We stopped in for a few drinks on a Friday night and had an okay experience! Despite not being very full, the wait was longer than I'd like for a cocktail and a few beers. I got a martini that was sweeter than I would have wanted but tasty nonetheless! Beers were.. beers! A big group yelling and just generally being super loud in the bar area was distracting but not too bad. Seemed like they knew some of the people who worked there. We'd like to come back and try food sometime - the drink experience was just fine. Hopefully this place has more to offer! read more

Great spot with a huge menu. They have everything you can think of on it. Haven't had a bad meal here yet and been here several times. The drink and beer menu is also a very big selection. From fancy cocktails to local and craft brews. Enjoy same apps and a few drinks and watch the games on the many tvs. Service has always been good even tho you can tell they're a little short staffed due to covid read more

Maggie McFly's - Maggies Nacho Platter Fried Calamari - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

See all

Food is good. Service could improve. I think the young bartenders could benefit significantly from bartending training. The bartender doing the training needs training. Pouring a beer the correct way is a good start, we watched all 3 bartenders pour beer the wrong way resulting in beer get dumped out. We also were slowly surrounded by dirty glasses seen in the photo attached. 5-6 employees were contributing the dirty glasses and the bartenders were just conversing as you can also see in the photo. Training needs to be improved big time. Your bar is losing money. read more

Maggie McFly's - Dirty bar - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

Had the opportunity to visit Maggie McFly's in Brookfield today for the first time - and will not be returning. I have always wanted to visit this restaurant and was glad to have the opportunity to try it today - but the food was disappointing. I tried the Pilgrim sandwich which turned out to be 2 slices of turkey on toast (menu says it is brioche), with a thin spread of cranberry sauce on the bread, and some sort of "stuffing" that was maybe apples & cranberry halves - overall disappointing and not worth the $15+ price. Partner had bacon cheeseburger that was "OK". We each had a side of fries - they were plain (no taste), and just warm (not hot). I wanted to like this restaurant but unfortunately there is nothing compelling us to go back. read more

I wasnt really taken with this place.. things were up and down from the start. Someone in my group called DAYS in advance to make a reservation, the hostess accepted, get there and they magically dont take reservations..? Ok. Now to wait for our table. We are put in a back room with a server who was clearly overwhelmed with no help. Had to ask several times for water AND water glasses. The menu is wayyyyy too big and doing the most. Idk. I think they need to fix some things. read more

New look super pretty, love that they will come at the table to ask if everything was OK, the place has a nice vibe , when in the first day 2 hrs after reopened, and I had a great experience.The drinks can use some kind of garnish, they were plain looking tho. I have been there in the past and was always great , bit this time w reno, has a more welcoming and brighter look , kinda fun to hang at the bar area, the outside patio looks fenomenal, good for them, well done to the owner Ray H. read more

See all

Maggie's has always a hassle-free restaurant for a quick lunch where you wanted to have something to eat without surprises. Recently, they've renovated and expanded, seemingly in an effort to "step up" their game. So far, it's working. No worries if you want a different kind of bun, want no ice, or anything within reason. Most menu items have been good (the chili is a nice starter if you're going to have a salad) and the ingredients (though having some back-story about your cheese) are high quality without diverting from what one would expect from the description. I was apprehensive about the open patio to the bar, as I'm not an outdoors person and prefer air conditioning, but I was happily surprised to learn they have 'zones' that can accommodate that. The one thing that would SIGNIFICANTLY increase going there is that their "separated friers" are not separated based on fish, but for gluten. That means no french fries or fried food for an immediate family member with a very serious allergy to all kinds of fish. read more

One star for poor service. Food was good, ambiance great. We moved from outdoors to the bar inside. I know jerk move. It was a nice day that turned cold fast. The bar was not full, there was plenty of room for our three persons. We settled up with our server to avoid any confusion. Our server Malik was great and continued to take care of us after we moved indoors, AS NOONE ELSE WOULD. The two bartenders Whitney and Daniel did not engage with us at anytime. Not one, "how ya doin". Our food came, and we had to get our own utensils off the table behind us, after waiting 5 minutes and getting ignored from bartenders. They proceeded to blatantly ignore us and talk about us while we just ate our food. We settled up with our main guy Malik. We unfortunately were not able to get anything else to eat or drink as we were never asked. read more

Ordered takeout for the first tine. Online ordering was a bit confusing with multiple options including "XT S.O.S." whatever that might be. Order page and email confirmation said it would be an hour before food would be ready, but showed up 25 minutes early to check the place out and it was already bagged ready to go and also already cold. Had the potato's skins - which were three half potatoes with melted cheese and green onion. Not really skins, and also there was no bacon. The BLT wedge was basic, with lettuce and tomato, but again NO BACON! Finally, had the Brie and Fig burger, paid extra for bacon, and you guessed it, NO BACON! It was only a dollar for the extra bacon - but if you're out of bacon or rebranded as a kosher restaurant - let me know. read more

Haven't been here in a year...needless to say I'm not in a rush to go back! Sat down for lunch with my parents and there were two nasty plates on the table! TWO! It would be impossible for nobody to notice this! I'd hate to see the state of their kitchen if this is how tables were/are reset! I am done with every Maggie's establishment, and I recommend you be as well! read more

Maggie McFly's - Dirty plates! - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

See all

Love the atmosphere but the food could be better. My table ordered the coconut salmon which was dry. I had the ribs, the first time it was ok, the second visit I didn't care for them. They tasted like they were parboiled then placed on a grill to crisp them up on the outside with the sauce. I won't order them again. The waiter said they weren't a big seller, I just love bbq ribs but not here. The sides that came with the ribs were mac & cheese, that was dry, served at room temperature and so were the sweet potato fries. The second visit I substituted the mac and cheese with truffle fries and they were room temperature as well. The drinks are nice as well as the staff. The men's room had a broken urinal that was taped off and the two toilets had urine on the floor because no one was making hourly checks to clean the place. It's a nice concept but poorly managed. read more

Hubby and I had lunch here on Saturday. The service is decent - our waitress was very nice and friendly. The food eh, it was just okay - sub par for me. I had the French Onion Soup and French Dip (lunch deal - soup and whole sandwich). Liked my soup but it was a bit salty, my sandwich was quite bland and the meat was cut too thick for my liking. Maybe I made a bad selection :-/ Hubby had the same lunch deal with Chicken Tortellini Soup and the Pilgrim Sandwich. He liked his soup a lot and said his sandwich was tasty. We shared a side of fries that cost us 4.95.... I'm fine with paying this price for a decent portion ... NOT here! Look at my picture of them.... SKIMPY!!! What a rip off! I'm in no rush to come back here, that's for sure. read more

See all

Pros: Good food, good service and a nice atmosphere - kid friendly. Cons: The menu can be a bit overwhelming.

went in for some apps and drinks and had a great time! quick and friendly service and drinks made beautifully by the bartender Caitlin. Will definitely be visiting again soon! read more

Absolutely amazing service and food today!!! Cici, the bartender and our server for the bar area which we were sitting - A++++. She is bright, personable, attentive, and on top of her martini game!!! I'm a bit picky about my martinis, and she nailed it! Even made suggestions based on what my likes were, took her up on them, and it was amazing! My friend and I also did a sampling of appetizers from the happy hour menu and everything was delicious! I'm so happy we made the decision to come in. Bartenders/Servers like Cici will keep us coming back! read more

The service has gone way down hill here. Service sucks! Seated with sticky gross menus and we waited for a server to at least ask us if we wanted drinks. We waited 15 minutes and walked out. On our way out we stopped at the front kiosk and told someone about the bad service and told them we would never be coming back. They just shrugged their shoulders like they could care less. Take my advise avoid this place at all costs!!! read more

Mother's Day and was told a total of 4 times 11/2 seating was applied to table. Service was awful. The server bought out 1/2 meals and took another 20 min to bring out the rest. My recommendation is if you are a mother and are going here to experience a special day don't go here. read more

Excellent food and food choice, staff were very friendly and helpful. My salad was huge it could feed a family and very delicious. We went as a big soccer team. read more

I've been here a few times and the food has always been exquisite. But, haven't in a while bc of the pandemic (Although, we did get curbside takeout on Mother's Day). Well, my mother in law's bday happened to fall today on Memorial Day so we ventured out to eat for the first time since the pandemic started. Outdoor dining was great with being given disposable menus and the choice of plastic or real silverware. The tables were far apart and the whole experience was great. The food was excellent and could not be happier with our amazing server Olivia. 10/10 experience. read more

See all

Really big portions and nice atmosphere!! super big menu as well, plenty of options for everyone

The golf simulator is cool, beside that the food is average and service is VERY slow ESPECIALLY if you're doing the golf simulator. They had one very cool drink called babies dream house that was amazing. Waiter was very apologetic about the slow service. Wouldn't come here if it weren't for the golf thing read more

Maggie McFly's - Golf simulator - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

Large group? Picky eaters? NO problem here. The menu is gigantic. There is something for everyone, every appetite, and even for those with many allergies. I was once with a friend who basically created their own dish due to allergies. The menu has everything from sandwiches to fried Mac and Cheese balls to orange chicken and beyond. The best dessert (there are many options) is hands down the red velvet cake! They take reservations and their beer/wine/cocktail/martini menu is just as long and wonderful. Celebrating? Have an electric martini for some added fun. As of the last time I was there, this venue is not dog friendly. read more

See all

Everytime I come here I am not disappointed . Jack is an excellent server and makes dining experience even better!

In response to the management reply I got. We would've loved to inform the server or manager if either one ever came by, which they didn't.

Ok our first time here and I'm kinda undecided on how much I like this place. It feels 'empty' for some reason, theres no ambiance at all... the menu, is extremely extremely long/big. If you cannot find something here to eat, its 100% you. For those Bar Rescue watchers who have heard JT say a menu is to big... this is it!!! Thorough YES but where do they keep all the stuff????? Anyway our meals were very good, would definitely come back for the food/menu/options just not sold on the lack of decor. read more

Thank you Noah like an arc for a wonderful experience at Maggie. You are a wonderful server with a very enjoyable energy. Food was great

The beautiful and modern exterior lured us in and the interior was just as nice! They have many options on the menu, including for vegans, though they did not have vegan cheese when we went so they were unable to make the pizzas (what my boyfriend wanted to try because he doesn't eat meat or dairy). Boyfriend ended up settling for the sesame crusted tuna, which was really nice except for the sides, which were over-charred but soggy Brussels sprouts and chunky white rice which you could tell was poorly reheated as it had a terribly grainy texture. He just ate the tuna. My shepherd's pie was decent but meat could have been a bit more well seasoned. I took home the leftovers so not bad at all. The kids ordered Hawaiian (regular) pizza and ravioli with a giant meatball and they both liked their dishes. Truffle fries and buffalo cauliflower appetizers were pretty good. Drink refills were free. Service was decent as well. I took an entire star off for the tuna dish sides being inedible. We will return and try other foods and will update review, if warranted. read more

I've been coming to Maggie's for quite some time now but have never been blown away by the service until recently. I visited Maggie's on two separate occasions during the weekend. I was served by a gentleman named Jake who was very competent, kind and helpful. His customer service was wonderful as he knew exactly how to make my family and feel welcome and taken care of. The second time I visited I was helped by a young man named Jonny who was very knowledgeable about the establishment and made sure to answer all my questions fully. He was patient, determined and a great overall employee. Thank you Maggie McFly's for hiring employees who care. read more

The Pilgrim sandwich was good, but not what I was expecting. The stuffing that came on it was more of a cranberry topping, than a stuffing. The tossed salad was a bit boring, but at least it had croutons. read more

Maggie McFly's - Pilgrim sandwich and side of tossed salad - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

I hate to do this to a restaurant but it needs to be done. Horrible service and mismanaged. One of the worst experiences I have ever had. They were obviously short staffed and didn't realize it and it is very mismanaged. We asked to be seated inside and the hostess sat us at a bar high top table right next to a huge opened sliding door, frustrating because we got very cold. The manager took our drink order and then the bartender took our food order about 15 minutes later. Then we saw no one for 20 minutes. I pushed our empty glasses further and further toward the end of the table during this time. We finally asked a bus boy to please send over whatever server was responsible for our table. We watched him approach another employee and they both shrugged and walked away. 5 minutes later we asked the hostess for the manager. The manager never apologized but asked us if we wanted to move into the dining room so we were not cold. when she moved us, no one told the server or bartender. The person who brought our food out couldn't find us and we had to flag him down after we overheard him offer our food to another table. We asked him for forks and it took about 4 minutes for him to come back with any. Then we waited and waited. I finally had to walk up to the bar to ask for boxes and the check which took another 5 minutes because the 2 bartenders on staff were clearly overwhelmed. It wasn't his fault, no one told Him we moved and clearly someone else needs to be responsible for waiting bar tables. Then we went back up to the bar again to pay the check as well. This clearly wasn't just us. We watched another table go up to the bar and ask them to send a server out to them and a third table actually left their table at the patio and went up to the bar for another round of drinks because they couldn't find their waiter. Nice people, other than the manager who doesn't do her job well, but horribly mismanaged read more

Came for a work party, Camille was absolutely amazing. give that girl a raise! Will be back. Thank you

This restaurant has such great potential but disappoints on several levels. The menu had always been extensive and great local options. The drink menu is very creative. The problem is the staff. They are inattentive at best. We were there two days ago and waited for a server for 15 minutes only to be told when she arrived how busy they were, like that's my fault. We heard no less 5 times how busy they were. My drink order was incorrect even though I was very specific when ordering. The explanation was "we are so busy". Food was good but service needs repair. I think they could use some more mature management to make this place great read more

Great service and food!! We sat outside by the fire on the first sunny day in a while. Our server Noah was great!!

Belle waited on us and we had the best business dinner ever! We are in the hospitality industry and the food was amazing, the entire team took care of us but Belle was simply amazing! Please let her know how much we appreciated her care. And for the record I never write reviews- great experience and great time had by us all! read more

Maggie McFly's - New American Near Me - Brookfield, Connecticut

Jack was an incredible. He changed our seats swiftly when additional people joined our table. His recommendations were on point and he was beyond courteous. We would return just on jack alone, although the food is great too. read more

Absolutely fantastic place! I've been going there over 100 times now and it is spectacular. The menu is enormous and the atmosphere is perfect. Colin always goes above and beyond with speedy and excellent service while also making sure everything comes out alright. Everyone there would not be surprised when I say I recommend the burgers, the bacon and egg burger is my personal favorite. read more

Let me start off by saying Maggie McFly's is an amazing place! To begin with, the service is fantastic. As soon as we walked in, we were kindly greeted and quickly seated. We were surprised by how big the menu was and the amount of options we had to pick from! Our order was taken soon after we were seated, so we didn't wait long to be served. There was a mistake where one of the main entrees was incorrect, but the manager and waiter worked extremely well with us. They were extremely apologetic and were very polite, and offered alternatives/solutions which all in all resulted in happy customers. The service was exceptional, something we have never experienced anywhere else. Everyone was kind and understanding, and they went out of their way to make sure the rest of our evening was nothing but pleasant. The food and drinks were great! The menu is pretty impressive, and there's a ton to pick from. There is definitely something for everyone in the party. Overall, I would highly recommend this spot! This spot is a go to for a night out with friends, family, or even date nights. We will most definitely be going back! read more

So we decided to go back for the grand opening after having a bad experience years ago with the staff. I have to say my family and I can't wait to go back. They did a great job with the remodel. Inside and out look great. The outside seating area is awesome. Nice fire pit in the middle for the cooler nights. The staff was amazing this time around. Very helpful and tentative to our dinking needs. We love the menu as you can have everything from Mexican tacos to fresh fish or steaks. We kept watching the different foods passing our table thinking we need to try that next. The bar area it huge. 30+ chairs at the bar. Can't wait to go back read more

Was passing by and decided to see what the new renovation looked like. The owners did a great job giving the place a chill and relaxed makeover, and the crowded outdoor patio and fire pit was buzzing. Incredible amount of choices on the updated menu (love that local items sourced are named and labeled), and everything looked amazing coming out of the kitchen. Decided to have dinner at the bar and watch the three games being shown on the big screens. Colin behind the bar could not have been more accommodating, professional and with an added great sense of humor as well! Food and service was spot on!! Good luck and Congratulations on doing such an outstanding job in remaking MM's into my new "go-to" spot! read more

I just went there tonight with my husband. I've not been to a Maggie McFly's in years, now I remember why. The food was mediocre at best. I had the lamb gyro with fries; The lamb was so dry I thought I was eating the skin of the lamb. The lamb was so tough and chewy, and the gyro is more lettuce than anything else. I think they had that meat seating there all day it was like jerky meat. The fries were stale and the iced tea was watered down. My husband ordered the bang bang with shrimp and chicken and that was like a bucket of salt and grease. I could have gone across the street and order McDonald's and I'd have been less disappointed!!! The 2 stars is for the service. Our waitress was nice but the food....THAT WAS AWFUL!!! read more