I love Maggie's. I appreciate the absolute binder of a menu. The drink selection is huge as well. I like when a restaurant has plenty of cocktail options on the menu, and their menu is certainly creative. There are so many dinner choices that it's easy to go and make everyone happy every time. I like that they use local sources for both food and drink (Litchfield bourbon!) and it would be cool if they were able to incorporate CT wineries on the menu. I think they already do have local beers. The molten lava cake is my favorite dessert, my friends and I have gone many tiles to Maggie's after a movie (or even after dinner somewhere else!) for drinks and dessert. One of my favorite dinner places in the area. read more

Decent family fare, better than the big chains. Kids menu is a bit pricey and drinks/dessert are not included. Food was cooked well, good beer list on draught. We wound up spending $80 for 2 adults and one kid. Way too expensive for what you get. read more

Beautiful renovation. Carrie, the manager came over and was so pleasant and a joy to speak with! Wonderful time for a girls night out post COVID read more

Wow what a difference, I posted a great review of two visits to the restaurant. This time it was my wife's Birthday and I wish we went somewhere else. We ordered takeout, We got the Ahi tuna nacho appetizer, the Ahi Tuna meal and the seafood casserole and a side of french fries. When I got home we realized we were missing an item. My wife called back and mentioned it and said she didn't want to pick up the item because she just wanted to have her birthday dinner together, but the manager convinced her that it would be quick. My wife told he that I was 5 minutes away and was told the come right back. I went back the item wasn't ready when I arrived and after 25 minutes I called the Manager to ask about the food. She stormed out from the back went to the hostess desk and got the food and brought it to me saying they expected a woman to pick it up. I was not happy wasting time while my food sat cooling. I called the restaurant and asked for the owner and got the Manager Kerry again only to be told that I shouldn't be angry since it's only food. Clearly she shouldn't work in this environment since she doesn't realize it can be more than just food it can be, an anniversary, a birthday ( Sean M and Carla R. Will agree) a graduation. Lastly it seems that the staff that cooks on the weekends doesn't work during the week. My tuna was over cooked and the brussel sprouts were burned or charred. read more

We recently had a 30th birthday party in the virtual golf simulator. There were about 45 people and the service was amazing. The food was great and we were well taken care of the entire night. It made the party so much more enjoyable and memorable. The manager and two servers were amazing and made sure everyone had enough food and drinks at all times. It was such a great night and we got so many compliments from our guests on what a great party it was! I will recommend Brookfield Maggie's to anyone who is trying to host a party with excellent food and service. read more

This place has a lot going for it. A huge menu, nice atmosphere, plenty of seating, good location, ok bar and nice staff. The only reason I give it 3 is that although I've never had a bad meal here I can't remember ever raving about anything afterwords either. The menu is seriously large, so if you have a large group and no one can come to a compromise on where to go this place should be top of the list. From pizza and pasta to burgers and tacos or American favorites like pot roast. Prices seem very fair and most portions are on the large size. read more

Maggie's is usually on the list of places to stop for a drink and appetizer with a friend. Last time I went they said they didn't carry the brand of vodka anymore that I usually get there and their margaritas tasted like they were made from a bottled mix. We got a few appetizers. The beef skewers were cold and the dipping sauce was tasteless. The french onion soup was gross. Way too salty and I'm sorry but where were the onions?! The only good part about that evening was the Thai lettuce wraps. I probably won't be returning to Maggie's anytime soon. read more

Drunken chicken strips are always awesome but the tacos, not so much. The cabbage is a great crunch but their meat seasonings were overpowered by spice and hot peppers when the menu said sweet. They remade them for me but honestly not impressed. read more

Maggie McFly's - Tacos - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

I met an employee named Cara F last week. I told her my previous concerns about the restaurant and she convinced me to try Maggie's again. I owe a thank you to her because it was so delicious and oh, how things have changed. The food was so fresh and the menu had some great new options especially with their gluten free options. I had the BBQ chicken salad. It was fresh lettuce piled high with chicken and all the sides, including avocados and fried onion strings! I have to admit the bbq aside was the best part; It was the perfect mix of sweet and tangy. Their drink menu was far better than I remember. I went during the early afternoon so I missed the happy hour, but reading over the menu, it had some awesome specials with apps and their awesome drinks. Thanks to Cara for changing my mind, I had no idea what I was missing out on! read more

We've been going to Maggie for years but recently it seems like service is slipping. We had a reservation for a group with my handicapped mother in law and we had to wait 20 minutes. Then it took awhile to give our orders and get our drinks. Waiting for food took longer than it should. It just seems like Maggie's doing well so maybe it's time for an upgrade or new management before people stop coming back. Ps the soda drinks are flat Pss my meat was way undercooked. I asked for very WELL DONE and clearly that is not what I received. I switched from two to three stars because the manager removed my burger from the bill. read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

Maggie's exists in a void of restaurants. Suffice it to say no one is coming to Brookfield for the regional culinary offerings. Maggie's does a very consistent and almost always perfectly cooked burger. The bar menu offers a wide selection of smaller plates ranging from $4-6, and they are all surprisingly good. The motivation for the current review and the rationale behind the 3 stars is the drink prices. $12 for an average sized margarita is simply not in line with what the market demands, especially considering this is not a tequila bar offering a variety of choices. Likewise, $9 for a 12oz pour of a common IPA is steep as well. Management may want to consider undertaking some market analysis to better determine an appropriate price for drinks in a relatively rural area. read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

This place has some delicious food. I ordered fish and chips which came with cole slaw. The food was great! The atmosphere was great! The price was decent as well. Roughly 50 dollars for two meals including a drink. I would without a doubt visit this place again. read more

Omg! So first of all this was our first time here and it did not disappoint! All seating here are booths. Loved the red booths. Servers were very friendly and quick. Food was AMAZING! I got the spinach and artichoke dip which is huge cake with veggies to dip garlic bread and home made potato chips-YUMM! My husband got a California roll which I've never seen done this way. Check out my pic. He loved it! We ordered burgers for me and my son- cooked to order perfectly and tasted phenomenally. My husband got a chicken and pasta dish with a sauce that was to die for. Smore dessert made by us at the table was the best way to end an awesome lunch. Top notch all around Ave we will def be back. Ran into our in laws neighbors on the way out. We live 30 minutes away but completely worth the trip! read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

See all

Since there has to be at least one star.........if I could rate 1/2 a star, I would. Granted, I was at least hopefully for something edible....okay there's the a smig of a star earned, the hamburger was edible...only hardly, especially after what I experienced. The other majority of the star is for the delicious Napa Valley Markham SB---which was made from Californian grapes---the sun, the soil, the farmer, and the varietal does that, not Maggie McFly. I work in a restaurant, 5 nights a week, 4 weeks a month, 52 weeks a year! Not like that means anything to anyone but me---yet it does mean I have a keen sense of what good service in a good restaurant IS and what it IS NOT. As far as first impressions go, I walk into the restroom, there is a female employee in there getting ready for her night after her shift. That's cool except she had her stuff, dirty work shoes (with money stuffed into one), her work clothes, and all her shit on the baby changing table, strewn, in plain sight of guests using the same facilities.......she launched her excuse because she must have seen my expression, "I'm getting ready, I just got off." Ya think? I said, as I motioned at all the stuff, "Yes, I see, and this is inappropriate." She frumped as I walked out. (Um, ever heard of an employee restroom or workroom?) Met my company at our table and sat there a full 10 minutes without any acknowledgement. I saw employees of this restaurant applying lipgloss, laughing, hanging out with each other------most importantly, ignoring their guests, well, thirsty-hungry me. I got up and asked one of the young ladies if she were "our server." She said, "yes." I asked her for some of her attention. (worse question ever---"who's my server?") I know, I know---not a great way to embark on a customer-server experience and still, I was miffed. (What I know is that if I were too busy to attend to them, I'd at least go over to the table and let them know that I would be over to them and give them my undivided attention just as soon as possible. Seems like the polite thing to do.) I wonder, spit in my food, that extra loving? Good thing I take my vitamins for instances just as these. I digress. We also had the seared ahi tuna tartare....I was looking for something less fat ladened and what I got looked like dyed kinda-something-like-quasi tuna-esque stuff...a heavy cinnamon taste I attribute to the "crust." It was gross. As if a glutton for punishment, we ordered the Granny Apple dessert...my company asked if it could be heated, "it is," replied the server (a girl that was also behind the bar with short black hair). And yet, somehow this dessert which was nothing more than some doughy apple clump of YUK that came out cold and yes, gross. I know this all sounds harsh, and I guess it is, but not because I am such a hard person to please...it's more like I work hard at what I do, and to be not attended to, seem like an inconvenience rather than a 20% tipper and not a guest of Maggie McFly's---------"F" this place and you people with jobs in the restaurant industry remember, it is a craft as well as a good way to make money (cuz in Maggie McFly's you sure are spending money, it's not cheap here) and you work for someone who this is their livelihood, respect that. In times like these....it's good to have a job, value that. The nice thing is....even though I was discerning and somewhat b*tchy, the server remained somewhat pleasant, sort of. It IS about the tip now! read more

I've been here on numerous occasions. I enjoy the patio as inside is as noisy as the meeting house in bethel. The beer is always good. I had the nachos and to my amazement they had layered it with Velveeta. Are you kidding me?? I know getting the cheese to melt down deep into the chips is an art, but to be lazy and use Velveeta and think it's OK...cmon now....I won't be having the nachos again. It was a smaller plate too. Oh well the beer was good. I might have been wrong about the Velveeta ..it could have been Cheese Whiz. read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

Maggie McFly's Middlebury location was always my favorite place. Went to Brookfield last night.. absolutely TERRIBLE! My fiancé never complains, & will never go back there. Service was absolutely horrible. Server was extremely lazy (couldn't even find her for a long time & didn't check on us).. & she had a huge attitude. Fish n Chips were horrible.. so when someone finally came over (which ended up being a manager), we sent it back. We ordered a salad because manager said it would be really quick.. well, it took FOREVER. I was finished eating well before the salad came out, so we were just sitting there waiting & waiting. We were just getting up to walk out, when it came.. so we had to take it to go at that point. Then, we were still charged for the meal after this horrible experience. read more

Very good food for price and large array of Gluten Free Choices. All fries naturally GF Service can be suboptimal and you must confirm your food comes out GF. read more

Tonight I had the pleasure of dining with my family for an amazing outdoor dinner. Our waitress Lauren was incredibly attentive and helpful with the menu choices. She was kind and it was a pleasure to have her as our server . The food was delicious and the atmosphere delightful. Thank you Lauren and Maggie McFly's for a great first night out post-Covid quarantine!! read more

This place is great, awesome service and they have really good food. Not a place where if you want food their goanna throw something on a plate and call it a day, I got the Ruben and it is awesome. If you're in the area definitely try it. read more

The place looked like a tornado went through it! The floors were all full of napkins and other debris. Just very unappealing. Also the manager's shirt was filthy and the waitress said that she was looking for the bar tender after I ordered some wine. Very unprofessional. Not returning to this establishment ever! read more

Don't offer a late night menu if you not going to uphold it. I come here every week late because my jobs keep me from eating during the day. Every week I come and every week it's a oh sorry whoops. I also have to send people to late night menus thus Maggie mcflys. I now have to reconsider. Thanks for wasting my time and hopes. read more

Love this place. It's our go to because we know anything we order from here will be good. My boyfriend always gets the chicken Milanese it's so good. Service is also good and a good variety of drinks. read more

This place is ok if you have the palate of a 5 year-old. If you're lucky enough to get what you order, you'll find the food is mediocre at best. I have unfortunately been here a few times as the menu is extensive and seems to be a crowd pleaser when everyone wants something different, but this should be a red flag. You can't do everything well. You're better off at a local diner. I had the ahi tuna salad which I had ordered before and it was ok, this time it was terrible and totally different. It had a weird cinnamon flavor, the dressing was absent or flavorless...The service is slow and many times the order was wrong. Never again. read more

Employees get rowdy and drink a lot after their shift at the bar. You can hear them from the bathrooms. Shot after shot after shot screaming "shots! shots! shots!". I recommend going to this place before all the employees get off and start drinking. It happens pretty much every weekend I go. It would be a nice place otherwise. Food is good. read more

Pizza was okay, wasn't fond over the dough/crust. Service was slow which is unacceptable we came for lunch & it wasn't packed at all. Server also complained about their tip which was also unacceptable to say the least read more

Worst food ever. Never go here has not gotten any better. Food is all frozen not fresh

My sister and I have ate here the past two weeks, food was great and consistent every time, the service on the other hand was atrocious on both occasions. We stood near the hostess stand for about three minutes before anyone greeted us or said hello but could see the waitstaff meandering around. Both times eating here were during lunch around 2:30 and the restaurant was not packed whatsoever . Our second dining experience I had complained to a manager who simply apologized and said have a nice day. Will probably not return to this establishment again, awful service and poor management . What a shame since they do have great food, maybe the night shift workers are a little more competent. read more

The staff at Brookfield is clueless, it took 25 minutes to get a drink and almost an hour to get a few late night bites. The order was also screwed up. The bartender was clueless and couldn't handle the few patrons at the bar. It's been a while since I've been here and I must say it's gone down hill. My buddy that was with me is a chef and agreed management is absent and food was under par. I would pick 189 over Maggie's any day. Food is better and restaurant is run far better with a very competent staff. Just don't park in Maggie's lot they will tow your car lmao. read more

What a food! I always have a good time at Maggie McFly. Our waitress was like a comedienne. She had us cracking up all night. The food and Drinks were just right and it's always a fun time. Thanks Maggie. By the way, never forget to have a dessert. They're unbelievable! read more

Service is slow and food is not very good. Maybe ok for a burger. It took 40 minutes to get a drink. I had the jambalaya which was a breaded chicken cutlet with a few pieces of Italian sausage with fennel and one shrimp. I would have sent it back but it would have taken forever to get a burger. The staff is nice but food and service is terrible. I would give zero stars for food if could. read more

Food is excellent but there are to many things on the menu, portions are huge and so expect left overs unless you are really hungry

large menu. Ive been here a few times at different times of the day. During the day/evening it is loud, but not as overbearing as it is late night. The menu reminds me of the cheesecake factory, but the food quality just isn't CF. The drinks are good and well made read more

Not very good not very clean outdoors area repulsive the food was good but the flies were all over the place

Gluten Free Food, Gluten Free Beer, Gluten Free Pizzzzzzzzza! Love his place. I order pizza out sometimes and will get an extra box which I just pop into the freezer and heat up at a later time in the oven when I want some gluten free cheesy goodness. If they sold gluten free pizza dough that would get them the last fifth star! I wish the pizzas were a little bit larger maybe an inch all around because gluten free dough tends to shrink. oh and their drinks are amazing. read more

The food here was good. But the menu is like a book. There is just so much to choose from it's daunting. I was leery about the range of stuff they have from American to Asian. But all in all it really wasn't bad. read more

Maggie's is always my go to place whenever I can't decide what I feel like eating. The menu is massive and there are all kinds of dishes to eat. Want Asian, you got it! Want Italian, you got it! I can get spring rolls while my fiancé gets calamari. The drinks and dessert are also really yummy. With all that being said I've never had a meal there and thought wow this is the best meal I've ever had but the food is always solid and the prices are reasonable. I also like the happy hour snacks where I get to try a little bit of everything. Overall a wonderful atmosphere! read more

Disappointing experience. With my 14 yr old for a date. Told had to sit outside cause they were full. A bit chilly. Ordered one appetizer and dinner. Ordered appetizer at 630. Came out at 7. Asked to go in as we were freezing. We're seated inside and dinner came at 722 (hamburger and club sandwich). Fries were only warm. Didn't get condiments with burger. Asked three different servers. Went to kitchen myself. Finally got condiments but burger no longer hot. Totally disorganized service multiple servers come to table and really loud. While no one would check on us during our dining experience they were quick and attentive on bringing the bill and asking for the credit card. I will continue to go to the one in Southbury but won't come back here nor would I recommend it. I gave 2 stars as the food was okay just cold. read more

Maggie McFly's - Empty water glass been waiting over 10 mins for water-after specifically asking for it. - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

Food is descent but service is always bad it's not that the people don't try they do they are just not super knowledgeable and lack common sense server skills which I think falls on management. It's a good spot if you don't know what you're in the mood for because they have everything possible on the menu read more

Went to Maggie's in Brookfield twice last week. Chose the executive lunch ; had soup, salad and iced tea. Just enough and at a good price. Onion soup and Caesar salad the first time and clam chowder and Caesar salad the second time. Good service. Looking forward to going back. Have also had a large salad with chicken, shrimp and steak which was great and I had leftovers to take home! read more

Love this place. Have been there a million times and almost never had a bad meal. I've had lots of delicious meals here and the menu is very large. They have great martinis - try the ginger pumpkin martin around Halloween. Atmosphere is really good too. It's a big place and has a nice bar with a couple of TVs. Can't go wrong here. read more