Been coming here for many many years, the food is hardcore Italian and the food outstanding. The service is outstanding and the owners great host. Highly recommended read more

Looking for great pizza without that NYC price? Italia's Pizza is a good place to check out. Friendly and efficient service, reasonably priced. Try their plain cheese slice - it's greasy heaven. Wasn't too crazy about their mushroom slice. And add an order of garlic knots on the side. You'll be set to go. read more

So good the pizza, the sicilian was worth the money and wait. It was a huge pie made just right and cooked perfect. I'm an offical fan of the pizza read more

Italia Pizza - So good, this sicilian was the truth - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best pizzeria by LIGHT YEARS !!! food phenominal , staff super nice , great prices great people ... im not much for punctuation and spelling but i know how to eat ! ( best franchese i ever had EVER!) NV read more

Calamari was so bad looks like it got cooked with dirty oil it's so gross ! I regret ordering it from here read more

Italia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Crummy Adding artificial texture because oven incapable of producing any type of authentic crust. Like eating a pizza that fell on a dirty floor. Gimmick Better off with sesame seeds Or going natural or going natural with coal or wood. Step up your game Or get out of the business of pizza as there are way too many predominant choices that literally surround you. Insulting to NY pizza Let alone Brooklyn read more

Really love it. I came in and asked for suggestions about which one is the best one and their most favorite. I ordered by what they suggested me and the result is so satisfied. The taste, size, smell of the foods everything is perfect for me. A MUST TRY!!!!!!! read more

Awful first experience. Ordered large with an order of wings and a slice of cheesecake. Driver called saying he was here and my buzzer wasn't working. Turns out he was 10 blocks away, but it took him 16 minutes to get here. Then he brought me the wrong pizza. Luckily I caught him before they left. He then brought me the my pizza and wings but not the cheesecake that was part of my order. Then he argued with me about bringing it back. Pizza was no longer hot or warm. Wings were not to order and also cold. The delivery was two teens, utterly confused and who apparently can't follow GPS. Not a good first experience. Will never try them again. He came back 20 minutes later with a frozen slide of cheesecake. Yes, Frozen. Maybe that's why they never sent it in the first place? Horrible, horrible experience. read more

The price could've been better. I am not supporting their business because they raised their price so high. $2.50 to $2.75 or maybe now $3.00 for one slice of plain pizza. read more

this place has arguably the best chicken roll south of kings highway. highly recommend, only reason it doesn't get 5 stars is because the slices are average read more

Probably one of the, if not the best pizzerias in the area. I always come here for their eggplant slice and the chicken parm slice. Their pizza has that nice thin crust and their ingredients are always fresh. I love how the eggplant is sliced thinly and fried crisp. It goes perfectly with their marinara and mozzarella cheese. It's basically an eggplant parm pizza. Their chicken parm slice is just as good. The chicken is always tender and I love the addition of the ricotta cheese. Definitely give these two slices a try if you ever stop by! read more

Love the margarita pie!! Love the cornmeal on the crust. BEST Chicken tenders anywhere!! Made fresh not the frozen BS.

Their pastas are unbelievable and taste good. The staffs are nice and respectful. I would recommend the place to anybody that love italian foods read more

Ordered delivery from here a couple times. I like their food. Haven't tried the pizza, I always get pasta dishes and they're pretty good. My favorite so far is the penne a la vodka. Their wings are also good. The food always arrives quickly and is piping hot. The prices are good. Don't skip out on their pasta dishes! read more

See all

Good pizza! Especially that they offer whole wheat crust. Soups are delicious.

It's like they keep experimenting with the ingredients . One day it's good the next day is not. I don't understand it. I have always ordered for delivery and never had an issue until I actually stopped in the actual pizzeria , first the owner was rude. I know he was the owner because he mentioned it atleast 4 times, he really needs to work on his people skills or let his workers deal with the customers instead. read more

This restaurant was great! We ordered, then a few minutes, our food arrived. The calamari was delicious!

After reading so many good reviews, decided to check out the place. Ordered a grandma pizza but looks like a pizza margherita, even though I was told, they do not have any pizza margherita. The crust tasted rubbery and the overall flavor was unimpressive. For $3, I had better... it was not worth it. At least, the garlic knots did taste good. The eggplant parmesan was not up to par in flavoring. I have no plans to come here again. read more

Italia Pizza - Grandma pizza... For $3, the crust tasted rubbery and was not impressed at all - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Still as good as I remembered this place 10 years ago. I've been having a lot of pizza cravings lately. I like to order my pizza here through Yelp's Eat 24 app. It's quick and simple! I do only live a block from this location so I take a little walk to pick up my pizza and it's always piping hot whenever I pick it up. Great place for good pizza. Highly recommended. read more

Italia Pizza - Plain cheese is the best - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza is made a little different here. They put something in the dough to make it crunchy. I wouldnt say it is a bad thing but it is not your classic ny slice. That being said it is definitely serviceable and i would come if i was in the area looking for a slice. It isnt spumoni or peter pizza but it will do if you have a pizza craving. read more

The pizza was delicious. There are plenty of pizza shops in Bensonhurst, but their pizza is one of the best. However, their deserts are a whole other matter... what you get of them anyway. I ordered a slice of cheesecake ($2.75) and a slice of tiramisu ($3.95). I was disappointed with the size and taste of the cakes. I've ordered desserts from this pizza place before and it seems each time I order the slices get thinner and thinner, until today when they were practically razor thin. From now on I'll stick to only ordering pizza from Italia Pizza. read more

Italia Pizza - Ridiculously thin slice of cheesecake with graham cracker crumbs instead of graham cracker crust. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

The pizza, garlic knots, and rice ball here is delicious! However, I have had a negative experience here. My boyfriend and I ordered a slice of pizza, a rice ball special, and two orders of garlic knots upon entering the store. We seated ourselves and waited for the food. The pizza came out first, followed by the rice ball special 5 minutes later. We figured they probably forgot about our garlic knots, so we asked them again for two orders of garlic knots. At the end of the meal, probably about 15 minutes later, still no garlic knots. My boyfriend went up to pay and the guy realizes that he had left our order of garlic knots sitting on top of the oven for god knows how long. Asks my boyfriend "You still want this?" to which my boyfriend replied "No" There was no apology from him, or even an acknowledgement that it was his fault for forgetting our order. We asked TWICE, waited for a total of about 20 minutes and still did not get our order of garlic knots. This probably won't deter me from coming in the future because the food here is amazing. However, just make sure they give you the correct order and don't leave anything out when you're ordering for delivery or pick up. Also, on one occasion, there was a lady there picking up orders on the phone and screaming them out the entire duration of our meal there. Her loud raspy voice screaming out orders still rings in my ears to this day. It seems like she didn't understand how to talk in a normal toned voice despite the fact that the other workers were right next to her. The tv wasn't on either, so I spent 20 mins listening to other people's orders. 5 stars for the food, 1 for the service, so 3 overall. read more

Very tasty pizza! They have really good chicken rolls which I highly reccomend. They use a semolina flour to coat the bottom of the pizza that elevates this pizza to a "so glad i found this" level for me. It is a family run business with the family working at the location. I always like to patronize family businesses. Try there once and you will be hooked. read more

The pizza located here on west 6th is definitely one of the best if not the best pizza restaurant out here in Brooklyn! My favorite thing to order from there is either a pepperoni or mushroom slice. When your in the restaurant itself, you can't help but smell the fresh pizza in the oven right in front of you. They make it quick! The restaurant is above ordinary and seems fancier than any other pizza place I went to. The employees are nice and friendly. The place isn't that big and can get crowded during times. I also ordered from here a few times and the service is fast since they are by car. A pepperoni pie and a 2 liter Pepsi cost me around 21$ before. Not bad because of the quality you get. Defiantly recommend checking out this fine place :) read more

Italia Pizza - Pepperoni pizza pie - My favorite! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Love it !! Our 1 st time here and pizza is sooooo delicious and amazing customer service!!! Definitely coming back read more

Italia Pizza - Alfredo pizza yammmi - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Best thin crust pizza I've ever had.. Seriously. The chicken parm slice and full veggie slice made my stomach swoon. The pizza here is so top notch and definitely screams Brooklyn. My sister and I ordered the calamari as well and it came out very crispy on the outside and tender on the inside. Italia pizza has been the spot for years and it stays for a reason. Great place. read more

Italia Pizza - Calamari and mozarella sticks. Delish! - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Was working when I decided to stop to get me something to eat. Pizza was great well my regular cheese slice pizza took me to pizza heaven. I haven't had good pizza like this a in while. I went here on a Sunday and now it's Monday and I'm craving pizza again. This time I want a pie. read more

I ordered lentil soup ( which my friend did not like it), Clam chowder soup ( it was okay, a little bit salty), and fried Calamari ( which was undercooked, too soft). I don't recommend this place. read more

SOOOOO GOOD!! If your looking for some delicious italian pizza and food, i would definitely recommend this place. The eggplant slice and italia salad are my fave... so good. But anyways anything i ordered here was definitely top notch for a pizzeria. The staff is friendly as well, making you feel very welcomed. So if you want good and reasonable prices for italian food and pizza this is definitly the place to go! read more

Just moved here and I live so close which is a blessing and a curse, the pizza is a good size for the price and tastes amazing, I go often and have had their focaccia and regular slices. The employees are welcoming and provide great service !!! read more

Italia Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Way back dated review. But I took my first ever date here back in 5th grade Abs the pizza was really good. And I remember it being really hot inside. But it wad good back then. read more

Best crust on pizza! Lots of selections classic to modern toppings and combinations. My favorite are grandma and vodka sauce pizza. They also have chocolate moose cake, cheese cake etc and coffe for sweet cravings although I'm full from pizza, I take cake to go for later. There are tables and big screen HD tv for customers who prefer to stay. I'm very lucky that I live few blocks away which is only a five minute walk. There are few other pizzerias nearby but this one is my favorite read more

I went here one time in the fall, they have some terrible employees. Those white dudes kept saying if I was ok and kept staring at me and asking me questions. I really don't like that Italian young lady because you can't understand what she's saying with that terrible Italian accent. The pizzas' are okay. They are not the greatest because on some of the slices, they give you so little chicken and so little cheese. It is also very expensive for one slice. $2.50 plain slice costs about $.50 to make, they earn a lot of money. I am planning to never come here forever. read more

The only good pizza in Brooklyn I'm talking about only when it's fresh from the oven ( pie ) and not as a reheated Nice place for a pizza read more

Best local pizzeria in Brooklyn (kingshighway). Their eggplant parm & chicken parm slice is the bomb. Their crust is very unique, seems like they added bread crumbs which makes the texture flaky and crispy (Perfection)! The best i have tasted! $3.50 for a giant slice! Definitely stop by when you are around the neighborhood! read more

See all

Cozy, family-friendly classic Italian Restaurant Hand tossed, best crust ever! Fresh sauce Great salad Competitive prices read more

Is this Vics old Pizzeria because they had one of the most scrumptious squares you ever ate. Hopefully these are those squares.

Great pizza, friendly staffs and reasonable prices. Will return soon and start ordering pies from here.

On 02/01/19, I ordered meat and mushroom plate w/salad. Unfortunately, there was something wrong with the salad. On 02/02/19, I woke up with naseau and loose bowel movements. I contacted GrubHub and New York City Health Department to have this place inspected for poor food preparation. This was the first time and last time I order food from this Restaraunt read more

Not just pizza.!! Go sit down for some really great authentic Italian meals. Veal dishes...OMG! Good food.! There pizza is some of the best around. My first time eating there...1987 read more