the ambiance of this restaurant is so nice - it's dark, moody, and the perfect cozy dinner spot. in the winter, you can start off with wine while you wait for a table. they don't take reservations though so be prepared to wait. these pastas were INCREDIBLE, though. probably my favorite i've tried so far in the city. highly recommend the spinach gnocchi and the ravioli, could definitely have gone without the penne arrabiata though. read more

Malatesta Trattoria - pastas - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We walked in on a Friday around 6, and there was plenty of seating, but they let us know they needed the table by 7:30, which we understood. It's got a homey vibe that makes it a great place for groups! While the servers were nice, it felt like we were being rushed through our meal, with them starting to remove plates that we were still eating from, which wasn't really necessary because we finished and paid by 7:15. As for the food, we started with the bruschetta, which I think was the best part of the meal. It's incredibly garlicky, the tomatoes were bright, and the bread was crispy. For my entrée, I ordered the penne arrabiata, which was a filling portion and spicier than I expected. We ended on the tiramisu, which was subpar. It wasn't particularly flavorful, barely sweet even, and too wet. read more

See all

We were sat immediately and ordered two fresh pasta dishes that made us both very happy. The service could use a little attitude adjustment, but at the end when I tipped in full I got a "btw, we also serve brunch and you should come back." Lol. I definitely will! The food is worth it, and the prices are great, the location is lovely, and the quality of the food is fresh, clean, and perfectly made to order. The creme brulee was nice and citrusy and not too sweet, which I loved. The host was also really kind and super helpful and sweet. This is how you attract repeat customers!!!!!! read more

Made dinner reservations and we got an amazing family style table in this really amazing, rustic looking, happy vibes place! Noise levels were on the higher end and you had to speak loudly to hear the other person across the table! José our server was friendly, attentive, and quick with his service. This is a very kid friendly place - so highly recommended for families with kids. At the same time, a great place for date night too. An extremely well priced menu, with great options is how I'd describe their menu. Our order consisted of Crostini Misti ($10.50), Calamari ($18), Funghi di Prato ($12.50) - an excellent mushroom salad, for appetizers. Mains included a very tasty (and slightly cheesy) Spinach Gnocchi ($18.50), Penne Arrabiata ($16), and Tagliatelle al Ragu ($18). Kids thoroughly enjoyed their butter pasta which they polished within a few mins! Overall, we had a great time at this place, and I can clearly see Malatesta become our go-to Italian dinner place on weekdays or weekends. Great service, excellent quality food, and a very well priced menu! Can't ask for more. read more

See all

Wow! Glad I found this place. Easy to walk in, delicious food, and reasonable prices. Chicken cutlet was crisp, tomato pasta tasted super fresh... need to try the gnocchi as well! read more

See all

Very, very loud!! Acoustics inside are horribly bad. Eat outside if you'd like to have a conversation with someone during your meal. I highly recommend the meatballs. Service is excellent!! read more

It was raining so unfortunately outdoor seating was closed. The indoor area was a little stuffy and crowded but the vibe reminded me of Italy. We got the grilled calamari for appetizer and the spinach gnocchi and tagliatelle ragu for entrees. We felt like all three dishes lacked a little salt and extra flavor but I really liked the pillowy texture of the homemade gnocchi and the chewiness of the homemade tagliatelle. read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Spinach gnocchi (top) tagliatelle ragu (bottom) - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

A cozy Italian spot with indoor and outdoor seating. Food was solid and came out quick. Service was quite absent in the beginning despite there being only 2-3 tables but picked up later on with staffs consistently checking in on us. Overall a decent meal. Note that there is only wine and beer for alcohol option, no cocktail. read more

See all

Holy gnocchi this was delicious. We went as a big group and ordered a bunch of wine, a few appetizers to share, and all nibbled on a few entrees and everything and everybody was absolutely incredible. It's a small place, very homey and comforting. read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

One of the best places to get Italian food at the best price. For this quality, you usually have to pay way more. Fun with a date or a friend read more

Ate every. single. ravioli on my plate. Panzanella salad with watermelon, mint, feta and croutons was a perfect starter, and the special that day. $10 glasses of house wine, great fresh pasta, what's not to love? It's a very small restaurant, so expect to possibly get grazed when you eat here. Servers are cute and very attentive, possibly because the restaurant is so small. Went on a nice day with a friend and sat near the window. Would sit outside next time, a plus is that the Hudson River is super close and you can take a nice leisure walk after. read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Ravioli Formaggio - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Our experience at Malatesta was amazing! Roberto, our server, gave great suggestions and was very friendly. We enjoyed the calming ambience of this quaint Italian restaurant and appreciated how quick the food service was. The pasta was great and we loved the unique specials too! read more

Malatesta Trattoria - The top was the Fettuccine special with calamari and red sauce and the bottom is their Ravioli Formaggio with pink sauce. - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

This was by far the best Italian food I have ever eaten. When I finished, I wanted seconds. The ambiance was so incredible! The servers were sweet. If you have not been you are missing out. Located in a cute part of town. Definitely somewhere I will revisit and highly recommend! read more

See all

Very charming Italian spot in the west village; have been coming here for years and always had a pleasant experience. Showed up at around 6:30 on a Friday night and walked right in with a party of two. Service is efficient and friendly. Pasta, wine, and fish were delicious. read more

One of my favorite spots going all the way back to my college days, this corner spot in west village serves classic NYC Italian dishes. And it's super affordable! - Ravioli al formaggio - Penne arrabiata While not the largest portions, both the ravioli and penne are well seasoned and the pasta itself is cooked nicely. It's a little tight but I absolutely love the old school vibes here too. And don't sleep on their list of wines! Seating is definitely a little tight but that's expected for an older restaurant. It gets busy for weekend dinners so expect to wait but otherwise lunches are usually fine. Follow my Instagram and TikTok @thephotographerfoodie for more! :) read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Penne arrabiata IG: @thephotographerfoodie - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Phenomenal. One of my favorites in the west village. The freshest of pasta. Great wine and service. A intimate setting and I will be back. I'm getting hungry just thinking of the restaurant read more

See all

It was good! Not a lot of food but the price reflects that. Very good for small bites to share and the drinks are very reasonably priced read more

See all

Came here with a group of 7 and was able to walk in. The service was super fast and the pasta was fresh and cooked well. Def would recommend the gnochi and tagliatelle al ragu! Great thing about this place is that it's well priced pasta for NYC. Will be back again! read more

Great food, with a lot of flavor and simple preparations of freshly made pastas, sauces and quality ingredients. We started with the bruschetta, and Burrata, which went well together. The Burrata was a perfect balance of creamy center without being watery sitting on hand sliced prosciutto, with cherry tomatoes and arugula and a light vinegarette that was sweet, light and with some fresh herbs on top. Bruschetta was lightly seasoned with fresh basil and tomato and Olive oil that makes Italian foods simplicity its strength. We had the spinach gnocchi and gnocchi patate, with tomato sauce, and the Penne arribiata which were all excellent. Definitely a nice copy interior, and delicious light dishes filled with flavor. read more

Walked in around 5:30 on a Sunday and was able to get a great table inside by the open windows. The interior is cozy and there's a great atmosphere. It wasn't busy yet so service was quick and smooth. The ragu was great, definitely one of the better ones I've had! read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Tagliatelle Ragu - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

Really good pasta for a decent price! Kind of crowded but the vibe is great and the staff is super friendly. Highly recommend!

Saw this place only has 4.1 and immediately went to write a 5 star review because that is what this place deserves. I have been several times and have never been disappointed. Food is fantastic and price point unbeatable. You don't have to play the resy games and can usually walk in especially on a weeknight. Pasta is made in house. Wine is CHEAP. Just obsessed. Going for my 28th this week and cannot wait read more

See all

Stopped here after a splitting a bottle of wine with a date at christopher street pier. This place was close by and we were hungry therefore it was perfect! It was a Monday evening, sometime between 9-10pm. They brought bread over pretty quickly, and theres olive oil and balsamic on the table. My date and I had a glass of wine each, and shared the tagiatelle with meat ragu and spinach gnocchi w/ gorgonzola sauce. Both were delicious and hit the spot. The total was ~$60! Which i feel like for Manhattan is unheard of! Was this anywhere near the best italian food in NYC? No, definitely not. But it service was quick, the food was good, and it was decently priced - would definitely recommend if you're hungry and in the neighborhood! read more

Great dinner spot with delicious food and affordable prices! No reservations here, but my friend and I were seated immediately. The hosts and wait staff were friendly, and the bussers were extremely attentive in making sure our dining experience was clean! Low lighting. Small space and a bit of a squeeze, but worth it for the food and service. I got the Spinach Gnocchi and would definitely recommend. The sauce was flavorful, as was the gnocchi, which had a great texture. Was perfectly cooked. Will definitely be coming back here! read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Spinach Gnocchi - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

A cute little Italian restaurant with Al fresco dining and a patio seating. Came on a Sunday afternoon with lovely weather, perfect for brunch. The price is reasonable for the food. We decided to get two appetizers and two pastas. The waiter seemed less than enthused to take our orders, so if you're looking for top notch service this ain't it. But for a nice casual lunch it's great. - Bruschetta: Cut into 4 pieces. I usually don't get bruschetta but this was really nice and refreshing with the basil, tomatoes, and light seasoning. - Grilled calamari: Excellent! I really enjoyed this, the calamari had a nice light char to it and was well cooked. Served on a bed of lettuce. - Tagliatelle Ragú: We enjoyed this for the meat sauce. Great pasta as well - Spinach Gnocchi: Comes with a cheesy cream based sauce that slightly tasted like blue cheese. The gnocchi were soft and paired well with the cream. I'm not a huge fan of gnocchi but this is one of their more popular dishes. They have several specials but I don't think they serve it at lunch? Or perhaps we came at a time when there's nothing on the special menu. But some of the photos on Yelp were special items and were no longer available. read more

See all

Visited this place with a friend for dinner this week. It's a cute restaurant, with both outdoor and indoor seating. It's a bit tight, but that's normal for NYC. The menu is extremely veggie friendly. So many options and the service was great. Our server kept running into my chair, which was a bit annoying. Wish he was a bit careful walking instead of running into me all the time. The bread they gave was too good. I ate like 6-7 pieces of that bread. Amazing! We ordered the following: - Penne Arabiata: this was so good. I absolutely loved it. The flavor and seasoning were just amazing. - Spinach Gnocchi: a bit creamy, but so delicious. Perfect portion size as well. Overall, loved the vibe, restaurant, and the food. Definitely recommend if you are looking for some amazing pasta. read more

See all

Found this place when looking for an Italian spot on the west side and i'm so glad I went! It's a cute little casual restaurant that's great for a date night or a dinner with friends. We got the tagliatelle ragu ($17) and spaghetti chitarra ($16). They both tasted very fresh and the noodles were cooked to perfection. I did wish both dishes were seasoned a little bit more as it was more on the bland side, but it still tasted fine. I would personally get the tagliatelle again over the spaghetti as it had more depth to it. I felt the service was pretty quick and the waiters were decently attentive. However, there was one waiter who consistently seemed very annoyed from the second he interacted with us all the way to the end, but it could have been an off day. Overall, I recommend coming here especially if you're craving some pasta. read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Tagliatelle Ragu - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Cozy spot in the west village!! Very relaxed dark ambiance :) Very solid pasta! We had the gnocchi and the ravioli, the ravioli was very good and the gnocchi was a little bit too salty but wish that it had more of a creamy flavor. Also had the burrata which was super yummy & fresh! Service was quick and attentive. Not overly bearing read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Spinach Gnocchi Ravioli Formaggio - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

The food was very good. The portions for the gnocchi were very small. I was still hungry after. The prices are ok. You can't make reservations on the web but you can call and make reservations. The place is small. read more

See all

I randomly found this place on a Thursday night while walking around the area. On a Thursday, the had an hour long wait for a table for 2 people (unfortunately not even seats at the bar were available) we waited and it was totally worth it. Ordered the lasagna and the spaghetti a la porcini- loved it! I will provide an update on the rest of their menu because everything sounded amazing! Will be going back read more

Saw a popular review that says it's cash only so figured I'd mention that's NOT the case, we were definitely able to pay with a card. The menu did say a cash discount is available. Food was good and prices were surprisingly reasonable given that it's right by the water and all of the craziness of West Village. Service felt a little rushed, but that was understandable as they did get pretty busy as the night went on. Outdoor seating on a nice night made the experience very enjoyable! Spinach gnocchi was delicious, spaghetti vongole was pretty good too, apple salad was skippable but still decent. read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Spinach Gnocchi - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

This place is a bit over hyped. The portions are small but yummy. I have been to better Italian places. read more

See all

Cute Italian space in the area! Really wanted to check it out myself as there were lots of good reviews. My friend and I were able to get seated right away on a Tuesday 6pm. There were plenty of seating then but got crowded very soon after. I do wish the tables were a bit bigger because we were barely having space for our pasta place and smaller plates to eat the bread. Service was just ok; they didn't check up on us as often as we wanted, kept asking us if we were done with the olive oil for the bread even though clearly we had a lot of bread left, and took awhile to get the check back ): For the price, I think the pasta was pretty good! My friend and I had a clean plate afterwards (eating with the bread was also good) and it was awhile since we finished all the foods we ordered! read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Tagliatelle al Ragu - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Ottimo! Cute, quaint, and (very) original spot on the corner of a local West Village neighborhood. Known for their seasonal specials, homemade pasta & simple decor - I can see why many tables began to fill at an early time (6PM). The atmosphere is calm, authentic, and historic with picturesque tables / chairs plus classic wall art even across the outdoor seating area. The food is spot-on and quite affordable. They have a range of "piadine" dishes - traditionally thin, good tasting crust sandwiches that are traditionally from the Roman cuisine of Italy (ranging from $9-11). A couple salads are present including a basic mixed salad for less than $10 and, apparently, very authentic "al dente" cooked pasta including spinach gnocchi (that's not easy to find). The staff were very friendly, capable of speaking Italian and making anyone feel comfortable. I came with my 7 month old (and puppy) in a stroller and never once felt awkward sitting at an outdoor table without a reservation. Overall a very charming neighborhood spot, one that I would love to revisit the next time I'm in West Village. read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Outdoor decor - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

The food here was exceptional and well priced. They had very healthy options (rare for an Italian restaurant). I can't wait to go back.

Nice spot in NYC, let's go! What I liked: - "Local" restaurant/small space - Service - Pasta was spot on! What I'd like to see changed: - Bread (basically a sliced up, no crispy focaccia bread) thrown in a bread basket - Timing of drinks vs. apps vs. main course.....I get it, small place and the tables must get turned! However the waiter was pretty insistent to get the full order in at once, and our apps weren't even done when the food came out As an "out of towner" no I wouldn't go out of my way to come here....instead, if you live local/in NYC- then yes, good spot for dinner, especially when you take into consideration the "low" prices. read more

Great service. We called to make a reservation and they called us back when they had a cancellation. Good wine deals read more

See all

This place is not the same as malaparte, I learned this when I went to malaparte and none of my friends were there. Fortunately this restaurant was only 5 minutes away and it was a beautiful evening so I walked over. The wine was good, desert was good, food was good, service was ok (they were understaffed). Would definitely come back read more

What a lovely experience!! You can make reservations for 4+ people but there's always more walk in availability than reservation spots. There are indoor and outdoor seating options. The prices were reasonable and the overall experience was great with super friendly staff. There is only wine on the menu for drinks, but you can get glasses, carafes and bottles. The food menu is great with a set of daily specials. With our group of 4, we got a few appetizers and also chose the spinach gnocchi as an app to share (!!!) and it was amazing!! Also recommend the tagliatelle. The homemade pastas are delightful. There's a small % fee if you pay with a card, but they do take card now! read more

Malatesta Trattoria - Tagliatelle Ragu - Italian Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This has been my favorite Italian restaurant and go to spot since they opened back in 2009 and I will never go back again because of the way I was treated the last time we got there at 4:30. They don't open till five they wouldn't even let us sit at the bar or have a drink outside. I wanna know where the owner was where he's turning customers away a half hour early an not letting customers even sit outside. Does the owner know this? I am sure he would not approve since I am a regular and it wasn't only me another couple as well lost business. read more