe how good it is... pizza has big chunks of tomato in the sauce and soup had big chunks of veggies. Everything is so fresh and the people behind the counter are great- superior service!! read more

Fusilli Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza and soup are piping hot and delicious!! - Pizza Near Me - Miller Place, New York

Everything was delicious from start to finish and the lobster bisque soup was by far the best we've had around!

Disappointed as the take out dinner was cold - bland - the appetizers all had to be reheated - lacked the really good NY Italian flavors. Salad looked like it came out of a grocery store pre- made bag. The desserts though were ok. But I will never go back Ronn just Ronn The whole in the wall food guy. read more

I ordered a Sicilian pizza. The pizza was terrible. The online menu says 12x18 pie with 10 slices. I received a small pie with 8 slices. The pizza was all dough. Very little sauce and very little cheese. The old owner was making pizzas which worries me. Seems like he is making horrible pizza to drive customers away. I'm sure he will than try to buy business back for less the price. I sure hope who ever owns fusillis doesn't sell. Old owner is a snake. Never had an issue with pizza since new owner took over. If old owner takes over again, you'll never see us there again. read more

Kid ordered food without asking my permission . I called to cancel the food order 30 seconds later literally . Was told sorry "HUN" by the manager; even better was his reason.... because the pizza was already in the oven. read more

My wife and I came here as guests of another couple, so Fusilli was off of our radar. It's a pizza place in the front and restaurant in the back. 4 dinners between us all and all were recieved well. Chicken Parm, sausage and Broccoli Rabe, etc. All were excellent. Great service from Jessica ( Ihope I remembered her name correctly). Would I go back? Yes. In fact my wife wanted to go recently for the Date Night promo, but I thought it was too soon. read more

It's terrible that Fusilli closed Chad and his family were wonderful and the food was delicious . Best of luck to you

The restaurant switched owners, the new owner tweaked the dishes on the current menu which made them more appealing. My wife and I usually eat here for lunch. She loves the grilled chicken salad and I usually stick with a slice of a rice ball parm. We are here for dinner last night (8/30/21). My wife had the eggplant rollatini with a healthy side option of a salad and I went with the Piscatory which had fresh seafood in a garlic/oil sauce (see picture below). We HIGHLY Recommend this restaurant and look forward to seeing the positive changes to come. read more

Fusilli Restaurant & Pizzeria - Shrimp, muscles, clams, calamari - Pizza Near Me - Miller Place, New York

So sorry to see that Fusilli closed! We went there last evening, planning to get a great Italian meal with excellent service...and were sad to see the place permanently closed. I wonder what happened? read more

I ordered through GrubHub and the food arrived 30 minutes past the late end of the deliver window. It was cold so I had to wait longer while I reheated it. I called the restaurant at about the 20 minute mark but they were already closed so I couldn't even find out where it was or cancel my order. The penne alla vodka was good but was the smallest serving of pasta I've ever seen at an Italian restaurant. I normally get 2-3 meals out of a pasta dish and was able to finish this in a single serving (and I'm a small person). The calzone wasn't a calzone at all. It was a panini and the bread was so hard that my jaw got tired from chewing it so it wasn't even a good panini. The seafood soup was okay. The flavor was there but there wasn't a lot of seafood in it for how expensive it is. The last thing that really annoyed me is that I checked off for contactless delivery and to be texted when the food was delivered. Instead the delivery driver knocked on the door and waited to hand me my food. During a pandemic when this option is specifically there for people trying to limit contact with others you'd think they'd pay a bit more attention. read more

Wow, what a pleasant experience! We ordered Sunday night dinner. We ordered mozzarella sticks and artichoke shrimp and garlic knots AP, so good. We had salmon piccata, veal piccata and lobster ravioli with shrimp. All entree's were fresh, hot and delicious. Our son commented that the pasta itself was very tasty. The delivery was excellent, on time and the delivery person was delightful. Excellent experience, we will be working Fusilli in to our takeout rotation and look forward to dining in! read more

See all

Very nice restaurant and pizza place. Friendly staff. Clean. Good service. My husband ordered meatballs and the shrimp/clams appetizer. Meatballs were tasty and had a nice consistency. The shrimp (oreganata) & (whole) baked clams were delicious. I had the stracciatella soup, which was delicious. My husband ordered the veal parmagiana, which was very thin & tender and fried nicely. The fettuccini Alfredo was creamy and had a good, cheesy flavor. I had the Pescatore. It was pretty good. I do prefer the sauce thicker, this was more thin with chunk tomatoes. I didn't care for the mussels, the taste was "off" I didn't eat more than 2. Overall, a decent place we ended up dropping into and we would go back. Definitely a good value for the meal we had. read more

Went here for a quick dinner. We found this place through groupon and used a voucher. Sat in the pretty back dining area. We ordered the shrimp and chicken francese and he had the eggplant rollatini. My chicken franchese was delicious and they put the franchese sauce on the pasta too. Really good. I wasn't a fan of the shrimp franchese part but my fiancé loved it. I never had chrome that was and it seemed too soggy for my liking. The eggplant rollatini was huge! They give you your own personal cheese to sprinkle which is nice and convenient. They gave a basket of toasty warm garlic knots and another type of bread for the table. We definitely will come back again without the groupon. read more

See all

Waited a long time for three dinners. Dirty dishes on the surrounding tables. Place was empty too. Finally received two but wrong dish. Ordered spaghetti with white clam sauce they brought red. When ours finally came out corrected it looked like remnants of tomato sauce. Tasted awful. Lasagna was dried out. Will not be back. They did have some customers for pizza. read more

Have not tried any challenging entrees or creations, but if you can't do pizza at an Italian spot....... probably won't? Fusilli with a LOT!!!!!! of competition in the MP, SB, RP, MS PJ area does stand at the top according to me and my band of experts! Plain is very very good and my reference standard. As well the Buffalo chicken is a frequent reorder. Better than the rest (I won't name names but they AND YOU my Italian pizza connoisseurs) know who I am talking about. I will say a little pricey pie for pie but so far worth it. read more

This pizzeria has the most consistent quality italian food in our area. We've tried a lot of items off their menu (along with pizza) and we are always very satisfied. They provide friendly service at competitive prices. During this covid pandemic they remained professional, wearing masks and providing safe delivery service. Today, after being without power for 3 days now, I had asked if they could bring a side of ice with our order, meaning a cup. They went above and beyond by bringing us a take out bag full of ice! The delivery driver was empathetic and kindly stated "we are always here for you!" Come on! How nice is that?! Couldnt ask for more in a neighborhood restaurant. Thanks guys! read more

First of all the pizza is so gross and undercooked forget about that look and the AC vents fans ceilings the grout on the floor absolutely disgusting I wish I saw that before ordering I took my slice home and straight in the garbage how can such a filthy place stay in business will NEVER go back my friend ate theirs and got sick probably from the filth if you think I'm kidding go in and take a look oh I forgot water stains in ceiling (can grow mold) I will be calling the BOH read more

Finally tried this place again and I can say with confidence that they are back! The chicken alla vodka pizza was amazing... along with the stuffed garlic knots and brick oven pizza. I'll definitely be back! read more

Was excited to try a new Italian place. Eh... Not that good at all. Very disappointed. Shrimp and scallop oreganata pizza sounds good on paper. In reality it was a bunch of cheese with a few pieces of chopped shrimp. Vodka sauce was lame. Pasta over cooked. Even the bread had a weird doughy taste... The search continues for good pasta and vodka sauce on the North Shore Rocky Point area. read more

We had my son Daniels communion party here on May 11th.. We just did some Italian favorites .. Eggplant rollatini ,chicken franchese, penne alla vodka.. some appts and some very goof cannolis The food was great and the service was great .. Thanks to the young girl and Joe the owner for all his help and excellent service .. we appreciate it!! Also thanks for the pie to take home so I didn't have to cook that night .. Janine , Tom and Daniel read more

Chicken Franchese (also Flounder) very tasty. Had over spaghetti with the entree sauce. Service was prompt and friendly. Moderately priced. Brought friends here as well. They were well pleased. read more

The food is alright from this place but the only reason I'm giving one star is because how rude they are to the costumers and how incredibly long they take making the food. I understand they aren't McDonald's, but it shouldn't take 25 minutes for 4 garlic knots and one pie. Ridiculous. I just mentioned to them that they should consider speeding up the process and they yelled at me and kicked me out. I would like to consider myself a calm person so I was frazzled when they spoke to me like this. Needless to say I won't go here ever again. read more

In NY and especially Long Island, there is a pizza place and Chinese place every mile at least. So sometimes places are overlooked. I usually wait a few times till I review to check for consistency and I'm glad I did. Fusilli is a nice pizza place/restaurant in Miller Place. The staff each time has been very nice, pays attention to detail, and offers a quality product. Their regular pie (Neapolitan) has a nice flavor unlike many others who under season. The taste is on top and not buried in the sauce. The Marsala pie is a hidden gem. My daughter wanted some grilled chicken and it also didn't disappoint. A nice marinated flavor with a fresh off the grill taste. The chicken parm hero is also very good. Don't just pass this place up. Give them a shot. read more

I made a 7:00 reservation on the open table app. I walked in and walked to the back half of the restaurant since the first half is a pizza place. Once I reached the hostess sign, a rude waiter immediately said "there aren't any tables available." Didn't greet us or anything. So I said "excuse me I have reservation for 7 people" his response "when did you make the reservation" I said "I made it earlier for now." (To me I thought does that matter) And he said "oh well uhh I don't know if you made a reservation we will do something " (with an annoyed attitude as if We inconvenienced him.) I said "never mind you what that's not the way to handle the situation for a larger party, so we will take our business elsewhere." I was so irritated and turned off by the level of service at this place, I will never return. From the onset it was obvious that they didn't want to help us. The staff that helped us was beyond rude and ruined the experience from the start. I understand a restaurant is busy. We would have been fine waiting a few minutes for a table. But the approach of the waiter was less than acceptable. read more

This place falls short on flavor and customer service. My family and I were there on a Wednesday night in the small dining area (the only people in the room for the night) The waiter was an older gentleman and was extremely unfriendly, and slow on service. We ordered "stuffed" garlic knots where I struggled to find the cheese. And the lasagna had minimal meet and cheese in it, just tasted like 5 layers of pasta. Get italian elsewhere in the area. read more

We had Tom as a sever, he was great. He made our experience fun and stress free. The food was perfect. We ordered both a special and a pizza. The special was fresh and delicious. We are not from LI but if we have time to visit again we will make a special stop to see Tom again. Thank you!! read more

Fusilli Restaurant & Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Miller Place, New York

This isn't gnocchi. I'm very disappointed. Don't get delivery & check when you order pickup

Great customer service. My delivery order was incorrect, however, Joe rectified the issue. Delicious food! Thank you. read more

Really appreciate the service this place provided on a short notice for a catering order we placed today. The food and pizza was very good and great customer service I will be back.. and very reasonable in price.. read more